The KDE vs. GNOME Schism In Free Software
|
|
|
Comments (21)
After following the link through to Martin's blog
Probably because you were way OT, his post was not about KDE or Gnome screwing over its users but about KDE vs Gnome and how their developers collaborate or not as the case may be.
Now dont get me wrong I loathed the way KDE and Gnome have treated their users and am not a KDE fan boy im an XFCE one but if you had posted OT on my blog, I would of warned you that you were way OT and that if you posted OT again then i would of blocked you the only difference between him and myself would be the courtesy warning.
OT is OT ive been blocked for it myself but have learned my lesson, although sometimes I forget, so im glad the Lxer moderation crew are fairly leniant :)
Now dont get me wrong I loathed the way KDE and Gnome have treated their users and am not a KDE fan boy im an XFCE one but if you had posted OT on my blog, I would of warned you that you were way OT and that if you posted OT again then i would of blocked you the only difference between him and myself would be the courtesy warning.
OT is OT ive been blocked for it myself but have learned my lesson, although sometimes I forget, so im glad the Lxer moderation crew are fairly leniant :)
In what way is a post disagreeing with him OT?
I agree with tracyanne. Martin is engaged in a straw man argument, blaming the users for their "petty disagreements among desktop environments" while ignoring the actual real complaint of users against their OWN desktop environment.
Pointing this out is not OT.
Pointing this out is not OT.
Linus Torvalds made some interesting comments in a recent interview:
http://h30565.www3.hp.com/t5/Feature-Articles/Linus-Torvalds...
Quoting: "The code itself is unimportant; the project is only as useful as people actually find it.”
I'll add at this point that this isn't just a programmer problem. I've seen entire companies get locked into the idea that “perfecting” the program was everything. They then neglected what the users wanted from the program...
"...that's why the Linux kernel team is “so very anal about the whole ‘no regressions’ thing, for example. Breaking the user experience in order to ‘fix’ something is a totally broken concept; you cannot do it. If you break the user experience, you may feel that you have ‘fixed’ something in the code, but if you fixed it by breaking the user, you just violated that second point; you thought the code was more important than the user. Which is not true.”
"Torvalds concludes, “Way too many projects seem to think that the code is more important than the user, and they break things left and right, and they don't apologize for it, because they feel that they are ‘fixing’ the code and doing the right thing.”
http://h30565.www3.hp.com/t5/Feature-Articles/Linus-Torvalds...
The Principle of Least Astonishment, applied to UI's.
How many UI paradigms has Windows had?
How many has MacOS had?
Which is more successful as a UI?
How many UI paradigms has Windows had?
How many has MacOS had?
Which is more successful as a UI?
If KDE4 had a switch labeled "Make it work just like KDE3", I'd use it.
@bob, I think the KDE3 functionality is pretty much all there (except Dolphin).
The point I'm making here is that GNOME and KDE are just as bad as each other in this respect, treating the current needs of the users as unimportant, or less impotant than the code. That the real issue is not users fighting over which is the best desktop, but the devs neglecting the needs of the users, and, as is the case here with Martin (he's a KWin developer) attempting to blame the current problems on the users, and i a manner that is totally spurious.
It's quite insulting, that he attempts to lay the blame for developer unhappiness at the feet of the users, when it is the developers who have decided that pretty code in the future is more important than functionality users rely on right now. He seems surprised that users would complain.
The point I'm making here is that GNOME and KDE are just as bad as each other in this respect, treating the current needs of the users as unimportant, or less impotant than the code. That the real issue is not users fighting over which is the best desktop, but the devs neglecting the needs of the users, and, as is the case here with Martin (he's a KWin developer) attempting to blame the current problems on the users, and i a manner that is totally spurious.
It's quite insulting, that he attempts to lay the blame for developer unhappiness at the feet of the users, when it is the developers who have decided that pretty code in the future is more important than functionality users rely on right now. He seems surprised that users would complain.
Sorry but you are OT, he is talking about kde users slagging gnome users and vice versa, this has nothing to do with the KDE Devs vs KDE users or Gnome Devs vs Gnome users.
Thats the way i read it, and i can see from the article comments as well that is how the majority see that article as well.
Some folks need to get over this KDE stuff and move on, KDE made it clear they dont give a monkeys about their users so just use something else and forget about them, I know i have. Absolutely no point on dwelling on it as they are not going to change their ways any time soon.
Thats the way i read it, and i can see from the article comments as well that is how the majority see that article as well.
Some folks need to get over this KDE stuff and move on, KDE made it clear they dont give a monkeys about their users so just use something else and forget about them, I know i have. Absolutely no point on dwelling on it as they are not going to change their ways any time soon.
@koriel,
he is indeed. not only that he is making the case that this is what users are most intersted in, and that it is this behaviour that is leading to developer dissatisfaction
I disagreed with him pointing out that most, if not all user griping and aguing and complaining ans slagging and sniping has been because the developers are so damned arrogant they have ignored theirs user's basic needs, that any developer dissatisfaction is because they have had to deal with complaints from their own user base.
I am very much on topic.
There is no real schism. both GNOME and KDE users agree they have been treated badly by the devs.
Quoting:Sorry but you are OT, he is talking about kde users slagging gnome users and vice versa
he is indeed. not only that he is making the case that this is what users are most intersted in, and that it is this behaviour that is leading to developer dissatisfaction
I disagreed with him pointing out that most, if not all user griping and aguing and complaining ans slagging and sniping has been because the developers are so damned arrogant they have ignored theirs user's basic needs, that any developer dissatisfaction is because they have had to deal with complaints from their own user base.
