Advanced

LXer Feature: Early results of the (Dutch) Windows refund survey

Posted by tadelste on Jan 1, 2006 1:37 AM · 39 comments
LXer; By Hans Kwint

 LXer feature

Sometimes as a Linux user, you wish you could buy any computer with Linux preinstalled, or if that's not possible, just without an operating system, but that's not the reality. If that isn't possible, is it possible to buy any computer with Windows pre-installed, and then, return the unused Windows, and ask a refund for it? That's a question many non-Windows users ask themselves. The answer however, isn't clear to consumers. There's only one way to find out: ask your hardware manufacturer. Or do they neither know the answer? Time to find out.

In many countries, tying sales of two products is sometimes forbidden. So, when trying to get a refund for a Windows OEM product, you could state, the Windows OEM is tied to the purchase of a computer, and try to sue someone.

Officially, Windows OEM can't even be bought without buying a computer also. On the other hand, it often is also impossible to buy a computer without Windows OEM tied to the purchase. This is a hindrance to competitors. If people buy a new computer, they can't use their products without also paying for Windows, and most people don't need two operating systems.

The most important indicator of tying is probably the price: Windows OEM is always included in the price of purchasing a computer. This means, people don't know how much they pay for their software in first place, which is anti-competetive. In the second place, people cannot buy some (in practice, that means 98%) models of computers, without also buying a Windows XP OEM license. In most countries, including The Netherlands, where I live, it is not clear if this is forbidden. But since Microsoft didn't want to face the risk of being sued over this, they gave the EULA a strange twist.



The first lines of the (Dutch) Windows XP OEM EULA state:

This User-agreement ("Agreement") is an agreement between you (the end-consumer / natural person or 'rechtspersoon') and the manufacturer ("Manufacturer") of the computer system or the computer system parts ("HARDWARE") where you obtained the mentioned Microsoft-software products ("SOFTWARE").

So, if you agree, you don't have an agreement with Microsoft, but with the manufacturer which made your computer. That way, Microsoft can't be sued for tying, since it is the hardware manufacturer who is responsible for this. If that's the case, we should also try to get our refund at the hardware manufacturer.



Point one of the Dutch Windows XP OEM EULA states:

If you do not agree with the provisions of this Agreement, you're not allowed to use the SOFTWARE, or copy it, and you should directly contact the Manufacturer for instructions concerning the returning of the unused product following the return policy of the Manufacturer.



So, we only need to know what the return policy is, it seems. However, this term is (deliberately?) vague: What do you return? Your whole lap- or desktop? Or just the Windows CD? And then there's the stuff on your hard drive, if Windows is on your harddrive, how can it be returned?



The return policy of the hardware-manufacturers tells this. Though, this policy can't be found on the sites of the hardware-manufacturers, or it must be I'm blind. Then, there's nothing else we can do, than contacting our hardware-manufacturers to straight this out.



I decided to do this, and sent out nine letters, in my own language (Dutch), to the big hardware-manufacturers. I did this first in an electronic way: find forms on the websites of the manufacturers, or find an e-mail adress. This is where the first troubles arose: which department should I ask? For registered customers or companies having questions for soft- or hardware support, there are plenty places to ask. But there are no forms or mail-adresses to ask questions about the policies of the companies. So tired of it, I just picked some addresses and started. Finally, IBM (Lenovo), NEC/Packard Bell, HP/Compaq, Acer, Dell, Toshiba, Medion (sold at the Aldi in Europe), Fujitsu-Siemens and Sony ended up with one of my letters. Sony got a written one since I couldn't find a right e-mail-address. I got two auto-responses, and after that, nothing.



The first to let me know they received the letter was Medion. They said they forwarded it to the right person. Apart from that, I received no answer within three weeks. I decided this didn't work, and sent written letters by post to everyone, except Medion, and added Targa (sold at the Lidl in Europe) to the list, using the whois output of targa.nl, which probably was a bad idea. Since Sony already had a written letter, I sent them a registered letter. Sony replied, the Dutch Sony-headquarters wasn't the right place to ask, and I should contact the VAIO hotline (couldn't they do that for me instead? I explicitly asked for a written answer, since I knew from windowsrefund.org, phoning eventually forwards you to someone in India). Only Fujitsu-Siemens replied they were working on it, and they would give answers within 10 working days. As you might suspect, it did take them longer, but they were the first to send the full policy, so kudos to them. Nothing from the others and from Medion, even after to weeks. Not even the affirmation they received my letter, like I asked.



As a simple consumer, I needed a more powerful way of communicating, especially since I have no fax (most consumers don't). So, I decided to sent seven registered letters, excluding Medion, Sony and Fujitsu-Siemens. This time, I received more reactions.

