Advanced

Why I don't use Apple products

Posted by jdeslip on · 46 comments
BerkeleyLUG; By Jack Deslippe
Mail this story
Print this story

In the important realm of science, technology and ideas, I believe that the continual conversion of ideas and development effort into the private property of companies like Apple is a great threat to continued free innovation.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial; Groups: Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (46)

26 earlier comments in the full thread.

Quoting:Sigh. Freedom is wonderful as long as everyone agrees with us, huh?
When, in the name of "freedom," one aligns oneself with those who would take that selfsame freedom from others, one is merely demonstrating his freedom to choose his own shackles.

It's like the "tolerance" conundrum. There is no requirement to be tolerant of intolerance.
gus3 -

When, in the name of freedom, you seek to spread that freedom to others, you are furthering the cause of freedom.

When, in the name of "freedom", you get all pissy because others are taking advantage of that freedom to spread it around, you become a living oxymoron.
Quoting:In fact, as long as Apple continues on its present reprehensible course, we should want a clause in the GPL to say that this software may be installed on any computers except those branded Apple


That would make it non-free software. As (mis)attributed to Voltaire:

Quoting:I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
Quoting:When, in the name of "freedom", you get all pissy because others are taking advantage of that freedom to spread it around, you become a living oxymoron.
Ah yes, that "freedom to innovate" that Redmond whines about, but never really uses.

Quoting:I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
Of course. I could tell everyone what a jerk you are, but it's easier to let you show them on your own.
Quoting:Ah yes, that "freedom to innovate" that Redmond whines about, but never really uses.


I don't care one bit what Redmond does or doesn't do. When Microsoft came out with it's own set of "open source" licenses, we all cried foul because one of the licenses restricted the software to only run on Windows. But now you defend to restrict free software from running on Apple hardware?

Quoting:Freedom 0: The freedom to run the program, for any purpose


That includes running it on Apple hardware if you wish so.
Quoting:But now you defend to restrict free software from running on Apple hardware?
Alcibiades is doing that, yes. I'm merely pointing out the contradiction--hypocrisy, even--of Free Software users and defenders buying anything from Apple. Such action is funding a company bent on shackling people to itself.
> ...one is merely demonstrating his freedom to choose his own shackles.

True. But life is all about choosing which shackles you're willing to wear and which ones you're not. From friends to country to family to religion, we're all bound by shackles of our own choosing. The fact that others might choose shackles different from our own doesn't lessen their right to choose.

> I'm merely pointing out the contradiction--hypocrisy, even--of Free Software users and defenders buying anything from Apple.

I'm not buying anything from Apple. However, others are free to do so, and even to run free software on it. It's not my choice to make; it's theirs. Their money, their choose of what hardware to buy, whether I agree or not. Their hardware, their choice of what software to run, whether I agree or not.

It a huge step from saying people shouldn't buy Apple products to saying free software should not be allowed to run on those products. Free software is, after all, first and foremost about freedom.
Quoting:From friends to country to family to religion, we're all bound by shackles of our own choosing.
Wow, I get to choose my parents? *g*

The others would shackle me, only so long as I allow it. I am free to change my alliances: my country, if another will have me; my friends and religion, from whom I can sever ties on my own terms. I have never impinged on the freedoms for others, so I myself retain the same.

But I'm not allowed to buy a piece of equipment and study how it works? Nobody would have any objection if I blew it up with C-4, or melted it with thermite. After all, I own it, right? But let me try to take it apart and figure it out, maybe make it work different, and all hell breaks loose. *cough*iPhone*cough*
> Wow, I get to choose my parents?

You can choose not to acknowledge them. However, the most significant family member is usually chosen.

> ...and religion, from whom I can sever ties on my own terms.

Not a Muslim, I see. But yes, you can largely change these as you wish. That's why they're the shackles you choose.

> But I'm not allowed to buy a piece of equipment and study how it works?

