Copying is Stealing
|
|
Comments (263)
Few notes: On 'micropayments'
Choice out there but of course there are gonna be some who don't play by the rules. Oh well..
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/09/23/orlowski_interactive...
Andrew Orlowski calculated that with a "tax" of $27 per household per year, everybody can download whatever they want and the music business would make more money that they have ever made.
This is, after all, what people have always done when new media threatened the old. We set up some independant body. We make a big pool of money and we find some way of dividing it. We did that with radio licenses, TV licenses, air play for bars and discos, mandatory performance licenses, etcetera.
Someone calculated if we all pay $5 a month to RIAA/MPAA & co, they still earn the same, though I'm not sure where the calculation is.
Problem however is how you share the income between the creators.
Just let creators charge what they want. People who want it will pay for it, those who don't, won't.
Edit: Please let me elaborate.
I've seen an argument that those who copy consider themselves "entitled" to the work of others.
Having a tax to pay the RIAA is justified by considering the RIAA "entitled" to the money of others.
If one is wrong, why is the other right?
@Bob: Levy pools should be managed and distributed by an independent body. The RIAA isn't independent so it wouldn't manage it. It would receive a portion of the pool though, as they are the rights holder for some music.
Considering that I currently spend $0 per month, I don't have much desire to move to that system.
A bigger problem is that we'd hear about starving musicians and all that jazz, and all of a sudden it would be $100 a month.
Quoting:Considering that I currently spend $0 per month, I don't have much desire to move to that system.
True. That's why you might have different description models.
The ones who download 100kB per month don't have much desire for a system which offers a 20Mbit connection either.
So I think that problem can be solved.
His suggestion was a flat fee "per household", not "per blank CD spindle". In the USA, taxes must be based on money valuation (salary/wages, possession, or expenditure). "Per household" becomes a "per person" tax, with single-occupant dwellings having the highest rate per person.
However, I over-spoke: Poll taxes are prohibited from being a precondition for voting. (Amendment XXIV)
Quoting:I personally do not think the tax model is going to work.[...] What we have today is revolution
Radio was a revolution, so was TV, so was the tape recorder. I'm not saying that the levy system is perfect. But a system doesn't need to be perfect, as long as it's "good enough".
Quoting:"Per household" becomes a "per person" tax, with single-occupant dwellings having the highest rate per person.
You could do it "per connection", with higher speeds of broadband being levvied more. After all, how much music and movies are you going to download when you only have 256Kb down? As above, "good enough" will suffice. It doesn't need to be a perfect system. Perfect systems just fail anyway, they get waaay too complicated (micro-payments, I'm looking at you).
Based on the assumption radio stations pay artists for airplay I'm not all too sure about that; Once I calculated how much some radio station earns. Than I tried to calculate how much of it goes to the right holders (half?), and how many people listen. In such a way, one could calculate what it costs per person to listen to that song. Only several cents, it seemed.
However, a song at iTunes is about a whole Euro.
The interesting thing about the radio song is, the more times I hear it, the more the artists end up receiving. With iTunes and traditional albums, not so much.
Well, no, it's copyright infringement.
40 earlier comments in the full thread.
Quoting:I wonder how many of the people that don't agree that copying is stealing would feel about GPL'd code being taken and put into proprietary software without the developer's permission?
IMHO that's still not stealing, though it is wrong. It's still a matter of civil law, not criminal law. I would think it very wrong if the owner of a piece of GPL'ed software can call the cops and tell them to raid Bill Gates' office because MS used his GPL'ed code in one of their products. Instead, the author of the GPL'ed code should sue MS in civil court and prove infringement though discovery.
Stealing is criminal law. Copyright infringement is civil law. That distinction should stay. Precisely because of what was said above and in other threads: with copyright infringement, the owner is not deprived of use of the product.
Indeed. It should be obvious that I am no lawyer.
I'm sure you could remedy the problem, but seriously I don't think it's worth your time.
> Who has been damaged how?
Funny, that's exactly where many people disagree with me.
My position is: Prove damages, receive restitution.
It's not up to me to define who is and is not harmed. Let the person harmed do that. Not only does that eliminate any requirement for statute law, it also means keeping up with changes to technology in "real time" without the delays inherent in legislation.
I said that the buyer of a $10 "Rolex" is not being defrauded, because there is no expectation that a _actual_ Rolex is being sold for $10.
Neither is the Rolex corp. being cheated out of a sale, since the person who buys a $10 "Rolex" isn't someone who would be buying a real Rolex in the first place.
You chopped off the final qualifier in what I wrote: "if he did so without permission." That's the whole point of my comment.
Just like lifting GPL'd code and putting it into a piece of proprietary software is morally wrong.
Both are infringements of copyright.
Quoting:Look at what the GPL is trying to accomplish, figure out how to do it without copyright. The only reason Copyright is used is because copyright exists.
I don't know how it'd work without copyright, to be honest. I don't think it *could* work without copyright. In most cases, since the software is distributed for free, you couldn't even argue that it is hurting the author financially - and even when the original author isn't distributing for free, the fact that anyone who ever got a copy of the software is allowed to redistribute for free really makes it hard to claim financial damage. The only means of protecting the original author at all is copyright, unless some new legal means is created.
You might find it interesting to look into the origins of "criminal" vs. "civil" law. It's not such a nice distinction once one knows why it exists.
Seems Shakespeare understood trademark and its importance a whole lot better than you do,. From Othello:
Who steals my purse steals trash; 'tis something, nothing; 'Twas mine, 'tis his, and has been slave to thousands; But he that filches from me my good name Robs me of that which not enriches him, And makes me poor indeed.