Dell contacted me to say they received the letter, and they had several questions for me. They asked why someone not willing to buy for Windows, wouldn't buy one of their non-OS computers. I replied the questions were principal ones about the license, and not all Dell computers can be bought without an OS. After taking notes (how to spell LXer), they promised me to forward the questions to the right person. I sent a mail to Medion if my mail was forwarded, and received an English e-mail from Germany, my mail was forwarded again. I asked to whom, but till now no reply. After that, Acer sent the full policy in a cryptic way, but that was OK for me. Toshiba asked me to sent the letter to their European headquarter in Germany, which meant translating the letter to English. In between, I found a mail-address for Sony, and they also asked for an English letter, so I translated it. So its on its way to Neuss now, and it will go to the same Sony mail address, but this time in English, tomorrow. I also got mail from IBM (well, it came from Lenovo, I should have known that), telling me they were researching it, and after that, HP sent the full policy to me. At the moment, I can't tell about the policies, since I don't want the hardware-manufacturers taking over each other's policies.

What can we conclude after all this?



Getting a refund, if possible, takes very much time and efforts. It may even be not worthwhile all the time and efforts. If you're not willing to have high phone bills and talking to people in India, you need a fax or recorded mail, and probably do it in English. The return-policy mentioned in the Windows EULA, isn't on top of the people of the hel­pdesks. If it even exists, it is hidden far away from usability.



When all answers are in, I hope to publish all policies, so consumers can compare them. If I'm not happy with the answers, and the chances are I'm not, I will ask the Dutch competition authority (NMa) to look at my results. Stay tuned at LXer, and you will be the first to know!

Return to the LXer Features

Comments (39)

Shame on the Manufacturers!

Hans, I don't know how you had the patience to follow through on any one of those. What a nightmare! Manufacturers should be ashamed of themselves over this!
No kidding. What a farce. I guess these sorts of consumer policy questions are national security.
Yep! Top Secret! Need to know basis only. And consumers do not have the need to know. Oh, wait, aren't they the ones buying the products? Very well, then. They definitely have no need to know.
I continue to consider this hyperventilation silly.

The real shame is that manufacturers don't offer their pcs without Windows.

As to Windows refunds --- huh?

Dell's answer is probably best: If you don't want Windows, don't buy a Windows PC.

I agree that they are pretty stupid not to disseminate a clear policy to the appropriate people.

There is no magic, no need to do anything special. The answers could be along these lines:

1. Oh sure. Just bring the whole thing back and we'll give you a refund.

2. On the other hand, if you want to return just the operating system, we will need the bar code so that we can void the warranty and mark your box as unsupported. Oh...and there is a $50 special handling fee which -- What do you know! is exactly the refund value of Windows. But we're happy to help you.







Quoting:The real shame is that manufacturers don't offer their pcs without Windows.


Indeed. Consider this as a 'forcing' attempt.

Quoting:1. Oh sure. Just bring the whole thing back and we'll give you a refund.

2. On the other hand, if you want to return just the operating system, we will need the bar code so that we can void the warranty and mark your box as unsupported. Oh...and there is a $50 special handling fee which -- What do you know! is exactly the refund value of Windows. But we're happy to help you.


Darnit, they should offer you a job at some OEMs legal department! In the interest of the survey, I can't tell about the answers I got, but you're real close!

Anyway, thats what we got the Competition Authority for. Its a shame you don't speak Dutch, since there's a very nice legal essay on this subject by S. van Geffen:

http://www.ivir.nl/publicaties/vangeffen/scriptie/tekst.html

(Well, the subject of the essay is a bit different, but the closest I could find)
The really irritating thing about Dean is that he is so grounded in reality. When he speaks he makes so much "God Damned Sense (tm)". :-/
Hans --

I worked a few months in Rotterdam twenty years ago. Determined not to be too ugly an American, I proceeded to learn some Dutch phrases. It's not easy, by the way. I came to understand why I saw so many conversations between a Dutchman speaking Dutch and somebody else speaking English. Understanding Dutch and speaking it are two different animals....

Anyway...

My first experience trying out my pitiful little bit of Dutch came late on a Saturday night, and I was lost. I went up to the first person I saw and asked for directions in Dutch.

You know what I got?

Yup! Directions in Dutch.

Fortunately, the guy had a great sense of humor and, on recognizing my plight, gave me directions in better English than most of us speak over hear in the US of A.





Ok guys, isn't kind of unfair not to mention HP as the only OEM that offers most of their business desktops with both Windows AND Linux? You can even configure and purchase on-line. What more do we need?

http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/us/en/sm/WF04a/12454-64287-89... http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/us/en/sm/WF04a/12454-64287-89...

