Advanced

Microsoft Breakup Imminent? GNU/Linux Wins

Posted by tadelste on · 47 comments
LXer.com; By Tom Adelstein
Mail this story
Print this story



Who will buy the pieces of Microsoft after the final breakup? No one would want the operating system. A leveraged buyout for the Office group seems likely. Oracle looks like the winner in the business services business and it's the auction block for the rest of the company. The DRM and codecs go to Real Networks.

Text of the CDC v IBM case in the article body.

With Ballmer threatening to sue for intellectual property violations, what would become of Linux? Who would become destined for the Computer History Museum at Mountain View? If anybody cared, then it would be Microsoft taking its place in the museum way back where no one could see it.

Can you think of any villain in today's genre comparable to Microsoft?

So in a interview with Forbes Ballmer does his "Paper Machines and Phantom Computers" routine.



Well, I think there are experts who claim Linux violates our intellectual property. I'm not going to comment. But to the degree that that's the case, of course we owe it to our shareholders to have a strategy. And when there is something interesting to say, you'll be the first to hear it.


This is the same kind of thing for which IBM wound up in an anti-trust action in 1968 and something for which Judge Sporkin blasted Microsoft in his 1995 edict:


"This Court cannot ignore the obvious. Here is the dominant firm in the software industry admitting it `preannounces' products to freeze the current software market and thereby defeat the marketing plans of competitors that have products ready for market. Microsoft admits that the preannouncement is solely for the purpose of having an adverse impact on a competitor's product. Its counsel states it has advised its client that the practice is perfectly legal and it may continue the practice. This practice of an alleged monopolist would seem to contribute to the acquisition, maintenance, or exercise of market share. . . . February 14, 1995


Microsoft admits that the preannouncement is solely for the purpose of having an adverse impact on a competitor's product. Microsoft's lawyers said it was perfectly legal. Now that Vista has a projected date of February 2007, do you wonder if they have announced their product for the past 2.5 years to freeze people from going to the competition?

Note: Unfortunately, the entire text of Civil Action No.: 3-68-312 ControlData Corporation, Plantiff, vs International Business Machines, Defendant does not exist on the Internet at least anywhere reasonably available. However, we have reproduced for our readers' consideration, the text of section 23 items (a)-(e) with the original commentary from the complaint.

Pay particular attention to item (c) and consider if that looks familiar to you in today's situation.



EXCLUSIONARY PRACTICES.
23. Defendant IBM, directly and through its subsidiaries, has willfully acquired and maintained monopoly power in the computer markets and submarkets, or has had the specific intent to obtain such power, in that it has consciously, deliberately, or intentionality engaged in the following acts, behavior, conduct and practices, among others:
Development. Delivery, and Performance of hardware and Software— ‘‘Paper Machines and Phantom Computers’

(a) It has misrepresented the status of design, development, production. and performance of certain of its computers, and programs or software for certain computers, particularly with regard to the capabilities and availability of large size computers, time sharing computers, and compatibility between models of computers. all for the purpose or with the effect of depriving customers of the opportunity to accurately evaluate competitive computers, thus obtaining or retaining customers for itself and depriving Plaintiff and other manufacturers of sales;



(b) It has, as a means of obtaining or retaining customers and depriving Plaintiff and other manufacturers of sales, offered to lease, sell, or make delivery of, and has entered into agreements to lease, sell, or make delivery of computers, software or programs which were not yet in production, for which it was not ready to commence production, and as to which it had no reasonable basis for believing that production or delivery could be accomplished within the time periods specified by such offers or agreements;



(c) It has, having prematurely announced and marketed its computers to deprive its competitors of sales and due to computer development and production deficiencies arising from such prematurity, frequently changed and delayed its previously announced or promised delivery schedules as well as announced or introduced changes in, or cancellations of, certain types or models of computers, their specifications and alleged capabilities, thereby creating confusion in the market and, at great cost to its competitors and its customers, deferring procurements until its competitive deficiencies could be discovered or overcome and maximizing its revenues on outdated computers on lease;



(d) It has repeatedly entered into contracts, commitments, and letters of intent in which it was obligated to furnish computers and software and, having deprived its competitors of such sales, has then failed to fulfill the obligations undertaken in such contracts. commitments, and letters of intent;

(e) It has consistently induced customers, upon the execution of a contract with it, or even prior thereto, to expend substantial sums of money preparing data, training personnel, preparing a site for the computer, and preparing for the use of certain software or programs, all for the purpose or with the effect of irrevocably tying the customer to its computer irrespective of actual delivery or performance of the computer or software thereby precluding said customers from acquiring computers from Plaintiff and other manufacturers;

The actions of Defendant IBM alleged in the foregoing subparagraphs (a) through (e) were taken with knowledge of and to take advantage of its dominant position in the computer markets and submarkets, Because of the large dollar investment in computers their complexity, the difficulties of verifying claimed specifications of undelivered products, and a history of rapid technological obsolescence of computers, customers in the computer markets and submarkets readily rely upon representations and promises of Defendant IBM. This is particularly true when the representations concern a new product line of computers allegedly meeting all needs of customers and compatible from smallest to largest.









