"Hey ya!" also came out in 2003 —

Appeals court keeps alive the never-ending Linux case, SCO v. IBM

SCO says IBM released a "sham" version of Monterey OS to prop up AIX for Power.

The IBM logo is seen on its building's headquarters in New York on Tuesday, December 22, 2015.
Enlarge / The IBM logo is seen on its building's headquarters in New York on Tuesday, December 22, 2015.
Richard Levine/Corbis via Getty Images

A federal appeals court has now partially ruled in favor of the SCO Group, breathing new life into a lawsuit and a company (now bankrupt and nearly dead) that has been suing IBM for nearly 15 years.

Last year, US District Judge David Nuffer had ruled against SCO (whose original name was Santa Cruz Operation) in two summary judgment orders, and the court refused to allow SCO to amend its initial complaint against IBM.

SCO soon appealed. On Monday, the 10th US Circuit Court of Appeals found that SCO’s claims of misappropriation could go forward while also upholding Judge Nuffer's other two orders.

As Ars reported, SCO (then named Caldera Systems) filed suit (PDF) against IBM in March 2003 for allegedly contributing sections of commercial UNIX code from UNIX System V—which the SCO Group claimed it owned—to the Linux kernel's codebase. SCO Group claimed that the alleged presence of its proprietary code in the open source kernel devalued its proprietary code. By making the source code available, IBM had violated its license agreement with SCO Group, according to SCO. Along the way, SCO filed for bankruptcy, and the group claimed that anyone who used Linux owed them money. All the while, Novell successfully claimed ownership of the allegedly infringing code and agreed to indemnify Linux users.

If SCO is ultimately successful, it could stand to take in billions of dollars from IBM.

In essence, SCO has argued that IBM essentially stole, or misappropriated, its proprietary code (known as UnixWare System Release 4, or SVr4) in the May 4, 2001 release of the "Monterey operating system," a new version of UNIX designed for IBM’s "Power" processors. However, this Monterey OS was incomplete, as it lacked a compiler.

On that same day, according to the 10th Circuit: "IBM released for general distribution a version of its own proprietary AIX for Power product that included the code. SCO thus argues that IBM released a ‘sham’ version of the Monterey system in order to legitimize its own general distribution of the AIX for Power product containing Santa Cruz’s code. (Aplt. Br. 2, 13.) This is the essence of misappropriation claim."

The case will now go back to Judge Nuffer in federal court in Salt Lake City.

Channel Ars Technica