In your example, the buyer of the watch is not harmed, but Rolex is. Inferior goods that bear your trademark diminish your reputation and your ability to profit from it.
That may not matter to you, but lots of us out in the real world rely on reputations as an aid in our decision making.
Maybe your search button can bring you back to my post above where I mention the importance of reputation. Or you could read the prior postings in a thread.
Then you won't make such statements as "That may not matter to you" on a subject where I brought it up long since.
Neither is the Rolex corp.
puts the lie to your protestations.
Seems clear that you can wave the "r" word around when talking GPL, but don't believe it to truly have any value ---
Or, back to my real point, that your position is unprincipled.
You disagree with it, that doesn't make it unprincipled.
If you believe Rolex is harmed, then bring suit, prove damages, and receive restitution.
It is my opinion that Rolex is not harmed, because there is no reasonable expectation that the $10 "Rolex" could have anything to do with the real Rolex product, any more than a photograph of the Mona Lisa has any reasonable expectation of being the original.
Simply stating that they are harmed is insufficient. Demonstrate it.
And my point was that he doesn't need permission. The licensing is compulsory. The original artist can't deny permission. All he needs to do is pay for the use.
My agreement is not what makes it unprincipled.
You pretend that reputation has value when you talk GPL, then pretend it has no value in other contexts. And that's all it is -- pretense. You don't care about anything more than your argument.
As to your ludicrous suggestion that I bring suit in the belief that Rolex is harmed. I would have no standing to do that, but the real Rolex files criminal complaints on a regular basis to protect its name, a name it considers to be valuable. Rolex and other companies daily take assorted legal actions to protect their trademarks. Protecting your trademark is, in fact, a legal requirement for keeping it.
Funny. I have no idea how to contradict that statement in any stronger terms than I already have. I'm left to leave you to your error.
> but the real Rolex files criminal complaints on a regular basis to protect its name, a name it considers to be valuable.
Again, I am left to wonder why you say you disagree, then agree. They are doing exactly what I have said is correct to do, yet you say I am "unprincipled". Does that make them unprincipled as well?
Rolex is a trademark, not a copyright. The arguments for and against both may be similar, but they're not the same. The original discussion concerned copyrights.
And then drop them like a hot potato when they decide it's no longer convenient. The brand C&P Telephone has a long and respected history. The brand Bell Atlantic, not so much so. Yet it was C&P Telephone which was cast to wayside. Likewise for GTE, which disappeared in the merger which created Verizon, as then the formerly so much more important Bell Atlantic. So, exactly how much is was the brand C&P Telephone worth? I guess that depends on when you asked the company, doesn't it?
Having no training in the legal distinctions, I have to plead that any errors on my part come from simple ignorance of where one ends and another begins.
To me they're all just make work for lawyers and politicians, better left in the dust bin of history, like chattel slavery and serfdom.
Quoting:You think it's permissible to violate the law (hey! Gosh -- it's ok to break the law now! Guess I'll get me into some nifty Ponzi schmes...) to take a valuable interest from another person who to whom that interest has been legally granted.
That would be one of the lamest straw man I've ever been accused of. You spend days and weeks arguing according to the finest points of "the law", yet when it comes right down to it, you're willing to change something that not theft (copyright infringement) into theft.
According to the law, copying might be infringement, and it might not. It's also a civil crime.
I wrote nothing about breaking laws, or the stealing of property. You falsely accuse me of something that I just didn't write, nor did I give any indication that I believed it.
Differences exist between "ideas" and "things". You can steal one, you can copy the other. People have different ideas about where copying stops and stealing starts. Right now, copying is infringement, not theft.
But yes, I'd say it's OK (maybe "ethical" would be a better word) to copy in some circumstances. Reviews of movies or books. References in technical literature. Whistleblowing documents, things like that. Calling that "theft" is at best overblown, and at worst it's surpressing civil liberties.
How about published algorithms? Is copying them "theft"?
And that's just the start of the problems. Two people can come up with the same idea independently. If we allow "Intellectual Property", then one of them, maybe not even the first chronologically to think of a concept, gets to "own" the idea.
My sister, an architecture major in college, claims she thought of curtain walls before she ever heard of them. In 4th grade, I thought of the same atomic propulsion that Freeman Dyson's "Orion" used. More mundanely, I thought of circular windshield scrapers, a patented idea. You don't have to believe those things, but surely you can think of others.
The whole realm of "intellectual property" is so murky, so filled with problems where an arbitrary line must be drawn, that to allow it is to risk everything of the current social order.
If you want to change a major policy, you need to ensure that the fix for the problem doesn't cause more harm than just leaving things as they are. Instituting "copying is theft" would do just that, cause more harm than the good that would come from fixing any problems.
Quoting:And my point was that he doesn't need permission. The licensing is compulsory. The original artist can't deny permission. All he needs to do is pay for the use.Okay, perhaps you're talking about the rights-holder, but I'm talking about the performer. If the performer has not secured the permission (via payment of royalties or license fees), then there is a copyright violation.
Yes, in that case you are correct. Though even there I'm not sure payment has to be made in advance. I think there's a time frame for making the payment after the fact. Probably to allow for things like requests from the audience and such.
I consider it very likely that, through the endless machinations that people must go through to make something as arbitrary as "copyright" function in the real world, such a convention would have to exist.
Consider the lounge singer, who cannot know in advance what will be requested. Or do such casual violations get ignored for the sake of not being worth anyone's effort?
I am left wondering how anyone can still consider "ignorance of the law" as no defense. Seems to me to be the standard state of affairs.
