Advanced

Microsoft Hicks Take Backward Stand On Interoperability

Posted by dcparris on · 32 comments
LXer - Editorial; By D.C. Parris (Charlotte, USA)
Mail this story
Print this story

LXer Feature: 19-Feb-2007

Microsoft's recent letter argues for choice of formats, not office suites. Yet, their argument undermines the foundation of interoperability that a single standard can offer. In other words, their argument is so backwards, it makes this old hillbilly's head spin.

I grew up in rural West Virginia. The nearest thing to a city was 10 or so miles from our house. Now that I live in Charlotte, NC, 10 miles is across town. People consider West Virginians to be "backwards hicks", "hillbillies" and sometimes worse than that. I didn't help that impression while my Marine buddies were teasing me, either. I firmly upheld the "Mayberry" image, letting some of them believe Pa was among the first in the Southern part of our county to own an automobile.



Regardless of how backwards I may seem or even be, the recent "love letter" from Microsoft to IBM makes me feel like a modern-day, global jet-setter. Consider the following:


"The IBM driven effort to force ODF on users through public procurement mandates is a further attempt to restrict choice. In XML-based file formats, which can easily interoperate through translators and be implemented side by side in productivity software, this exclusivity makes no sense – except to those who lack confidence in their ability to compete in the marketplace on the technical merits of their alternative standard. This campaign to limit choice and force their single standard on consumers should be resisted."



Microsoft is attempting to turn the tables on the OpenDocument supporters by arguing for choice in document format standards. Ironically, having a second standard will only serve to perpetuate the interoperability nightmare. Picture two businesses, each with an office suite that supports only one of the standards. Oh, sure, bigger companies will have less to worry about. Still, a small business may find it difficult to do business because it cannot support, say OOXML documents. The situation could be reversed. The point is that one business may find itself locked out of competing with other businesses simply because they chose a solution that implements a different standard.



I spoke with the IT manager of a local engineering firm here in Charlotte some time ago about the potential for using OpenOffice.org. He was not willing to risk losing the fidelity of documents in a document conversion exercise. This is exactly the problem that any "open" document standard should solve. The customer deserves to have a choice of office suite, regardless of the underlying format. The already accepted OpenDocument Format standard already offers that. Adding a new standard means having to continue worrying about document conversion, which will, in turn, perpetuate the notion that a business cannot migrate without risking interoperability. And Microsoft will, of course, use exactly that argument in their future marketing campaigns.



The purpose of OpenDocument, as I have always understood it, has been that it will enable me to use the office suite I want to use, while still being able to share documents with people who use other office suites, including Microsoft Office. Unfortunately, someone at Microsoft decided not to participate in the development of OpenDocument. The company has thus created a self-fulfilling, paranoid prophecy of their enemies being out to "get them" with this "inferior" document standard.



Had Microsoft contributed to OpenDocument, they could have helped to ensure its compatibility with the billions of aging Office documents sitting on hard drives everywhere. I seriously doubt they could have helped to make it perfect - that is likely impossible, even with OOXML. They certainly could have helped improve ODF. Instead, they rejected ODF, and threw millions of dollars into developing an alternative format, apparently thinking like George Bush, that they would be greeted with cheers and ticker-tape parades.



Microsoft's only arguments for choice have been about choosing which versions of Windows and Office you want to use. Their only use of standards is to adopt so they can adapt to lock customers into their solutions. And now, instead of contributing to the biggest interoperability push the world has ever seen, they want to force you to keep converting between document formats. How backwards is that?



Note: The author has no connection whatsoever with IBM, other than having met a few people who claim to work for IBM. The author is a member of the OpenDocument Fellowship and lurks on the mailing list, and occasionally annoys the list members with off-the-cuff remarks.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community, IBM, Microsoft

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (32)

totally agree

ya when I read their letter - the first thing that popped in my mind was that their argument was retarded.

they are the ones that are afraid of competing - they want to compete with standards and not products. this is retarded. can you say LOCK-IN.

standards will make it a true level playing field and that is what they are afraid of. people will actually be able to chose products because of what they like and not because their documents are in a certain format. this will help with piracy too because people won't want to steal work's office software just so they can work at home.

this letter is the whole problem with microsoft - it is that bill gates thinking - they still think like bill did in the netscape video tapes. they still continue with their monopolistic practices and show no sign of changing their ways - in fact they are going the opposite way in my book - they are getting even worse with their monopolistic practices.



