Advanced

Windows 7 may not be the solution for the troubled Microsoft

Posted by DaMan on · 61 comments
ItrunsonLinux.com
Mail this story
Print this story

Microsoft who is already suffering from Netbook makers using the older Windows XP & custom-made distros of Linux, probably won ’t find a remedy with their upcoming Windows 7.

MS is planning to offer several editions of Windows 7 for Netbooks. As several specialists/analysts from Gartner & the PC industry stated "this would not be a wise decision".

"That upgrade’s going to be tough for a bunch of reasons. Microsoft has to figure out: What’s their strategy?” Intel Chief Executive Officer Paul Otellini said at an investor conference in San Francisco last week.

Microsoft does also get though competition from another big player in the industry: Google. Google has anounced recently it will release a Linux/Android Netbook version & subsidize (3G) network operators to bundle it with a service contract.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Linux, Microsoft

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (61)

Windows 7 Will Succeed and Fail on Netbooks

20 earlier comments in the full thread.

For what it is worth consensus economic forecasts are about as accurate as you get in economics (which is not saying much). Here are some

http://www.philadelphiafed.org/research-and-data/real-time-c...

They show an inflation rate for 2010 and 2011 of 1.9% and 2.3% respectively. That does not sound at all bad.

The longer range forecast shows 2009-2013 2.2% 2009-2018 2.4%

Again hardly terrible.

With regard to a recovery they are showing a modest one in 2010.
Inflation is caused by an oversupply of money. The more they print, the less it is worth, the more things cost.

http://www.foxnews.com/video2/video08.html

Edit: Yeah, I know. He's a right-winger. But ignore that and just think about the numbers.
> Inflation is caused by an oversupply of money. The more they print, the less it is worth, the more things cost.

Only in the very long run. Without going into the details (you can use Google if you choose) what is different now is that we have a 0% interest rate, in which case changes in the money supply have no effect on the economy. Japan has provided us with a perfect example. They increased the money supply by large amounts and they failed to get out of their deflation.

It is true that we have to worry about inflation once the interest rate goes above zero, but the Federal Reserve is aware of that and plans to reduce the money supply accordingly.
Interesting, the link is no longer working for me. Or, rather, it is working but showing an entirely different, unrelated vid.
OK, this is better. Here's the original chart from the Federal Reserve. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/BOGAMBNS?cid=124

Bigg: In less than a year they pumped more new cash into the system than in the cumulative history or our county. There is no historical precedent for this. Do you really believe it's business as usual?
NoDough,

The inflation forecast I linked was by the Fed also and was updated this month. I am therefore sure that the additional government debt (printed money as you put it) will have been taken into account by any competent economist and so should show up in their projection.

Some historical context is useful as well. In the mid 1940s the ratio of government debt to GDP was significantly higher than now. That period was not characterized by high inflation.

http://zfacts.com/metaPage/lib/National-Debt-GDP.gif http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USDebt.png

Bottom panel of the second link is the inflation adjusted data.
> In less than a year they pumped more new cash into the system than in the cumulative history or our county. There is no historical precedent for this. Do you really believe it's business as usual?

Yes, the monetary base has risen a lot. It's just that things are different when the interest rate is zero. Provided that the Fed cuts the monetary base when the interest rate starts rising, we should not get hit with inflation.

The Japanese case does provide a precedent because they ran into the zero interest rate as well. I don't have a fancy graph to link to, but the Bank of Japan website shows that Japanese monetary base growth peaked at 36.3% in April 2002. In November 2006 the rate of change fell to -22.3%. (Series BJ'MABS1AN11@) They have not had any problems with inflation.

Just to clarify - I'm not disputing that money growth will cause inflation, but I disagree that it will be a problem now, and expect the Fed to appropriately cut the monetary base at a later date.
It'll be interesting to see how this plays out. I still say you can't play these games with the monetary base without inflation; zero interest or not.

We should revisit this thread in 6 months and compare reality to our guesses. Somebody will get told-you-so rights. ;-)
> We should revisit this thread in 6 months and compare reality to our guesses.

I'll have to leave that to you. I have trouble remembering appointments six hours into the future.
>> I'll have to leave that to you. I have trouble remembering appointments six hours into the future.

Man, do I know that feeling. Getting older sucks. The only thing worse is not getting older.
> It's just that things are different when the interest rate is zero.

