Advanced

'GNU/Linux', 'Linux' -- What's the diff?

Posted by dcparris on · 34 comments
LXer; By Terry Vessels
Mail this story
Print this story

  LXer Feature: 29-Jun-06

Why do Linux advocates argue over whether to call their operating system 'Linux' or 'GNU/Linux'? It's all open source, right? At this point there are blood pressures rising among free software advocates, while any casual software user reading this is simply thinking, "Yeah, so?"



Introduction



People get involved with free software. They embrace it, cherish it and want to enlighten everyone else about why this zero-price software is so very valuable. Because of the nature of software, the earliest adopters are geeks. Geeks pick nits. When they begin to try to educate non-geeks about technical matters, geeks debate endlessly over the nits they pick. This is not madness; it is a result of the type of attention to minute detail that is necessary for the creation and maintenance of complex hardware and software. A misplaced or missing semicolon can literally kill.



One of the terminology nits that has been simmering for years among Free/Open Source Software advocates is the debate over the proper name for the operating system commonly called "Linux". The patriarch of the GNU system, Richard M. Stallman, is

vocally opposed to calling the operating system by the name of its kernel alone
. He insists on using the term "GNU/Linux" or "GNU+Linux", in recognition of the thousands of developers who have worked on the GNU system over the years. Naturally, there are many people who consider his insistence on the name "GNU/Linux" to be unwarranted and even annoying. This group is just as insistent that naming the operating system by its kernel is sufficient and a long-standing tradition.



Dave Whitinger, publisher of LXer, and I, a formerly long-haired but now just white-haired free software advocate, recently had a mild email debate over this issue. Since neither of us are rabid advocates of our respective view on 'Linux' versus 'GNU/Linux', the discussion may be useful to others who, likewise, are not inclined to beat plowshares into swords over the terminology.



I am in Stallman's camp in this matter, though not as insistent as he. This less intense commitment on my part is understandable, as I have not devoted 22 years of my life working and fighting for free software. I deliberately use the name "GNU/Linux" or "GNU+Linux" out of respect for GNU.



Dave is slightly in the opposing camp, though not fervently so. He is not opposed to the name "GNU/Linux", as evidenced by his use of it on LXer, such as in the About page.



Dave was beginning to work at Red Hat about the time that I was staring at the blinking cursor after having booted Slackware for the first time and wondering, "Now what?" He launched LinuxToday about the time that I was learning how to connect to the Internet through a 486 computer running Red Hat.

Opening Dialogue





Our discussion began as I was sifting through "pending" stories, looking for things to post to LXer's Newswire. We just stumbled into the naming discussion. In the following, "TV" is me, and "DW" is Dave.



TV:
Just edited a story about Xandros and discovered Xandros is not among the groups listed.



DW:
I have added Xandros to the categories.



TV:
Also, when the category 'Linux' is auto-selected, couldn't 'GNU' also be selected? Most of the time when a news story talks about 'Linux' they're really talking about a distribution, which includes 'GNU'. Unselecting 'GNU' for the times when the story is about the kernel alone, e.g., an embedded device or the kernel developers, would amount to much fewer times than selecting it now.



DW:
My original intention with adding the GNU category was for articles that are specifically about the GNU project.



Examples would be articles concerning the FSF, Richard Stallman, Hurd, or announcements from them concerning their specific offerings.



The intention behind the "Linux" category was for a catch-all category. We need -something- in the category field and when nothing else is caught, it just selects Linux.



TV:
I've been using "Community" as the catch-all. Sometimes an article will be about some company open sourcing their software, but it's not distribution-specific, GNU-specific, nor even Linux-specific, yet it may concern many readers. This is also based on your "About" page:



"Our top quality editors create, edit, and present information about GNU/Linux and free/open source software via our frequently-updated newswire."





(Heh, top quality. How'd I get in here?)



DW:
Community is a good catch-all, to be sure.



