Advanced

Mark Shuttleworth: Ubuntu's Bug #1 Is Fixed

Posted by muktware on · 34 comments
Muktware; By Swapnil Bhartiya
Mail this story
Print this story

I think the world is a much more balanced place now with iOS and Android so, perhaps we can consider that one fixed.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (34)

14 earlier comments in the full thread.

Ubuntu "moved the ball forward" for Linux and free software, no question. But the honeymoon between Canonical and the geeky masses is over. It's hard to court the already converted while digging for new markets (mobile, TV, tablet). I hope they eventually get it right. Things are more than a bit bumpy right now in the Ubuntu ecosphere/community.

It'd be worse if Canonical was actually finding some kind of success in the post-PC market. Right now it's a lot of talk and a lot of changes to the flagship product (Ubuntu PC desktop) to accommodate other devices, but not a lot of uptake on said devices.

That said, look at Ubuntu Server. They seem serious about it, and it is a very credible and compelling product. No Unity-like mistakes there.

dinotrac wrote:I don't think anybody ever hid Ubuntu's true nature.
Not even when they took "Linux" off their home page?

dinotrac wrote:there is nothing contradictory about a corporation fostering a community. Apple does it, Microsoft does it, IBM does it.
And so does Oracle, and so did The SCO Group, despite their best efforts.
Quoting:Not even when they took "Linux" off their home page?


Especially then.
So, you're really talking about Canonical, not Ubuntu?
gus,

SCO was a takeover followed by the name appropriation that gave the wrong impression, because too soon legal blackmail became their business' modus operandi. That was due to Unix not delivering the level of profits they felt they were entitled.
Dino,

You perhaps did not listen to Shuttleworth's rhetoric in the early days. He used the name Ubuntu to promote the distro as having a central role for the community of users. Ubuntu still makes great play of this:

https://wiki.ubuntu.com/CommunityCouncil

The consequence of this was that a large number of people including me took part under that understanding that when major decisions were made that the community would have a serious input into the future of the distro. The community in the process added a large amount of value to the distro. Shuttleworth played both sides of the street on this and in the process pissed off a lot of people including the Debian folks you mention. I think if you suggested to Shuttleworth in those days that his community was analogous to the Microsoft "community" then he would have objected violently. That after all is what Bug #1 was all about.

Ultimately I am not particularly concerned since I will revert to Debian or a Mint variant of same if Shuttleworth continues further along the path he is taking. I just am irritated by his mealy mouthed spin.
I think that the Canonical M$ and his minions sorta MUST set some high expectations for their Baboontu Dev Summit thing out there in Oakland,California this week. Notice the DEV emphasis in this super-hyped hullabaloo rather than on the "Community" and its wonderful LUnity-accepting (more like UNaccepting!) end-users. I agree with dinotrac insofar as just by looking at the corporate sponsors of this, we can see the high stakes Canonical is putting on its "Developer, Developers, Developers, Developers, Developers, Developers, ....." Does that Bug #1 refrain sound familiar to anyone??

2c
Quoting:That said, look at Ubuntu Server. They seem serious about it, and it is a very credible and compelling product.


I respectfully disagree. Red Hat offers 10 years of support and SUSE offers 7. Canonical offers 5 but the server build is useless long before that. Red Hat and SUSE both backport patches and support for new hardware into their enterprise kernels. Canonical doesn't do that with Ubuntu so even a year after release it may just not work with a new server due to lack of hardware support.

In general, I don't see anything compelling about Ubuntu server that isn't available in a much better supported package elsewhere.
Caitlyn,

I did a quick comparison of subscription prices on servers also. I was surprised that RedHat which is the acknowledged market leader with a rather large technical support staff compared to Canonical has pricing apparently little different per server per year.

Surely if you are competing with RedHat you should offer a significantly lower price point? Not that I understand the practicalities of such decisions......
@monte --

You might be surprised. That brand recognition of Ubuntu is worth something.

I've been in several situations where people have recommended Ubuntu servers. I presume personal familarity with Ubuntu is spilling over into server choice. Not so different from the initial growth of Windows NT with one glaring exception: NT grew when Unix servers were expensive non-commodity items costing arms and legs.
@dinotrac: In my business I have run into many Red Hat shops, a fair number of SUSE shops, lots of smaller businesses using CentOS, a few using Scientific Linux, and an occasional Debian installation. I have yet to encounter even one Ubuntu server shop. I have heard of exactly one in this state. Of course, I'm in North Carolina, the home of Red Hat.

My take is that if the IT Manager decides the Ubuntu hasn't got a chance. If the admins have free run then you never know what might turn up. I remember replacing Gentoo with Red Hat in one place some years back. Management was terribly unhappy that an admin had put Gentoo on any of their servers. Miraculously he didn't get fired even when he objected to Red Hat at every turn.
I would bet that Ubuntu is getting no uptake in real professional IT shops.

Web startups might be a different matter. They aren't often blessed with that professional outlook.
Quoting:I was surprised that RedHat which is the acknowledged market leader with a rather large technical support staff compared to Canonical has pricing apparently little different per server per year.
Quoting:In my business I have run into many Red Hat shops, a fair number of SUSE shops, lots of smaller businesses using CentOS, a few using Scientific Linux, and an occasional Debian installation. I have yet to encounter even one Ubuntu server shop. I have heard of exactly one in this state. Of course, I'm in North Carolina, the home of Red Hat.


