Ubuntu 12.04.1 out now, 10.04 users prompted to update
|
|
|
Comments (35)
15 earlier comments in the full thread.
If the problem carries over to distros using other package systems then the answer is yes, and I believe in some cases it may. If it is unique to how the Debian packaging system works then the answer is no.
Whoever's fault it is, it happens and it's annoying.
Also, @Steven-Rosenberg, as originally used what you describe is not "dependency h#ll". That term was coined when Red Hat upgraded rpm way back when and you got into a situation where packages within a distro repository were literally incompatible with one another, leaving you with no easy way to make things work. That was back in the '90s.
The closest thing I've seen to that in recent years is the circular dependency problem in Gentoo, but there is an easy workaround for that one, which amounts to using portage to install a binary package of the offending library and gcc version first, as binaries, with no dependencies. The Gentoo developers were smart enough not to insist everything be built from source in their packaging system precisely because changes in the compiler and/or toolset could cause a problem when doing a large number of upgrades.
I also saw what could be considered a mini version of dependency h#ll because of some poor repository management in one of the very early Fedora Core releases but that got fixed awfully quickly.
The closest thing I've seen to that in recent years is the circular dependency problem in Gentoo, but there is an easy workaround for that one, which amounts to using portage to install a binary package of the offending library and gcc version first, as binaries, with no dependencies. The Gentoo developers were smart enough not to insist everything be built from source in their packaging system precisely because changes in the compiler and/or toolset could cause a problem when doing a large number of upgrades.
I also saw what could be considered a mini version of dependency h#ll because of some poor repository management in one of the very early Fedora Core releases but that got fixed awfully quickly.
Quoting:Whoever's fault it is, it happens and it's annoying.Granted, but eliminating dependency resolution and letting you break GNOME entirely, as a Slackware + GNOME system lets you do, is not any less annoying. It still doesn't provide an example of where not having automated dependency resolution is an advantage.
I suggest you look at how much of GNOME has dependencies on Evolution libraries. You're in for quite a shock. I suspect the package manager actually worked correctly in your example. If so, BernardSwiss is right: the fault is either with the GNOME devs or the packagers for the distro. I'd bet it lies with the GNOME devs.
> I have had zero, as in none, as in no problems with "dependency hell" as claimed by Slackers in at least seven or eight years...
Slackware is older than seven or eight years, Caitlyn. It's possible that you are correct and that dependency resolution is now a "solved problem", but that wasn't the case for a long time. I'd actually be willing to place a small wager that it's not the case even now, but I doubt we could reach an agreement on the terms.
Patrick may revisit the decision some day, who knows. It's not like he hasn't changed his mind before.
Slackware is older than seven or eight years, Caitlyn. It's possible that you are correct and that dependency resolution is now a "solved problem", but that wasn't the case for a long time. I'd actually be willing to place a small wager that it's not the case even now, but I doubt we could reach an agreement on the terms.
Patrick may revisit the decision some day, who knows. It's not like he hasn't changed his mind before.
It's been a while, but I've had issues compiling software on a dependency managed distribution before. One thing about Slackware is that if you're willing to put the work in, you can always get it to do exactly what you want. That doesn't always seem to be true of other distributions. I agree that problems that require Slackware's lack of dependency tracking are rare these days, though.
I'd just like to comment on Bodhi being called a "one man show" project - we have a good deal of people that work on our releases -> http://www.bodhilinux.com/about_team.php
~Jeff
~Jeff
Quoting: It's possible that you are correct and that dependency resolution is now a "solved problem", but that wasn't the case for a long time.
@jdixon: I don't disagree with you, but I think that was solved quite some years back. Ditto the issues with early iterations of PAM, which is still not included in Slackware. I chuckle when people recommend Slackware as a server distro since it doesn't support multiple methods of authentication without PAM and doesn't enable SELinux. From a security standpoint Slackware is nowhere near enterprise or even small business server ready. It was once. It isn't now.
Quoting: One thing about Slackware is that if you're willing to put the work in, you can always get it to do exactly what you want. That doesn't always seem to be true of other distributions.Now here is a statement I completely disagree with. I have yet to find a general purpose distro where I can't do what I want how I want from the command line. Not a one. Since I used to write reviews for DistroWatch and O'Reilly I've tried way too many distros. Under the hood it's all Linux and anything I can do in Slackware I can do in any other distro.
