Advanced

Increased Media Chatter Targeting Linux Desktop

Posted by tadelste on Aug 31, 2005 11:22 AM · 26 comments
Lxer; By Tom Adelstein

The media buzz about Linux's alleged failure on the desktop probably means Linux is continuing to take a significant share of Microsoft's market - maybe even more than we think. Why else would the big Redmond company's minions write such claims? Disinformation provides an insight into someone's fears. The noise level has gone up and that probably means Linux is creating trouble for Windows.

Unless you live in an isolated fortress you probably know about "terrorist chatter". Officials in various government agencies say that an increase in traffic on the Internet by known and suspected terrorists often precedes a planned attack. Similarly, anti-Linux chatter often means problems in Redmond. When they feel the heat, that usually signals the start of a disinformation campaign.



Right now, you can see evidence of a classical disinformation campaign against Linux. If you asked me to guess who had commissioned such a campaign, I could think of a few interested parties. One of those parties announced they planned to invest heavily in an advertising campaign at the beginning of 2005. Frankly, I do not know who has sponsored the disinformation. I can only guess.



If we look around then some people seem to have added to the anti-Linux chatter. Peter Galli wrote in a recent Article

Microsoft has once again stirred up a hornets nest in the open-source community, this time approaching the OSDL (Open Source Development Labs) to work with it on a joint, independent research project to do some facts-based analysis of Linux and Windows.


Microsoft's proposing a joint research project with OSDL is like asking someone if they have stopped beating their spouse? Say yes or no and you lose.



So What's the Subject of the Disinformation?



Major media has started a full court press against the Linux desktop. Suddenly, the Linux desktop has become irrelevant and has failed against Microsoft. I don't have to point you to the noted pro-Linux writers who have fed the smoldering fire. You can read the headlines for yourself. "Gartner pours cold water on enterprise Linux desktops" and "Self defeating desktop Linux strategies" or "Cost of abandoning Windows too great for Linux Desktop migration". Then there's the one that states "Linux on the desktop nearly there, but not quite".



One headline states that "Linux is harder to live with, reckons poll" and then goes on to explain Linux actually polls out as less hardware hungry and preferred by the respondents. The same writer states, "Companies find that their Linux server setups are less hardware-hungry than Windows-based systems, if the results of a recent survey are to be believed." Does that mean we're supposed to doubt the survey that favors Linux but believe whole-heartedly in the ones that favor Windows?



You might feel a little concerned when you see these subliminal messages but don't give it too much thought. The message isn't aimed at you. It's aimed at our elected officials and regulators. The propagandists and disinformation junkies have fired shots at governments around the globe who were counting on Linux and Open Source software to help them dig out of their collective piracy status. Even an agency in China yesterday spoke out against the Chinese government's sojourn into Linux. You can read about it in Open opposition. It looks suspiciously like articles that came out when the State of Massachusetts proposed going with open source and Linux.

You might like this too. Have you noticed articles about how countries such as Cuba, Iran, Syria and Viet Nam have all embraced free and open source software and Linux? Those are subliminal messages aimed at our elected officials. What does it say? Open source must be communism and terrorism.



Disinformation is Real and Based on Science



People have proved the phenomenon of social perception exists through real time experimentation. Several variations of Solomon Asch's work involves groups of participants with each entering a conference room. On a black board the instructor draws seven to ten lines of which all are the same length with one noticeably longer than the others. The instructor asks each of the participants which line appears longer. While the fourth line from the left appears measurably longer, each participant says the fifth line. This experiment went on countless times at countless universities and workplaces in the western hemisphere beginning in the early 1950's.



The instructor had secretly told all but one of the participants to say the fifth line appeared longer with one participant having no prior instructions. In over one-third of the cases the answers and influence of the participants affected the unknowing person's perception such that he or she thought they observed the fifth line as the longest. In some studies, all the subjects had their perceptions affected.



While in college, I had a sociology lab class that subjected me to this experiment. When I first entered the room I noted the lines on the board and countered them. When my turn came to answer the instructor's question, I had to count the lines again because I had trouble determining if the fourth line was really the longer. I remember feeling groggy and slightly dazed while I attempted to count the lines. The sensation seemed odd.



I grew interested in perception and eventually got my hands on materials that led me to understand the reticular activator, consumer behavior, political behavior and subsequently disinformation. While I don't use disinformation tactics in my own writing, I can recognize when others do. Conspiracy theorists have identified about 25 activities people can use to spread disinformation. The Wikipedia has an entry on disinformation.