What course does Microsoft have when it can't deliver its next operating system on time and on budget? They try to scare people from going with GNU/Linux. But perhaps they have been announcing vaporware all along.

A New Face of War: Economics



Analysts have argued that the US and Russia won the battlefields of Europe and Japan in the last world war. I remember footage of Omaha beach among others: The surf ran red with blood of allied troops. The color of the ocean on the beach ran blood red.

But, by the US assisting in the economic recovery of Japan and Germany, we lost the new era of warfare: Economics. The US turned over its manufacturing to those countries. Those countries'enterprises inherited the distribution channels and substituted their products as the producer. The main advantage of the US had to do with distribution. We had more navigable rivers and sea ports than any country in the world and still do.

Our stupid President wanted to let a middle-east country own US ports. People have said that he's ignorant and ridiculous. Now, it's no longer an opinion. He's beyond the worse things his critics can say about him. Here's another thing, I'm a precinct worker and have taken on the job of alternate election judge. I'm a member of the Republic party. So, for me to say this takes some serious risks. I consider our country deserted by my party's leader.

Microsoft should overtly sue Linux for intellectual property violations and do it now or shut up. No one would care much either way. But, Linux has vocal advocates and the Internet. Congress beware. We'll either get what we want or take you down. Did you hear that senator Kennedy? Imagine hundreds of thousands of pissed off Linux advocates digging up your voting records, ties to special interests and trips paid by lobbyists. Keep the DMCA in place and keep the Free Software community in check and see what happens.

Microsoft Survived But Not on Technology Superiority



Think about this scenario. Microsoft gets broken up. Who on earth would covert their operating system? What is it without a monopoly keeping it in place in the market?

All those brilliant commentators invading Free Software community sites will have no rebuttal. Their sound bytes remind me of boxers who have had their brains damaged. They don't know the first thing about Windows desktop extensions and how difficult they are to program and secure the system. Dumb, dumb, dumb.

How dare those crackers consider themselves technologists. They don't have a clue about how to make an operating system work. All they can say about Windows is "it's still number one and I like it". Well, enjoy your evolved DOS system.

Superior Technology - Linux



Anyone worth their salt as either a userland programmer or a kernel hacker will tell you: GNU/Linux ranks far ahead of Windows technologically. This doesn't even begin to become a sustainable argument for Microsoft's own programmers.

GNU/Linux has inherit benefits and draws the best of the best. As Eric Raymond once wrote:

Hackers are naturally anti-authoritarian. Anyone who can give you orders can stop you from solving whatever problem you're being fascinated by - and given the way authoritarian minds work, will generally find some appallingly stupid reason to do so. ..

Authoritarians thrive on censorship and secrecy. And they distrust cooperation and information-sharing - they only like "cooperation" that they can control. So, to behave like a hacker, you have to develop an instinctive hostility to censorship, secrecy, and the use of force or deception to compel responsible adults.


Is the Break-up of Microsoft Inevitable?



Ask yourself how long a monopoly can continue to disrupt the market, export jobs and fail to deliver? The exporting of jobs bothers me the most. Conservatives and Liberals have to take this on as a bi-partisan effort.

I really do not mind Intel and IBM helping less developed countries establish technology to benefit the people in those places. I do mind Microsoft and others sending jobs overseas and then bringing the products back to sell to our own people. I consider that treason, especially with chronic unemployment among the technology industry.

Yesterday, I went to a CompUSA to ask about a Linux computer. Linspire says that CompUSA will sell thier products. Ooops! "We don't do Linux at CompUSA". Yet, I watched a salesman telling a customer how great Windows XP Pro would work on the $3000 laptop computer the customer wanted. Having studied the market, I know the system. It came from Taiwan. IT cost the people who put their label on the system approximately $300.

Hello Consumer affairs division of the Attorney General's office. You will get a visit from me on Tuesday. Everyone get ready. The longest journey begins with but a single step: quote from Asian enlightened master.

Hey you screwballs who apologize for my activism. Soon.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (47)

Here's an article on the problems of monopoly production.