Not really. Deflation can trump an increasing money supply, especially if you don't do a good job of getting the money into the economy. It's called pushing on a string.

> Provided that the Fed cuts the monetary base when the interest rate starts rising, we should not get hit with inflation.

True, but that's a loophole big enough to drive a semi through. If the government insists on maintaining spending levels, interest rates will have to go through the roof to cut the money supply by that amount. If the government cuts spending accordingly, then I'll grant that you should be correct.

With the current administration, I expect government spending to decline about the same time pigs start filing flight plans. I'd love to be wrong about that, of course.
If the government insists on maintaining spending levels, interest rates will have to go through the roof to cut the money supply by that amount. If the government cuts spending accordingly, then I'll grant that you should be correct.

I completely disagree. During 1933-1936 FDR spent huge amounts of money on the New Deal. Inflation did not resume. The deflation cycle was arrested but there was no inflation. When FDR decided to tackle the federal budget deficit and reduce spending the result was that the economy went into reverse again. Only when spending resumed in 1938 did the economy start to recover again. When spending went through the roof as the U.S. first aided the British in WWII and then entered the war the depression finally ended.

Cutting spending and even freezing spending was tried during the Great Depression from 1929-1932 by the Hoover administration. The depression only got worse.

We don't need less spending. We don't need tax cuts which don't stimulate much. What we need is new WPA or TVA type projects that put people to work. When people work they can spend which increases demand which stops the downward spiral.

In another thread I pointed out that what we are seeing now really does parallel the beginnings of the Great Depression. We don't have deflation *YET* except in gas and housing prices. We do have rapidly rising unemployment leading to a reduction in demand leading to less production leading to more unemployment.

In another thread I pointed to the writing of Marriner Eccles, Chariman of the Federal Reserve under FDR. His theories actually predated Keynes and when you read what he wrote or his testimony at the time it actually sounds frighteningly like what we are seeing today. The following is from his book "Beckoning Frontiers". I'm going to quote a part of what is quoted on WikiPedia:

As mass production has to be accompanied by mass consumption, mass consumption, in turn, implies a distribution of wealth -- not of existing wealth, but of wealth as it is currently produced -- to provide men with buying power equal to the amount of goods and services offered by the nation's economic machinery. [Emphasis in original.]

Instead of achieving that kind of distribution, a giant suction pump had by 1929-30 drawn into a few hands an increasing portion of currently produced wealth. This served them as capital accumulations. But by taking purchasing power out of the hands of mass consumers, the savers denied to themselves the kind of effective demand for their products that would justify a reinvestment of their capital accumulations in new plants. In consequence, as in a poker game where the chips were concentrated in fewer and fewer hands, the other fellows could stay in the game only by borrowing. When their credit ran out, the game stopped.


[...]

Debtors thereupon were forced to curtail their consumption in an effort to create a margin that could be applied to the reduction of outstanding debts. This naturally reduced the demand for goods of all kinds and brought on what seemed to be overproduction, but was in reality underconsumption when judged in terms of the real world instead of the money world. This, in turn, brought about a fall in prices and employment.

Unemployment further decreased the consumption of goods, which further increased unemployment, thus closing the circle in a continuing decline of prices. Earnings began to disappear, requiring economies of all kinds in the wages, salaries, and time of those employed. And thus again the vicious circle of deflation was closed until one third of the entire working population was unemployed, with our national income reduced by fifty per cent, and with the aggregate debt burden greater than ever before, not in dollars, but measured by current values and income that represented the ability to pay.


No, none of my ideas are original :)

In the other thread I also linked Eccles' testimony to the U.S. Senate in 1933. It's 36 pages long but it's well worth reading precisely because so much of it reads like what's happening right now. [url=http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/docs/MeltzerPDFs/ecctes33.pdf#search='marriner eccles']http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/docs/MeltzerPDFs/ecctes33.pdf#s...[/url]
Caitlyn, the section you quoted has little to do with your comment. My comment was solely a comment concerning money supply and interest rates. High interest rates act to slow the growth of the money supply. Increased government spending grows the money supply. If you want to reduce the money supply, but maintain government spending levels, your only real option is to increase interest rates. Whether maintaining government spending is a good or bad thing has nothing to do with the matter, and wasn't what I was discussing.

> We don't need less spending.

I didn't say we did. That's another discussion entirely, and would definitely result in a TOS violation.

> We don't need tax cuts which don't stimulate much.