GNU+Everything







TV:
I've had an email conversation with RMS, trying to convince him that LXer is a good place for him to post an article, and one of the things he expressed concern about was the use of "Linux" when talking about the OS and not just the kernel. I'm inclined to agree with him, though not as fervently, because without GNU and his foresight with the GPL 'way back when, we would only have BSD as a free Unix.



DW:
In that case, maybe the "Linux" category needs to be removed altogether. We already have the "Kernel" category...



I'm familiar with RMS' arguments and I've talked to him in person countless times on the subject.



I'm willing to go along with the GNU/Linux nomenclature, but I would also insist on honoring other groups at the same time. So, GNU/Linux as a name is insufficient. It should at least also be GNU/X.org/BSD/Linux but there are other groups that would still be left out, who are also worthy of recognition. Where does the madness stop?



TV:
C'mon, now. You know it's trivial to set up a system without X. You can leave out just about everything except Linux and the GNU utils and libs and have a perfectly functioning operating system. You can also make a minimal operating system using GNU plus a BSD kernel or even OpenSolaris (which is really weird -- GNU's Not Unix + UNIX = huh?). You can't make a general purpose X.org/Linux or Apache/Linux operating system. You can add either of those to a GNU+BSD or GNU+Hurd (masochists do exist) operating system.



Red Hat is free to call their system Red Hat Linux and Debian is free to call theirs Debian GNU/Linux, certainly, but, if the bare bones foundation requires both GNU and Linux to function, it's not madness to credit both. You and I can use either term interchangeably and figure out whether it's the kernel or the OS being discussed.



Keep in mind that SCOG likes to confuse the masses with name games. Sprinkling the term GNU/Linux or GNU+Linux on FOSS-centric websites helps educate newbies. The strength of the GPL is what has stopped SCOG cold as well as turned IBM into a Linux zealot. Each time a newbie asks why we use GNU/Linux and Linux when we mean the same thing, it's an opportunity to educate another person about why protecting the user is important.



I spent a great deal of time at Groklaw before showing up here. You can't overstate the significance of GNU, the GPL and the FSF. It is the combination with Linux that changed the world, but without RMS's foresight, there would simply not be a Linux.


[Ed.: It would be extremely hard for anyone to read the collection of documents, research and court transcripts at Groklaw and not be impressed with the strengths of the GPL.]



DW:
You make excellent points, in a concise way that hasn't yet been done successfully in the public eye.

The Messenger v. The Message



DW:
Now, in my earlier email I gave some reasons for my hesitance to use the term, and you have successfully addressed each of them.



There was one more significant reason that I left out, thinking it wouldn't be necessary but I am now compelled to put it forth:



RMS is the last issue that keeps me from wanting to use the term GNU/Linux.



RMS ... have you ever met him in real life? Have you ever watched him destroy youth's passion for free software? It's heartbreaking to remember how cruel and uncaring he can be with his harsh words.



I spent time working with the FSF (in person) in order to get them to fix RMS' image, and they had some success (they even got him nice clothes and a haircut!) but not enough yet that I can see.



His contribution to free software was incalculably valuable to the cause; I just wish it had been someone else.



I just don't want to join him on his bandwagon. :( Just some thoughts...



TV:
I've never met Stallman in person.



Actually, you're not the first FOSS VIP to tell me these things about RMS and his image. I had a real knock down, drag out email battle with someone whose identity I'm not at liberty to reveal, over whether RMS's ATI protest should be publicized. The story ran on LXer. The argument then deteriorated into one about whether LXer was turning evil. (That actually convinced me that LXer must be having a good effect, as no one would try to get that FOSS advocate to doubt LXer if it was insignificant).



I suspect it's RMS's Asperger Syndrome that gets in the way of social interaction. Reference: Chapter 3: A Portrait of the Hacker as a Young Man [Free as in Freedom Richard Stallman's Crusade for Free Software By Sam Williams]



DW:
Some thoughts...