In some cases, it is the venue that pays, not the performer.
Creativity at a crossroads
You are right to point out that the pre-Internet era was no bed of roses, either.
While you didn't address software, one of the main reasons I turned to open-source software was was my lack of comfort with the status quo, which is using proprietary software that was generally stolen and passed around.
Hate to be a stickler, but...
In 1831, that went to 28 years with a 14 year renewal. In 1909, it the renewal was extended to 28 years.
Not today's insanity, but still pretty long well before Disney's lawyers got into the act.
Yes, it is stealing
46 earlier comments in the full thread.
Now that we have that straw man knocked down (dino and hans). We can address that if nothing is removed nothing is stolen. Pretty simple. Since it's not theft, it must then be something else, illegal use of copyrighted material seems to fit the bill.
This leads us to copyright infringement, which is still illegal and still has ramifications. But calling it theft is buying into the RIAA/MPAA kool-aid. Theft removes, copying copies. Propping up the strawman is ludicrous, annoying, and ultimately untruthful.
Talk about straw men...
You're as bad as Bob -- simply refusing to acknowledge any value that you yourself don't receive or that you may wish to ignore for your own self-interest.
Again you seem to have me confused with someone else.
There is no entitlement. If no one will trade for your gold, the gold is worthless. No one is entitled to value.
And no one is entitled to take that which belongs to another, even if that something is a legal right, such as the right to rent a house, explore for minerals, cross a piece of land, or get paid for work performed.
Buyers get to offer a price for things of value, and sellers get to determine if the price is sufficient to alienate the valuable item.
I couldn't agree more, and have stated so many, many times.
Unless the buyer is a government, (in some states) a utility company, or (again in some states) someone who has curried favor with the government. Then the seller is out of luck. :(
Quoting:your arguing theft when nothing tangible has been taken again dino.
Nothing Tangible has been taken away, In fact the copyright holder still has possession of the original, and they still have the right and the ability to make copies, and to sell those copies. Nothing has been taken from the copyright holder, all rights, and items remain with the copyright holder. Not even the means to make a living from the sale of copies of the original have been taken away, as would be the case if it was theft, and the original had been removed from the copyright owner's possession.
Let me try and help: and anything defined as "tangible" should be protected because?
Quoting:and anything defined as "tangible" should be protected because?
All sorts of reasons, depending on what the tangible is. Short answer, it depends.
However this is rather irrelevant to the original argument that making copies of Music or Movies, or any other copyrighted material is Theft.
Anyway, like said:
It's the configuration of the medium from which its value is derived. The configuration is scarce, not the medium. No matter if it's the configuration of some matter which make it gold, or of a harddisk, or characters in a book.
In both cases the medium is tangible BTW, while the recipe for the configuration isn't.
It depends on the configuration being scarce what you get for it. Hence why U235 is much more valuable than U238 while it is the same material.
Copying a certain existing configuration to another medium can't be considered theft, but it surely diminishes the value of the existing configuration because it has become less scarce now. So therefore, one could consider the original owner of that particular configuration being harmed.
Has a disinherited child lost anything tangible?
No.
So long as the parents are alive, all he has is a claim against the estate, with no present right to take.
Has a disinherited child lost anything valuable?
By your reasoning, no. Others might argue.
And when did this "Bob's tangibility" -- whatever that may be -- become an essential part of property rights. Easements, right of ways, transferral on death, and all manner of property rights -- non-tangible legal constructs -- have been recognized for centuries.
But, what the hey -- what do the assorted legal systems and social structures of most modern civilizations know?
Seriously, Bob -- You should step up the plate and take your throne.
While it is still wrong, and the artist is still entitled to compensation, it is not theft, to the point that even as a matter of law it has a separate name. Are all those other lawyers and the supreme court wrong too?
Slightly long answer: primarily two reasons, one that it is of direct utility to the owner, and two that it provides some value proposition to the owner (even though no substantial direct utility may be there). The second one is the point of discussion here.
> However this is rather irrelevant to the original argument that making copies of Music or Movies, or any other copyrighted material is Theft.
It is not irrelevant at all, if you pause a moment to give it a thought. Even in normal conversation "passwords are stolen" even though the owner very well still remembers the "original", or "credit card numbers are stolen" even though the original one is still embossed on the card. The reason being that something was taken (precisely a copy in these cases) that diminishes the value of the "original" to the owner, so whether it is the "original" or a copy is irrelevant.
Yes, it is theft, regardless of what statute it gets prosecuted under.
Your argument is like saying that fire is not fire because it's really combustion.
When you take something that belongs to somebody else, in this case the legal right to make a copy, that is a theft. It doesn't matter that the person has the right to make a lot more copies, just as it doesn't matter that stealing a watermelon leaves the farmer able to grow more watermelons.
You have taken a valuable interest from somebody. Something, by the way, every bit as tangible as American money, which, if you look at it, is actually a promissory note.
No. They have everything that they had prior to the parent's change of mind.
The parents who decide not to give their money to the child have not "stolen" anything. They have chosen what to do with their own property.
Copyright violates private property, by saying that the book I bought is not mine, the music I perform is not mine, the disk I made is not mine.
> And when did this "Bob's tangibility" -- whatever that may be -- become an essential part of property rights.
It didn't. You're arguing with someone else again.
I said "scarcity".
> Easements, right of ways, transferral on death, and all manner of property rights
Yes. Every one of them dealing with scarce objects. A piece of actual property can only be owned by one person at a time, or there is no such thing as private property.
The entire world can inherit a song, or a book, without anyone stepping on anyone else's equal rights to it. It requires the artificial scarcity of the monopoly grant of copyright in order to disinherit the entire world in favor of one "heir".
