Advanced

Ubuntu moves away from GNOME

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 17 comments
NetworkWorld; By Joe Brockmeier
Mail this story
Print this story

The big news at the Ubuntu Developer Summit? Moving to Unity as the default interface for Ubuntu Desktop with Natty Narwhal (11.04), rather than GNOME Shell. Earlier this year, Canonical representatives had to deny that they were forking GNOME with the work on the Unity interface. (Quick disclaimer, I'm a GNOME Member and help out with GNOME PR.) Unity is a Canonical-sponsored project that was initially delivered for the Ubuntu Netbook Remix. GNOME Shell is the interface being developed for GNOME 3.0, which was delayed to spring 2011. Apparently, Canonical were being asked the wrong question. During the opening keynote, Mark Shuttleworth has announced that Canonical is committing to making Unity the default desktop experience "for users that have the appropriate software and hardware." Unity requires compositing to work properly, which means users need functioning 3D support to use the interface.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: GNOME, Ubuntu; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (17)

This isn't moving away from GNOME

GNOME 1.x and 2.x always supported alternative window managers and 3.x supports an alternative shell. That isn't "moving away from GNOME". It is using GNOME is a non-standard configuration is all.

Whether the Ubuntu user community, particularly the newcomers who Ubuntu caters to, like it or not is another entirely open question. I do expect that seasoned Linux users will generally hate it as they seem to hate most netbook interfaces. I also don't see the sense in bringing the netbook interface to a desktop but that's just me. I'm clearly not Ubuntu's target audience.
Nope, caitlyn your not the target, your not Dorothy's Scarecrow.
Or the Cowardly Lion.
So is Mark Shuttleworth the Great and Terrible Wizard of Oz?
Yup, just a guy using smoke and mirrors to project a much larger image of himself.
nah, Flying Monkey maybe.

*tandem post, gus snuck in on me. very nice*
Quoting:Yup, just a guy using smoke and mirrors to project a much larger image of himself.
Yeah right - a billionaire promoting himself as a debian developer and leader of a debian spinoff. Are you serious?
Quoting:Yeah right - a billionaire promoting himself as a debian developer and leader of a debian spinoff. Are you serious?
One can be a billionaire, and still be in over his head. Likewise, one can be a good project leader, and make very little money from it. Neither one implies the other.

In Mark Shuttleworth's case, I posit that his self-promotion, made possible by his cash reserves, and his accompanying promotion of "Ubuntu" (not Linux), does more harm than good to the Linux, GNU/Linux, and Debian brands and Free Software in general. By playing down Ubuntu's basis in Debian Sid, the rickety underpinnings are hidden away; when the frame breaks, it's a black eye on all of FOSS to the naive user.
@gus3: Well said. I agree with you but pardon me if I hide when the folks with the tar and the pitchforks and the torches come for you.

Seriously, I think the one thing Ubuntu does well is sell itself to OEMs so that preloaded systems get out there. Of course, right now, Google is doing that with Android as well. Heck, you can even by a few netbooks with Android at K-Mart right now.
Some sensible comment I read somewhere:

If you're tech savvy, you're probably not Unity's target audience. Then, you should be able to configure Ubuntu to use Gnome yourself.

However, if you're not able to configure Ubuntu to use Gnome instead, then probably Unity is for you.

Have to confess, almost makes sense.
A very Jobsian way of looking at it I suppose.
Quoting:pardon me if I hide when the folks with the tar and the pitchforks and the torches come for you.
I've gone up against far better minds than any of the Ubuntu fanbois have.

And I have the scars to prove it, too.

All things considered...

All things considered, I'm indifferent to this move. I pretty much use Cairo-dock & Compiz as a WM replacement, anyway. So, this won't impact me. They better have Unity's act together by then, though.
If they can make a better interface, good for them. As much as I like computers and Linux, the desktop environments and application interfaces still have a long way to go. A great test is to spend some time with an intelligent but not computer-guru user. Suddenly you notice design deficiencies that you ordinarily gloss over because you're used to them. Here is one example: save a document in OpenOffice with a new name, and in a different directory than the one it opens to. Notice how you have to navigate all over the screen, and there is no logical sequence of steps-- you have to know already what to do. It's even more mixed-up creating a new directory or saving to a different format.

Speaking of directories, am I the only old fossil who remembers how you could delete directories from inside Word Perfect?

Another chronic problem with KDE and Gnome is naming inconsistency-- application launchers might have names like 'text editor' or 'file manager', or they might use the actual application or command name, or both. It's different in the various distros and changes from one release to the next. Always re-arranging the furniture.
Have you looked at Unity, TuxChick? See Bruce Byfield's review of Ubuntu Netbook Remix. Add a few bugs and general clunkiness he doesn't cover and you pretty much have what Unity is right now: an unholy mess.

Yes, if Ubuntu really does come up with something better I'm all for it. Mark Shuttleworth talked about turning the computer into an appliance with Unity. That doesn't sound at all appealing to anyone who isn't a total newbie or who does more than light computing and social networking. Thanks but no thanks.
Nope, haven't looked at Ubuntu anything for awhile. I'm having fun with Arch and POD, Plain Old Debian :). Ubuntu is OK, but I'm tired of tracking a randomly moving target. Every release has all these drastic changes to important subsystems, and nothing is ever really finished. Of course that is true of software in general, but with Arch and Debian I get nice regular fresh packages without the pain of weird customizations.

After I finish working the kinks out of my kewl new Arch-based backup server I'm going to pay serious attention to some different DE/WMs. KDE4 is just plain not for me, and while Gnome has gotten pretty nice I'm overdue to check out some of the others. I'm wondering if all this energy that has gone into making KDE apps and Gnome apps means they won't integrate well into other environments, or will lose functionality.

I will check out Unity just to see what all the noise is about. They're building it up to be Spectacularly Awesome and Stuff.
It's Ubuntu. For some, by definition, it IS Spectacularly Awesome and Stuff simply because it is Ubuntu.

What you are experiencing with Debian and Arch pretty much explains why I stick with the Slackware derivatives and Red Hat for work. OK, with Red Hat I really don't have a choice but if I did I'd probably still stick with it. I get the idea that you would like SalixOS, which is a Slackware derivative with some of the niceties you are used to from Debian, like sane package management with automated dependency checking.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post