It may seem long, but it's well worth while reading. Think about the Microsoft Monopoly, and especially the excuses used to justify it, while you read.

http://www.mises.org/story/2088

The Production of Security, by Gustave de Molinari
Bob, Thanks for the link. A good read.

I don't want to see Microsoft broken up

1 earlier comment in the full thread.

I want to see Microsoft broken up. It should have already happened but your friend George Bush got lobbied so hard by Ralph Reed that when Bush took office they back off.

Break them up.

tadelste:

I have never been able to figure out the justification the appeals court used for tossing out the judgment against Microsoft. A judge talks to reporters so the court allows the basis of years of criminal activity to continue?

After that we have the (alleged) Depart of Justice _winning_ a case and suddenly wanting to strike a deal with the defeated criminal. The deal lets the criminal take part in overseeing the criminal activity, and decide, unilaterally, whether any particular part of the "punishment" may be ignored. It's no wonder that OEMs have been tripping over each other since 2002 to be the first to offer other operating systems pre-installed.
Quoting:I have never been able to figure out the justification the appeals court used for tossing out the judgment against Microsoft.


Lol... No kidding.
M-O-N-E-Y to get GWB elected and to help him win S. Carolina where my brothers (in spirit) believed they were voting for a man of faith. They want to put his Library three blocks from my house. There goes the neighborhood.

OK, I've written a lot of articles on the Ralph Reed-Jack Abramoff-Preston Gates-BSA-GOP connections. Why else would the verdict go away? Can you think of a plausible reason?

M-O-N-E-Y!
Maybe it can be investigated when Clinton is back in the White House.
Checks and balances only work when there is a difference in thinking among the various parts of the U.S. federal government. When each branch acts as a rubber-stamp for each other branch, it leads to a government of itself and for itself.

We have 2 parties: incumbents and non-incumbents. We need to keep shuffling the members of those two parties so that they understand they are temp workers and so that they do not have time to sell their services to the bidders that we can't match.
> We need to keep shuffling the members of those two parties so that they understand they are temp workers and so that they do not have time to sell their services to the bidders that we can't match.

I'd suggest something more radical than that. Make congress an assigned position, chosen by random lottery. Every qualified citizen's name gets put in the hat, and the unlucky winner has to go to Washington for 2 or 6 years to serve his fellow citizens. Sort of like the draft with no option of serving multiple terms.
jdixon,

Your suggestion would solve the problem of giving too much power to the political parties that term limits cause, but it would essentially turn the country into a nation run by the bureaucracy.

Think about it, every two years Washington gets flooded with eager young congress critters, fresh off their service lottery ‘wins’ to serve their term. They show up in D.C. scratching their heads, wondering what to do. Well don’t worry the Congressional staff is there to guide them and show them. All of their problems and conflicts will be resolved if the just follow the plan.

We would pretty much be giving up any representational government and giving control to the bureaucrats that live and work in government full time.

This is why political parties are so keen on automatic term limits. If we limited all politicians to one or two terms, the non-elected parties would hold the real power. Politicians would not be able to build up the war chests of campaign funds for themselves, and would instead have to go to the party for financial backing and campaign foot soldiers. The candidates would become cogs in a machine, disposed of and replaced like party officials in the old Soviet states.

If a particular Congress member proved highly popular, they might make the cut and get run for the Senate position for their party, but only if they were a good party member and not a trouble maker.

Oh, there might still be a few billionaires who finance their own campaigns. Like the former Senator from Illinois, Peter Fitzgerald. He was a Republican and kept promoting fiscal responsibility, ethics reform, and a lot of real law and order stuff. His strong stance on these issues made him very unpopular with the current administration, he was considered a trouble maker and often demonized by the talk show media. Although Peter Fitzgerald is not related to the federal prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, He is the Senator who nominated Patrick Fitzgerald for the position. He nominated him based on his record, not on his work for the party. Patrick Fitzgerald is the prosecutor in the Abrahamoff trial.

Compare that to the head of FEMA who was nominated to his position because he was a good party fund raiser.

No, the solution is really simpler than you think. People actually have to start voting. And they have to vote based on the strengths and weaknesses of individual candidates. They have to vote the bad ones out of office and keep the good ones in as long as they stay effective.

Automation of the process with term limits or mandatory random service is not the solution.

Participation is the solution.

> Well don’t worry the Congressional staff is there to guide them and show them.

This assumes you have a continuous duty Congressional staff. There's no reason we should have one now, and no reason to have one in the future. However, I agree that the entreched bureaucracy is and will continue to be a problem.