The artist who wishes to retain control of their creation has the absolute monopoly about what they wish to do with it. If they truly want no one else to mess with it, they have the undeniable right to keep it to themselves and NOT PUBLISH.
theft Pronunciation: ˈtheft Function: noun Etymology: Middle English thiefthe, from Old English thīefth; akin to Old English thēof thief Date: before 12th century 1 a : the act of stealing; specifically : the felonious taking and removing of personal property with intent to deprive the rightful owner of it b : an unlawful taking (as by embezzlement or burglary) of property 2 obsolete : something stolen 3 : a stolen base in baseball
> Your argument is like saying that fire is not fire because it's really combustion.
Well fire is fire AND combustion.
There seems to be some confusion on this forum about what is and is not "theft".
I think some are using the term in the loosest sense where others are talking about legal definitions. Arguing about different things is pointless.
In English law, theft is strictly defined as "permanently depriving someone the use of their property". The law was originally formed around the concept of physical items and does not translate well to something more ephemeral.
If you borrow a key, copy it, then give it back, it is not theft.
If I buy a Toyota Corolla Haynes manual, and make my own car, I have not stolen a car. Have I infringed Toyota's copyright though? Maybe.
Mark my words though, if someone invents a machine that can duplicate exactly a physical item in the way that a computer can with music and video, copyright law as it pertains to selling things is going to get very messy indeed.
theft=stealing;
Copyright Infringement in a broad sense can be defined as a type of theft. In the legal sense they are two different things. In the US Copyright Infringement is a civil crime dealing with Intellectual property. Cases are taken to civil court and dealt with between two private parties. Also in the US Theft/Larceny/Stealing is a criminal crime and depending on the value of the item sold, one can go to jail for it.
So (Stealing != Copyright Infringement) in a manner similar to (3.14 != Pi). They are close and commonly referred to as the same thing even if legally they aren't.
So please can we quit flaming about Legal shit and get back to flaming on emacs vs. vi (emacs all the way btw). :)
Quoting:So please can we quit flaming about Legal shit and get back to flaming on emacs vs. vi (emacs all the way btw). :)
Sorry, I'm a vi man. ;)
Oh, and well said BTW.
"Trespassing", not "Stealing"
If I find a hole in the fence at Disneyland and sneak in, I've comitted an obvious wrong, but I've not "stolen Disneyland". I argue that this is very much analogous to making a copy of a copyright-encumbered "for pay" work without rendering payment.
If I set up a fake ticket booth in front of a hole in the fence at Disneylan(tm) and give out "free passes" to go in, I would again be committing an obvious legal and moral wrong, but I would still not have "stolen Disneyland". ("File sharing"...)
And the difference is what, exactly?
A right is, in and of itself, a valuable good.
The best and clearest example is the right to offer your services to the highest bidder.
If you do a job and don't get paid the agreed wage/price, then somebody has stolen your services.
Trespassing is an interesting perspective, it certainly works in the metaphysical "someone has trespassed against me" way. The original that is copied is not interfered with in any way, so I don't think it works out as a clear analogy.
Copyright is a legal extension of contract to individuals who are not party to the contract.
For example, if I get a document from Dino under the agreement that I not copy it, give it to Jim over there and Jim makes a copy of it, Jim has violated "copyright" without ever having been party to the original contract between Dino and I.
I get a public domain video, digitize it and share it, the person who accepts it from me is just fine.
I get a copyrighted video, digitize it and share it, copyright makes it so that the person who accepts it from me has "broken the law".
This is one of the fundamental flaws of copyright law, which differs from any other kind of actual contract.
Neither true or false, it's a slogan
Lots of the other threads on this article contain both feverish support (for opposition as well as agreement) and careful thinking. Sometimes both in the same post! My position: please don't pollute the social space with slogans. For example, I think copyright is not the same thing as author's rights. Where in the bellow and smoke of the `debate' is there space for keeping that in mind?
Here's another slogan: ' "Copyright is theft" equals "Papparazi are kidnappers" ' which is an adaptation of something I saw on Groklaw this morning: if copyright is theft, is it kidnapping to photograph some-one without their permission?
Some people *want* their stuff copied, some people will do anything to get on a photo, and others will charge a fat fee for the same. Regardless of how much money you think ought to change hands and how the market for such exchanges should be regulated, it really doesn't help to reduce the debate to the truth/falsity of slogans.
From the spelling alone i get the sneaking suspicion that means your French*. Gods, just preening in the glow of past history filled illustrious rational thinkers. What do you call it? Yeh, philosophers but remember what they did to Socrates? Shut him up fine, even his followers had to write in code that may not have been understood until very recently. Now that's effective. Kept the rabble in line.
Another thing, LXer and most of the commentators are U.S. based where irrationality rules. Just look at the meaningless slogans that propel our political debate. Clear thinking just confuses the electorate.
Here in America we believe in what we believe that we know in the gut is truth. Therefore, we are not easily confused by either facts or logic. We have an innate sense what is good for us personally, alone and that's just got to be the way it is. So quit with the lectures our minds are made up and we know whatever we have decided is Right. Moreover, with the recently enhanced second amendment rights with can enforce our conclusions with effective, targeted fire power**.
So there,
YBT (a.k.a. Your Buddy Txt.)
* Why can't you be an honest Henry and American like?
** My only regret was in the past due to my volatile temper and to protect one kid I had to keep my weapon in a safe deposit box that for years was inaccessible due to its location in another state. The problems I could have solved*** had I had the restraint and sufficient target practice. Had I kept the weapon in the glove compartment of my car, I could have changed the world [op. cit. ***].
