Point and click GUIs: why are we still stuck with them?
|
|
|
Comments (35)
15 earlier comments in the full thread.
Mostly aimed at developers right now, with an sdk available. The sample applications on there seem to be fairly good examples of "real world" use cases, but I can't imagine typing a document with this thing though as it's done using an on-screen keyboard.
It's a $300 purchase, so I won't be trying it out on a lark either. :)
It's a $300 purchase, so I won't be trying it out on a lark either. :)
Dasher has supported eye-movement tracking for a while.
http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/dasher/Demonstrations.htm... (scroll down for videos)
http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/dasher/Demonstrations.htm... (scroll down for videos)
Most GUIs are slow and inefficient, and getting worse with the modern trends of either removing features because some dev doesn't like how all those options look, or making users to click through even more tabs and menus to find anything, like they're micro-organizing a file cabinet. For something that you use once in awhile, or are new to, some kind of helpful self-documenting interface is a nice thing. But most devs stop there and don't think of experienced users, and how to make their graphical interfaces faster and more efficient. Pointy clicky GUIs themselves aren't bad, like everything else it's all in the implementation.
TC,
Would you say the same of the Mac OS X interface? I'm not in a position to know, but maybe you are.
Would you say the same of the Mac OS X interface? I'm not in a position to know, but maybe you are.
Quoting:"Talking" commands to your computer is too time consuming.
It depends I think. For information retrieval it's quite fast, provided that language recognition works well. E.g: "computer, I want to go to Munich by car. Show travel directions and a weather forecast". But for getting work done, speech doesn't work so well.
Quoting:unless there would be a combination of speech and touch such as in Minority Report... maybe the screen embedded in the top of your desk laying flat instead of upright in front of you.
Try to play with a table or wall touch PC if you get a chance. You'll tire out your arms within the hour. Flailing around your hands Minority Report-style looks cool, but doesn't really work if you're using it for a prolonged time.
> For information retrieval it's quite fast, ... But for getting work done, speech doesn't work so well.
As was addressed above, _StarTrek_ used whatever medium was convenient at the time, and a GUI and buttons are sometimes exactly the right things.
If there is anything utterly unusable, the Microsoft "table-top" was pure marketing.
If there is anything utterly unusable, the Microsoft "table-top" was pure marketing.
The trouble with developing a neural interface is that the brain doesn't interpret language in a standard manner. For instance, the word 'dog' will conjure up different images for different people, as will 'perro', 'grandmother' or 'abuela'.
With sound and vocalized utterances, there is a enough similarity between different voices that it is possible for the computer to discern what words are spoken. But the differences in brainwaves for the same word between different people make a neural interface exponentially more difficult for tasks beyond the most rudimentary.
With sound and vocalized utterances, there is a enough similarity between different voices that it is possible for the computer to discern what words are spoken. But the differences in brainwaves for the same word between different people make a neural interface exponentially more difficult for tasks beyond the most rudimentary.
Darren, neural interfaces are not about thinking words, but rather a control system that works on thought patterns that are memorised, so some calibration is required.
gus3, it's been awhile since I've done any real Mac-ing, so I don't recall individual apps very well. I know I don't care for a big fat dock, and I don't like how awkward multi-tasking is on the Mac. I also don't like taking away physical buttons and replacing them with dippy icons, which never seem to be where they were the last time you had to find them. I'll wager the volume of the cussing from Mac users resorting to sticking paper clips into tiny holes to eject CDs, or trying to figure out how to turn the darned things off are audible across the skies.
What about taking a cue from some of my favorite TV shows.
A hand based input graph type dealie thingy (official name I'm copyrighting it ;)
instead of a keyboard and mouse have a 10 point mouse.
See the Organic Computers in Eureka and the Wraith Spaceships interface in Stargate Atlantis.
A hand based input graph type dealie thingy (official name I'm copyrighting it ;)
instead of a keyboard and mouse have a 10 point mouse.
See the Organic Computers in Eureka and the Wraith Spaceships interface in Stargate Atlantis.
...and the Wraith Spaceships interface in Stargate Atlantis.
Throw in Jewel Staite and I'll work through everything else. h
Throw in Jewel Staite and I'll work through everything else. h
Get in line behind me, Ken.
@Helios
Why the hell not!
But really a mouse/keyboard integration system that allows you to manipulate objects onscreen like you would in a garage seems like it could simplify input an allow you to have infinite control. After all the amount of information that can be stored in a curve is limited only by your ability to read it.
Why the hell not!
But really a mouse/keyboard integration system that allows you to manipulate objects onscreen like you would in a garage seems like it could simplify input an allow you to have infinite control. After all the amount of information that can be stored in a curve is limited only by your ability to read it.
@jacog - I agree ... and that's part of why complex neural interfaces are impossible with the current approaches.
Maybe if more extensive use of statistical modelling (like is done with the modern speech recognition systems) was done with non-invasive neural sensors (ie EEGs) then perhaps the capability to interpret complex thought would be possible. Sort of like using dozens of people with hours of audio recording to create a single Acoustic Model in a Speech Rec system.
Maybe if more extensive use of statistical modelling (like is done with the modern speech recognition systems) was done with non-invasive neural sensors (ie EEGs) then perhaps the capability to interpret complex thought would be possible. Sort of like using dozens of people with hours of audio recording to create a single Acoustic Model in a Speech Rec system.
There was an article in National Geographic about an arm prosthesis that has a near-neural interface. They didn't connect the nerves directly because of issues with keeping the connection clean, but instead they used unused arm muscles as a bridge. The patient says that after a bit of training it feels just like a real arm (only without feeling, but that's in the works too).
The brain has an amazing capability to rewire itself if given enough practice.
The brain has an amazing capability to rewire itself if given enough practice.
@jezuch:
Some sensations (hot and cold) via prostheses are already available.
Some sensations (hot and cold) via prostheses are already available.
Reminds me of an prosthetic eye replacement I read about a few years ago. the user could see the world at a resolution of 8x8 pixels, which does not sound like much, but apparently the brain has quite a talent for filling in the blanks.
> apparently the brain has quite a talent for filling in the blanks.
Seen your blind spots recently?
I recall some Nova or SciAmerican or such back in the 70s, where a man put on goggles that optically inverted everything. He wore them constantly for weeks.
At first, of course, everything was up-side-down and backwards. But in something around two weeks, he realized he was seeing everything right-side-up again just like normal.
After confirming that he indeed had lost all the hesitation and mis-judgement that he had had at the start, that he was operating perfectly normally again, they removed the goggles.
I don't recall how long it took to "revert", but for nearly or about the same time as with the goggles, without them he was seeing everything inverted!
Then, one day, he wasn't.
The mind really is _software_.
Seen your blind spots recently?
I recall some Nova or SciAmerican or such back in the 70s, where a man put on goggles that optically inverted everything. He wore them constantly for weeks.
At first, of course, everything was up-side-down and backwards. But in something around two weeks, he realized he was seeing everything right-side-up again just like normal.
After confirming that he indeed had lost all the hesitation and mis-judgement that he had had at the start, that he was operating perfectly normally again, they removed the goggles.
I don't recall how long it took to "revert", but for nearly or about the same time as with the goggles, without them he was seeing everything inverted!
Then, one day, he wasn't.
The mind really is _software_.
Quoting:The mind really is _software_.
The mind is software, but it runs on self-modifying hardware :)
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Maybe...
h