> People actually have to start voting. And they have to vote based on the strengths and weaknesses of individual candidates.

I've seen no evidence that anyone who can make it through the party system is actually worth voting for, nor any evidence that this can change (for example, I don't see the Republicans ever again allowing a Reagan to make it through the system). And given how the parties stack the deck against third party candidates, I don't see them as a viable alternative either (I'll continue to vote third party, but I don't expect them to win).

So, if you expect voting to actually change anything, you're probably going to be disappointed.

Personally, I see the existing process continuing and resulting in the eventual economic collapse of the US, probably ushering in a totalitarian state. Hopefully I'm wrong.
grouch said:
Quoting:We need to keep shuffling the members of those two parties so that they understand they are temp workers and so that they do not have time to sell their services to the bidders that we can't match.


Makes no difference... The two party system stopped working long ago. This is just the same snake with a different head. -------

number6x, sorry to burst your bubble, but the country already 'is' a bureaucracy. Look around you ;-). -------

jdixon, That's pretty much my assessment too. Far to late for the voters to do much of anything. All those years of defaulting the vote have finally caught up and lately, it is like "we have seen the enemy, and they is us."

There is only one party in this country, republican and yet to be elected republican.

There will never be another democratic President, why? Because all a republican has to do to get elected is say "Gay Marriage, if you don't vote for me there will be men kissing in church."

Every conservative in this country will vote for that person, regardless of political affiliation.

One party, one branch, one people.

Simple isn't it? Just the way they like it.
Jimf,

I live in Chicago, the city that works.

We have no problem with our government.

Benevolent dictatorships aren't really too bad, once you get the retraining and therapy treatments !

:)

Sounds like its time to revolt.
number6x,

I lived in Chicago for 30 years, and I know just how well it 'works', and how 'Benevolent' it is. Kenosha may not work much better, but at least in WI they don't tax the food :-).
Yeah tell me about it.

I took me 13 months to get a permit to add a dormer to my house. I actually obeyed the law and did it all the correct way.

At every level, at least one person let me know there were easier ways, all it would take is cash.

I remeber sitting in our alderman's office with my pregnant wife. The alderman asked us why we needed more room? She could see that my wife was pregnant. Her office helpers were the ones who would offer to "expedite" the permit process for us.

My wife and I enjoyed working against that alderman in her bid for re-election. Her defeat was especially rewarding. What goes around comes around. We were not the only people fed up with her!

It works if we participate and stick to our principles.
Well, that is true on most 'local' government levels. But, I've got to say that it's much less intense living up here. I've never regreted making the move.
My dad lives just west of Kenosha county, on Powers lake. He's just about a stone's throw from the county line.

Nice country, I hope all the development does't ruin it.
My belief is that the party system is the source of the problem. Why should we, as constituents, be limited to only two viable candidates? Why should the Democratic and Republican parties be written into our laws? How much power have they gained by limiting our choices?

An excerpt from President George Washington's farewell address http://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc.php?flash=old&doc=15&page=tr... ...

Quoting:I have already intimated to you the danger of parties in the State, with particular reference to the founding of them on geographical discriminations. Let me now take a more comprehensive view, and warn you in the most solemn manner against the baneful effects of the spirit of party generally.

This spirit, unfortunately, is inseparable from our nature, having its root in the strongest passions of the human mind. It exists under different shapes in all governments, more or less stifled, controlled, or repressed; but, in those of the popular form, it is seen in its greatest rankness, and is truly their worst enemy.

The alternate domination of one faction over another, sharpened by the spirit of revenge, natural to party dissension, which in different ages and countries has perpetrated the most horrid enormities, is itself a frightful despotism. But this leads at length to a more formal and permanent despotism. The disorders and miseries which result gradually incline the minds of men to seek security and repose in the absolute power of an individual; and sooner or later the chief of some prevailing faction, more able or more fortunate than his competitors, turns this disposition to the purposes of his own elevation, on the ruins of public liberty.

Without looking forward to an extremity of this kind (which nevertheless ought not to be entirely out of sight), the common and continual mischiefs of the spirit of party are sufficient to make it the interest and duty of a wise people to discourage and restrain it.

It serves always to distract the public councils and enfeeble the public administration. It agitates the community with ill-founded jealousies and false alarms, kindles the animosity of one part against another, foments occasionally riot and insurrection. It opens the door to foreign influence and corruption, which finds a facilitated access to the government itself through the channels of party passions. Thus the policy and the will of one country are subjected to the policy and will of another.
Quoting:Maybe it can be investigated when Clinton is back in the White House.


Clinton? Nope.