As a child, I was diagnosed as borderline; my personality creates additional difficulty for my interaction with other people, but I also see it as a huge asset and wouldn't have it any other way.



It helped that I married a woman exactly like me, although that creates new sets of problems for ourselves... :)



TV:
I'm really glad my wife is not a grump like me! Her 27 years of teaching elementary school attest to her ability to tolerate rude and outlandish behavior. (BTW, she's become a picture-posting monster on Dave's Garden since I made an html step-by-step guide for her home page).



DW:
With borderline, autistism, schizophrenia, etc, it takes extra work to see that other people have intrisic value and that you are not the only person on earth. RMS seems to have yet to learn this fact. Maybe he's incapable of it, having perhaps a more severe case than I and many others have, but I doubt it.



TV:
I can appreciate Van Gogh's paintings. His vices and personal problems don't detract from that appreciation.



DW:
Excellent point! I'll be digesting that some more.



TV:
GNU is Stallman's masterpiece. The simplicity and power appeals to the geek and the wanna-be engineer in me. Events have proven his early insistence on vetting all code accepted by GNU to be extremely valuable. There are no SCOG-like predators going after GNU. Only patents and patent trolls stand a chance at attacking it. The power of the GPL, as shown by its ability to attract corporations like IBM and even Sony, has produced some protection even in the area of software patents.



Note that the BSDs never got such support, because corporations are users, too, and the BSD license does not protect users. This is Stallman's genius -- that protection of the computer user, with those 4 simple freedoms, effectively removes so much power from those who consider computer users and developers as simply revenue generation units to be exploited.



Closing Remarks





As you can see, this was not an exhaustive, research-laden, scholarly debate. There is no absolute, undeniable, single correct answer to the question of what to call an operating system which is based upon the GNU system and the Linux kernel. The freedom that is guaranteed by free software licenses, as defined by GNU, must include the freedom to name the system as the user sees fit.



However, in my opinion, it is a disservice, disrespectful and discourteous to avoid giving credit to all the people who worked all those years before Mr. Torvalds provided the last major piece of the puzzle for a complete, free, Unix-like operating system. It is not an undue burden on those of us who know the history and enjoy the benefits of truly free software, particularly software provided under the user-protective shield of the GPL, to inform those who have been under-informed by the popular press about that history and the GNU philosophy.



My work on free software is motivated by an idealistic goal: spreading freedom and cooperation. I want to encourage free software to spread, replacing proprietary software that forbids cooperation, and thus make our society better.
-- Richard Stallman, Copyleft: Pragmatic Idealism





Sprinkling "GNU/Linux" or "GNU+Linux" around is not hard work, yet this simple act points out to others that you recognize that idealistic goal of "spreading freedom and cooperation" and agree that it is worthwhile. Rather than confusing, you provide an opportunity to educate a "newbie" about why the freedom in free software matters.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: LXer Features; Groups: Community, GNU, Linux

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

Comments (34)

Guh-nuu

13 earlier comments in the full thread.

"I deal everyday with Suits, and they do not know about nor care about 'GNU'. "

I guess that's why Sony included several printed pages of the GPL with my tv and makes the source available for download. It also explains why IBM is using the GPL in their case against SCOG. Silly suits just never heard of GNU.
"The FSF did all the hard work. Then Linus comes along and writes one little package, the Linux kernel, and gets all the credit. It's not fair. When The HURD, started in 1990, is finished, the FSF will eat Linus' lunch. Just wait!"

Quoting: Welcome to the GNU Project web server. The GNU Project was launched in 1984 to develop a complete UNIX like operating system which is free software: the GNU system (GNU is a recursive acronym for “GNU's Not UNIX”; it is pronounced guh-noo, like canoe). Variants of the GNU operating system, which use the kernel Linux, are now widely used; though these systems are often referred to as “Linux”, they are more accurately called GNU/Linux systems.


