Advanced

Comment of the Day - February 9, 2006 - You Misunderstand Pieces of Our License

Posted by tadelste on · 2 comments
LXer.com - Article; By Ned Lilly - President/CEO, OpenMFG
Mail this story
Print this story

Ned Lilly responds to yesterday's reader comment.

Related to:
Comment of the Day -February 8, 2006 - OpenMFG isn't Open Source

I think you're misunderstanding pieces of our license. Sure, it prohibits you from developing another ERP system while you're a licensee of OpenMFG. But it's hardly the case that you couldn't do so "ever in your lifetime." Only while you're actively in business with us - I think that's reasonable.

And we do try to go out of our way to let people know we understand the difference between FOSS and what we do.

Both the EULA and the VAR/SI partner agreement provide for full source code, and the ability for enhancements to come back into the mainline supported product. If you're a VAR, it's a ticket to ongoing customer-paid development work (as well as support and other services), and you've got the vendor standing behind you after the code goes live. Unlike "pure" open source, also, there is a commissionable license fee - so that's additional money in the VAR's pocket.

We think it's a good model for ERP, which is by its nature heavy on customization and services. If you'd like to take a look for yourself, we make a fully functional demo client available for download (Linux, Windows, or Mac OS X client), at [HYPERLINK@www.openmfg.com.]

Cheers,



Ned Lilly
President/CEO, OpenMFG

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: LXer Features

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (2)

Ned, you'll limit your market

Ned, I founded a company in 1999 with a product I wanted to develop as a clone of Outlook for UNIX and Linux. We started as a pay-per-incident Linux support company. People had said you can't call anyone if you want Linux support, so I put in an 1-800 line and went to work. Still, the primary goal was to serve some customers: Intel, Boeing and Ericsson.

Those large UNIX shops were in Exchange hell. We discovered numerous other shops with the same dilemma. So, we wrote a CDO proxy and gave people the opportunity to use an Outlook clone for Linux, Solaris, AIX, etc. It gave people the ability to do meeting management and to handle mail functions, etc.

We had also developed a Linux solution for Exchange. I've written about this a few times in articles. We broke the wireline code and created a plugin for Outlook. It worked well.

Our first client for the server: Winnebago Industries running Linux on an IBM S/390 mainframe. That created IBM's first reference account. IBM embraced us and put us into the marketing system.

You would think that would have been all we needed. But it wasn't.

We used OpenLDAP, Apache, Cyrus IMAP, Proftp, Pam, EXIM, etc. - all open source components. But we had investors and those guys knew N-O-T-H-I-N-G about the open source model. They saw it as a cheap way into business. They wanted me to write software patents and develop a intellectual property portfolio. So, my clients were in Exchange hell and I was in VC hell.

I worked my butt off to market our product, but we never made it really BIG. I made presentations to WalMart and companies of that stature. Business partners and Blue Suits took us into the biggest and best. We did a major pilot with Merrill for example.

Meanwhile, Marc Fleury over at JBoss experience overwhelming success by giving away the code, creating a robust community and making money off of training, then support. Check his market share. He's bigger than IBM now.

A moral exists to this story. Don't do what you're doing, it won't work. I'm telling you, your ERP system may have a few wins, but the vision in your mind will never come to fruition. Open the code, GPL everything, create the facilities for a big developer community, sell training - implementation - support.

You'll cut the legs out from under Microsoft and win the market. You potential customer base is gigantic. Do it right now and you'll only win.

Of course, people say free advice is worth the price. But, not in the free software community. You're getting the benefit of someone whose had numerous successful startups. Listen to it.

Thanks, Ned.

Ned:

Thanks for responding. I understand what you are saying. It is good that you give customers the source code and it is also good that you use FOSS in your solution since it cuts your costs and lets you charge the customer less.

I still think this would be a good area for a "traditional" open soruce project. There are many, many home-grown systems out there, so it is not like people can't do it. They would get a lot more out of it if they collaborated.

Thanks again,

-Joe

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post