But John McCain? Now, you have something. Do you think he will forget Ralph Reed and Microsoft in South Carolina from the 2000 campaign?

Revenge is best served cold.
Hello. I'm currently monitoring this site and will henceforth. While we do not want to have the appearance of policing the site or restraining creative thought, we will work within certain guidelines as do most news organizations.

Based on our terms of service, most of these posts are prohibited from the site. I will act in accordance with our terms of service and moderate these posts in the future.

If you did not read our terms of service when you signed up, then let's look at an excerpt.:

Do not place any material on our service that could be considered offensive, indecent, abusive, hateful, harassing, libelous, profane, vulgar or unlawful. Our audience tends to be professional in nature, and we have the right, but not the obligation, to remove, edit, or relocate any content that we feel violates the standards of our site. Because of the real-time nature of our forums, it is not always possible for us to remove offensive material immediately.

Also:

Discussion and debate of a political or religious nature is not allowed on the site.

Discussions exist on the web site in the comments section. Any political or religious debate occurring here will face moderation in the future. No one has immunity from the terms of service including editors, authors and moderators.

If you have a political statement which you wish to make, use the article submission form. Otherwise, you can expect deletion of comments.

You can reach me through internal email if you have any comments.



One Senario

I really like the tone of this piece Tom. Certainly you describe one entirely possible scenario. One that is both enlightening and frighting at the same time. Whether it is the 'likely' one is perhaps another matter. I would certainly be looking to soon divest myself of any MS stocks, but....

You said:
Quoting:Ask yourself how long a monopoly can continue to disrupt the market, export jobs and fail to deliver? The exporting of jobs bothers me the most. Conservators and Liberals have to take this on as a bi-partisan effort.


Whoever started the 'outsourcing' concept, should, quite literally, be strung up for high treason. I feel the frustration, but, we've seen how long people will put up with even more frustrating situations, and, that is obviously a 'very' long time. 'Logic' has always said that this can't go on much longer, but history says it can. As you've said yourself visions of the future are very tenuous indeed, and, justice is rare.

I do think that if MS can't produce something viable in another 8 months, what you envision is indeed likely. Where Linux goes from there is anyone's guess. I'm not sure it is all for the good, but, it can't get any worse... can it? ;-)
It can get worse if we let it. We get outraged and all that. But other people don't understand it. They call us a vocal minority, etc.

Contrary to people who think otherwise, we have to take our outrage into the market and rub it off on others. I wanted to yell in CompUSA " you people are getting hosed".

I called SBC because I had trouble with my email. I wound up in India with a girl named Rachel who passed me on to Jerry Johnson in level two support. Rachel? Jerry? How about Ranjana and Kahlil?

Now, I happen to speak Hindi and I got them going a bit.

Here's what I can't understand: we had call centers set up all over the Texas in little towns where we gave people who had no hope, jobs. They earned $2 more than they're paying the Indians in New Delhi. WTF?

We've all bad had experiences like that. Sometime I'll tell you of my experience with Lexmark ;-). The problem with outsourcing is by no means limited to Linux. or indeed the common man in countries like GB, or Germany. The big corporations are striping all the jobs out of the home country and sending them (usually) to the far east to save a few pennies. citizens are now treated as second class both as employees and as customers... Raped coming and going. Even worse, Government usually promotes and supports it. Sold out... that doesn't even begin to cover it.

People have been aware of what's happening for a long time and have done nothing. Bushites have, in fact, encouraged Corporations to sell us down the tubes. The whole situation needed to be resolved years ago, and, my real fear is that it is far too late to recover from this. We are already, truly, screwed no matter what we do now.
Excerpts from a Stallman interview on Kerneltrap.org:

"You know, it's no coincidence that we're having all this outsourcing. That was carefully planned. International treaties were designed to make this happen so that people's wages would be reduced."

'FTAA. The World Trade Organization. NAFTA. These treaties are designed to reduce wages by making it easy for a company to say to various countries, "which of you will let us pay people the least? That's were we're headed."'

"Businesses very often do it, they move operations out of a country to punish that country."

'Corporations are too powerful now. We have to knock them down. I don't believe in abolishing business or even in abolishing corporations, but we've got to make sure that no corporation is powerful enough that it can say to all the countries in the world, "I'll punish any country that doesn't obey."'

BTW, I think of that interview as "Understanding RMS 101". http://kerneltrap.org/node/4484/18389
He's mostly right. But, it's not to punish a country. It's for M-O-N-E-Y!!!!!
grouch:

I don't diagree that international treaties have that effect, and were even intended to, and implemented with the desire to. OTOH, for a lot of those countries, the pay level that turns out to be the least is also better than lots of people there have ever had.