Since the subject is GNU, rather than HURD, I think 1984 is the appropriate date to consider.
1984?

So, does that mean that the GNU project was failing to gain traction a full 7 years before Linux came along with Linux?
"Silly suits just never heard of GNU."

Grouch: Walk into a small business (1-100), attempting to convince them (Non IT Business People) to switch from a M$ based data center to a Linux based datacenter, and have to explain what a recursive acronym is, what GNU represents, and why it is SO important that they always use a name that most can't even pronounce. OR Walk in and use the term "Linux" and concentrate on the Features, Secutiry, and TOC, and ACTUALLY make a sale, rather than be treated like some geeky fanatic!!!

I live in the REAL world, and know my market! Yes, I'm glad Sony knows about the GPL, (Along with TiVo, Linksys, and others) and I am an active member of Groklaw, and have been following to SCO foolishness since the begining.
"""Walk into a small business (1-100), attempting to convince them (Non IT Business People) to switch from a M$ based data center to a Linux based datacenter, and have to explain what a recursive acronym is, what GNU represents, and why it is SO important that they always use a name that most can't even pronounce. OR Walk in and use the term "Linux" and concentrate on the Features, Secutiry, and TOC, and ACTUALLY make a sale, rather than be treated like some geeky fanatic!!!"""

rstanley,

I sooooooo hear you on that one. The FOSS community shoots itself in the foot all the time with names like GNU/Linux, gKrellM, AMaViS, and Podfuk. (Yes, that last one is a real project!)

Remember a while back when people were *seriously* proposing that we call Linux "LiGnuX"? (That way Linux, GNU, and XFree86 all get credit. Isn't that wonderful!)

It's insane. It does not inspire customer confidence. And it is totally counterproductive.

-Steve
dinotrac: >"So, does that mean that the GNU project was failing to gain traction a full 7 years before Linux came along with Linux?"

Nice distortion of reality just for the purpose of sneering. Linus used GNU in the creation of his kernel. After thinking about it, he then adopted GNU's GPL.
rstanley: >"Walk into a small business (1-100), attempting to convince them (Non IT Business People) to switch from a M$ based data center to a Linux based datacenter, and have to explain what a recursive acronym is, what GNU represents, and why it is SO important that they always use a name that most can't even pronounce."

Please show me where I insisted on such actions.

The importance of GNU is its protection of users, specifically, users' freedoms with respect to software.

I refer you to sander's comment above, which is very sensible, IMO:

Quoting: I agree with giving GNU credit, but I don't use GNU/Linux all the time. When I write about a specific distro I usually use whatever the converion of that distro is. When I write about the system - not a specific distro - then I usually write GNU/Linux, but I speak "Linux". Speaking "GNU/Linux" breaks the flow of a spoken language too much, but for writing it doesn't matter one bit.


In a written proposal to a business it would be advantageous to include the term "GNU/Linux", if for no other reason than to lead into discussing how the GPL protects that business, as a user, from consequences arising from dependency on a single vendor. A discussion with a CEO, in person, may or may not involve a summary of the history of how the operating system evolved, depending on the person you're talking to and the time they have for questions and answers.

In my somewhat limited experience (sole proprietorships only, in face-to-face meetings), the owner always wanted to know how MS gets away with exorbitant fees if there is a free system which can handle the business's needs. Explaining this requires a summary of the evolution of free software in general and GPL'd software in particular.
sbergman27:

Quoting:I sooooooo hear you on that one. The FOSS community shoots itself in the foot all the time with names like GNU/Linux, gKrellM, AMaViS, and Podfuk. (Yes, that last one is a real project!)

Remember a while back when people were *seriously* proposing that we call Linux "LiGnuX"? (That way Linux, GNU, and XFree86 all get credit. Isn't that wonderful!)

It's insane. It does not inspire customer confidence. And it is totally counterproductive.