*** Surely I could have lessened the traffic congestion by offing selected, stupid drivers****. Thus, raising the average intellect in this country.
**** Though a few times I might have had to use it on myself for my own transgressions*****, due to being distracted or unattentive.
***** Sad, had I lived an ethical life we would not be having the exploding population problem we are now experiencing. Such is life ...
An excellent example of what you're referring to is the AP. An AP 'journalist' will write a story about something Brittany Spears has done. It is illegal to copy that story unless you pay an outrageous amount of money. Yet Ms. Spears receives no compensation, and the only reason the story has value is because of her name. If I were walking around without underwear, believe me, nobody would want to know.
This is not to say that she should receive compensation. It's the absurdity of the current system that says the world will fall apart if someone does not have a government provided monopoly over all the profits from her labor.
Monks predicted the world would fall apart and it didn't. If copying books was the job of some monks however, some monks lost their job. I think the internet might do the with todays monks: Publishers / studio's.
After the invention of movable type printing, there was a transition period of 'uncertainty' and changes until a new equilibrium with a working model of content creation / distribution and reward was found. I think we're once again in such a transition period, and both publishers / redistributors, consumers and creators try to arrive at a new equilibrium which is best for their 'group'.
The interesting thing is, more people become creator because of the internet era. Before I wrote stuff from time to time and earned money by producing drawings (non tangible wealth I suggest?) I thought different about these ideas too.
One of the problems in the discussion I think, is models proposed for the internet era which doesn't involve state monopolies, is they haven't been tried yet (at least not in the internet era) so we can not be sure what the result for the different 'roles' will be. That's why lots of people may be hesitant about abolishing state monopolies.
In my country, it's pretty much the same with some forms of art: The state has to cut back on expenses, those forms of arts (like ballet, opera and such) are going to receive less subsidy, and they think the world will end. Pretty much because they can't remember how it was before the subsidy era, and because just like the monks they're afraid to loose their jobs, and they're afraid their skills will loose their value.
Nonetheless, internet stores more and more start to proof how a world without 'paid copiers' (publishers) where the creators still are rewarded might look like, so I'm pretty sure eventually things will settle. Before equilibrium is reached, some turbulence is sure to occur however.
legal right yes, moral right maybe not, but who cares
Quoting: ... creative artists have a right to be paid. If we enjoy a piece of recorded music, a book, drawing, photo, movie, and the condition of owning a copy of that work is paying for it, then not paying for it is stealing.
Legally that's absolutely true. But the law should be created from morality and not the other way around, and I am not so sure ANY copyright law can be right.
If I hear, see, read or otherwise sense data (even if I don't want to), I will immediately have a copy of it in my brain. Not a perfect copy, but if I make an imperfect copy of that imperfect copy and publish it, it will still be a good enough copy to violate a copyright. But that initial copy doesn't violate anything. Funny, eh?
Paper, harddisks, CDs etc are all extensions of our brains - external memory. Without a brain to interpret the data they're just objects. And yet we distinguish between neurons and other matter.
Copyright is the idea that the first person to think of a particular really large number (any piece of data really is a large number) should have some type of control (but not complete control) over who can think of that same number in the future and who can forward this number to others. This control may then be sold or rented to someone else.
Why should this right exist?
Seriously, why?
It did not always exist and I've been told the claimed reasons for its existence have changed while it did exist. Even now there may be different reasons. The popular reason is that artists need money for food (and other things) to be able to continue providing a service we consider important.
Do artists really need a "feed artists whose works you like" law, with all the negative side effects that causes, to be able to do their thing? I'm not so sure that is the case, and if it isn't then copyright is immoral.
For comparison... There are plenty of other things that are important. It's important that people are nice to each other. But not being an *** who ignores everyone takes time, and therefore costs money, which means it "should" be subsidized somehow. Should there be a law that requires we pay everyone who is friendly to us?
Of course I might not be the right person to argue morality, because I believe that every argument about it is a fake-logic justification of gut feelings.
In this case people who used to be paid and people who no longer want to pay them are throwing nonsense arguments at each other in the mistaken belief they can convince someone who cannot be convinced because of opposite gut feelings. I'm sure both sides could find more productive uses for their time.
Doing work
88 earlier comments in the full thread.
Quoting:Ripping off artists and creators doesn't do a thing to challenge or fix the current system.
But there you go again. Who is suggesting this?
The summary of your last post goes along the lines of:
1) Bigg: I disagree; what are you talking about? 2) Freeloaders are all frikkin' turds.
It rather does seem as through you have a particularly vitriolic (I do like that word) agenda which has nothing to do with copyright law.
You just hate frikkin' freeloaders.
That's been tried, though the primary focus was (and should have been) the limited time section. Lifetime plus 50 years is not really a limited time by most people's standards. Except in the same sense that infinity minus 1 is. As I noted, the legal methods of protest have been exhausted. People are using what they have left.
Seriously, you're asking that question?
>Seriously, you're asking that question?
Yes. He is asking that question because neither Bob or skelband have been suggesting that this should be done. jdixon and I advocate it as a last resort because all legal avenues have, so far, failed. Pirate parties might be able to change this, and you can be d@mn certain where my vote's going next election.
That I believe copyright to be utterly useless (and patents outright harmful) is a matter completely separate from respecting the artists: I do give artists my money whenever they offer me value in a convenient way: Most gigs of bands I like in Helsinki I go to, and I buy physical CDs in addition to downloading stuff. Ebooks hold no value for me, hence I buy deadtree books. 99% of all games I own are legal.