FYI, a couple friends are now complaining about the cost of living skyrocketing in Bangalore. Rent on apartments has doubled in the past 3-4 years. Where will US companies go next? Nigeria?
The point, for whatever reason, is to level the playing field. Eventually, they want everyone to work for cheap.
Did you mean enslave people?
You mean there are people in this world who would try to do something as vile as that? ...
jimf - Your joking aren't you? I guess you are not aware of Con(man)do Rice's big accomplishment in Nigeria? Well go to the BBC and you will see it leaves an unstable situation when those under the boot see they have little or nothing to lose.

Have you noticed why their is a premium built into the price of crude oil, part of is attributable to the perceived unreliability of the continued, unhindered flow of Nigerian crude. And others ...
Cynical is more like it ;-)

FUD and Treason

Adelstein: >"Microsoft admits that the preannouncement is solely for the purpose of having an adverse impact on a competitor's product."

Ballmer: >"Well, I think there are experts who claim Linux violates our intellectual property. I'm not going to comment. But to the degree that that's the case, of course we owe it to our shareholders to have a strategy. And when there is something interesting to say, you'll be the first to hear it."

Ballmer's comments appear to be preannouncement of vaporware lawsuits for the purpose of having an adverse impact on Linux. Instead of vaporware, we have vaporsuits. Of course Microsoft may do lawsuits-by-proxy. Such actions could have an adverse impact on Microsoft's battles in Europe, Korea, etc., though.

Adelstein: >"I do mind Microsoft and others sending jobs overseas and then bringing the products back to sell to our own people. I consider that treason, especially with chronic unemployment among the technology industry."

Some historical context for Microsoft and treason:

http://newsvac.newsforge.com/newsvac/03/02/28/1631236.shtml?...

'NZheretic writes "In May, under oath at the antitrust hearing Jim Allchin, group vice president for platforms at Microsoft, stated that disclosing the Windows operating system source code could damage national security and even threaten the U.S. war effort. http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,3959,5264,00.asp

Now in February, Microsoft signed a pact with Chinese officials to reveal the Windows operating system source code. http://news.zdnet.com/2100-3513_22-990526.html

Bill Gates even hinted that China will be privy to all, not just part, of the source code its government wished to inspect. Either Jim Allchin lied under oath, to prevent code revelation being any part of the settlement, OR the Microsoft corporation is behaving traitorously, by exposing national security issues to foreign governments"'

It looks like we have a corollary to "a leopard never changes his spots" -- a weasel never changes his tactics. Microsoft relies on just about anything except technological advances to maintain their market domination.

Yep. And when Bill Gates made a trip to the White House, the first anti-trust action in waiting went away after Gates went to China and got Windows named the national computer system. No connection, of course, Clinton got tons of money from the Chinese put into the Democratic coffers and of course, we had the sell of nuclear secrets transferred to the Chinese,

No connection.

This stuff exists in several documented articles under "features" at the top of the page.

We even broke the Abramoff story months before it got around and people were saying ah that's nothing. I saw Fred Barnes burn Morton Kondracke about it. Well to all those genius commetators in the public media - raspberries!

smiley icons

I didn't read the article because I told myself I will never again read anything the assbag ballmers says.

but if he did say that he must mean that useful patent they have on those similey icons.

I doubt vista will be out next year

it's nothing but marketing hype and he needs to keep it pumping for his stock holders.

I am sure his stock holders were not too happy with the previous article about why would anybody buy his os when there is linux.

why would I want to waste time with his os when there are so many linux distributions out that let me just install and get on with my work. no wasted downtimes with viruses, spyware, and tojans.

anybody that calls me up now with windows problems I tell them I don't do windows but I will surely help them install linux and show them how an os is suppose to be and that you don't have to reinstall four or five times a year. who has time for that anyway.

I converted two of my neighbors recently and they love linux and are never going back to windows. so put them in all those stats that show microsoft owning the desktop.

Viruses Instability Spyware Trojans Adware = VISTA
jsusanka: I enjoyed your post. It's very clever and pretty straight forward. But now that Gates got his windfall of $600,000 extra from the dividend because Bush got the dividend tax rate lowered, the rest of those guys could care less about their shareholders. That's my opinion based on having been in executive suites myself. Public companies could care less about their shareholders. In fact, they joke about their shareholder's stupidity for buying their stock.

I'm not making it up. I've seen the market manipulated for stocks many times by insiders. They will make news worse while they sell short (don't say they can't sell short - they use shills). They will make things better so they can sell their options.

