Advanced

Linux News Responds to Washington Technology on OpenDocument

Posted by dcparris on Nov 23, 2005 5:51 AM · 14 comments
LXer; By DC Parris

  LXer Feature

LXer editor, Don Parris, responds to a confusing and misleading Washington Technology article focused on OpenDocument.

Diggable

According to Doug Beizer's Washington Technology article, Open Source is gaining momentum. While true, beizer's article seems to dwell more on OpenDocument - a document format standard approved by OASIS and submitted to the Organization for International Standards (ISO) - than on Open Source software. To his credit, Beizer opens the article with statements supporting the title. He then moves on to address the OpenDocument issue exclusively, thus confusing the issues for the uninformed. And Beizer seems to have worked hard at confusing the issues in this article. Whether or not this is intentional, it deserves clarification.



Stephen O'Grady's remarks should be taken with a grain of salt. Beizer writes,

"A looming issue is that the OpenDocument format won't necessarily have the same fidelity when it comes to accessing documents."


He then goes on to quote O'Grady,

"It depends highly on what's the nature of the documents," O'Grady said. "If you have average Word documents with not a lot of formatting or relatively simple spreadsheets, the odds are pretty good they will translate well."

First, it is not clear what documents O'Grady is referring to. If O'Grady is suggesting that the OpenDocument format won't reliably present Microsoft's OpenXML documents, I would suggest that is a safe bet. But then, that is like suggesting that apples have to taste like oranges or something. Frankly, I think they have intentionally attempted to confuse the issues. OpenDocument does not have to render OpenXML. They are two different formats. OpenOffice.org and other office suites may need to be able to translate between the two formats, but this is at least possible, assuming Microsoft's format is as open as OpenDocument. If not, then Microsoft will suffer in the long run, as no one wants to use a limited-use 'standard'.



OpenDocument is a well-defined, fully-published specification. The fidelity of rendering documents using the format is entirely dependent upon the developers following the specification. If they do, the result is bound to be a high level of fidelity, regardless of the type or complexity of the document. Consider that, for years, developers have had to fumble their way through Microsoft's undocumented binary format specifications with little or no help whatsoever from Microsoft. Now they have a published specification to follow in OpenDocument. I could understand O'Grady's concern were I the programmer in question. I do well to render decent HTML. However, most of the programmers working to implement OpenDocument are professionals or at least highly skilled.



Red flags start popping up all over the place when Microsoft suggests that OpenDocument is the pet project of IBM and Sun. Earlier, the European Union's TAC had encouraged Microsoft to get involved in the OpenDocument development process. In the wake of the Massachusetts decision, they claimed they didn't see the relevance. Microsoft's Stuart McKee goes on to say,

"And it is really an attempt in a competitive space to create a procurement preference for their products."

That's funny. Microsoft was fully capable of supporting this standard. They simply chose not to, and now have the gall to accuse IBM and Sun of promoting a preference for their own software. Even if IBM and Sun are trying to promote a co-developed format, neither one of the companies has absolute control over the format, as Microsoft currently does with OpenXML. The accusation calls to mind something about pots calling kettles black. Frankly, Microsoft's accusation is far more insidious.



Beizer points out Wilcox' argument that standardizing on one company's document format rules out competition in the market place. Then, near the end of the article, Beizer records McKee's fallacious argument that a government mandate will narrow the choices. Did you catch that? McKee is saying that a Government mandate will lead to fewer choices. Granted, Wilcox responds that such a mandate would ultimately lead to more choices. The question is, how many choices does the state of Massachusetts currently have - two? But don't get too excited about all those choices. Even given the stamp of approval from the Ecma, Microsoft is attempting to flaunt Massachusetts' policy. Andy Updegrove, of The Standards Blog, points out Microsoft's response to the Massachusetts mandate:

'...Yates had this to say to the Globe about whether the Microsoft formats – and the covenant not to sue - should pass muster with the Massachusetts Information Technology Division:


Yates said Open XML is in the spirit of the Massachusetts initiative, although he conceded that it still "doesn't meet the explicit policy" of the state that recognizes OpenDocument as its standard.'

It really leaves us wondering if Microsoft has any intention of adhering to Massachusetts' policy. It appears they are more interested in grandstanding, making outlandish claims while all along they've been preparing to submit their own format to Ecma. It is true that the customers should determine which formats they want supported. In this case, Massachusetts is the customer. While Microsoft's formats may be open to most developers and applications, it must be open to everyone in order for it to be a standard.



Let's face it. OpenDocument offers far more opportunities to far more players - including Microsoft - than Microsoft's own XML format. I'd like to use an illustration from our standards of measurement. Most people are at least familiar with the imperial and the metric systems of measurement. Anyone can use them. Imagine if I were to approach any government with a standard all my own - the Parris system. Now imagine if I try to tell the government that most people can use the Parris system of measurement. However, my patent license may prohibit a few from being able to use it. I wonder how that would fly in the hallowed halls of Capitol Hill?

Disclosure: Don Parris is a member of the OpenDocument Fellowship.