Despite all this, I think the law should be repealed, because it simply doesn't work. It tries to artificially scarcify ideas, and keep them intensely bound to specific pieces of physical media which is completely contrary to their nature. I'm 100% against the increasing Orwellization of western society, and keeping copyright law advances that because big money wants it to be enforceable.
If that's your basis for deciding the moral authority of copyright, then I can't take anything you say on the topic of moral authority seriously.
The Constitution grants Congress broad authority to establish and regulate copyrights. I can't imagine a term of years falling outside of that authority. If you want to rail against the constitutionality of copyright laws, better to go after the provisions in the DMCA that prohibit bypassing or reverse-engineering technical copy protection schemes.
Yep. Just another failure of merchantilism.
Did I give the impression that I expected you to?
> I can't imagine a term of years falling outside of that authority.
You obviously have a far different understanding of the term "limited time" than I do.
> better to go after the provisions in the DMCA
Why are you assuming I haven't? But this discussion didn't concern the DMCA.
> jdixon and I advocate it
Actually, what I've said is that I don't support the law and I don't care if anyone else breaks it or not. That's not quite the same thing as advocating that people break it.
Link: http://yro.slashdot.org/story/10/07/06/211213/AU-Band-Men-At...
The basic gist of if for those that won't follow the link: Apparently the group Men At Work has been ordered to pay royalties for an instrumental riff in their song 'Down Under'. It seems that the riff is derivative of a well-known children's song 'Kookaburra Sits in the Old Gum Tree'. Written in 1934.
Quoting: Faced by someone who does not support copyright, rather than address copyright, you demand that I re-address the last 10,000 years of social exchange to rationalize something you already agree with.Probably you need to pay more attention. I ask you to rationalize how you come up with the idea that "someone gets to have a "natural right" to "scarce tangible" possessions (*and by corollary, no right to other kinds of those*)". You created an artificial differentiation between "scarce tangible" and other kinds of possessions which you have so far not even defined properly, let alone rationalize why one has a natural right to those but not to others.
Quoting: So no, I am not going to spend several years trying to educate you about something you are already perfectly well aware of.No, the reasons I agree with it are completely different from your reasons (which btw, seem completely arbitrary to me so far).
> You created an artificial differentiation between "scarce tangible" and other kinds of possessions
If you care to go back and look, I have not used "tangible" or "intangible". It's been used many times referring _to_ what people think is my argument, but that's all.
Scarcity, however, is very much central to the issue.
Something that is not scarce, like "air", is not an economic good. Compressed air, filtered air, liquid air, etc, can be priced because they are not scarce. But what is being sold is not the air itself but the service of liquification, filtering, compressing, etc.
I believe that creativity is the most scarce resource of all, and deserves every reward and remuneration that the creator can finagle for themselves. Don't let the assertions that I want "starving artists" to distract you.
An idea is not scarce. A copy does not deprive he who possesses the original of the original, any more than a photograph deprives a person of their soul.
This is why "intellectual" property requires statutes to create and enforce it.
If you are interested, there are many excellent dissertations by people far better than I at educating:
A Book that Changes Everything, Jeff Tucker http://mises.org/daily/3298
Against Intellectual Monopoly, Michele Boldrin and David K. Levine http://levine.sscnet.ucla.edu/general/intellectual/against.h...
Against Intellectual Property, Stephan Kinsella http://www.scribd.com/doc/7511095/Against-Intellectual-Prope...
> (which btw, seem completely arbitrary to me so far)
Then here's your opportunity. The first one above is quite short and to the point, if you're actually interested in the subject.
My 2c: When you use a piece of GPL software, you basically agree to the terms of that license. Not because a court of law will beat you on the head if you do not comply, but because the person who made the software wished it so.
Same goes for music and movies. The makers of "Sita Sings The Blues*" wants you to copy it and give it to all your friends, but the makers of "Transformers 2" do not (perhaps a good thing).
I too really would prefer it if all media came unrestricted, and it's probably worth working to convince the media makers that it should be - for many of the above-stated reasons, but...
...it all comes down to respect. Respect the wishes of those whose efforts went into creating something in how they want it to be distributed (or not distributed). If you don't agree to the terms of use of something, then don't use it.
* And yes, I know that Nina Paley is a very strong "Copying is not stealing" advocate.
Quoting:I do not doubt that you believe in the concept of private property, otherwise you would not be supporting copyright.
Sigh Bob, you didn't learn at all? Sounds like you understood nothing of what I tried to say, and have a binary mind. Someone is for or against something. Sad to have to say, but you sound like your own previous administration.
The whole sentence quoted is your assumption. Nowhere did I say I was supporting the current copyright system. The same goes for the patent system. Neither do I believe in 'private property' on its own, because it doesn't exist / is meaningless outside human society. Just like law, it's a social structure humans invented. Most people don't believe or support social structures, instead they try to live with them.
What I did say however, is those who have something that becomes less scarce and therefore less valuable have a right to be compensated - in cases where society thinks so.
Like explained, in some cases society agreed someone shouldn't be compensated, like if someone's gold becomes less scarce and therefore less valuable.
Most of the society agrees, if the central bank makes paper money less scarce, this shouldn't happen, and some consider it theft (even if nothing was taken away).
Then, when talking about copyright, ideally it would be a social structure to compensate the creator of information for the information becoming less scarce, limited to the cases where the creator wants compensation.
Such a structure could work without law or state. However, it's certainly not going to work, if those who don't have a direct contract with the creator can multiply it without being liable / required to compensate the creator.