I am very much on topic.
There is no real schism. both GNOME and KDE users agree they have been treated badly by the devs.
We will just have to agree to disagree.
I read the article and I can sort of see why TA would see what she sees.
I think his main ghist is about the animosity between the different desktop camps, but I think he shows a small amount of bias and a secondary message is slipping in, probably by accident.
I think his main ghist is about the animosity between the different desktop camps, but I think he shows a small amount of bias and a secondary message is slipping in, probably by accident.
Wel, as I'm not the only person, in the context of that blog, to take him to task over the way the devs of both KDE and GNOME have treated their users, it appears he no longer thinks I'm OT .
I haven't seen any Gnome vs KDE fanboyism on LXer in quite a long time. What I DO see all the time now is ex-KDE users angry at KDE devs and soon to ex-Gnome users angry at Gnome devs.
@patrokov: I have to agree. I really haven't seen much of the fanboyism in ages, just people either bashing the devs or the DE in general (not that all this bashing is unwarranted; maybe I should call it "criticism" instead as "bashing" seems to imply that it's unwarranted or excessive, and I don't think that's the case, though some devs seem to think that any criticism at all is unwarranted and unnecessary).
Quoting:I haven't seen any Gnome vs KDE fanboyism on LXer in quite a long time
True and what I also see is that, those who are dissatisfied with Unit/Gnome 3 are now giving KDE 4 another look.
Quoting:...some devs seem to think that any criticism at all is unwarranted and unnecessary
Their primary response to anyone who complains, takes them to task, or in any way argues with the excuses they use, is to blame the user for.... complaining.
I disagree
Martin Gräßlin wrote:When Linus turned first from KDE Plasma to GNOME and later from GNOME Shell to XFCE he was exactly demonstrating the advantages of choice. ... These two events have not shown a failure of GNOME or KDE as the media seemed to suggest, but the opposite: it highlighted the great advantage of choice in the free software ecosystem.
No, what it highlights is that one one Free software project goes off the deep end and ignores the needs of its users, there's alternatives. In the proprietary world, it isn't so easy; if Windows decides to force everyone into a smartphone-like UI in Windows 8, imagine the uproar. Of course, from what I'm reading, it seems that (unlike Gnome developers) MS isn't quite that stupid, and is preserving the traditional UI for all the people who are used to it. In fact, it seems like proprietary companies are far more conservative and less likely to so obviously disrupt their users than the FOSS developers, at least the ones who work on DEs.
Martin Gräßlin wrote:If a user switches from GNOME Shell to KDE Plasma, it is not a lost user to GNOME. It is a user won for free software and not lost to the proprietary competition.
Wrong. Martin's obviously not heard of something called "fragmentation", and doesn't remember how it nearly destroyed UNIX in the 80s and early 90s. Furthermore, a FOSS project without any users isn't going to go anywhere. Anyone still use twm? I thought not. Has it advanced any? Nope, it hasn't changed a bit for probably 15 years. The 3 twm fans out there probably are happy with that, but most software does need to grow and evolve, even if only a little bit to keep up with changes in the rest of the system. Is it relevant? Not at all. If all the users abandon Gnome, then it's going to go the way of twm.
Martin Gräßlin wrote:Why are release notes of GNOME not published on the KDE news site, isn’t it a news worthy event if our collaborators have a release?
Why should they be? Should Gnome publish release notes for LXDE, XFDE, Enlightenment, FXWM, Unity, and every other DE out there? There's a lot of DEs besides just KDE and Gnome. If people want to read about other DEs, let them go to those projects' websites. A short list of alternatives and links to their websites is fine, but keeping up with all the news from them all is too much.
@Grish
Agreed why on earth should one DE publish the release notes of another DE and vice versa their are so many DE's and WM's out there the situation would get crazy.
Or as I suspect they are being arrogant again, that since they are the 2 biggest DE's no one else should get a look in.
Agreed why on earth should one DE publish the release notes of another DE and vice versa their are so many DE's and WM's out there the situation would get crazy.
Or as I suspect they are being arrogant again, that since they are the 2 biggest DE's no one else should get a look in.
Quoting:If a user switches from GNOME Shell to KDE Plasma, it is not a lost user to GNOME. It is a user won for free software and not lost to the proprietary competition.
Wow, sounds like a plan to get filthy rich by moving funds from one checking account to my other one. ROTFLMAO.
[Edited:]
Sorry, my bad, I shouldn't have made fun of the idea, I think it has some insight & merit. Like BF (Benjamin Franklin) used to say, "A Penny saved is a Penny earned/gained," " which originated here..
Sound great
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

quote:: My hope is that our users would stop to fight each other. While our users fight, they demotivate the developers, they undermine efforts to improve the collaboration. There is no need to fight for KDE. ::quote
I have never fought for KDE or GNOME or any other Linux desktop Environment.
What I and countless other users have fought against is the stupidity of the developers abandoning the desktop, we as users are using, and creating a new desktop that lacks all of the functionality we have come to rely on, and expecting us to be grateful that we are faced with the choice of finding another desktop that hopefully allows us to continue with the work flow we have found is the most efficient for our needs, and have to learn and configure a whole new desktop environment.
What I and countless other users are fighting is the arrogance of developers who abandon their users,or expect their users to become beta testers, while the functionality gets built back in.... hopefully.
Personally I think you are ignoring the real problem, while systematically dismantling the strawman, that users are fighting each other, you've created, because you don't wish to deal with the real problem.