Advanced

Vyatta VP undresses Richard Stallman

Posted by dcparris on · 82 comments
NetworkWorld.com; By Paul McNamara
Mail this story
Print this story

Vyatta's Dave Roberts went to Hawaii and all Richard Stallman got was this undressing ... which, depending on your view of Stallman, either reeks of unfairness or fits the man to a T (my vote).

[Finally, an honest, eloquent crticism of RMS without all the pinko-hippie-commie inflamatory drivel. This is something to which the community can respond. - dcparris]

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial; Groups: Community, GNU, Linux

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (82)

Stallman is consistant, and that is a good thing.

1 earlier comment in the full thread.

Loved the comment on combining GNU and Linux ;-)
Well bob r, I don't see how RMS is dictating to you. He never says "you should do this." He says "I believe this is what is right." You wanna see dictatin' to, go run Vista!

Incidentally, the official retail release of Vista was today. Some stores opened early. There were screaming mobs lining up to buy Vista. No wait, there weren't either. :)
> He never says "you should do this."

No, he just 'implies' in strongest terms that you're an immoral, unethical SOB who apparently supports slavery if you don't...
My opinion, and only my opinion:

Richard is doing exactly what he's supposed to do. Obstreperous, dogmatic, maybe even monomaniacal, still he's a public figure with a well-defined posture, and he won't go away even when he's inconvenient. He announced his position with his GNU project and manifesto in 1984 and he hasn't wavered since.

Linus is also doing exactly what he's supposed to do. He has a farsighted pragmatism even as he's seeing to the minutiae of overseeing the development of his vision of the best possible kernel for a freedom-based operating system. He's the "shut up and show us the code" guy; the fact that he gets along well with the suits means (aside from grooming issues) they can understand his pragmatism.

There are others on this stage, of course, but these two represent the current main poles of the debate. Between them, they have persistently kept the issues of licensing and freedom in the forefront of the F/LOSS movement, to the point where sites like the Register/Inquirer are reporting on GPL violations just as if it matters (because it does), and major corporations find advantages to using GPL'd software in their day-to-day practice, which means that they know what the GPL means. If either of these two hardheaded individuals took a softer public stance, I don't think the F/LOSS paradigm would be near as well established and understood as it is today. I think it's their dichotomy of thought which keeps the topic fresh in the public eye and gains it incremental mindshare by constant exposure.
I found the article pretty much fair except for one thing:

Who cares how shabby RMS is?

He is a spokesman for the FSF, the organization he founded for the purposes he has in mind.

He is not an evangelist. Evangelism is about spreading the word and winning converts. I don't believe RMS wins converts so much as gather up the flock.

That's ok. There are evangelists galore, many with different takes and concerns, equipped to resonate with people who will turn away from shabby ol' Richard.

Stallman is a compass. He may not always point in the direction you want to go, but he is always pointing in the same direction. If you want to know the "one true pure free" software perspective on an issue, check what RMS thinks and position yourself accordingly.





What Dino said... But then you all expected that :D
Oh great, now we have Dino and Mini-Dino.
Well tuxchick, at least I don't see it becoming the Dino cult ;-)
HEY ... I want to be Mini-Dino ...
Humm... maybe I was wrong :D
aieee, a Dino herd. Hmm, I guess I could be the dino-herder... now where is that prod.... probably need the 240 volt stick...

Cattle prod? Did someone say, "Cattle prod?"

Me first! Me first!

waitaminute -- that was "Cattle prod," not "Saddle mod" -- nevermind.
> now where is that prod...

I suspected you had a few of those around ;-)
Riding crops, yes. Cattle prods, no.
pshaw, do you really believe a mere riding crop will have any effect on these here wild LXer critters?
> aieee, a Dino herd. Hmm, I guess I could be the dino-herder... now where is that prod.... probably need the 240 volt stick...

Sounds too much like Barney to me. Never mind the 240V stick, use C-4.
Oh my...

Did I forget to turn down my incredible magnetic charisma again?

That's so irresponsible of me.

Please, children, I'm just another man.

Well, not quite just another man, but just another spectacular man.

So please, while it is hard to keep from idolizing and wishing you could be me, please try. At least a little.

TC: I was going to fly out to Chicago with my cattle prod, but I remembered what my Pa told me about the FAA guidelines saying you couldn't take your cattle prod on the airplane with you. Sorry, but I always take my cattle prod, and if I can't take it on the plane, how do they expect me to keep my herd simmered down during the flight?

Well, back to my point, since I can't take it on the plane, I'll have to drive, but I just don't feel like driving that far today. The batmobile is in the shop again...
Between throwing up at dino's last post, and laughing at the others, I'm not fit to be around people right now.
>Between throwing up at dino's last post

You see? To idolize me is to have your digestive system cleared at the same time you implement an effective (if unpleasant) weight loss regimen.

seems pretty drivelous to me

41 earlier comments in the full thread.

Regarding the almost religious fervor you've been making your points with, I think the term fits pretty well *ggg*
incinerator:

I guess what's got me confused is how does a government (which is not a religious institution) own "profane property"?

Is your use of the word "profane" referring to its more archaic meaning of "ordinary"?
> For instance, copyright and patent protection doesn't last forever.

Give Disney time...
Quoting:For instance, copyright and patent protection doesn't last forever.


IIRC one US senator proposed "Eternity minus one day".
Yes, Disney the creator of Snow White, Bambi, Mowgli, and so forth certainly deserves an eternal lock on its property.

Sander, that must be a relative of the brainiacs in the Indiana state legislature that tried to legislate a fixed, finite value for pi.
> Yes, Disney the creator of Snow White, Bambi, Mowgli...