Return to the LXer Features

Comments (14)

And I like it! It's about time someone started calling the alleged "professionals" on their terrible reporting and analysis. Well done, Don.
Well said. Some of the crap that passes for journalism these days is appauling. And I only notice it on the Linux/Unix/Sysadmin related topics.. I can only imagine how poor some of the reporting is on subjects I'm not as knowledgeable on.
Inhibit --

Believe me, you don't want to know. Depressing is the kindest word I can come up with. On the bright side, some media types seem to understand the problem ... even if they haven't come to grips with ways to solve it.

I've been pleasantly surprised by the writings of Don Wycliff, public editor for the Chicago Tribune, but I'll bet there are more like him all over the place. It's a new world for the press, what with fractured audiences, blogs, what have you. Here's hoping they adjust.







What really bothered me was that O'Grady quote about ODF (I assume) not being able to maintain the fidelity of documents. I found myself thinking, what documents? Word Documents? That would be like expecting JPEG to render GIFs with a high-level of fidelity. Beizer must have ommitted some important contextual information, but for the life of me, the way it reads, I can't figure out what the real issue is.

If they're talking about not being able to maintain a high level of fidelity when accessing complex documents, or spreadsheets as opposed to word processing documents, then one wonders why there should be any loss of fidelity when the spec is fully published. For a writer with a technology-oriented publication to miss that is beyond me.
What really bothered me was that O'Grady quote

She is almost as bad as Didio and Enderle.

You can rest assure that any article that quotes any of those 3 is fluff at best and never worth reading.
Quoting:LXer is becoming a Media Scold


You're correct about that. No one else seems ready to do it. If freedom of the press means people can lie and spin the truth, then readers need to see the truth and have the lies pointed out to them. Of course we could write articles about purple orchids if you would rather. But, I don't think that's quite your bag.

Of course we could write articles about purple orchids.....

I believe the New York Times has already called dibbs on that....since the entire paper seems to have evolved into one large editorial section. they will need SOMETHING objective to write about.

helios
The Times has some real issues at present. How they let Judy Miller get away with what she did beats me (not to mention Jayson Blair). My suspicion is that the star journalist system there has got out of control. Time to get some strong sub editors and bring these brats into line.
helios - I guess you and dino never really read the NYT, you are going by its past reputation. That reputation, by the way, was an honorable one, which can no longer said to hold. The paper of record is mostly in the pocket of the powerful and it still fails to admit at the highest levels for its recent grievous errors.
txt -

I read the Times on a regular basis, though I read the online version far more often than the dead tree. I usually only get the real paper paper when somebody leaves it on the train.

The Times has always been a family-owned publication, which is both good and bad. Honorable is in the eye of the beholder, but I think the Times has generally qualified. That's not the same as unbiased, BTW, but bias is merely a fact of life, not a mark of dishonorable intent.

I've actually seen a few encouraging columns from Times editors that indicate somebody there might be starting to understand the problem just a teensy bit, though not nearly so well as the Tribune.

Still, a start is a start, and something to be appreciated.

Dino: This is the same Times that had information on the Nazi Death Camps and never published it. People were beating down their doors with stories about their relatives in Europe with pictures. The same Times as we read today does about the same kinds of things. As Tsela says, even a broken clock is right twice a day.
Tom --

Lots of eyes should be downcast with regard to the death camps. The Times is not nearly alone on that score.

I feel mightily uncomfortable taking up for the Times, as I consider it both haughty and biased, but... It is a human endeavor and no such endeavor lacks warts. Admittedly, their near-French air of superiority makes it all the more galling (or is that Gaul-ing?).
Admittedly, their near-French air of superiority makes it all the more galling (or is that Gaul-ing?).

Grooooaaan!

I'm biased. I admit it. I decided objectivity is relative - along with just about everything else. If Microsoft can manage to call the studies behind their "Get the Facts" campaign "objective", then it has to be a relative term.
Dino --

I can imagine the discomfort taking up for the Times.

And while lots of eyes should be downcast with regard to the death camps, they could have done something about it and didn't. Of course, later they apologized like that made any difference.

Let them rot.

Those are my taking points and know let's get on with the regular part of our broadcast.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post

LXer

  Latest Features
bob: LXer now speaks Markdown
Oct 27, 2026

bob: How to protect against PHP2Shell
Oct 26, 2026

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): Linux That's Small
Oct 14, 2024

penguinist: Encryption, Trust, and the Hidden Dangers of Vendor-Controlled Data
Aug 27, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): My Linux Mint Tribute
Aug 23, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): How I Turned My Chromebook Into A "Mintbook"
Jul 08, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): Adventures With My New Chromebook
Jun 10, 2024

Scott Ruecker: My Linux Laptop
May 08, 2022

Scott Ruecker: Laptop Dual Boot Project: Part 2
Nov 30, 2021

Scott Ruecker: Laptop Dual Boot Project
Nov 30, 2020


View all

  Search Features

Search LXer Features:

[ Copyright © LXer | All times are recorded in Central Daylight Time (CDT) ]

[ Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | About us | rss | Mobile ]

Login