And the names like "Google", "YouTube", "Yahoo" or "Flickr" are any better? Who is to decide what kind of name sounds cool and sexy anyway? It's a subjective thing anyway, and the biggest reason why some, even silly names, start sounding so cool are because alot of money has been spilled into brainwashing people to start liking the name.

That said, any name, including "GNU", gKrellM, AMaViS and even podfuk can be made to appear trendy and cool, if you give it some marketing twist. Some people actually already like them. Ask my sister, she recently told me that one of the things she likes about GNU/Linux world is funny names which sound cool and different than usual - she is 16 years old!

rstanley:

Quoting: "Silly suits just never heard of GNU."


Well teach them then! The insistance on calling GNU/Linux properly is not just about giving credit where credit is due. There is an even more important reason; it rightfully associates it with the philosophy for which GNU Project has been started in the first place, philosophy which is also at the root cause of all the benefits that GNU/Linux provides those same IT people with and which many of those suits are starting to see.

If suits don't yet know of GNU then that is just regrettable because then they probably see it as just an exploatable resource rather than a cooperative community working in freedom, in a truly free market within the realm of software industry.

Thank you
> Since the subject is GNU, rather than HURD, I think 1984 is the appropriate date to consider.

Actually, I was going use 1984, but then, since the point I'm making is that the FSF has never been able to come up with a satisfactory kernel, I looked up the start date for the HURD. The intent was to be as fair as possible to the FSF. I didn't want to imply that they had a 7 year head start on Linus' project and still haven't come up with an acceptable kernel after 22 years of trying, when the reality is that they only had a 1 year head start on Linus and have not been able to come up with an acceptable kernel after only 16 years of trying.

Still, it kinda takes the wind out of the sails of that oft-used FSF argument that Linux is just one package out of many.

>Nice distortion of reality just for the purpose of sneering. Linus used GNU in the creation of his kernel. After thinking about it, he then adopted GNU's GPL.

It seemed only fair given GNU-heads' propensity to do precisely the same thing with regard to Linus's contributions.

Linus's contribution of the Linux kernel was no small thing. For that matter, Linus's personal leadership of Linux from geek oddity to mainstream powerhouse is no small thing, either. In that regard, his "insignificant" contribution eclipses anything the GNU folks have done. Without Linux, GNU would be nowhere.

Which in no way denigrates the nice little set of tools they've developed. They've obviously done a good job there, or Linux wouldn't rely on them.
>Explaining this requires a summary of the evolution of free software in general and GPL'd software in particular.

Much as I appreciate the goals of the Open Source Initiative -- to be a marketing tactic for free software -- I believe they went down the wrong path.

The OSI guys performed a major service by making it clear that you can love, use, and profit from free software without wearing sandals, growing a beard, or memorizing the Communist Manifesto. From the standpoint of correcting perceptions, OSI has done a great job.

But...as it turns out...

The more I have worked in companies that use -- or should use -- free software, I realize that open source is not the major draw. Programmers might be amazed how few people really want to crack open the source code of their tools.

What really helps businesses is the freedom, not to mention the ability to use things gratis. There is no free lunch in business. You pay for everything. Paying for support? Fine. Doing it yourself? You've got to pay the employees. But free as in gratis matters when you need to re-configure, do disaster recovery, pilot programs, any number of things where you would rather operate according to your business needs instead of license restrictions. Free as in freedom matters because --well -- exactly the same thing.

Whaddya know? Freedom for suits and freedom for "hippies" ain't so different after all.
"""Well teach them then! The insistance on calling GNU/Linux properly is not just about giving credit where credit is due. There is an even more important reason; it rightfully associates it with the philosophy for which GNU Project has been started in the first place, philosophy which is also at the root cause of all the benefits that GNU/Linux provides those same IT people with and which many of those suits are starting to see."""

There are times that I touch on the matter. Universally, my customers' response is to change the subject, thereby letting me know that they don't really care about all that philosophical, ivory tower stuff. They care about the nuts and bolts of whether it can do what they need. I can't say as I blame them, either.