These pair of comment snippets bring back some recollection of Red Hat's mutually reciprocal antipathy towards Ubuntu in the written piece of less than two years ago, 'Ubuntu Empire Strikes Back', linked to LXer via http://lxer.com/module/newswire/view/139397

As author Susan Linton wrote:
Quoting:The old "Ubuntu doesn't contribute back" argument cropped up again when Dave Neary released a report of the talk he gave at GUADEC on the contributions made to the GNOME desktop environment. He found that Red Hat and Novell contributed the most, and that Ubuntu and Mandriva (primarily a KDE distribution) were among the lowest. A firestorm of debate ensued, and Shuttleworth was accused of name calling and guilt to try to win the argument.

The report spurred reactions from many community members, and their responses usually depended upon which side of the fence they sat. Greg DeKoenigsberg, former Red Hat Community Architect, held no punches in his scathing criticism of Canonical and Ubuntu. He said Canonical was little more than "marketing organization masquerading as an engineering organization" taking "credit for code that Red Hat engineers wrote." Debian developers have been saying that for years about their work, but as a primarily KDE distro they didn't make the Top 20 list at all, so it appears they are staying out of this fight. Other distribution developers have been overheard expressing the same sentiments as well. DeKoenigsberg even touched on another one of Mark Shuttleworth's battle cries that really rally his troops while rubbing most of the Open Source community against the grain. He said, "they have the gall to suggest that Red Hat should change its release schedules to make it even easier for them to ride the gravy train.".....


Indeed. One could even expect that this mutual antipathy between Red Hat and Canonical will no doubt continue, especially between their respective supporters. This, surrounding the facts of Ubuntu's latest server offering.





> I would bet that Ubuntu is getting no uptake in real professional IT shops.

And with the financial problems and then sale of Novell, I'd bet SuSE uptake has seen a severe drop in favor of Red Hat.

Managers don't like to bet on a product they think may not be around in 2 years.
Quoting: ...but the server build is useless long before that


I am not sure what you mean by that, do you mean a Linux that is supposed to run for ever it suddenly becomes useless?

Quoting:Canonical doesn't do that {backport patches} with Ubuntu so even a year after release it may just not work with a new server due to lack of hardware support.


It would have been more convincing if a link was furnished.

Quoting:Of course, I'm in North Carolina, the home of Red Hat.


Very appropriate disclosure. And if I am not mistaken, I believe you mentioned some where else that you worked for Red Hat previously, so you could be better informed about RH than Ubuntu.

I agree with Dino about the "personal familiarity spilling" thing, you could be a proof of that. :-)

When I read the title of the thread, I imagined Mark Shuttleworth as Ubuntu's # 1 bug...

Quoting:I am not sure what you mean by that, do you mean a Linux that is supposed to run for ever it suddenly becomes useless?
No, I mean if it doesn't support current hardware, meaning any server a company is likely to buy, it is useless.
Quoting:It would have been more convincing if a link was furnished.
Or you could look at any Ubuntu LTS kernel and see for yourself. http://dag.wieers.com/blog/ubuntus-need-to-catch-a-wave
Quoting:And if I am not mistaken, I believe you mentioned some where else that you worked for Red Hat previously, so you could be better informed about RH than Ubuntu.
Not exactly. I worked as a consultant for Red Hat but I was a third party contractor for seven months. I was offered a permanent position but the nearly 100% travel schedule was simply too much for me.
With all due DISRESPECT for your casting aspersions and assuming that I an 1) not knowledgeable about Ubuntu and 2) speaking from personal bias:
Quoting:I agree with Dino about the "personal familiarity spilling" thing, you could be a proof of that. :-)
In a word: no.

p.s.: Dino never made such an accusation leveled at me.
Quoting:Or you could look at any Ubuntu LTS kernel and see for yourself


I don't claim to be knowledgeable about Ubuntu LTS kernel and I am not sure I can or need to determine anything, and thanks for the very informative.

So your point is pretty much an expansion on the article's main point quoted below:

Quoting: So what are you getting at ?

The sheer manpower to do this, together with new development and bugfixing for 4 different RHEL versions is something that Canonical/Ubuntu simply cannot take upon it. Even Novell does not support that many released versions in the way Red Hat does.

So ?

So Mark's article is wishful thinking and hoping to ride the wave that Red Hat (and Novell) are funding. If he can use that same kernel, with the same backports, fixes and regressions tests, Ubuntu LTS does not need to do anything to support the same vendor hardware. Easy, but at the expense of both Novell and Red Hat.


To me, what he is saying is that, Canonical is trying to piggyback RH kernel to avoid hiring developers to do its own since it would be too costly for them. I believe that is different than Canonical doesn't furnish such support.

Quoting:With all due DISRESPECT for your casting aspersions


Casting aspersions on anyone is never in my intentions. Sorry you took it that way.

All what I was saying is that you are more familiar with RH than with Ubuntu and because of that your are more inclined to gravitate towards using RH instead of Ubuntu.

Actually, it's been pretty well documented that Ubuntu LTS does not use the Red Hat kernel, which is why the hardware support deteriorates over time. Again, if it doesn't work on current servers it's pretty well useless to most enterprise customers. What Dag wrote is, unfortunately, not 100% accurate.

If that has changed recently, as in Ubuntu 12.94 LTS, my information may be out of date,

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post