Advanced

Have some Mozilla with that Windows

Posted by khess on · 35 comments
ZDNet Consumerization Blog; By Ken Hess
Mail this story
Print this story

Mozilla is complaining of massive losses due to a Microsoft technical error. Yes, it's as silly as it sounds.

The only way I can describe this to you is that it's the most idiotic ruling ever handed down by any group or judge anywhere. I'm shocked that it's really come to this. OK, the story is this: The European Commission (EC), whoever they are and whose real purpose and power is questionable, handed down a ruling that stated that Microsoft has to give Windows users in Europe a browser choice. And, the fact that they didn't in Windows 7 Service Pack 1, means that Mozilla lost millions of downloads of its Firefox browser. Mozilla estimates that loss in the range of six to nine million downloads during the non-compliance timeframe.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Microsoft, Mozilla; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (35)

15 earlier comments in the full thread.

Microsoft's DoJ consent decree has expired. It was for a limited duration. For about the last year or slightly more, they've been "free" to go back to all their old tricks,... in the US, at least,... and until they get busted for it again ...
John D. Rockefeller, savior of the whales!

I love watching all the bru-ha-ha over monopoly this, prosecution that, extortion the other thing.

Never had to use Windows, never had to use I.E.

I did have difficulties when trying to do download Chrome using Lynx on my last Linux install, maybe I should complain that Google is a monopoly. Hahahahahaha.

Can we get past this yet? Please?
No, Bob, we can;'t. It is way, way,, way past time the DOJ goes after Microsoft under the Sherman Antitrust Act for real. This isn't funny. It isn't a laughing matter.
@JaseP --

No, they are not free to go back to their old tricks. What let them get away with it before (well, other than being too stupid to make a deal with the DOJ) was their monopoly. Now...

Heck.

It's not enough that Apple is selling a whole lot more Macs these days. It's not even that IE is no longer the dominant browser -- or even a majority browser. Heck, it's not even that PCs themselves have lost out to mobile devices for enough applications to notice.

The real kicker is that Microsoft just plain isn't cool any more. And that's in context of the company that gave us the Zune.





Microsoft is still in business?
They're hanging in there.
I can add that Lubuntu sports Chromium as the default browser. If I recall correctly, Bodhi defaults to Midori. Of course Debian uses Iceweasel, but that is pretty much an alternately branded version of Firefox. Crunchbang offers an install for Chrome and Opera when you go to the Internet menu. The whole Linux world doesn't really stick to one particular browser.
I actually think it is silly that Microsoft has to offer alternative browsers as if that somehow makes them less of a monopoly. If the EC really wanted to level the playing field or somehow lessen the monopoly that MS has then they would have gone after the OEM's that only offer MS as on OS for consumers to purchase with their PCs. I believe that MS has every right to ship IE without offering the consumer choice of browser, just as I have every right to download Firefox, use Linux, or use Apple. To me it would be the same if the EC went to Red Hat and told them they have a monopoly on the server market and they have to offer the choice of Yast or Webmin when someone installs RHEL.
If the governments really thought Microsoft was a monopoly deserving of prosecution, they would stop using Microsoft's products.
Bob, that's nonsense. By definition a monopoly is the only game in town. For many in government the lack of knowledge of alternatives is frightening. Also, I've seen government agencies sign contracts that lock them in. I often wonder if those contracts represent incompetence or if someone was paid off.
> I often wonder if those contracts represent incompetence or if someone was paid off.

That's not an either or question, caitlyn.
@Dino;

Useful link;

http://semiaccurate.com/2012/06/21/consent-decree-over-micro...

They ARE back to their old tricks, ... just a little sneakier this time,... and on another platform ...
> Bob, that's nonsense. By definition a monopoly is the only game in town. For many in government the lack of knowledge of alternatives is frightening.

Caitlyn, I'm sorry to say you have me completely confused.

If their lack of knowledge of alternatives is "frightening", how can they possibly be trusted to prosecute the lawsuit? Not knowing there is an alternative on the part of the prosecution does not constitute a "monopoly".

I don't like Microsoft's business practices, and I'm very happy with the business they have driven away with their shenanigans. All the prosecution of them has done is line the pockets of lobbyists and politicians.

I am fully aware that my reading of the anti-monopoly laws is completely different from yours, but that's another point in of itself: If the laws are so abstract that their application is one of -opinion-, how can they be enforced with anything like fairness?

For example, four felons sitting around a table, get to talking about what they were imprisoned for.

The first one says, "I charged lower prices than my competition, and was convicted of predatory pricing."

Next, "I charged higher prices than my competition, and was convicted of price gouging."

Third, "I charged the same as my competition, and was convicted of price fixing."

And last, "My name is Martha Stewart, and I was convicted of insider trading because I listened to my stock broker."

@JaseP -

Let's see how successful they are.
Bob, the person doing the prosecuting and the person doing IT purchasing are unlikely to be one and the same. The rest of your post is pur politics. Leave it to say were are on opposite ends of the spectrum and I, for one, am not venturing deeper into TOS land other than to say that I'd like to see the law as it exists today enforced.

@jdixon: I never said the two were mutually exclusive and I do believe it's often a case of both.
So now we can't discuss points of law that directly effect I.T. and commercial software?

Usually you don't claim it's politics until I advocate repealing the law, not clarifying it. You're advocating prosecuting Microsoft. Isn't that politics?

But then, if legal ramifications cannot be discussed, a large portion of the articles posted to this site need to be erased. Ready for that?
Monopoly laws are not really about whether or not you technically have a monopoly. They are all about whether or not you have enough market power to extort distributors and/or customers into agreeing to things that they would not normally agree to. It's not even being a monopoly that's illegal, it's extorting the dealers and customers that's illegal.

Isn't predatory pricing when you use profits from one location or aspect of your business to sell at a loss in another location or aspect of your business in order to drive the competition out of business? I can see where that might be considered unfair to competition and dangerous to the consumer.

Price gouging is when you sell at high prices in response to temporary period of extremely high demand for a product and have no competition (at least locally, which is all that matters in the situation). So it's not charging higher prices than the competition. It's considered a form of extortion, and taking advantage of people who have been unfortunate.

Of course price fixing is an agreement for companies not to compete so they can all charge a higher price. It is rather against the principles of a free market.

Martha Stewart wasn't convicted of insider trading. She was only convicted of obstruction of justice for lying to investigators about what turned out not to be a crime in the first place. It does seem rather a stretch to claim that hiding a non-criminal act is obstruction of justice. It reminds me of the case in the beginning of A Few Good Men where they were pressing charges against a guy for having a bag of oregano that he thought was marijuana.
The original Martha Stewart investigation was insider trading, which she was not done because the "questionable" trade was on the advice of her stock broker.

If I remember correctly, the "lying" charge was because she made the mistake of talking to the investigators without her lawyer present.
Quoting: Let's see how successful they are.


I didn't say they'd be successful, ... I said they're back at it...
@JaseP --

Which is fine. It doesn't matter if they shoot their own feet.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post