Go ahead. Say my customers are foolish and short-sighted. I'm pretty sure someone will. Doesn't change anything, though, one way or the other. Reality is still reality.
dinotrac:

Quoting: Linus's contribution of the Linux kernel was no small thing. For that matter, Linus's personal leadership of Linux from geek oddity to mainstream powerhouse is no small thing, either. In that regard, his "insignificant" contribution eclipses anything the GNU folks have done. Without Linux, GNU would be nowhere.


I agree that Linus's contribution was quite significant, but I wouldn't go so far to say that it eclipsed anything GNU folks have done. It is still GNU GPL that was the "silent force" which has enabled the Linus to do what he did. GPL, in a sense, just works. I'd say that the credit should in full respect go both ways and the name GNU/Linux does that aptly.

Quoting: (...) Whaddya know? Freedom for suits and freedom for "hippies" ain't so different after all.


Well said that (and above). Just goes to show that the whole open source split up might not have been needed afterall. Actually, I do believe so. Today, it is practically FSF that does all the work at advocating and defending Free Software, legally, practically and philosophically. Just the comparative look at the FSF.org and OpenSource.org websites should tell you everything.

I'd say that the only thing left living of the whole "open source" split up is a formal organization (the OSI) and the increasingly vague buzzword.
sbergman27:

Quoting: (...) Reality is still reality.


Fair enough. It is still up to us to change things within that reality to the better. Noone said doing it has to be easy, but just because it's tough doesn't mean we shouldn't try.

Dean said:

"""They've obviously done a good job there, or Linux wouldn't rely on them."""

OSS projects tend to use whatever is available. Just look at the moaning about autotools. In a community where sometimes it seems that no two people ever agree on anything, the agreement that autotools sucks is more or less universal. It seems that everyone hates it, but most everyone still uses it.

Then again, you are referring specifically to the Linux kernel. And when Linus decides that some needed code is truly inferior, he has a history of tossing out the 5, 10, or 20 years of work that some group has done, and writing up something better on an evening that he happens to have some free time.

I've noted a lot of complaining about gcc on LKML over the years. But I suppose if he thought gcc was truly inferior, he'd write something better. However, compilers are hard to write, and even harder to get right. It might even take him the better part of a week.
Steve -

gcc has one strength: it compiles for a mess of platforms. It didn't used to do an especially good job -- lots of other compilers would kick it's butt on specific platforms.

I don't know how close it is to parity with the best platform-specific compilers, but I'm pretty sure it manages, at the very least, to squirm off to the side so that butt kickings don't land square.
> It is still GNU GPL that was the "silent force" which has enabled the Linus to do what he did. GPL

I don't buy that for a minute. The GPL was another good choice of tools, but Linus did what he did because he is who he is and the time was what it was. Last I looked, lots of free software projects have done quite nicely for themselves without the GPL.

>, in a sense, just works. I'd say that the credit should in full respect go both ways and the name GNU/Linux does that aptly.

Hmmm. By that logic, I suppose we should call certain other operating systems GNU/BSD. Sorry, but I can't even make that parse.
Quoting:Last I looked, lots of free software projects have done quite nicely for themselves without the GPL.


I have doubts that Linux kernel would do as good as it did if it wasn't under GPL. Those other projects aren't Linux.

Quoting: Hmmm. By that logic, I suppose we should call certain other operating systems GNU/BSD. Sorry, but I can't even make that parse.


Parse what? I am basically with the article grouch wrote here. If you can't parse that then fine. It is ultimately your decision what you will call it. I will call it GNU/Linux for the reasons stated. I believe it may better help the Free Software cause for anyone else to do so too, but if you wont.. so be it.



as dave said it:

"You make excellent points, in a concise way that hasn't yet been done successfully in the public eye."

thanks for that, eMBee.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post