Agreed, though tax cuts which do might be a good thing right now. :)

Whether, as a general principle, tax cuts stimulate the economy is a well tested historical matter. I'll leave it for others to review the information available and decide for themselves. Again, arguing the point would eventually result in a TOS violation,

> We don't have deflation *YET* except in gas and housing prices.

Well, I'd argue you could add stock prices to the list. :)

Since gas prices were largely responsible for our recent high inflation, I expect a decline in general prices in a few months as the drop in gas prices works it's way through the system.

Anyway. I never said that increased government spending was, in this specific case, a bad thing. I said that if the economy improves, maintaining that level of spending will result in inflation unless the money supply is decreased and that decreasing the money supply will require significantly higher interest rates. That's a simple economic analysis, not a political position.

I'm well aware of the Keynesian viewpoint, Caitlyn. I'm also aware of the Chicago school and the Austrian school and both of their basic theories (though I'm not a trained economist). There's no point in quoting them to me, though others may find them useful.
This dispute appears to be whether one subscribes to a monetarist or Keynesian view of the economy.

Monetarism became popular in the late 1970s when wage inflation was the big problem. Keynesian ideas became popular in the 1930s when a deflationary spiral was in evidence.

Moneterists believe that inflation is caused by an increase in the money supply. Keynesians believe you can disrupt a deflationary spiral by government deficit spending.

Why wasn't the massive spending of the 1930s and early 1940s inflationary? I think it was because the large economic growth that occurred after 1945 allowed the government to get back into balance by increasing tax revenues. Such revenues did not increase because of higher tax rates but because more people were paying tax on higher incomes.

So I don't think the key question here is really whether the federal government exercises discipline down the track it is more a question of how strong the economic recovery will be because that will enable the government to reduce debt through increased tax receipts.

If there is not a good recovery in 2011 and 2012 then that is when we need to worry.
> Moneterists believe that inflation is caused by an increase in the money supply. > Keynesians believe you can disrupt a deflationary spiral by government deficit spending.

Correct on both counts.

There's no inherent conflict between the two theories, so there's no reason both can't be true, and I believe that most economists now accept that's the case.

> Why wasn't the massive spending of the 1930s and early 1940s inflationary?

The classical answer would be because the growth of GDP was enough to absorb the impact. Also, how much of that was deficit spending? By my understanding, non-deficit government spending doesn't inflate the money supply, as that's money which would have entered the economy anyway.

> So I don't think the key question here is really whether the federal government exercises discipline down the track it is more a question of how strong the economic recovery will be because that will enable the government to reduce debt through increased tax receipts.

No recent government has been able to hold spending low enough that the recovery allowed them to reduce debt. This has been true for both Republican and Democratic administrations. Even the Clinton administration did not do so if the debts of Social Security and Medicare were counted. So there's no recent historical precedent for believing that will be the case. Again, I'd love to be proven wrong.
I agree that there is no inherent contradiction because the two prescriptions were aimed at very different problems and both appeared to be partially successful in their different jobs.

The dispute comes when analyzing the nature of the present crisis. If you think it is another Great Depression then you would have to back the Keynesian approach. If you think it is not nearly that bad and therefore the quick recovery will bring the release of excess demand from the government spending then you will be looking for monetarist discipline down the track.

It should be pretty obvious within 6 months or so which view is closer to the mark. We have deflation now. If it accelerates as unemployment sky rockets then the pessimistic Keynesians will prove right. If we come out of the downturn strongly then monetarists will likely prevail.
>Also, how much of that was deficit spending? By my understanding, non-deficit government spending doesn't inflate the money supply, as that's money which would have entered the economy anyway.

If you look at my plot above of debt in the 1940s you will see that virtually all of that was government debt which must have been generated by deficit spending because of WW2 primarily and the New Deal secondarily. The huge run up of debt came from somewhere right?
While an interesting read, and on a subject that it would be best for me to avoid, this conversation is being held on two threads ... any chance I could convince all the parties to consolidate on one?
Azerthoth: Yes, by all means. How do we do that?

Montezuma: The dispute comes when analyzing the nature of the present crisis. If you think it is another Great Depression then you would have to back the Keynesian approach.

Exactly. I am on record as having called this a Second Great Depression by the fall of last year.

jdixon: There's no inherent conflict between the two theories, so there's no reason both can't be true, and I believe that most economists now accept that's the case.