I once knew a guy who contacted the investment banking arm of a major Wall Street banker and asked if the rumor of a hostile take over of HSN had any credibility. The stock went from 3 1/8 to 9 7/8 almost over night and stayed there. All it took was one call to the right person.

may be not

I am not so sure whether I'd like to see MS broken up. I agree, that I've never quite understood why MS got away another time. I also agree that MS gets a lot of political backing - most probably due to lobbying and the odd amount of money spend from time to time. So, in the past, I was a proponent of breaking up Microsoft.

But nowadays?

The monopoly is getting more and more into their own way. They get into legal trouble all over the world. That combined with unpleasant experiences while using their software makes more and more people rather grumpy. The success of firefox proves that quite a lot people are willing to switch if the alternative seems to be working properly (the perceived value is most important here. IMHO Mozilla has been no worse than firefox so the sudden success was rather strange. The same applies to linux which is still attributed to be complicated and troublesome). Furthermore concerning the legal troubles: The official reaction of MS in the legal fight here in the EU furthermore adds to them appearing arrogant and unwilling to accept anything else than their own standards. I guess the very unhelpful comment to withdraw Windows if sued in Korea doesn't bode well with the Koreans (government and population alike) either.

Furthermore Microsoft is fat and immobile due to their monopoly and their desperate attempt to combine more and more products in order to keep their monopoly. That's our biggest chance. Vista get's delayed and bloated mostly because of that. Six years? For what actually? Everything that really would have been an improvement got cancelled - quite some time ago.

Add to this the complex bureaucracy of Microsoft and their divisions - the internal fights about positions, gratifications and whateever. Then I must say: They are much more vulnerable as big and fat as they are than they would be as a bunch of much more agile companies. And this will eventually help Free Software a lot.

There is one thing that is a pity though: MS being monolistic makes it european (BTW: I myself am from Germany), asian and south- and middle-american nationalists easy to point at Microsoft for the wrong reasons. These nationalists damn MS but they actually mean the United States. And though I think there is nothing wrong with _favouring_ regional products over others I do not approve of cheap talk against MS while at the same time protecting national players of our own.

--> Added somewhat later - due to an articel linked at digg (should be on lxer as well):

Even the NYTimes argues today a little bit along similar lines. You can find the article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/27/technology/27soft.html

This article adds the complexity that is caused due to backwards compatibility (due to my experience of unsupported hardware in XP I am not sure whether this argument is actually valid).

Nevertheless this very last line of the article sums it up nicely: 'Unless Microsoft can pick up the pace, "consumers may simply end up with a more and more inferior operating system over time, which is sad," said Mr. Yoffie of the Harvard Business School.'

rittmey: I won't immediately confuse the dislike people have for Microsoft with the dislike they have for the US. In this country some poeple consider Microsoft the ugliest American of them all.

Bring it on Monkey Boy, Bring it on

If Steve Ballmer truly believes there are intellectual property issues between Linux and Microsoft, he needs to put up or shut up. The Linux community has already weathered three years of mud slinging from the folks at The SCO Group, but when push came to shove, it has all been smoke and mirrors. The Judge overseeing the SCO litigation has said they were "astonished by the lack of credible evidence." that SCO has presented.

Microsoft is no stranger to law suits, but it must remember that Linux is not owned by a company with billions in cash reserves that can be tapped into to pay for a quick settlement. Whoever gets sued by Microsoft will have no choice but to fight until a decision is reached in Court. The accused will have the entire strength of the free software community to back them. This is a force that Microsoft has repeatedly failed to compete with in the technical market place. I believe Microsoft will not be able to compete in the legal arena as well.

If Steve Ballmer has actual issues With Linux, he needs to take them to Court, and back them up with some real evidence. Microsoft has often played the schoolyard bully, pushing around business partners and oem's. However this shows that they cannot bully Linux. Here Steve Ballmer plays that annoying little kid who only seems to have something bad to say about others, but never to their face. "Oh, did you know what I heard about Linux? Yeah I think it has intellectual property problems, and Billy told me he thinks Linux still wets the bed, but you didn't hear it from me..."

Until Steve can stand up and make his snide comments in Court, it is just FUD.

Steve Ballmer, put up or shut up.

Unless your too scared :)
I'm afraid that Mr. Ballmer may have some trouble coming his way. The hanky panky that the DoJ has ignored may find not make it past other officials now that IBM is investigating ole Microsoft. Keep you eyes open and wait.

You can buy some politicians some of the time but you can't buy them all any time. Do you think Mr. McCain doesn't know what went on in South Carolina with Microsoft's big bully Ralph Reed?



