Comment of the Day- November 6, 2005 What did Microsoft ever do to you?
I don't understand all this propaganda. |
|
|
Comments (18)
Some of us care...
Lookout!
I agree with your thoughts about hating MS(i'm not the poster child either) but you have to admit that at least SOME of the things they are doing to preserve themselves are wrong. And whether you think is people hating MS or not those issues deserve attention.
A lot of attention.
Sharkscott
P.S. Lookout for all the people whose chests you poked your finger into.
In answer to you question about what Microsoft does to protect themselves, I don't know how that comes into play. How does that take away from what they've accomplished? In other words, IT is one thing and a company's ability to compete and bring their products to market is something else.
They didn't invade Iraq. They advertise competitively and market their products through channels they helped create. All the universities I know about teach courses based around Microsoft development tools.
I'm confused about your phrase: poking my finger into people's chests. I don't see anyone reacting.
I am glad that you haven't had anyone tweak on you yet, that's what I meant :)
What has Microsoft done to me? Two words: viruses and worms
My Apache log files got clogged with Nimda and Code Red attempts for 3 years because of the various and sundry crappy things that you, the High and Mighty, Double-genius burger with extra bacon Microsoft programmers foisted off on the world in IIS.
My network communications got disrupted in January of 2003 for a day because of the incompetent design of SQL Server, and the under-the-cover installs of SQL server on machines that nobody really thought had SQL server on them.
I have to argue *against* installing "anti-virus" that will do nothign but waste CPU cycles on the Solaris production servers at work, because the general shoddiness of MSFT "operating systems" has made "install an anti-virus" as a checklist item for every checklist-security-officer with no wisdom in the world.
For all this, and all the of the restraint of trade that Microsoft has performed over the years, I really, really dislike Microsoft.
If people don't protect themselves on a public network, how is that Microsoft's fault?
I really didn't want to spend so much time here. I appreciate everyone who has helped me. But, I think everyone is short of material when you just boil things down and make IT the issue.
No reasonable person will criticize you for using Microsoft products, that's up to you to decide and not for anyone else to judge. But please don't play the innocent about their dirty, corrupt business practices, or how much damage they have done to the computing industry; dozens of industry publications and even mainstream news have been reporting this stuff for years. Don't shoot the messenger.
A federal matter of fact.
Microsoft was found to violate federal law by abusing it's monopoly on PC desktops. That finding was upheld by a unanimous Court of Appeals.
That finding required that consumers be harmed by Microsoft's actions.
So, it ain't me, babe, it's two levels of Federal Courts and a unanimous decision that means the Supreme Court would never choose to review it.
Microsoft has stuck it to us all.
Even in the Intel story, they don't complain about Microsoft, but say Linux is the fastest growing desktop OS and that some say MS will lose market share.
In my heart, I know the answer to his question, but it's difficult to argue.
I think their behavior is unethical but are we too focused on them?
That's a legitimate question. Take a look at the stories visible on the front page now, three contain criticism of Microsoft:
Intel®'s Bold Move with Linux™ Comment of the Day- November 6, 2005 What did Microsoft ever do to you? Intel® Linux™ versus Microsoft® Windows
out of 30 stories.
We don't want to turn into the Ranting Voices of Doom, but 3 out of 30, and two of them are the same story, hardly seems excessive.
Out of the next 40 stories, 4 could be considered critical of microsoft, but again two of them are the Intel story. The other two are "IE is dangerous" and "Firefox beats IE."
Considering the barrage of lies and propaganda that MS unleashes on a daily basis, I do not believe we are over-doing it. Oh yeah, and we try to tell the truth.
My contention with them has to do with restraint of trade. I question their control of the government. I thought their connection with the BSA and their Software Assurance version 6 was a significant cost during bad financial times in the country and the industry.
I don't like the way they compete. They create filters to connect to other people's formats but don't want people connecting to theirs. They make interoperability difficult a la IBM in the 1960's - 1990's.
I believe they have a big hand in keeping people from using their computers for watching DVDs and digital movies exacting a bounty unnecessarily.
Those are the kinds of things I think we should address as well as information sharing, staying true to Internet RFC's, etc.
Some corrections...
"UNIX people seem to hate the company that made the PC available, popularized it, took it to other countries around the world, made it user friendly, gave people an opportunity to make a living, simplified programming and made it possible for Linux to exist by giving Intel a market."
IBM popularized the PC, and a lot of companies writing software for it (ever hear of Lotus?) made it the de-facto standard. Microsoft had a part in this from the software side, but they were GIVEN that authority by IBM and at the time when the concept of a PC was being developed Microsoft didn't even exist.
"Do you really think Intel will abandon Microsoft? Not ever." "If they're smart, they'll know who buttered their bread."
You are correct that Intel and Microsoft have had a symbiotic relationship over the years. Some would say this rises to the level of illegality. It is no coincidence that each new version of Windows requires you to buy a new PC. Unless you are an employee or stockholder of Intel, this should not make you particularly happy. Since I switched to Linux I no longer have to buy expensive computers and can afford instead to have a computer in every room, guest computers and computers for special purposes and in many cases I got these systems for almost nothing. They run circles around Windows and I'm thrilled with them. My Windows using friends are however not so happy with their recent purchases and often tell me that the "machine" itself is buggy and slow, when both you and I know that the problem is with the software.
"Intel has done dumb things in the past and Microsoft always forgives them."
