Advanced

LXer update: The voting system has been redone

Posted by dave on · 12 comments
LXer; By Dave Whitinger
Mail this story
Print this story

The voting system at LXer has been completely re-written and has many new options, as well as features. Click to find out more.

Prior to now, readers could vote on stories, but they only get two choices: "Yay" or "Nay", nothing else. This has caused a lot of confusion as to what the votes really mean. Following the advice of some of the readers, I have implemented a new voting system that solves some current problems, and is scalable to include even more abilities in the future.

The first thing you'll notice is that the system now asks you to vote on a number of factors:

  1. Did you like and/or agree with the actual content of this story?
  2. Should this even have been posted to LXer?
  3. Would you want to see more stories from this source and author?

You may abstain from voting on as many of the question as you like. Abstained votes do nothing to the score of the article.

Once you have voted, your scores are figured up and the score of the article is adjusted accordingly. Furthermore, we can use the voting data to more accurately decide which stories were inappropriate for the newswire, and adjust our editorial review process accordingly.

You will notice that all the votes that you cast in the old system have been copied over to the new system. As a result of the new system offering additional choices, I had to put something into all the fields. Therefore, if you previously voted negatively on a story, the new vote reflects all 3 choices as negative. You may easily go back and change any vote done in the past, to correct this, if you wish. Just go back to the story, and click on the Vote link.

I think this will be a fun feature, and I hope you do, too. As always, if you have any more suggestions on the voting system, or any other feature of LXer, please do let me know.

Dave

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Announcements; Groups: LXer

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (12)

How does the Bar char work now

I voted on a few stories below to see what happened to the little bar chart. It looks like it only considers Content, is this correct and if yes I think that is probably OK. My voting windows is too small when it opens. Anyone else has this issue?

Otherwise good move
My voting windows is too small when it opens. Anyone else has this issue?

Yes, same problem here. It isn't tall enough to even show the submit button without resizing, and it could also be widened a bit too.
dave Story submitter ·
Quoting:It looks like it only considers Content, is this correct and if yes I think that is probably OK.


That was correct last night, but it was a bug. It should have been considering all three questions, and as of this morning it does.

As to the window size: I always vote in a new tab, which gives me a full size window. Would you prefer that I just make it full size? I'm also considering removing the target attribute so as to make the voting occur in the same window in which you clicked. Thoughts against that?

dave
The screen din't size right on small resolutions. 800x600, 1024x768 etc.

The probelm with opening a new tab automatically, is not everyone has tabs.

A full screen window

or

is there a way to make the content smaller? There is a ton of wasted space on my vote screens even at 800x600
I love Tabs but for the voting I think I prefer a new window. The reason is that voting is something you do and then its over. A window preferably sized correctly lend itself better to this mindset.

A tab is something you keep open for a while, maybe to read later or use as an info backgrounder while reading another item. At least this is how I use them
dave Story submitter ·
I've set it up so that the new window will be the same size as the parent window from which it was opened. That should help.

dave

I notice the HTML connection to CSS was fixed as well

Thanks, now I can have readable bylines as well as my low-eyestrain theme.
dave Story submitter ·
You're very welcome. :)
What? You mean the warning I keep getting in my javascript console?

Warning: The stylesheet http://lxer.com/inc/lxer.css was loaded as CSS even though its MIME type, "text/html", is not "text/css".

(I still get this error)
dave Story submitter ·
Thanks tzafrir, this should be fixed now, too.

dave

So far I like it

However, I have had to abstain several times on one issue or another.

I think you pulled it off more successfully than I thought possible, hence, my comments after your showing interest urged caution.

I am glad to say I was wrong.
dave Story submitter ·
Thank you for the kind words! :)

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post