I'm not the ones stopping you gus3. :)

I'm not advocating choosing Apple products. I'm merely saying that other people are free to choose that if they wish, and that's not a freedom I would want to take away from them.

Thinking we know better than others and should therefore be allowed to choose for them is very seductive. It's also almost invariably wrong. We can never know another persons situation as well as they know it themselves, and we can therefore almost never make better choices then they would.
I don't see the problem,

People paying about twice the cost price of hardware to receive the software as well are probably not going to add free software to their system. I mean, how many people buy a Mac and then install Free Software on it?

Sure, half of the free software / open source developers I came across at FOSDEM two years ago. Probably because the Macbook (whatever version, I don't know) just had the best hardware and looks. Nowadays, it's different, I'm pretty sure since the wave of 'netbooks' only one in five FOSS-developers use a Macbook.

So apart from the theoretical debat, I think this is a non-issue. That's what sets it apart from the anti-patent-covenant / anti-tivoization clauses in GPLv3, those were _real_ issues happening and preventing GPL software from being 'free'. But GPL software ending up on closed platforms (MacOSX isn't the only one!) doesn't cause the software to be 'closed', like TiVo did, and it doesn't divide the user base in two camps - like the Microsoft / Novell deal did.
I accept that you cannot have genuinely free software, and also restrict where people may run it. But you have to put it in those terms to make the point. Make no mistake about it, wherever the Apple model predominates, all the freedoms of free software will vanish instantly. You will develop by being a licensed developer, you will sell by being granted permission to have your app included in the app store, and your app will be able to access only content which is not on the Cupertino Index. And you will run it only on systems which conform in all respects to the Cupertino criteria. It may be hardware brand today. Tomorrow it will be what other software or content is installed on your devices.

Now you may, as an advocate of freedom and the Western liberal tradition, feel that it is OK for sects which limit their members freedom to be legal. You may even feel that the state should allow sect members to opt out of, for example, the state schooling system, and apply their funding to sect-run schools, regardless of what values these schools seek to inculcate. That is a legitimate, arguable, if wrong headed, point of view, with a long provenance going back to Voltaire and Mill.

What you cannot in good conscience do is work to broaden the appeal of such sects. You cannot work to broaden the appeal and acceptance of groups whose main aim is to abolish the freedoms which you claim to be supporting. You have to oppose them.

Apple, its ethos, its conduct, its approach to computing in the widest sense, place it in the camp of the enemies of personal freedom. It must be resisted. No-one with any commitment to OSS should have anything to do with it, still less with Fink.
And, up until recently, Apple hasn't been as bad as that. Also, Macs are (as of now) still outside of the draconian control Apple enforces on their more portable devices. I can honestly call OS X a good OS. The ones on iPhones and the iPad? Nope. Won't, and never will advocate those to anyone, precisely because of the draconian bullshit that comes with them. My disinterest in buying a new Mac has largely stemmed from Apple's new hardware design - I know I am about as comfortable on Linux as on OS X, and that I don't like Apple's new hardware, so no new Mac laptops for me. The day OS X develops control systems like the ones on iPhone is the day I stop calling the OS good.

(Part of the reason OS X is good, by the way, are things like Firefox, Adium, Songbird, MPlayer OS X Extended, openssh, OpenOffice, and so on. About 90% of what I use on OS X is FOSS.)
Quoting: [...] Make no mistake about it, wherever the Apple model predominates, all the freedoms of free software will vanish instantly.
Think mathematics, i.e. a necessary [perhaps*], but NOT sufficient condition. Yes, if it happened Apple's predilection for absolute control might lead in such a direction. However, Apple has another bent** that effectively precludes it's domination of the market. For example, premium pricing [not matter if the underlying hardware justifies the cost objectively], aversion to marketing directly to the [so called] Enterprise market. Moreover, potential competitors can always effectively compete upon price advantage alone. Furthermore, those smart enough could employ a Free OS along with more features and more resistance to breakage.