You seem to be confusing Microsoft with the Catholic Church. In spite of what you might have read in the popular press companies are not people. They don't have lovers quarrels, kiss and make-up, or have to sleep on the couch when they stayed out too late drinking. It may no longer be in the interest of either company to tie their futures to one another. Countries around the world are just itching to become competitive with us (the USA) in both hardware and software. You can build a perfectly useful PC without Intel components and run it completely without Microsoft software. The extent to which the two companies work together actually scares people off. Nobody likes being locked into one vendor, much less two in the same area. The way PCs are being used now in business actually make the old mainframe days seem cheap by comparison, and much of what people like you think of as "new and exciting" are just re-inventions of things that were around in the 70s. They built on the shoulders of giants, but the technology itself, once you get past faster clock speeds and denser pixels, is nothing revolutionary. In the future these two companies will have about as much relevance to computing as RCA has to the home entertainment business today.
"Also, the business world represents a much bigger user base than governments. They won't give up in Microsoft. They never have."
Uh... when I started working with government the standard was Novel networks, Wordperfect for word processing, and Lotus for spreadsheets. Let me guess... History is not your strongest subject in school, right? When the US government over a period of just a few years standardized on Microsoft products the effect was devastating for the "old guard" companies. Government IT people are not risk takers (in fact I'd amplify that and say that some of them are total boneheads). They watch what businesses do and gradually form a consensus about what is "good enough for government work". But governments also represent (unfortunately) a large percentage of our GNP (and in the rest of the world even more so). That means that private companies, particularly those that do business directly with government, have an incentive to match toolsets with government. If world-wide Linux use gets even as high as 20%, government IT people are going to feel safe about standardizing their departments on it. I don't think that the choice will ultimately be between Windows and Linux, it will be between open standards and closed. Once governments realize how important open standards are to them, and once they figure out that Windows will NEVER be secure, no matter how long it remains Microsoft's "top priority" they will be open to alternate solutions.
"I write all my code on my XP Pro workstation and load it up to this LAMP + tomcat that my client has. What does he care if I use Linux to write code or not?"
Well, if you are writing your code for the server side, congratulations for seeing the light. If you are writing your applications for business or government at the desktop level, you are about to be a dinosaur. There is nothing wrong with doing development on a Windows machine, other than that you are much more likely to deliver the product to your customer with a big fat virus in it (it's been known to happen). Of course, if they re RUNNING the application on anything but Windows they are probably safe.
"I'm glad you have something to obsess about. What would you do with all your free time anyway?"
I don't see that you are any less obsessive based on this post. What do you care if some people like Linux, BSD, or OS X and may prefer one of those to Windows? Are you one of those people who drank the MCSE Kool-aid? Those tests are expensive for all the doors they open aren't they? I retired early thanks to money I saved during my mainframe days. I got tired of all the re-invention and sloppiness of the PC world. If you want to know the future for PC "experts" such as yourself, read up on what happened to all the switchboard operators back when everyone was getting their first telephone. It's not a sustainable model for half our population to be in the DP industry and as using a PC becomes no-big-deal like using the telephone ("HEY... push buttons, no need to talk to an operator!) a lot of "elite" computer folk are going to have to find a real job.
"PS - I don't mean to be rude, but you have to admit something's wrong with this picture in the Linux part of the open source world."
Think nothing of it. People have been arguing about what the best software is since software was invented. If it wasn't for that, we'd all still be arguing about whether tube-based stereo components are better or who had that badest hot-rod. For far too many people computing is more of a hobby than a business (that is part of the problem with PCs) and as long as that is true, there will continue to be food fights over it.
What did they do to others is more important
Boldly bookmarked it!
When the story ran here at LXer, we already discussed, it was the best example of MS unethical moral, and we should bookmark it for people asking 'What did MS ever do to you?'
Especially read the comments, and out of the comments, especially don't forget the next one:
http://linuxtoday.com/news_story.php3?ltsn=2000-02-11-003-05...
"In Costa Rica there was a war, and many people were hurt. The bandage manufacturer's local representative, seeing this, discounted his bandages and didn't press the injured for payment until they'd healed.
"In El Salvador, there was a war, and many people were hurt. Before the rubble was finished bouncing, the bandage manufacturer was in the field... checking that top dollar was being paid up front for every bandage and slinging everyone who couldn't show a receipt (including hospital staff) into the brig.
"Meanwhile, back in the bandage manufacturer's own country, large companies and government departments freely steal bandages, and the bandage maker can't see a problem with this"
I've got a little list...
* Lying to their customers, the media, everyone handy.
* Misrepresenting and generally pissing all over every competitor, including FOSS products (although in some cases this has already backfired big time).
* Actively hunting down and destroying competitors by fair means and/or foul instead of improving their own products and services (think OS/2, "DOS ain't done 'til Lotus won't run", the encrypted anti-DRDOS code, etc).
* Locking people into their stuff; sacrificing features, stability, utility etc to do so.
* Focussing on marketable features rather than robustness or consistency. Or standards, interoperability, security, any of a dozen or so more worthy objectives.
* Doling out dribs and drabs of software with Scrooge-like reluctance instead of addressing customer needs.
* Dumbing everything down instead of simply streamlining it.
* Blackbird.
* Oh, yeah, making and maintaining a virus paradise.
* Suing everyone who disagrees with them.
* Back-dooring everyone they can't sue (e.g. MA's ITD)
* TFPC. And its asinine friend, the yellow dog (look up "Yellow Dog contract" on Wikipedia).
* Give-with-one-hand take-with-the-other "charitable" tax rorts.
* Putting OEMs over a barrel.
* Firing their MVPs.
* Hmm, don't want to be here all day...
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

I think the market is such that if the balance tips far enough there's isn't a company on earth that will "stand by" microsoft.