Advanced

Is XGL Really Worth It?

Posted by gsh on · 11 comments
OSWeekly.com; By Matt Hartley
Mail this story
Print this story

Perhaps I am missing something here, but why in the world is anyone worried about whether or not Xgl is outdoing the efforts of Microsoft's Vista? Seriously, we already know that Vista has problems of its own, and this is not even counting the fact that Xgl outperforms Vista's Aero hands down without the need for extra video card upgrades (without some tweaking, that is).

But enough of that. What I’m really hoping to touch on here is how we have completely forgotten about functionality and have in turn spent entirely too much time concerning ourselves as to how "attractive" the UI is. Seriously, give me a break.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial; Groups: Community

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (11)

...or do there seem to be a series of articles "on the net" that basically say "unless you are of above average intelligence with a penchant for fiddling, don't bother with Linux". Curious, seeing as how we're getting close to Vista release time.

It's not that I necessarily disagree, just that I keep reading articles that tell me "not to bother with Linux unless I'm a born again geek".

And such co-incidences get the old paranoia going.
Noo... I'm sure that some serious effort is going into that. And there will be some who buy into it.
Did you guys read this? Doesn't read like Microsoft "inspired" FUD.

I think the 'only smart people use Linux on the desktop' idea is simply what people think the current state of GNU/Linux development is. Compared to a few years ago there is lots to be happy about. Back then it was 'Linux is coming into its own in the server room.' All in all we can't be too upset about that, but of course adoption always comes too slow...

I thought, or was hoping, that this thread would be about OSWeekly.com itself. Is it just me or is it really just a rag? I don't think there is a strong PR influenced editorial line on that site, just lots of bad articles.

ABCC
Dino: maybe it's just good masquerading? The impression I get from reading the article is that Linux may be "good" for rare crop of "advanced users", but the distro makers are still *unprofessional* (they "don't earn cash" so they can afford to make crappy products). Something like that.
>ABCC: 'only smart people use Linux on the desktop'

I couldn't agree more.
Quoting:>ABCC: 'only smart people use Linux on the desktop'

I couldn't agree more.


Me either.

Perhaps we need a new acronym. The opposite of FUD. SCA (Security, Certainty and Assuredness).

Here's is my first piece of SCA.

"Only dumb people use Windows."
SFN: Is that the opposite of FUD, or just smugness? ;-)

It should be obvious that smart people use GNU/Linux on the desktop. However, I know some uneducated and technically illiterate people who must be pretty smart, since they also use GNU/Linux on the desktop.
From the article:

Quoting:For the advanced Windows user, however, interested in moving onto something new, I would consider Linux. So long as you understand that each distribution is as different as night and day, then you ought to be fine.


This doesn't smell right. Windows and GNU/Linux may be as different as night and day, but I think saying this for different GNU/Linux distros is pushing it a bit too far.

The biggest difference between two distros pretty much comes down to package managers, but it is still the same basic system underneath running all the applications that run on any other distro. I just don't think making it appear as if the difference is so extreme bears much truth.

My although possibly overly sensitive FUD detector shouted "FUD" here, but the article as a whole, as dinotrac noted, doesn't seem all too MS inspired. Maybe some mis-notions just get out "accidentally".

Quoting:SFN: Is that the opposite of FUD, or just smugness? ;-)


Um, yes.

Quoting:It should be obvious that smart people use GNU/Linux on the desktop. However, I know some uneducated and technically illiterate people who must be pretty smart, since they also use GNU/Linux on the desktop.


True but how many well-educated and highly technically literate people do you know who use Windows? At least, by choice.
"I thought, or was hoping, that this thread would be about OSWeekly.com itself. Is it just me or is it really just a rag? I don't think there is a strong PR influenced editorial line on that site, just lots of bad articles."

Agreed. :)

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post