Check it out and tell me what you think. The Linux or "no OS" configurations are usually $125-$135 less than the Windows ones. I & a friend of mine personally bought couple of them and saved $130 each.

I think HP deserves some good words for their support of Linux.

And yes I know, they have that "HP recommends Microsoft® Windows® XP Professional" every where, but hay, it is a company trying to make money any way they can.
I understand the motive and frustration? - I think everybody would like to see some competition in the OS market (except of course MS). There's a choice with all other ingredients - from the screws that hold the motherboard in place to internet service provider. (Not long ago Intel was the only choice of CPU but thanks in part to help from the German Government AMD is now another choice). But layman does not want to fiddle with installing an OS even if there was a choice. Just like no one would want to fiddle with installing software in their digital camera.

(Why are digital cameras not more like computers or visa versa? I can buy a computer in pieces for a self build (and I do - I'm writing from one). But not a digital camera. Why can't I buy lens, housing, CCD, LCD, board, etc. for a self build as I can with a computer? I think Apple tried to build computers as digital cameras e.g. everything. MS chose to stay out of the hardware but instead support the manufacturers. It didn't work for Apple but it is working for the digital camera makers. And there are lots of them.)

Ideally, the OS would not be something you buy preinstalled. Nor something you need to fiddle with. It would be on a flash drive or similar - something you pick out on aisle 17, plug into that new computer of yours and off you go.

I think Linux will keep gaining ground. But still only slowly. Involving money would increase the speed. I wouldn't mind paying for Linux - if everybody else also did. Alternatively I don't think I would mind banner ads in every window of KDE if that would help - just like Opera had until recently.

It shall be interesting to learn how hard the OS is tied to the computer. My guess is pretty hard because MS has the weapon of penalizing the manufacturers by reducing rebates.

Cool!

Thanks for making the effort to figure this out. More light needs be shone on this issue. Maybe we can get a major media outlet to pick it up once you have the answers. Fine work!
As if 60 Minutes would take on Microsoft? Oh, that's right, they're supposed to be _competitors_, MSNBC and CBS. Hmmmm....

Let's collaborate

Great work! I started a survey myself on US companies but haven't completed it due to a busy schedule. I'd love to collaborate with others on this if anyone is interested. If so, please contact adminATwindowsrefund.info

All the best,

Adam Kosmin windowsrefund.info
Ok, I'll drop a mail soon.

I already noticed windowsrefund a few months ago, which was the reason to start the survey, so thanks for the inspiration.

here is also a good one ;-P

Lawsuit wants Micro$oft to pay Iowans

Published March 12, 2006

quote : "DES MOINES, Iowa — Thousands of Iowans, who bought computers loaded with Microsoft Corp. programs since 1994 could get some money back if a lawsuit scheduled for trial later this year is successful.

A class-action lawsuit seeking hundreds of millions of dollars from Microsoft is scheduled to go to trial in November. The lawsuit recently made its way to the Iowa Supreme Court for the third time.

Roxanne Conlin, the Des Moines attorney pushing forward with the case, expects a trial of six months or more to be heard by a Polk County jury beginning Nov. 13.

“Our point is that Microsoft, through illegal means, eliminated competitive products, killed innovation and as a result, people are paying more than they would pay in a competitive world for those Microsoft products,” she said. “We’re saying to Microsoft, give us the money back that you took from us.”

Microsoft denied consumers were injured and said they have benefited from the company’s efforts to improve its products.

“Far from being harmed, we continue to believe that consumers are the direct beneficiaries of Microsoft’s efforts to improve our products,” said spokesman Jack Evans. “Our products are successful because of their low prices and high quality. Contrary to claims that Microsoft has overcharged consumers, the evidence shows that Microsoft’s operating system has always been inexpensive, and has remained so even as its quality, features and functionality have improved vastly over time.”

A flurry of motions have been filed in the case in the past week and a hearing is scheduled to be held March 24 in Polk County District Court.

The lawsuit is one of a few Microsoft class-action suits that continue to be pursued in state courts. Microsoft initially faced 206 class-action lawsuits across the United States. The company said 108 were consolidated in a federal antitrust case and 96 remained in state courts.

Today, there are six cases that remain unresolved that were part of the federal proceedings and four cases that remain unresolved in the state courts.

Most of the state cases were resolved when Microsoft agreed to provide vouchers to affected consumers to buy computer equipment and software Conlin said she wants cash for Iowans.

“I don’t take coupons,” she said.