One of those techniques interests me and we have a fairly good example of its use.

"Emotionalize, Antagonize, and Goad Opponents. If you can't do anything else, chide and taunt your opponents and draw them into emotional responses which will tend to make them look foolish and overly motivated, and generally render their material somewhat less coherent. Not only will you avoid discussing the issues in the first instance, but even if their emotional response addresses the issue, you can further avoid the issues by then focusing on how sensitive they are to criticism."


The example I refer to occurred when Microsoft went after Sergio Amadeu of Brazil. In a filing to the Criminal Court of Sao Paulo, Microsoft stated "... Amadeu, President of the National Institute of Information Technology (ITI), aiming at disseminating free software among Ministries, State owned companies and governmental bodies, made aggressive declarations lacking any kind of technical foundation about the use of the software developed by Microsoft... In defending free software, Mr. Amadeu does not abstain from criticizing Microsoft, accusing the company of a 'drug-dealer practice' for offering the operational system Windows to some governments and city administration for digital inclusion programs...These declarations made by Mr. President of the ITI, beyond being absurd and criminal, extrapolate prohibitions and violate duties inherent to the public office the Defendant exercises."



How's that for some serious misdirection? Consider how Sergio Amadeu might have reacted. Did Microsoft focus on how sensitive Sergio was to criticism? Regardless, the next technique Microsoft used was to disappear from the filing.



What's Wrong with The Linux Desktop? Could You Run that By Me Again?



Linux is making significant progress with the desktop. In next month's Linux Journal, for example, you can read an article about Project Utopia where Robert Love explains about how hardware just works now with Linux. He says:





Today, the Project Utopia mindset continues to foster new applications, interesting hacks and fresh projects aimed at making hardware just work. Linux distributions from Novell, Red Hat and others sport powerful HAL-based infrastructures. The GNOME Project is integrating HAL and D-BUS across the board. The Project Utopia cause is spreading beyond GNOME too, as other platforms implement HAL-based solutions in a similar vein.



I feel fortunate to see the success of Linux across the globe. Projects like those in Extemadura Spain say the Linux desktop is robust, practical and the best tool for the developing nations of the world. Commercial Linux vendors like Novell have seen significant uptakes in enterprise Linux. Community oriented projects like Ubuntu have demonstrated how well Linux fits in the rest of the world.



But, I do have to admit that even I resorted to using Windows XP recently. In a Five Star Hotel in a foreign land, I could only get a Microsoft OS to connect to the Internent. The Hotel deployed a 100% Microsoft Active Directory infrastructure. While I was at it, I did find something specific to Microsoft's OS. I could download and watch a pay-for-view movie. That's something that's difficult to do with Linux.



So, Microsoft is capturing the Digital Rights Management Market. You'll need XP to buy those movies. Of course, I forgot to mention that after I watched the movie, I had to run the defragmentation tool to get the system to run again. But, that's a discussion for another day.







Return to the LXer Features

Comments (26)

Vista has entered Beta

Could this just be because vista has entered Beta?

Microsoft has now actually committed to a delivery schedule, and a list of product features that will probably be delivered. Because WinFS, the new CLI, and other more fantastic vaporware have been stripped from vista (although they have kept their vaporware status as being promised "Real Soon Now(tm)"), Microsoft actually has some features for the next version of windows that are sure to be delivered.

Now we can really start to compare what MS will deliver in Vista, and what the competition delivers. Could this just be MS marketing trying to 'come out swining'?

It's still all dis-information, either way.

What will vista give to the desktop user?

They will have some big icons. Like you get with Mac, or some of the Linux desktops.

Their displays will be rendered by some form of page rendering format like NeXT gave us back in 1989. You know like Macs and Linux with NextStep do.

They will have more eye candy and animations. Like on Macs or with KDE or Elightenment on Linux.

IP v6, like Linux has had for years. Well that doesn't have any desktop implications.

Is vista 64 bit yet? Well, nevermind, that doesn't apply to the desktop either.

Oh yeah, they'll have better DRM so third parties can more easily use your computer as a vehicle to sell you things. I think Apple is working on that for 2008, but I think that MS will beat Apple to delivery with this. Is that a desktop item?

So, If you wait till the end of 2006, you will be able to get a Windows desktop that lets you do what Linux and Mac users have been doing for years.