Microsoft employees call for Ballmer to go

quote : "The diatribe set off a lot of feeling amongst Microsoft employees with several demanding that Ballmer should head the list of people who should be fired from the company. One remarked: 'Being a 10+ year vet I feel ashamed and sad. This company is a mess on so many levels'." http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/85527/microsoft-employees-call-f...
henke54 - read this and others last night, however, there are voices saying this was a good move to avoid bringing out a faulty package. I think that is a valid point. The problem is: how faulty was it that it was recognized releasing it would have been a bigger disaster than delaying it beyond the prime sales season. Moreover, there were references to financial analysts predicting further delays beyond January. The latter is consistent with some other questioners asking if it was so bad a delay was required, how is it going to be fixed in a mere two months more time? I guess it probably will not be if they stick to this revised date.

These views among the rank and file workers at MS can be highly destructive. Combine the negative opinions within MS and those leaving due to politicization of the evaluations, may result in two currents. The first is the flow of the best talent away from MS, both leaving and those never applying. Second the elevation of the louder voices of certainty, without concomitant abilities that cultivate timid supporters. That combination is a death sentence to the creative, because to do something really new results in more failures than successes. MS work force and management will become risk adverse.

What's left: innovative marketing - well they might lose their touch there too. So in the end they will resort to outright thuggery and drive by shootings to get their way. Might I suggest you watch for muzzle flashes when visiting your local Star Bucks where coder types congregate.

Now that's nothing but Innovative, the profit margins would be tremendous, think of all the business they could leverage themselves into: drugs, loan sharking, gun running ...
I'm waiting for the press candy from MS that claims that these anonymous MS employees are not MS employees at all but Linux Zealots(TM).
I think Herschel_Cohen ir right in that MS is really loosing ground and that its management is seemingly unable to even understand their problem. Once their marketing has been the very best in the world. They had to be, the products themselves haven't been innovative enough. But this has changed dramatically. In Germany they advertize for the new Visual Studio with two pictures. The upper showing a frustrated employee doing overtime. The lower showing the same employee being utterly relaxed. Problem is: Both screenshots show VisualStudio. Maybe the one in the lower picture is VisualStudio2005 and the one in the upper VisualStudio.NET 2003 or whateverthey might be named (one doesn't get even this tiny bit of information in the ad). But the message is still strange. Have we to assume, that VisualStudio has been a disaster in its previous releases? Might be true ;-) But why don't they show Eclipse, Borland's IDE or whatever else there is in the market? That's so stupid.

Another point about asttracting talent: In past years (including 2005) Microsoft even got voted as "best employer" (a competition where only the employees themselve decide upon the fate of the company) in Germany and a surprisingly large number of computer science students hold Microsoft in high esteem as a potential employer. Reports about flowing chairs (no matter if true - but, well, it could be true) employee frustrations and so on, will change that.

Not being able to attract or keep the most talented people combined with the fact that there products get more and more complex... Sound like a lot of trouble to me.

And one last thing: Microsoft never had a good track record on quality. So if they delay their core product because of quality problems - well this must be really bad. Could as well be that they changed their attitude and wanted to deliver a better product right from the beginning. But does anybody believe this? So, are their problems that bad?
Have you read the blog comments themselves? There is one that I find particulary interesting. The reason that the end-user Vista has been delayed but not the business Vista is the fact that many Software Assurance contracts end in december 2006. If they don't have a business Vista before 2007, MS will be sued to death by all the companies that were "coerced" into buying SA's from Microsoft under the veil that Vista would be out soon.

It makes perfect sense too. No sane business owner is going to upgrade to Vista when it just launches, especially if the end-user version is still considered "not suitable for consumption". And MS knows it perfectly well (hence the $500 million ad campaign -- if businesses were interested in Vista, they could do with 10% of that). The only reason MS has to bring out Business Vista in end 2006 is to prevent class action lawsuits against them (with probabely the US DoJ getting interested again, because they cannot ingore it anymore at that point).

As for the silver lining: Vista won't be done in 2006 but MS will *have* to bring it out nontheless to avoid the legal trouble. Business Vista 2006 will be so crap and recieve such bad response that it will damage MS permanently. GNU/Linux should be ready to step in at that point. Luckily with Suse Enterprise 10.x, Ubuntu Dapper for Enterprises, a new Red Hat and a couple more enterprise oriented distro's, we seem to be right on track to profit greatly from the vista debackle.

Perhaps someone better in the know should do an article about this (The expiring SA's and the 2006 release). tadelste?

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post