Also correct. I cited Fisher (a monterist) and Eccles (essentially Keynesian before Keynes).

I think montezuma hit the nail on the head. Unless you are a rigid ideologue from either the left or the right the solution you support depends on your interpretation of what this crisis really is. I read about the early part of the Great Depression and I am amazed at how much it seems like I am reading about today.
> It should be pretty obvious within 6 months or so which view is closer to the mark.

Agreed. I'm hoping it's merely a severe recession, but I'm expecting the worst. That way I'm guaranteed not to be disappointed. :)

> If you look at my plot above of debt...

Ah, I'd forgotten it. Yes, from the chart, it appears that the 1940 spending was indeed deficit spending, in which case the classical answer about GDP growth is probably correct, as shown by the drop in debt/GDP in the second chart starting in '46 or so.. Following Keynesian theory, It's also possible that the spending was replacing depressed private spending, which would not have been inflationary. I don't think the Chicago school would agree about that last, but...

> ...on a subject that it would be best for me to avoid,

A wiser man than I, apparently. :)

How is Windows 7 different?

1 earlier comment in the full thread.

Well, they're not offering a second pay toilet that's the same, but two pay toilets: One expensive and one cheap, but you cannot defecate at the latter unless you upgrade your license. However, probably the users will find a way around the technical limitations to defecate in the cheap one.

The result will be a stinky mess nobody wants to clean up I guess, which makes this a cool comparison!
Quoting:Netbooks will never, ever be profitable for Microsoft. Windows 7 doesn't change that.
.... and yet from one of the linked articles within the ItrunsonLinux.com piece itself :

Quoting:Microsoft is planning to offer several editions of Windows 7 for netbooks, scaled-down laptops that cost less than $500. Microsoft wants consumers to opt for the more expensive versions of the software, an approach analysts and even Microsoft partner Intel Corp. say may be a hard sell.
+plus+
Quoting:This time, as Microsoft readies Windows 7, the company is planning a basic version, as well as more expensive editions that are also targeted at netbooks. Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer said last week that he will make sure consumers can “trade up.”
+plus+
Quoting:To push customers to pricier versions of Windows 7, Microsoft is limiting the features of the cheaper edition. The most basic, called Starter Edition, can only run three programs at a time.

Microsoft will make it easy for consumers to quickly upgrade to more advanced versions, as all the required software will already be installed on the machine and it just takes a few minutes to switch from one version to the next, said Parri Munsell, a director at Microsoft’s Windows business.

“If you look at Starter Edition, I really don’t think Microsoft wants to sell that at all -- it’s pretty crippled,” said Michael Silver, an analyst at Stamford, Connecticut-based Gartner Inc. “It’s really there just so they can say they have a really low-priced offering.”
(three above quotes from Dina Bass's and Ian King's 'Microsoft’s Windows 7 May Not Cure Netbook Headache (Update2)', http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601109&sid=auGu.FxP...)

So this particular MS Windows 7 Starter Edition which is aimed squarely at netbook users is actually just an enticement for such users to move right into Microsoft's profit-centric version(s) of Windows 7 ASAP!

While there may not [yet!] exist an INDISPUTABLE case of Bait and Switch here -- see http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-a-bait-and-switch.htm -- red flags probably SHOULD go up now regarding Microsoft's strategy for Windows 7 for netbooks as enumerated in the Bass and King piece quoted here.

How does a company this lame make so much money?
@TC: The same tenet that says "pure drivel drives ordinary drivel off the screen, every time."
I can offer to upgrade the Windows7 basic to Linux with all the bells and whistles for Free.
@TA:

"Insufficient drivel, core dumped."
>> How does a company this lame make so much money?

I know that was rhetorical, but...

Four of my employer's mission critical applications run on Windows and only on Windows; ERP, estimating, CAD, and shop floor control. Three of those applications integrate with Microsoft Office. So, what do you think the chances of us converting to Linux are? Out of about 120 client computers, I can count on one hand the number that could get by with Linux (with fingers remaining.)

Additionally, we don't do Vista. So we pay a little extra to downgrade (well, upgrade really) from Vista Business to XP Pro.

It's easy to make money when you're the only game in town. And the application vendors think it's great because they only have to code for one platform. But they'll cry you a river when MS decides it wants their market.