Do I need to say [serious]?

YBT

* Perhaps, because Apple is not the only avenue towards restriction of individual freedom.

** Sometimes they perversely breakup worse suppressors of freedom, just because they can.
Hans --

Lots of people add free software to their Apple systems, especially in business. You might be amazed.

That said, I don't know how much they add. One reason for buying an Apple is the consistent GUI and the apps that run under it, and those apps tend to be things like Photoshop, Final Cut, etc.









> That is a legitimate, arguable, if wrong headed, point of view, with a long provenance going back to Voltaire and Mill.

Well, at least you recognize the point. Software freedom is only one aspect of freedom, and far from the most important one.
jdixon -

I'm not sure that he does. What seems likely is that he's read, but failed to grasp what freedom is. Note the immediate resort to name-calling (sect) to set up an us-them dichotomy.

Since those "sect" sorts aren't us, they are some kind of foreign horror that shouldn't be allowed to indoctrinate their own children -- and can we really consider the children to be theirs? After all, children are innocents. Perhaps we shouldn't subject the poor dears to "them" ?
> I'm not sure that he does ...

It's possible, Dino, but I'll give him the benefit of a doubt for now.
I believe that Le Pen in France and the BNP in the UK, and the comparable parties in Europe, must be permitted the same freedom of expression that we all enjoy.

I do not believe that we should patronize their enterprises, if they have them, donate to them, promote them.

They are fundamentally opposed to freedom. It is one thing to protect the freedom of opponents of freedom. It is quite another thing to promote them.

We need to do two things: one, recognize them for what they are. Two, avoid doing anything that may support them.

The issue of sects and schoolings is just an example, but its a more complex one than you might think, and one the UK social services are confronted with daily. What do you do about religious schools in which beatings are common? What do you do about curriculums which promote the oppression of women. Who are, after all, British citizens too.
I believe that Le Pen in France and the BNP in the UK, and the comparable parties in Europe, must be permitted the same freedom of expression that we all enjoy.

I do not believe that we should patronize their enterprises, if they have them, donate to them, promote them.

They are fundamentally opposed to freedom. It is one thing to protect the freedom of opponents of freedom. It is quite another thing to promote them.

We need to do two things: one, recognize them for what they are. Two, avoid doing anything that may support them.

The issue of sects and schoolings is just an example, but its a more complex one than you might think, and one the UK social services are confronted with daily. What do you do about religious schools in which beatings are common? What do you do about curriculums which promote the oppression of women. Who are, after all, British citizens too.

There is an argument to say that the proponents of free software should be in favor of Apple's right to conduct its business how it likes. There is no argument for their helping it to conduct its business in ways that are opposed to the basic values of the free software movement.

Similarly, whatever your arguments in favor of permitting sectarian schools, even ones which do not adhere to our standards of child protection and gender equality, there is no valid argument that a liberal society should finance such schools, when they inculcate standards and values incompatible with our own.
Alcibiades -

Already on a wrong foot with "our own". Haven'y you heard? Common standards are out of favor these days. All cultures are equal, diversity rules, etc.

However, more seriously and directly in point:

Helping people put free software on an Apple may help Apple in some trickle-down manner, but it primarily promotes freedom for those people. It is little different from the provisions of the GPL that prevent distributing binary code without making the source code available. One accepts restricted freedom in the name of promoting freedom.

As to sectarian schools, I don't know how they do things in the EU and the UK, but religious freedom in the US can be limited by certain kinds of laws, laws preventing abuse of children among them.

Zealously so, sometimes.

In 2008 more than 400 children were forcibly removed from their parents in a raid on a Mormon fundamentalist compound based on allegations that underaged girls were forced to marry the group's men. The taking of the children turned out to have been completely improper, and overblown response to shady allegations against one man, but...

hey, it supports the point.

Absent illegal actions, however, I'm all for being allowed to raise your kids as you wish.





Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post