Does vista have different color screens of death, for different kinds of crashes? Blue for a kernel panic, red for a device driver crash, green for memory problem, something like that. I remember reading that new colors for the screens of death would be a feature in Longhorn. Did that make it into vista, or was it left on the cutting room floor?

Linux sure doesn't have that.
I believe you have it: "Vista" entering beta means some free media anyway, why not try to use that free media as a "force multiplier" by getting a few big PR Hits?

Maybe if we aggregate all the possible Wagg-Ed story plants, we could run the text through stuff like the Gender Genie http://www.bookblog.net/gender/genie.html and other algorithms to try to detect common authorship. At the very least, aggregating Wagg-Ed story plants might give us a clue as to what the next Hot, Hot MSFT catchphrase will be. I mean, "enterprise ready apps" is now about as tired as "rich client experience" or "productivity apps".
Clever :)

Good background info

This kind of story always gets me a little confused about how I should react. It could all be true, Or, maybe the writers of some of the referenced stores, particularly the Manek Dubash piece are just not good at drawing conclusions. Isn't there an adage about not attributing to malice what may just be stupidity?

The biggest problem is that these kind of articles can make Linux users seem like conspiracy nuts. Maybe they are out to get us, but I usually just try ignoring nonsense.

I am sorry to see the admission(not the admission really, but what was admitted to) near the end of the story. I had a friend give me a computer recently. It had a Windows XP license with it and I debated briefly about using Windows XP on the machine. Even as a free OS on a machine I just use for crunching numbers, I decided that I don't ever want to run that unreliable excuse for an OS. Ubuntu should do nicely.

Anyway, it is probably good to see this kind of analysis ever once in a while just as a gentle reminder that Linux's main competitor is serious about crushing freedom. Just like any petty dictator.
Severian: One of the foundations of disinformation effectiveness is to make people who recognize it seem like conspiracy nuts.

Disinformation works well because of the "denial mechanism" in our mental makeup. The "they wouldn't do that" perpetuates an organizations effort to crank it out.

Manek Dubash looks like a classic shiller for Microsoft. He didn't even attempt to hide his techniques.

I've come to learn that Microsoft will provide mainstream journalists with accommodations in Redmond. One of my friends (acquaintances) recently spent three days there and came back and wrote a large frontpage special edition in the Business Section praising them. That appeared in the Dallas Morning News.

Apple, IBM, Wordperfect, Lotus, Real, Netscape, Novell, Act and many other companies with 90% market shares have underestimated Microsoft. What makes peole think they won't rise to the occassion and grow even stronger by taking on the Linux challenge? If they win, just think how much bigger and stronger they will become.



Evil eye

I think Tom hits the nail right on the head. As for his experience in being able to download pay-for movies under XP, I was reminded of a recent experience on a Qantas flight. It had an "entertainment center" on board, providing every passenger with a personal video, music and games screen in the back of the seat in front of him.

Nice... until I tried to push those controller buttons a little bit too fast. Called the cabin crew, who re-booted my display unit from the server... I could see the WinCE bootup messages scrolling by.

(Normally you don't see those as a passenger, and I think I know why. Here's to hoping they don't use that technology in their avionics ;-/ )

I am notorious with my colleagues for being able to crash Windows boxes just by walking past and giving them the evil eye. Did that a couple of times during meetings with powerpoint machines just about to be used... Once more confirmed.

:-)
Quoting:I am notorious with my colleagues for being able to crash Windows boxes just by walking past and giving them the evil eye.


Martin - I have never doubted the evil of your eye.

Seriously, though, I think there is a factual basis for a Windows evil eye.

One thing I have noticed is that end-users often collect an internal database of software oddities that they work around, and thus avoid crashes simply by not doing things that they darned well should be able to do.

This became painfully clear to me one year when I moved into a technical writing capacity and worked with people who made heavy use of things like Word, Excel and PowerPoint. I was continually having problems that resulted in answers like,

Yeah. That happens. You need to reboot.

or

That doesn't work. Try this instead.

or

Do you really need to do that?













I have the Windows evil eye, too. I can get Windows (98, NT 4.0, XP) and WIndows programs to totally hose up, in ways that no one has seen before, without too much effort. One of my co-workers has noticed.

Of course, back in the day, I could get programs running under CDC's NOS and NOS/VE operating systems (lamer than you can imagine, lamer than VMS) to hose up in ways that no one had ever seen before, either.