Sorry, had to vent.
OT: I've just been forced to start using MS Office 2007. It would have to be the ugliest looking application (the window the applications run in looks like a copy of the KDE web style window decoration, which is pretty ugly, and it's a sort of pale blue which doesn't match my desktop, which is the Win 98 style that you get when you set the desktop up for maximum performance (such as it is). Then you get to the Ribbon.... what a piece of puss (according to our new bloke you can create your own ribbon, but i don't want to spend time making it usable, but i suppose I will have to eventually, because it really is obscure. No wonder the french police wax lyrical about how easy it is to transition their members to Open office.org)
>> I've just been forced to start using MS Office 2007.

Which reminds me, we also paid extra for Office 2007 downgrades to Office 2003. Most of our users are... umm... digitally challenged. So, due to the sweeping changes, we cannot upgrade to Office 2007 without a huge investment in training.

However, I will give Microsoft the benefit of a doubt on this topic. They invested a lot of time and money on usability studies for Office 2007. The people who take the time to get used to the new interface see it as an improvement, but they admit that the adjustment is painful. It took courage to make such a massive change and gamble that it wouldn't be rejected. If they didn't own a monopoly, it probably wouldn't have paid off.
tracyanne as far as I can tell the keyboard short cuts are all the same. My school has installed Office 2007 on all of the computers and when I have to help the Professor I am working with on her computer I just use keyboard shortcuts, because it is easier to figure out how to do what I want to that way.
I don't know the short cuts, I don't use MS Office all that much, I tend to use Open Office except when I forced to use MS Office, so I never bothered. The only reason I'm using MS Office is because I'm working with my boss who looooves MS Office 2007.
However, I will give Microsoft the benefit of a doubt on this topic.

I don't give them the benefit of the doubt. I had to start using it a month ago and I'm absolutely not impressed.

They invested a lot of time and money on usability studies for Office 2007. The people who take the time to get used to the new interface see it as an improvement, but they admit that the adjustment is painful.

I'm pretty much up to snuff with the Ribbon now and I can tell you that it has nothing to do with usability at all! It is just all cosmetics on top of good old Office 2003. Most "pretty Ribbon pictures" are linked to the old bog standard O2K3 and earlier dialogs.

It isn't easier, you have to relearn locations, you have to remember pictures as well now alongside new text. It isn't more efficient. Some tasks take more steps now than in previous versions. Tasks that should be (and were) logically grouped, can be scattered over 4 different Ribbon locations in O2K7.

My feeling is MS just slapped on an icon bar to be able to say that O2K7 was "new". I haven't seen radical new features, only a few refinements here and there and a massive pain in the neck called the Ribbon.

It took courage to make such a massive change and gamble that it wouldn't be rejected. If they didn't own a monopoly, it probably wouldn't have paid off.

It took a marketroid to realize that O2K3 is as complete as it gets and instead of truly innovating and coming up with truly new stuff, they decided to use the old "MS makes new with lipstick" strategy. That and yet another incompatible file format.

Sorry, but O2K7 represents a major annoyance to me.
Quoting:That and yet another incompatible file format.


That's no excuse anymore because you can get that with 2003 as well. The only difference between 2003 and 2007 is UI lipstick.
I recently saw and tested Office 2007 for the first time. The ribbon feels very comfortable to me. Perhaps that is because I do most of my writing in LyX and before that Scientific Word. Mostly it was a big "so what" feeling.
tracyanne, most of the Open Office short cuts will do the same thing in Office. The default ones anyway, any custom ones you have set up probably won't work. When I am forced to use Excel or Word this is the only reason I can get anything done.
Sorry OT again.

We've just gone Silverlight on one of our major clients websites, but certain organisations are refusing to allow people behind their firewall to download the silverlight clientside components, sighting potential security issues. The managing director of our client company said "But it's a guaranteed Microsoft product, they shouldn't have anything to worry about."
> The managing director of our client company said "But it's a guaranteed Microsoft product, they shouldn't have anything to worry about."

And technically speaking, he's correct. If you choose to run a Microsoft operating system, you're already trusting Microsoft implicitly. What more threat does Silverlight carry than the latest MediaPlayer, .Net, or IE update?
Hahahah. TA, just show them the security history of ActiveX :-)
Given the history of Microsoft's security (or general lack of) I nearly choked when I overheard this.

But it does raise an interesting point. Microsoft has managed to completely divorce computer issues from their sieve like operating system, in the majority of people's minds.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post