Advanced

Microsoft and Red Hat announce cloud partnership, show .NET some love

Posted by bob on · 45 comments
The Register
Mail this story
Print this story

Red Hat Linux to be reference operating system for .NET Core Microsoft has announced a partnership with Red Hat to support Red Hat Linux in the Azure cloud.…

Full press release: http://www.redhat.com/en/about/press-releases/microsoft-and-...

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Cloud, Linux, Microsoft, Red Hat

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (45)

25 earlier comments in the full thread.

> If signing an agreement with Microsoft is no better or worse than not signing an agreement with Microsoft, why hold that against Red Hat?

It's worse. It implies that you trust Microsoft and opens you to their manipulating the agreement to their advantage. Something they've done too many times to count in the past.

> How does it prove or disprove Red Hat's CEO is "evil"?

Where have I even insinuated that Red Hat or their CEO is "evil". I've said that he doesn't "get" open source. That's not the same thing.
> systemd was started as a personal project.

no it wasn't. Poettering was a Redhat employee at that time and I guarantee you that he started it because it was something Redhat was interested in pursuing, all he did was he volunteered doing it.
>no it wasn't.

It absolutely was and that is a matter of public record.

http://0pointer.de/blog/projects/systemd.html

It goes further than that. Red Hat didn't really want to switch init systems since they had just committed to supporting upstart for a decade or longer in RHEL 6.

http://www.jupiterbroadcasting.com/73122/lennarts-linux-revo...

Feel free to provide evidence if you have a counter narrative.
@jdixon

>Connected does not equate to the same.

End result is the same. My question on why you think the current CEO does not get open source remains unanswered.

>Going to court is always a gamble. That's why contracts are based on trust.

Agreed on the former but that is true for any legal agreements. Not so much on the latter. Commercial contracts are based on commercial interests (duh) and they far over weigh any other factor. You have to work with competitors at times because you have customers using competing platforms and services. So here are the primary considerations here to my understanding

1) MS Azure as a cloud service needs Linux to be viable. A cloud provider without Red Hat is a non starter 2) Red Hat's OpenShift platform has .NET support for Red Hat customers

They have signed a contract to support each other's requirements without introducing other conflicts. Time will tell how successful this is going to be. If you are skeptical about the prospects, I understand that.
> My question on why you think the current CEO does not get open source remains unanswered.

My answer was that I couldn't help you, anymore than I can explain the difference between red and green to a color blind person.
>My answer was that I couldn't help you, anymore than I can explain the difference between red and green to a color blind person.

Your prior response didn't use that distasteful analogy and it looks like we aren't gaining much out of further discussions. I will leave it at that.
This exchange reminds me of the famous Zen parable, the one about the Western professor visiting the Eastern sage, and pouring a cup of tea.

http://truecenterpublishing.com/zenstory/emptycup.html
> Your prior response didn't use that distasteful analogy....

Distasteful? OK, if you say so.

> This exchange reminds me of the famous Zen parable...

Not really BernardSwiss. Neither of us has anything to teach the other.
"At Red Hat, I quickly realized I was leading a company driven by something other than the profit motive"

Now, doesn't that statement prove Jim's integrity and wisdom?

Heck, I'm convinced. ;)
>Distasteful?

Yep. I would avoid using a disability like blindness as a analogy if you I were you. There are much better ways to make the same point.
> Yep. I would avoid using a disability like blindness as a analogy if you I were you.

I'm sure you would. Fortunately, I'm not you. In any case, color blindness is not the same as blindness.
Well, you've convinced me. The hat isn't red.
> Well, you've convinced me. The hat isn't red.

Oh??? How can you tell?
>I'm sure you would.... I'm not you.

True but that still misses the point. Let me expand on that below.

>In any case, color blindness is not the same as blindness

It is a specific type of blindness and you were still using a disability (in several places legally classified as a disability and protected against discrimination) as a analogy which is in poor taste. What makes it worse it that it is factually incorrect. Red green color blindness is only one among several types of color blindness and unlike other types of color blindness, red green blindness is only one in which corrective lenses are readily available to get people to perceive the colors better. Even otherwise, color blindness is not necessarily total.
> True but that still misses the point.

No, it doesn't. I understood your point completely. And I rejected it.

> It is a specific type of blindness

No, it isn't. Blindness has a meaning. While it's possible that people have tried to change it over the past few decades (they've done their best to redefine marriage, after all), I don't really care.

> ...and you were still using a disability ...as a analogy which is in poor taste.

As I said, if you say so. It may have escaped your attention but I don't really care what you or anyone else who is easily offended about such matters thinks.

> What makes it worse it that it is factually incorrect. Red green color blindness is only one among several types of color blindness...

It's the most commonly understood one, which is why I used it.

At this point, I think I should drop the thread. No useful information is being exchanged to either us or anyone else who has bothered reading.
>No, it doesn't. I understood your point completely. And I rejected it.

Your notion that you can't teach color blind people the difference between green and red is objectively wrong. That is just a fact.

>No, it isn't. Blindness has a meaning.

Color blindness as a name should tell you something.

>It's the most commonly understood one, which is why I used it.

It is still inaccurate analogy like I already pointed out. Even with that specific type of color blindness, many people can perceive the color differences.
Quoting: Your notion that you can't teach color blind people the difference between green and red is objectively wrong. That is just a fact.


I am slightly red/green color blind. You cannot teach me the difference between what I see as a gray object and what you see as a green object. Nor can you teach me the difference between what I see as an orange object and what you see as a more red-orange object. The only way that it is possible to have me see the difference is with (newly invented) chromatic glasses.

Quoting: It is still inaccurate analogy like I already pointed out. Even with that specific type of color blindness, many people can perceive the color differences.


I just told you,... No, we cannot. We can learn to fake it really good (tell when a color is near our limit of perception and "guess" that it is the other). We cannot be taught to see what we don't perceive.
> I am slightly red/green color blind

I didn't want to personalize this but fyi, I have vision issues as well but I have already pointed out that red/green color blindness is only one of the types.

>I just told you,... No, we cannot

I would accept that if you are talking about yourself.
If you cannot accept facts (like the effect of the absence of working cones from ones retinas) that are contrary to your world-view, then there is no point in talking to you... I will, personally, not consider anything more that you have to say...
I am not discounting your personal experiences. We do have empirical evidence that it is a broad spectrum. Those are the facts.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post