In XML-based file formats, which can easily interoperate through translators and be implemented side by side in productivity software, this exclusivity makes no sense

I already highlighted this snippet of the Microsoft letter in other posts. Basically they are saying it is so easy to convert between standards that there should be others that compete. When actually their argument actually points to 1/ if it is so easy to convert 2/ aren't the standards therefore effectively equivalent and interchangeable 3/ why therefore not just use the one already in existence and accepted as an open standard.

The clear conclusion must be that they are deliberately not saying is they won't be compatible, they won't therefore be convertable and therefore the whole basis of the argument they present is in fact a lie. It just seems to be a magicians twirl of deception while they pick your pocket.
> In XML-based file formats, which can easily interoperate through translators and be implemented side by side in productivity software, this exclusivity makes no sense

Considering that MS Office formats had been a de facto standard for years, and MS could have opened them years ago, this is an issue because MS felt it was optimal to leave the development of an open standard years ago. How do they explain their exclusivity?

Microsoft's answer before was always an extension of the middle finger when someone else made a suggestion regarding the Office formats. The Office formats were designed in such a way as to maximize Microsoft's profits. Why should they get anything less than an extension of the middle finger now? Why do they think they had a right to force their profit-maximizing schemes on others before, but now they have a right to say anything about this issue?

I guess it's always difficult for the abuser to come to grips with the fact that things have changed. "Well it's only fair that you let me control you six hours a day."

If someone wants to use a specific file format, why should that make any difference to Microsoft? What difference does it make to them if they want to save documents in broken Chinese? Who's the customer and who's the supplier? It's always hard to give up the monopoly mindset.
Quoting:In XML-based file formats, which can easily interoperate through translators and be implemented side by side in productivity software, this exclusivity makes no sense
Compatibility via Standard Formats beats translators hands down. MS prefers translation for multiple reasons

a) It is time consuming & troublesome to convert and consequently users will be deterred from migrating to ODF when they want because it wont be easy.

b) MS isn NOT writing but rather out sourcing the translator plug-in development for a reason. If there are issues, and there will be, their customers can't blame them for inaccuracies and deficiencies.

c) MS OOXML Schema is controlled by MS only. So they are free to do whatever they want, whenever they want without notice. They also can change the promise to start charging for using the schema any time they want after many are hooked.

d) They can add their old office format documents as binary into OOXML without disclosing its format

Translators fundamentally don't work for the normal workflow case, as they don't preserve the features not supported, so it's a lossy conversion only suitable for doing once. The application itself needs to understand the format so it can preserve the features it doesn't understand while editing. The format needs to be designed in a non-'must-understand' manner as well.

Office Software and the Politics of GWB - No Connection

7 earlier comments in the full thread.

Alright guys, as someone who generally doesn't find politics very interesting (though, yes, I have been involved with individual campaigns and did cheer the outcome of the 06 elections) I vote that we avoid political discussions here, particularly about the Iraq War. I think the original comment was fine.
Well, at least no one is disagreeing with the fact that Microsoft was NOT "greeted with cheers" at their developing an alternate (and competing) format. In typical Microsoft style, I'd guess that they received the ODF information, passed it along internally, took the parts that made sense to them, modified those parts to fit their existing structures, and had some poor bloke write the 6K page "documentation" for submittal. The latter person (or persons) may have been purposely ignorant of the ODF, so that it wouldn't look like a paper written by a highschooler with an encyclopedia in front of him (i.e. plagiarized like crazy). Am I wrong?
> I agree in general with your main points regarding Microsoft and office suites/formats, but your swipe at GWB is gratuitous and in poor taste.

