Advanced

User Suggests There Might be Spyware in Ubuntu, Instructs Others to Compile the OS

Posted by hanuca on · 6 comments
Softpedia; By Marius Nestor
Mail this story
Print this story

A user by the name of Zack Smith, published an article on his website entitled "Is There Spyware in Ubuntu?" and targeted at Canonical, the sponsor of Ubuntu, and Jane Silber, the CEO of Canonical.

This is not the first time someone is accusing Ubuntu of spying on users, as three years ago Richard Stallman called Ubuntu a spyware OS because of the integration of Amazon Search engine that collected users' desktop search activity and sent the data over to Amazon.

According to Zack Smith, the Ubuntu Linux operating system should not be trusted because of Canonical's new CEO, Jane Silber, whose previous job was at the C4 Systems division of General Dynamics within the US Military Industrial Complex, which focuses on using computers for spying.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (6)

...but is a little paranoia wise?

Ubuntu is a product produced by Canonical, not a community project built on principles. With a majority share of the Linux desktop pie, desire to produce their own components, and drive to produce mobile device platforms it's clear they would like to lockin users and monetize them. Many other popular distributions piggy back off Ubuntu's binaries and infrastructure, I'm sure Canonical wouldn't mind spinning a buck from all of them as well. There's no way to easily verify the binaries they distribute are produced from the provided source code, or that the source code is thoroughly scrutinized or scrutinized as a whole since lots of little innocuous things across a range of packages could add up to a nefarious whole.

Purely speculative of course. A little paranoia could be wise, just how trustworthy is Canonical? The trust given to them could be a very valuable resource to exploit. Those leeching off Canonical should consider some due diligence with compiling and distributing their own binaries or considering a different upstream (I've always wondered why Debian Mint doesn't get much love from Mint users).
All that's necessary for a headline (click bait) story these days is simply an assumption or allegation, with no direct evidence to support it.

However, Canonical has definitely fed these concerns with their selling of users' search queries.
I have posted this link to the ubuntu forum, and it was immediately 'moved' to the 'Recurring Discussions' ;) : http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=2277914
> I have posted this link to the ubuntu forum, and it was immediately 'moved' to the 'Recurring Discussions'

... where a baboon2 fanboi insisted the party line that "Ubuntu patches of the kernel do not have spyware...only improvements that make ubuntu run better"

Sure they're just "improvements" ::rolling eyes::

2c
It's far more likely that Redhat Enterprise Linux (and therefore also it's clones) has backdoors given that the NSA is a major customer of Redhat and that RHEL is extensively used in businesses all over the world (therefore in loads of interesting targets for the NSA).
> It's far more likely that Redhat Enterprise Linux (and therefore also it's clones) has backdoors given that the NSA is a major customer of Redhat and that RHEL is extensively used in businesses all over the world (therefore in loads of interesting targets for the NSA).

Good point. But then there's also Canonical's recent announcement of their partnership with MS for developing IOT devices...

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post