Quoting:Do the innovators lose because of this? Probably... ...everybody else gains a lot more than the innovators loose. Good economic laws... are not designed to make a few people super wealthy, but to make the average customer better of"
What this says: "You can basically screw creators as long as anyone else gains more than the creator looses". That's exactly how Pirate Bay works.
Which, exactly like I said, is a description of a society.
It also says: "Initial ideas of an idea are owned by the innovators"
Which is totally ridiculous, given the pledge of the book against "owning ideas". This is where the problem is, it's about Mozart / Beethoven 'owning' the first manuscripts and such. It's discussing today's worlds in which copying information is cheaper than breathing, and using arguments from a very different 18/19th century where copying was more expensive and required more efforts. The same goes for inventions, technical drawings and what have you. And, of course, again there's the steam engine...
The book doesn't think for a moment about the effort needed to make a copy in 1750-1850 and nowadays, which drastically decreased. If a certain social behaviour is good for whole society when copying is expensive, doesn't mean it still is when copying almost became gratis. Why doesn't the book mention costs of copying a bit in 1950 and 2000? Why doesn't the book mention the invention of 5-axis CNC milling machines? Why doesn't it compare the price of copying a book in the time of the Monks / PirateBay? And so on.
It's like using "horse and carriage behaviour in the 18/19th century" as arguments in a debate about the "effect of traffic lights on Ferrari's": bound to fail and produce useless gibberish.
If you are interested, there are many excellent dissertations by people far better than I at educating:
http://userweb.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD10x... 2nd / 3d paragraph.
> Sigh Bob, you didn't learn at all?
Apparently not, because (seriously) what you wrote makes no sense to me.
You keep using words like "society", so look around and see what people are doing. Society is more than just laws, and those laws which enact what society does are laws that get followed.
> What I did say however, is those who have something that becomes less scarce and therefore less valuable have a right to be compensated - in cases where society thinks so. When you get to interview this "society", please let me and everyone else know what they say.
> Most of the society agrees, if the central bank makes paper money less scarce, this shouldn't happen, and some consider it theft (even if nothing was taken away).
All you're doing is demonstrating more abuse of monopoly power, which is exactly what I see happening with the monopoly grants of copyright.
Remove "legal tender" laws, and it doesn't matter how much they print. That's just removing the monopoly which supports the abuse, exactly like repealing copyright.
> Then, when talking about copyright, ideally it would be a social structure to compensate the creator of information for the information becoming less scarce, limited to the cases where the creator wants compensation.
I am all for creators getting every bit of remuneration, or whatever else they want, in compensation for their works.
So we're in complete agreement: Monopoly is bad, repeal it.
> "You can basically screw creators as long as anyone else gains more than the creator looses".
No. What is says is, that without the monopoly grants of copyright, it's very likely that there won't be the monopoly profits that copyright presently supports.
Removing the monopoly grants will always have losers, exactly the way slave owners were "impoverished" by the elimination of slavery.
Yet agriculture methods changed, and people figured out ways to do even better without slave labor than they had while the monopoly grants existed.
Yes, I'm equating copyright to slavery. Both are statutes that say that what I have is not mine.
> Why doesn't the book mention the invention of 5-axis CNC milling machines?
Likely because it's arguing principle, not utility.
If I may, paragraph 5,
> My reason is very simple: radical novelties are so disturbing that they tend to be suppressed or ignored, to the extent that even the possibility of their existence in general is more often denied than admitted.
Exactly the way the elimination of copyright, as an answer to the widespread violation of copyright, tends to be suppressed or ignored, especially in the "mainstream" media where such a radical (return to the root) idea would not entertained longer than to be dismissed.
I deeply appreciate the editors of LXer who have allowed this subject to get throughly thrashed out (again).
Quoting:I deeply appreciate the editors of LXer who have allowed this subject to get throughly thrashed out (again).Except that the LRU algorithm keeps pushing it to the top. It never gets swapped out.
(C'mon, people, let's have a little geek humor here.)
Copying megabytes of info per second however, that is radical. It diminishes the scarcity of information, up to a level where 1930's Austrian thinkers don't apply. They never contemplated scanning every document on earth and making it available for free to the whole world population, even if the creator doesn't approve.
Utility - btw - is what makes it less and less rewarding to create scarce / wanted information.
Discussing economics while only speaking about 'principle' is useless. We don't live between principles, we live in a society. Principles are useless today if they only apply to 18th century society. The whole book is full of historic stuff which doesn't apply in today's world anymore, and therefore, is pretty useless.
When you care so much about principles, start reasoning from today's society. Because the book doesn't make any sense in today's world.
And I don't have to interview society BTW, that's what we have democracy for. You can vote for The Pirate Party, or start your own party.
Let me know if Mises has a perspective which takes the new millennium into consideration and stops ruminating the non-applying useless 18th century trivia. Until then, I'm pretty much done with the topic. Because, with all due respect, I'm pretty interested in the principels of / what the mentioned bunch thinks (and it seems so are you), but if it doesn't apply to today's society, it's a waste of my time.
ed: OK, I kept up with 42 pages of the Kinsella stuff, but it's flawed to such a degree I don't even fancy pointing out all that's wrong about it. Most of it is because the many false assumptions made, about property, scarcity and such. Garbage in is garbage out, even with lots of fancy reasoning. I'm done with it for the next three months.
ed2: removed emotional stuff, sorry 'bout that.
> Elimination of copyright is not radical at all
Rather than push one way or the other to "reform" copyright, to try to make it work better for me, or someone else to get it to work better for them, I examine the "root" of the issue, the existence of copyright itself.
Thus, "radical" by definition.
It's also why the mathematical symbol for taking the "root" of a number is called a "radical".