You are certainly welcome to your opinion. However, my comment entails no disrespect. As a former US Marine, I fully understand what it means to show respect to the Office of the President.

Most of the responses to your post have picked up the correct tone of my statement. George Bush, along with some of his aides, told us on national television that the Iraqis would greet us with open arms. That has not born out in reality. Likewise, Microsoft assumed they could just develop an alternate document format standard, and that everyone would jump on the bandwagon. The comparison is quite apt. :-)
> That has not born out in reality

Government and Corporate both seem to love pushing fantasy when it's to their perceived advantage. It's all our responsibilities to haul them back to the real world... Whatever that takes.
I specifically recall Bush, et. al., stating the Iraqis would love us, and thinking that it was stupid of them to tell the American people that. Microsoft is trying to sell the public on the idea that 2 standards are, what? I dunno, better than one? Something like that. Anyway, they say two standards are better for interoperability. How so? I have grave concerns about the intelligence of someone trying to tell me that continuing to have to convert between document formats, when we could all be using one, is a good thing.
I'll show respect to GW when he shows respect to America.
>I'll show respect to GW when he shows respect to America.

Well that's something I understand. I say the same thing about nearly every Democratic politician. So, far, I haven't had to show much respect.
They're all pretty rotten, imo. BTW, what happened to the OP? Makes an accusation based purely on assumption and leaves?
>Makes an accusation based purely on assumption and leaves?

Seems so. Sigh. it's so hard to find quality agitators these days.
>>I'll show respect to GW when he shows respect to America. > >Well that's something I understand. I say the same thing about nearly every Democratic politician. So, far, I haven't had to show much respect.

Some guy once said that people who criticize of America is more patriotic than the people whom just blindly agree. While completely unrelated to your post, I needed something that I could bring to ask my questions. First, does anyone know the actual quote? And secondly, how do you quote things, in the little box thingy?
> Sigh. it's so hard to find quality agitators these days.

One of us has definitely been around the other entirely too long.

> First, does anyone know the actual quote?

Sorry, I'm lost on that one.

As for quoting in the forums, I always just use the '>', but someone here who uses the blockquote can tell you how that's done. I think it's 'quote' inside '[' and ']':
Quoting:This is a quote.


Yep, that's it. don't forget the closing tag.
>First, does anyone know the actual quote?

Quotes are among the easiest things to find on Internet since advent of the WWW and Google.

And you can quote me on that.

There is a whole page of quotes that express the sentiment you describe at http://www.betterworld.net/quotes/patriot-quotes.htm

I found that page in 1.4 seconds (well, about that) by just googling your own key words like [url=http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=criticize America patriotic quote&btnG=Google Search]http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=criticize America patri...[/url]
> So, far, I haven't had to show much respect.

Of the Presidents I remember, I've respected one. I don't think any of the others have been worthy of the office. Unfortunately, I expect that ratio to continue.
The usual way to phrase your arguments without starting a flame war is:

"Microsoft is telling us 'X'. If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you in Brooklyn."

You can convey the meaning without pushing people's buttons.
So how much do you want for the bridge in Brooklyn? And would you throw in one of the two in San Francisco too?
Actually you get one in Cincinnati with the one in Brooklyn, They are the same model and builder, just slightly different scales.

Here in Chicago we have 60 or so movable bridges, but you can only lease them, I'm not selling!
I too am disappointed in one-shot stinkbombers. Come on antiskid, have the courage of your convictions! Get back here and put up yer dukes!

Haw. Chikken! buckbuckbuck.
N6x -

But you remember -- a year or two back -- the guy who lived in the bridge tower? Ran an extension cord, had TV and everything.
> the guy who lived in the bridge tower?

Yeah, but the down side is the ocasional homeless bum who, thinking he's found shelter, gets caught in the gears :(
Hey that guy was living under the LSD bridge. Thats the high rent district. Right by Oprah and all those rich folks.

There was another guy living in the subways a few years back too. He had copies of a lot of the CTA keys!

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post