At least if I have source code, I can figure out what I do wrong. Under VMS, NOS, NOS/VE and WIndows flavors, I get a lot of blank looks and "what do you want to do that for?" and "you just can't do that" and "it is NOT buggy" responses.
> Yeah. That happens. You need to reboot. > or > That doesn't work. Try this instead. > or > Do you really need to do that? > Yeah. "You don't need to see his identification. These are not the droids you're looking for." Trust the Force...
> Yeah. "You don't need to see his identification. These are not the droids you're looking for." > Trust the Force...

Egg-zactly!!! ;0)

Linux was not up to snuff until recently.

We can go on about 'potential' benifits but the reality is that KDE 3.3 was not upo to snuff.and KDE 3.4 finally is as well as distros now reading hardware properly.

In the 90's the Linux community was unrealistic and it didnt compete with the Windows desktop as in user freindliness.

Sure their was 'potential' there but that is not solid reality.
Quoting:In the 90's the Linux community was unrealistic and it didnt compete with the Windows desktop as in user freindliness.


Rubbish. The famed Windows "user friendliness" and "intuitiveness" was only and solely a result of the monopoly status of Windows: almost every fool trade rag reporter and nitwit BASIC prorammer had used it.

In the 90s, MSFT released the utterly bogus Windows 3.11 which was no peach for users, and NT 3.0, which had an "interface" modeled after that of 3.11. Remember "progman"? Why did you WIndows Morons need a separate browsers for files and programs? In the 90s, MSFT released Windows 95, whose "user friendliness" led to the enormous plagues of viruses and email viruses we still suffer from today. That's fake "user friendliness", my friend.

Anyone who didn't come from a solid, Windows/MSFT only brainwashed background DID NOT find Windows "user friendly". They found it incomprehensible.

I've never owned a Windows box until my wife bought a Windows 98 Gateway in 1999. Horrible, misgrouped, poorly-labeled menuing system on top of a mishmash of 16 and 32-bit code. How Windows 95 and Windows 98 managed to even stay up, much less acquire their reputation for ease of crashing is beyond me.

Don't even start down that path: the road to Windows "user friendliness" is paved with the incomprehensiblity of "shortcuts", "progman", drive letters, backslash vs slash confusion, shot path names, "long file names" vs 8.3 file names, the pitiful design of Win32, endless buffer overflows, email worms, MSFT corporate conviction for illegal monopoly maintenance, a bad case of the Jaggies, and a lot of other crap.
>>How Windows 95 and Windows 98 managed to even stay up, much less acquire their reputation for ease of crashing is beyond me.
Hold on. I managed to get plenty of work done on text based terminals hooked to S/390's; VAX -VMS; R-6000's; System 32-38's; HP-UX; Apple Mac's etc.

Linux provided a pretty decent experience too. In the 90's Linux users were unrealistic? I guess if all one knew was DOS and Windows you could say that. But then, I would say that people limited to DOS and Windows in the 1990's could not really call themselves IT professionals. Wannabe's maybe.

IBM PC's in the 1990's were expensive toys with some limited functionality. But they definitely were not enterprise ready.

That's my story and I'm stickin to it!

Windows user-friendly? I completely agree with phsolide and tadelste here: except for people who have only ever known Windows, it cannot be considered user-friendly. And don't you remember the months it took you before you got used to the quirky Windows interface the first time you used it? My partner, after four years of using Windows, is *still* not used to it. How can you call that user-friendly?

There is a difference between user-friendliness and the force of habit. Moreover, what one might find user-friendly may not be user-friendly to the other. It all depends on one's experience. My experience with computers began at a time when computers were not shipped with a graphical OS but with a BASIC interpreter which took that place. Having learned to use computers using a keyboard and no mouse, I still have no problem going to the command line when needed, and the command line *is* user-friendly, to me.

That's the big problem about those talks about user-friendliness: it all depends on the user, and it is often confused with force of habit.
No one is born with the knowledge of what an "A:\" or a "C:\"drive is any more than they are born with the knowledge of what "/dev/hda" has do do with a computer. These things are not intuitive and they must be learned. The guis developed for people to use these systems are not intuitive.

I used to own an apple IIgs. Yes, an apple II, not a mac. If I put a cd in the cdrom of the IIgs, a little icon of a cd would appear on the screen. I intuitively knew the cd icon on the screen somehow represented the cd in the drive. That is intuitive. The Apple IIe I owned before the IIgs was command line only, not intuitive, but a nice little computer. Apple did a good job of developing an intuitive gui for the apple II line.