She said the amount of money consumers get back if she wins the lawsuit would vary by the amount of equipment purchased, its value and whether it was purchased directly or as part of a software package preloaded onto another manufacturer’s computer.

In the states that have accepted vouchers, consumers have received in the range of $15 to $35, Conlin said.

If the case is won, Conlin said she’ll try to get the court to establish a process that’s reasonable for the consumer to recoup what they’re owed even if they haven’t kept receipts.

Most people probably have not saved their computer purchase receipts back to 1994, she said.

“People need to be saving their receipts,” she said. “People will be surprised, if they’re computer users, how many Microsoft products they’ve had in that time frame,” she said.

In the case scheduled to be tried in November, Des Moines businessman Joe Comes is one of the plaintiffs representing all buyers of computer systems preinstalled with the Microsoft operating system and applications software.

Comes bought a Gateway computer directly from the company and it came loaded with Windows 98, court documents said.

“The plaintiffs initiated this action to recoup the overcharges on behalf of all Iowa and purchasers of Microsoft operating systems and applications software,” court documents said." http://159.54.227.3/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060312/NEWS...
Thanks Henke, I really appreciate your work.

Micro$oft doesn't like PCs sold without Windows

"Is selling PCs without an OS installed a bad idea for retailers? Microsoft thinks so. In an article in Microsoft's Partner Update magazine, (link found in this ZDNet article), Microsoft's anti-piracy head Michala Alexander advises retailers to avoid selling "naked" PCs, saying that doing so puts the vendors at risk." Systems with Windows preinstalled can be a source of frustration for shoppers. Even if you're only after the hardware and your plans for a shiny new PC don't involve Windows at all, you're still stuck paying for an operating system you don't want. The Free Software Foundation is not impressed with Microsoft's new initiative, saying that Microsoft is out to spy on retailers and consumers.

"It looks like a private sniffing service which is supposed to spy on these who do not want to pay the Microsoft tax anymore. It is an incredible piece of impudence which any politician, customer and journalist should recognise carefully," said [FSF Europe spokesperson Joachim] Jakobs. http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20060405-6531.html http://news.zdnet.co.uk/0,39020330,39261437,00.htm
Mon Apr 10, 2006 By Lindsay Beck

BEIJING (Reuters) - China's computer manufacturers must install operating software before their goods leave the factory gates, the latest effort to address the thorny issue of piracy before President Hu Jintao visits the United States.

The order was given in a notice issued jointly by the Ministry of Information Industry, the State Copyright Bureau and the Ministry of Commerce on March 31 and released to reporters on Monday." http://today.reuters.co.uk/news/newsArticle.aspx?type=intern...

micro$uck has found THE trick ... :-/
Hardware tax.

They do it here in the UK (or did last time I heard). Our schools don't pay MS per copy of WIndows, they pay them per machine capable of running Windows. So even if the school wants to go OSS, MS still get their pound of flesh (as well as discouraging people from changing).

This is beyond outrageous.

Of course, if MS were really serious about combatting piracy they would make Windows and Office genuinely affordable by the poor/disadvantaged.

Stories like this show their true intentions and should, I think, make us take all this "we're going to support Linux" stuff with a whole heap of salt.
"They do it here in the UK (or did last time I heard). Our schools don't pay MS per copy of WIndows, they pay them per machine capable of running Windows. So even if the school wants to go OSS, MS still get their pound of flesh (as well as discouraging people from changing)."

Yep, same here. That's how MS circumvents the totally ineffective U.S. DoJ settlement regarding per-CPU charges to OEMs. They simply moved the per-CPU charges outward one layer in the stinky monopoly onion. Same effect, but, at least here in the US, the MS DoJ is unlikely to ever make a noise about it again.

Do you want Vista? Do you have a choice?

quote : "far better to stay with the Band-Aid covered, MS Swiss Cheese and let some other businesses test it out first. Regardless, it will become the mainstay but only after a couple of years in the wild.

As for consumers? Come on, most consumers don't buy operating systems. They buy PCs and unless they have a specific reason they take whatever OS is standard and run with it. It's not condescending, it's fact. " http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=31426

Windows XP EULA in Plain English

"What does this document contain? Most people don't know, because it is written in legal-speak. Still, you are expected to read it and are required to agree to it before using Windows XP Home. Even if you don't read it, you are still bound by it, so it's good to know what's in there." http://linuxadvocate.org/articles.php?p=1
Actually, the Windows Eula is very easily summed in plain English:

"You're screwed."
A few things stand out in particular...

Microsoft is further not liable for failing to use “good faith,” “reasonable care” or for negligence.

Microsoft is not liable even if they break the terms of this agreement.