BTW, regarding dependency checking, I can turn that off in most distros as well if I had a reason to do it. The only time I do is when installing proprietary software (i.e.: HP's Lightscribe software) which will fail on dependencies when it isn't built against the same distro. Generally the deps are present but packaging differences between distros causes issues. If you stay within what is packaged for your favorite distro I'd say problems are pretty well non-existent nowadays.
Hmmmm......@Jeff91
I've got a couple of mythbuntu boxes I wouldn't mind migrating away. They're at 11.10 now, and that's bad enough.
Does bodhi offer anything for somebody running mythtv?
I've got a couple of mythbuntu boxes I wouldn't mind migrating away. They're at 11.10 now, and that's bad enough.
Does bodhi offer anything for somebody running mythtv?
Quoting:Under the hood it's all Linux and anything I can do in Slackware I can do in any other distro.
I think you're taking the statement too literally. Of course you can take whatever distribution you want and dismantle what makes it that distribution and reshape it however you like. However, you may have to break package management or dependency management to do so, or do something else that involves a lot of headache. In some odd situations, the extra work you might do with Slackware ends up being less work than you would do with another distribution, and leaves the original system intact. At least, I have found this to be true at times in the past.
@CFWhitman: I still strongly disagree with you. I mainly work (professionally) with Red Hat Enterprise Linux and there is no need to dismantle anything. Slackware is ALWAYS more work than.... just about anything else.
Quoting: Isn't that the fault of the Gnome devs (or maybe I mean the Ubuntu devs?), rather than Apt?
Just read this article and has this snippet about why Google uses Ubuntu for its internal desktop.
Quoting:That said, Bushnell was asked why Ubuntu instead of say Fedora or openSUSE? He replied, “We chose Debian because packages and apt [Debian's basic software package programs] are light-years of RPM (Red Had and SUSE's default package management system.]” And, why Ubuntu over the other Debian-based Linux distributions? “Because it's release cadence is awesome and Canonical [Ubuntu's parent company] offers good support.”
Edited: Added next paragraph
Quoting:When asked about Unity use, Bushnell said, “Unity? Haters going hate. Our desktop users are all over the map when it comes to their interfaces. Some use GNOME, some use KDE, some use X-Window and X-Terms. Some want Unity because it reminds them of the Mac. We see Mac lovers moving to Unity.” There is no default Goobuntu interface
Exactly what I have said in a different thread why I myself use Kubuntu, but coming from Google, it must carry some weight.
Just noting.
Quoting: http://lxer.com/module/forums/t/33759/
That is one reason why I don't favor other good distros like Suse, Fedora, etc... which are non-Apt.
Among the Debian based derivatives, I find Kubuntu to be best overall KDE based distro.
@caitlyn,
Quoting:Gentoo is ALWAYS more work than.... just about anything else.FTFY. ;-)
@gus3: Fair comment.
I'd disagree w/ that. More like PNFY than FTFY.
2c
2c
@dinotrac Not really. But anything possible to setup on a 12.04 core is possible on Bodhi
~Jeff
~Jeff
Like I said in the other thread, I read the "light years ahead" comment and it has no specifics. It's personal preference at Google not supported by any facts. Earlier in this thread I mentioned delta rpms. There is no equivalent AFAICT in Debian. I can't name on feature of Debian packaging missing from Red Hat packaging. So, the fact that the comment comes from Google, the company that wants to mine and sell my personal data, really carries no weight at all for me. The only way to make a comment like that compelling, let alone believable, is to back it up with specifics.
Caitlyn, I agree. The package formats themselves (.deb and .rpm) are one thing, but the tools that handle them (apt and yum) are another. From my use of RHEL-based distros and Fedora, I've found yum to be an excellent tool. I'm not unhappy with apt and Aptitude, but I have nothing but good things to say about yum.
I think that apt support for pdiff updates is equivalent to delta rpm, although I don't think it is supported so far in Ubuntu (it is in Debian, apparently even in the most recent stable release).
Edited for out of date information.
Edited for out of date information.
I've noticed the pdiff lines when I update. I had no idea it was for this kind of thing.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post