Of course, one of the ways to eject the cd on the IIgs was to drag the icon to the trash can. This was not intuitive.

kde and gnome still seem to be concentrating on developing their feature set, but both have a strong drive to make their gui's more intuitive.
number6x: Funny, this story about the little icon that appears on your screen when you put a CD in is exactly how both KDE and Gnome behave (at least on my computer ;) ) when you do the same (you get the same thing when you plug in a USB-key too, but you get a different icon :) ). And the funny part is that I read comments on Internet of people finding that behaviour annoying and unintuitive! They apparently prefer the behaviour of Windows, where when you plug in a USB-key one of three things can happen, apparently at random: - an Explorer window appears somewhere with the contents of the key. Not a bad behaviour I must say, although I prefer the icon thing, less intrusive (when I plug in a USB-key I don't always want to see its contents immediately). - nothing appears, but a new letter appears in the list available in My Computer. Already more unintuitive. - nothing happens at all. "user-friendliness" at its best I suppose! ;)
Tsela,

I'm usually working on my debian install. It has been updated and upgraded many times through apt. I still mount my cdroms at the command line. I'll google to see how to set gnome up to do that, thanks.

I have a suse 9.2 install on this machine as well, and KDE does just as you say. I guess I haven't used suse enough to notice that before you pointed it out. Thanks again.

The people who think that the one-to-one relationship between inserting media, and having an icon that looks like the media appear on the screen is not intuitive need to get their definitions of 'intuitive' checked out.

It may not be what they have learned to expect happen in their current desktop, but it is very intuitive.
"I'm usually working on my debian install. It has been updated and upgraded many times through apt. I still mount my cdroms at the command line. I'll google to see how to set gnome up to do that, thanks."

number6x,

This is just a guess as I have not tried it on Debian proper. In Ubuntu, to get this to happen outside of Gnome (that is in Fluxbox, XFCE4 and Enlightenment so far), I had to install gnome-volume-manager.

Just installing that then making sure it ran on startup did the trick.
I do not know what you guys are running, but from what began as Debian Sarge that was morphed by Testing and Unstable (with some screwups with extra video players that did not quite work out) I have been seeing the "Audio Disc" icon pop up for a long time. Moreover a player appears, with the name of the album including selection details of the track that begins playing. However, please note I am running Gnome 2.10.2, which was not the starting default version available with Sarge. Furthermore, if I right click on the icon a menu with a number of options appears including eject.

One problem I noticed: the disc icon sits on top of the Deer Park Firefox icon that was there first.
"I have been seeing the "Audio Disc" icon pop up for a long time."

Is that just audio discs or anything you pop into the CD/DVD drive? Also, what about USB drives?
It's locked up right now, but if memory serves me I think I see a disk like icon whenever I insert a disc into either my built-in CD (writable) or DVD ROM drives.
I am using Debian unstable (installed as Debian Sarge), and this icon pop-up has been there from the very beginning. I basically have the same installation as TxtEdMacs then.

SFN: with me it works with data disks too, both when I put them in my internal DVD and DVD-rewriter drives. I haven't tried DVDs yet. And it works with USB-keys too at least.
So it sounds like gnome-volume-manager is running by default on Sarge. Very cool.
SFN - finally got my DVD drive to work again, just like the CD-Writable with the icon a bit lower on the screen but still on top of the Deer Park Firefox (anyone see the beta yet?).

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post

LXer

  Latest Features
bob: LXer now speaks Markdown
Oct 27, 2026

bob: How to protect against PHP2Shell
Oct 26, 2026

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): Linux That's Small
Oct 14, 2024

penguinist: Encryption, Trust, and the Hidden Dangers of Vendor-Controlled Data
Aug 27, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): My Linux Mint Tribute
Aug 23, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): How I Turned My Chromebook Into A "Mintbook"
Jul 08, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): Adventures With My New Chromebook
Jun 10, 2024

Scott Ruecker: My Linux Laptop
May 08, 2022

Scott Ruecker: Laptop Dual Boot Project: Part 2
Nov 30, 2021

Scott Ruecker: Laptop Dual Boot Project
Nov 30, 2020


View all

  Search Features

Search LXer Features:

[ Copyright © LXer | All times are recorded in Central Daylight Time (CDT) ]

[ Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | About us | rss | Mobile ]

Login