If any part of this agreement is found to be illegal and therefor void, the rest of the agreement remains in place.

Talk about writing your own "get out of jail free" card!
sal -

Shockingly, Microsoft's EULA is not unique. In terms of liability, most software companies disclaim pretty much everything the law allows.

When I was in law school, I took contracts from a professor who had drafted contracts for Lotus 1-2-3. He all but cackled as he told us how Lotus not only didn't stand behind the spreadsheet's calculations, but effectively required users to double-check its results.

There is this myth of having someone to sue if everything goes wrong. There are precious few cases of a software company actually being sued, and fewer still of one losing the case.
dinotrac:

Every ladder I own has cartoon-like warning stickers plastered all over them, depicting someone falling. Since manufacturers of commodity products (not much inventiveness involved in a plain ladder) do not normally spend money on parts not required to sell the things, there must be a history of lawsuits from people falling off ladders who claimed it was the ladder maker's fault for not warning them they could fall.

If software licensors were held to the same level of liability, MS boxed software would have so many stickers on it each box would need its own shelf per aisle at Wal-Mart.
grouch:

I have to agree. The absence of liability is stunning.

Sad that any person of company should feel that they need or want to use such a contract(?). Equally sad that our laws support such a thing.
Henke54: Thanks very much for the link, it's really usefull (for people not bothering to read the EULA).

Most stunning (this is _only_ in the XP System Builder License) is term 16.1 (I believe that's the number), which states that 3d parties (system builders, the OEMs) are forbidden to tell how much people pay for Windows.

Here is the MS SysBuildLicense: http://hkwint.50webs.com/MS_SysBuildLicense.jpg

(Please be patient with the site, it's a bit slow, if it gives error 403, select the address in the addressbar and click enter. Excuses for the quality, but it's a free FTP server, so the files may not be too big).

And something else comes to mind: When asking Microsoft where people can find the EULA online, the telephonists at Microsoft plagued by an attack of shyness, and they use Google to search for it, since it simply can't be found on any MS website.
Con Zymaris authored "A Comparison of the GPL and the Microsoft EULA" and makes it available as a PDF at http://www.cyber.com.au/cyber/about/comparing_the_gpl_to_eul...

The license allows copying.

The Naked Truth About "Naked PCs"

" The term naked PC is used by Microsoft Corporation to refer to a personal computer that is sold without any operating system preinstalled on the hard disk drive (HDD).

Misleading Terminology

The term was coined for its dramatic value and as a means for creating the impression that it is evil to sell computers without operating systems because they might be used for so-called software piracy (i.e., copying or using software in violation of its license). This is due to the fact that the word naked implies both that something is missing and that it is an inappropriate or immoral condition. " http://www.bellevuelinux.org/naked_pc.html
>This is due to the fact that the word naked implies both that something is missing and that it is an inappropriate or immoral condition.

Gosh, I thought it meant the PCs were ready to party.
dinotrac:

Please turn your webcam off now. You're scaring the pets.
grouch,

Why are you letting your poor pets watch dino's webcam in the first place? Shame on you both!
jimf:

Caught. I confess I have used cruel and unusal training methods on my pets. (I fear one poor dog will be constipated for life).
grouch:

You don't happen to have one of those weiner dogs, do you?
dinotrac:

1 lab and 2 mutants. They all seem to be brain damaged for some reason.
grouch:

So, you say you've got a lab for making mutants?

Sweet.

Chinese firm develops under 200 dollars computer

Quoting:The chip reportedly can operate both Microsoft and Linux operating systems, but the use of Microsoft Windows would significantly increase the price of the computer, industry analysts said.
http://www.smh.com.au/news/Technology/Chinese-firm-develops-...

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post

LXer

  Latest Features
bob: LXer now speaks Markdown
Oct 27, 2026

bob: How to protect against PHP2Shell
Oct 26, 2026

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): Linux That's Small
Oct 14, 2024

penguinist: Encryption, Trust, and the Hidden Dangers of Vendor-Controlled Data
Aug 27, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): My Linux Mint Tribute
Aug 23, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): How I Turned My Chromebook Into A "Mintbook"
Jul 08, 2024

Scott Ruecker (San Diego, U.S.): Adventures With My New Chromebook
Jun 10, 2024

Scott Ruecker: My Linux Laptop
May 08, 2022

Scott Ruecker: Laptop Dual Boot Project: Part 2
Nov 30, 2021

Scott Ruecker: Laptop Dual Boot Project
Nov 30, 2020


View all

  Search Features

Search LXer Features:

[ Copyright © LXer | All times are recorded in Central Daylight Time (CDT) ]

[ Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | About us | rss | Mobile ]

Login