> Copying megabytes of info per second however, that is radical.
The word you want is "revolutionary", not radical.
> It diminishes the scarcity of information, up to a level where 1930's Austrian thinkers don't apply.
Non sequiter. Ideas have never been scarce, which is why copyright had to be created in the first place: to enforce an artificial scarcity, justified by allowing the artist to charge monopoly prices "for a limited time" for something that is not by itself scarce.
The same principles apply now that applied in the 1930s and before.
For example, the Wright Brothers so retarded American aircraft development with their patents that when the US entered WW1, they had to buy their aircraft from the French.
> And I don't have to interview society BTW, that's what we have democracy for.
So the fact that copyright violation is so wide spread and casual means that you agree to abide the will society, that copyright is to be abolished?
I'm being very serious. If you are so wedded to the idea of democracy, then look around you and see what is going on. "Society" has spoken, loud and clear.
For some reason, I get the feeling you like democracy because you think it will go your way. Mob rule sucks now, it has always sucked. But then, so does dictatorship. That's why I choose voluntary interaction.
> OK, I kept up with 42 pages of the Kinsella stuff, but it's flawed to such a degree I don't even fancy pointing out all that's wrong about it.
Which directly confirms my earlier citation, that because you do not share some measure of first principles, what is obvious logic to him is complete gibberish to you.
Can you comprehend now how what I see you write is just as much "garbage in garbage out", "false assumptions" and meaningless "fancy reasoning"?
I don't think you can, because you are convinced you're being perfectly clear. For that matter, I don't think I can make that leap either, which is why I keep trying to explain these principles to people who really could not care less.
I will only make a final comment on the subject and then I will be silent.
Everyone knows the laws that are bad. They are the ones that are most flouted and have the most dubious reasons for existing. I will list some here:
Copyright for reasons mentioned often above.
Pornography, not pictures of abuse, just of sex: there is nothing wrong with sex per se, so why are pictures so bad?
Alcohol for teenagers I'm going out on another limb here to say that I think youngsters should be properly educated about alcoholic beverages like in France instead of it being this mysterious substance to be abused and experimented with in secret by kids. Prohibition doesn't increase safety, just abuse. Adults who abuse alcohol do (in the main) because of the attitudes they accumulated as children and from likewise media messages.
Draconian Terrorist laws. Police powers to just stop people for no justifiable reason other than somewhere, someone was bombed at sometime in the past. In the UK, we didn't need it during the world wars or during the Northern Ireland troubles. What we need is trust, not laws.
And there are so many others. The above laws are widely broken/abused because there is no sane justification for their existence. They assume that people are stupid and because a very small minority of people are, we must all be treated the same.
We see the same justifications and attitudes:
"We need copyright laws because most people are crooks and they would copy music rather than buying it so no-one would make any money and the sky would fall down." "We need terrorist laws because any one of you could be a terrorist, so we must assume you all are" "You are all perverts because you want to look at pornography. I am a religious person and my priests say it is bad, therefore it must be against the law for everyone." "All teenagers are stupid and their parents are incapable of educating their children, so we must have laws on alcohol consumption"
See some patterns emerging? Before long, we will not be trusted to drive cars, ski, climb rocks, have sex, grow our own food and a host of other things that we take for granted now.
Like I said in a previous time, the vast, vast, VAST majority of people are decent, kind people. However, you only hear about the jerks.
You may or may not agree with me, but that is what I think.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

One of the most important reasons it's difficult to directly award the creator, IMHO is micropayments. If I had to pay €0,20 to read a good article, I'd be willing to do so. If I had to pay the same amount for a song, I might do so either. And I'm not the only one, I bet more people who currently don't buy that many content are willing to pay these amounts. Even if voluntarily. But it should be easy, and most of it should go to the artists, and not to the banks.
Credit cards are the most insecure way of paying, apart from that you're paying with wealth you haven't earned yet (the current crisis clearly shows this is wrong), and it's more expensive than paying with debit cards. Moreover, not everyone is entitled to have a credit card (at least not in this country). So, given the costs and disadvantages, credit cards can't serve as micro-payments. GoogleCheckout relies on a creditcard, and so does the AppStore AFAIK. Credit companies - moreover - are exactly the parasites mentioned, the ones we should get rid of.
We have a nice system in this country - involving debit cards - which is quite cheap, and you only pay for the bare product, and no fancy stupid insurances like with the creditcards (why the hell would I want to insure a song I buy? Is it going to be stolen?). But it's only in NL (and in Austria IIUC) currently. Just like the newest creditcards, it uses two-factor authentication, so it's pretty safe.
Then there's PayPayl, but I'm not to sure about that one either, since it relies on a password only IIRC. It doesn't have the same 'safe' feeling as two-factor authentication using a token device. And it's not that cheap either, I understood. It's also pretty prone to phishing / social engineering. So it's no real alternative.
So that's why I don't pay for content currently: Most of what I want is on Youtube for free, or already on my PC. Apart from that, there's no convenient way to pay €0,20 or so.
Something like Magnatunes - with a subscription - might be a nice idea. But only if I consume a certain amount of content per month, not if I only download one song per month. There are a multitude of websites providing paid content, and it would be pretty clumsy to have to arrange a subscription for all of them. A "pay €0,20 to view this article" button would be more convenient for people like me, who might only read one WSJ / NYT / The Times / Science article per two months or so.
Unless there's a cheap way for micropayments, parasites like the creditcard companies will keep existing, and I'll still wonder how to reward artists.
Currently, everytime I see a 'you have to pay $1 with a creditcard to read this article' message, they lost me as a customer.