Well, except for the fact that Disney didn't "create" any of those. They merely adapted them to the screen in animated form. And in the case of Bambi and Mowgli, poorly.
/me baps jdixon

That was sarcasm, son.

:)
That's right, boys and girls! Good old Walt himself was one of the greatest "pirates" in entertainment history. How ironic that the company now seeks to prevent what it was allowed to do. All hail Walt Disney! Now, peasants, pay your tribute!
"Is your use of the word "profane" referring to its more archaic meaning of "ordinary"?"

Archaic it might be, but it still was a valid meaning of the word last time I checked.
> That was sarcasm, son.

Sorry TC, I figured it was, but I didn't want to risk someone taking it seriously.
dcparris -

one note on copyright - it's not technically a "right": it's a grant of limited protection by the government to a person, or persons, over a work product.

incinerator -

Last time I checked, "profane property" has no "legal" meaning with regard to incorporeal property. So in the end, you're talking apples and oranges when trying to apply principles of tangible property to intangible property.
apples and oranges, exactly. I'm talking apples and oranges because my point is that apples aren't oranges. And it's not me who's applying the principles of tangible property to intangible property, I believe that was you.
incinerator - You're the one talking "profane property" - and that means "tangible property".

Copyrights, patents, and trademarks are considered "intangible property". There are many other types of incorporeal property.

The same rules concerning tangible property do not necessarily apply to intangible property, but that does not mean that intangible assets are not property. And this goes to the heart of your premise that copyrights are not property.

They are. Copyrights are intangible property. Attempting to use the rules about tangible property to show that Copyrights are not property does not work, because the rules regarding tangibles don't necessarily apply to intangibles.

And there is where we will simply have to agree to disagree, because this thread has become only tangentially related to LXer.com
DarrenR114 -

This whole IP isn't property stuff drives me nuts, generally because people seem to know nothing about property.

What they end up arguing is that IP isn't things. Can't argue with that.

However, there is nothing special about things that make them property, either. Property is a legal concept. Land becomes property because somebody recognizes and can defend it as such. Same for things. If you put a DVD player out on the curb with the trash, it's not really property anymore -- presuming your town doesn't have anti-scavenging ordinances, anybody can pick it up and claim it as their own -- which would make it property again.

For that matter - what about money? We generally keep it in a completely intangible form. Does that mean we don't own our money?

Property is a matter of specific legal rights, and can those rights can be applied to all manner of things or non-things.
Dino - exactly.

The only reason I know anything about this sort of thing is because I've worked for estate planners/attorneys. But you know what they say - a little knowlege is a dangerous thing. But I do know enough to know that I will never go pro se in a court of law.
If I had wanted to refer to IP rights as intangible property, I would have used that term. However, Ideliberately avoided it and used the term "profane" property. Call it "ordinary", "old-school", "traditional" or "real" property, probably everyone except you has understood what I meant. You didn't and I guess that wasn't an accident, either. I've listed enough examples of intangible property in one of my posts. You're the one that tries to add IP rights to that mix, no me. Unlike me you haven't been able to back up your arguments with a single line of legal code, yet. All you have offered so far is insults, syllogisms that aren't applicable, plus some incoherent gibberish about little knowledge being more dangerous than no knowledge.

I certainly don't expect my opinion to be the ultimate wisdom on that matter, on the contrary. I'm well aware of the fact that there's a sufficient number of people that actually think that IP rights are property. However, at least I've undergone the effort to educate myself, and that wasn't just reading up on legal code either. I've formed a theory that has merits and has sound reasoning as far as it can get in these matters. All you have to offer is the argument that IP rights are property because they are treated similalry, backed up by the god-like revelation that you have worked for a lawyer once in your life. Either you are brainwashed by BSA, RIAA, MPAA et. al or you just like to troll. Have a nice day.
incinerator -

FYI - my mini-rant wasn't directed at your post so much as general frustration. Your posts in this thread are well within the range of opinion and reasonable differences based on actual information.
incinerator,

The majority (if not the totality) of your posts toward me in this thread have been rather inciteful in nature. Why?

Is it simply because I pointed out that the logic you were using to support your "theory" is flawed?

Pointing out the flaw in your "strict constructionist" argument about the non-use of the word "property" in the constitution and the statute did not justify such vitriol, I don't believe. Why did you lower yourself to such?

Showing that there are differences between tangible and intangible assets does not make such insulting responses reasonable. Why did you lower yourself to such?

Since it was you who took this entire thread off on a tangent with the ill-conceived pronouncements using terms such as "profane property," I could have very well been the one to accuse you of either being a troll, or being brainwashed by the FSF and I would have been just as "valid" in doing so. But I did not. Why did you lower yourself to such?

"wannabe arguments" ... "blatent lie" ... these are very inflammatory accusations that obviously arose out of an inaccurate reading of my post. Why did you lower yourself to such?

Why?
I think there's plenty of room for us to disagree with each other respectfully guys. Incinerator, you might think Darren's post missed your point intentionally, but I really think he honestly disagrees with you. For my part, I can only say that regardless of whether we treat copyrights and patents as property, I sure don't want so-called "software patents" getting anymore teeth than they seem to have now.

Darren, thanks for your counterpoint to my argument. I suspect that you are probably correct, at least at some level, and I'm still not sure I agree with you. I think it would be ridiculous to expect all of us to be experts in everything, and I've acknowledged my lack of expertise in this area already.

I don't so much object to the direction this thread has taken, but let's keep it fun guys. That's what makes LXer what it is.
> ... that tried to legislate a fixed, finite value for pi.

Standardization is a good thing. Look at what happened to the inch. And everybody knows that pi is equal to three, but only for large values of three.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post