Advanced

Alfresco to drop GPL, goes LGPL

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 50 comments
Heise
Mail this story
Print this story

Alfresco has announced that it is changing the licensing of the community edition of its enterprise content management system from GPL to LGPL. The move was announced by the company's CEO, John Newton, in a posting on his blog. He explained that the company had initially gone with the GPL licence three years ago as it was the "most widely used open source license and provided a fairness of use that meant we could comfortably grow the project, company and brand".

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Community

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (50)

30 earlier comments in the full thread.

> Wonder if that's true elsewhere in life?

Indeed. Like is the pole up one's butt an aid to keep one upright, or just a hinderance?
>Like is the pole up one's butt an aid to keep one upright, or just a hinderance?

Don't know. You tell me.
Heeeee, the only comebacks that come to mind at this point are rather rude and inappropriate for public consumption, I'm afraid. :D
jacog --

Glad to see there is still room for, ummm, reason!

FWIW -- I vote hindrance.
Jacog,

Your perspective is EXACTLY the problem with open source.

It's a 'community' project. Don't hold the 'community' responsible. Let's contribute to the 'community'. The concept of the 'community' is a myth. As a label the word is often used to invert the meaning of the thing it signifies. Think about it very hard.

Historically, the rebellious inclination to break things and replace the old with the new isn't useful for 'communities'. What has been useful is stability, consistency and incremental change.

The 'disorder' inherent in a 'community' driven project like KDE would make it ineffective as a capitalist market entity. For some, it may be easier to drop KDE3 and move on to KDE4, but continued support for KDE3 at this stage is the right thing to do. You can choose to ignore that, but it's still there.
Sadly vect your contempt of 'community' falls apart rather rapidly when examined. Your point would hold true were there no guidance from a person or committee of people who perform peer review. The development model for the Linux kernel is a prime example of this. Linus trusts a handful of people, who in turn trust a handful of people, and so on. Each vetting the work done both cross and downstream, with accountability.

Everyone seems to be of the opinion that KDE3.x is no longer in existence. Sadly this is incorrect, I can go home this evening and had I the desire, install it on of my currently running systems. What everyone is belaboring and mis representing is that more and more binary distributions are dropping it. The code is still there and functional, any person or group of people who want to expand or continue it are more than welcome to. It is the mark of hubris that you would insist that once someone has scratched their developmental/creative itch that they keep scratching yours.
Azer --

Nobody thinks KDE3 is not longer in existence. Heck, WindowMaker and FVWM are still in existence too, as is XFree86.

However, KDE users used to believe that the KDE team would keep current and develop the best desktop in the world, instead of casting it into a virtual graveyard to be pointed at and told "Hey! If you're too dense to appreciate what we think you should like, you can still use that stuff over there. Maybe whip a few buggies while you're at it, loser."
Dino,

It really does come across that way.

[deleted several brilliant paragraphs about expectations, change, and a bit of no **** sherlock, that has been hashed over way too many times.]
azerthoth,

How do your observations about the kernel affect my observations about community?

'Careful how you respond. The core kernel developers are paid to do their jobs. Do you consider the kernel a 'community' project? (HINT: Where it benefits the kernel to be a 'community' project, it's a community project) BTW, who do you think benefits MOST from the kernel development?

If KDE were catering to users, they would maintain KDE3. They are not catering to users. This is at the heart of problem I'm pointing out. Because KDE is community driven, it will do whatever it wants with no responsibility. Users who criticize their half-assed commitment to the tools they offer are asking too much from tools that are 'free'.

How dare we 'proud' users expect anything from KDE, -this stuff is 'free'. We just need to be knocked off our high-horses. The community left hundreds of megabytes of code on the internet for me to download. All I need to do is stop being lazy and start using a text-editor and a compiler. They did their job and now I need to do mine.

I can't wait to start mucking around with the old amarok code base...
Thank you for emphasizing my point so dramatically vect [hint soundbites].
azertoth,

Btw, Linus has not been the core kernel maintainer in several years. You never really had a complete thought in this thread.
Still trying to validate your contempt by shifting topics? oh, and the word you were looking for is coherent not complete. Thank you however for completely mis representing that point as well. Thank you as well for trolling, would you please, if you care too, address the real failings of the community model instead of imagined ones in your next response?
The only distro I know that defaults to KDE 3.5+ is PCLOS. Are there any others I am not aware of? Forgive the dumb question but where is a good place to pull tarballs of the 3.5 line from off the internet?
ftp://download.kde.org/pub/kde/stable/ and ftp://ftp.trolltech.com/qt/source/

Gentoo has KDE3.5.x off in it's own overlay (nutshell def: repo) which makes continued use of it under Gentoo and derivs fairly simple.

Doing it yourself, here is some starter information: http://techbase.kde.org/Getting_Started/Build/Stable_Version
Hello Azerthoth! I can see from this discussion that you would be the perfect new member for The Community Kitchen.

At our special community kitchen, you can participate by fixing meals with other chefs in our kitchen or by eating whatever it is we feel like serving! Here's your salad... enjoy.

Did you say something? 'Took your plate back before you were finished eating? 'Need a menu with a few fixed items? 'YOU WANTED DRESSING!? OHHH-HO, Hey there Azer-bub buddy we're not THAT kind of 'community'! It's fine if you want to contribute but don't be a complainer, -there's an un-attended half-boiled chicken somewhere in the kitchen from the old 3.5 days. Pop that out and make yourself a sandwich. It's up to YOU to make the kitchen special, not US! We're a community here, bub.

Occasionally, Mell Phone and Jane Frame make profits from packaging 'our' 'community' meals with a product. Less occasionally, one of them will throw chump change on the floor (leave it there it's mine THANK YOU).
> It really does come across that way.

Yep. Unfortunate, but true.

> Are there any others I am not aware of?

While Slackware 13 has moved to KDE4, it's reported that the qt3 and kde packages from 12.2 still work fine.
Azerthoth, if you are being 'mis-represented' that is your own fault. No one is interfering with your ability to post here.
now thats funny, you avoid the topic and use a kitchen analogy ... fitting, because right now dont feed the trolls is running around in my head. goodbye troll.
If you can't write something poignant, don't resort to name calling. Just be silent and at least pretend to use your brain for one moment.
vect,

Quoting:[...] don't resort to name calling
Perhaps you have not noticed, but I am the only person allowed to practice weak humor on this site's forums. So cease and desist. Should you persist, expect that I will insist upon a formal redress via a court order enforcement with the costs heaped upon your head.

For one purporting to believe is such a conservative memes, you act a rampaging bull in a veritable China Shop, that is more the revolutionary bringing proprietary to smother the free and open. The position is filled, I alone am the authorized astroturfer. You are too late and lack the ability to perform the task properly.

In closing, regarding the calling of names. If I were "Community", would I be pissed at you.

As always,

Your Buddy Txt. [aks YBT]

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post