Advanced

Carmony Says Raymond Mail Not Tied to Linspire

Posted by dcparris on · 3 comments
LWN.net; By D.C. Parris
Mail this story
Print this story

LXer Feature: 24-Feb-2007

When Eric Raymond sent off an e-mail complaining about the Fedora project and distribution, some suspected his action was motivated by his conflicting values, with respect to including non-free multimedia codecs in Fedora Core, and that there might be some connection to his work with Linspire. Linspire's CEO Kevin Carmony posted a comment on LXer's forum to clarify the unilateral nature of Raymond's mail.

When Eric Raymond sent off an e-mail complaining about the Fedora project and distribution, some suspected his action was motivated by his conflicting values, with respect to including non-free multimedia codecs in Fedora Core, and that there might be some connection to his work with Linspire. Linspire's CEO Kevin Carmony posted a comment on LXer's forum to clarify the unilateral nature of Raymond's mail.



Carmony pointed out the fact that, had Raymond really been trying to benefit Linspire, he would have endorsed Freespire or Linspire, not Ubuntu, despite the partnership with Ubuntu. Carmony also pointed out that Linspire has not hired Raymond, but that Raymond is serving as a volunteer. For his part, Carmony stated he was unaware of Raymond's action until it hit the newswires.



Carmony also stated that Linspire certainly would not have wanted Raymond to stir up animosity amond the Fedora developers, with whom he has been trying to build a positive relationship. Carmony said that Linspire believes developers from various GNU/Linux distributions need to work together more, not less. Carmony recognizes that Raymond's e-mail could create unnecessary tension between distribution developers at a time when he is trying to work closely with those same developers to resolve challenges facing the Linux desktop.



In a story posted yesterday, Lxer noted the responses of several Fedora project developers. Raymond's dissatisfaction seems to have been focused primarily on the lack of non-free multimedia codecs in Fedora, since the other problems he cited were aptly answered by the developers. Raymond's e-mail reflects someone who is seemingly intent on burning bridges, rather than keeping them intact.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: LXer Features, News Story; Groups: Community, Fedora, Linspire, Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (3)

Thank you for sharing this and trying to clear this up.

I'd like to add that Linspire has a great relationship with Fedora. We HAVE been working with them on bringing our CNR technology to Fedora users (via an optional plugin). Fedora has been nothing but very good to work with us. The main reason you saw the Ubuntu deal before Fedora is simply supporting an RPM-based distribution, such as Fedora and openSUSE, will take us just a bit longer than the Debian-based Ubuntu, because historically CNR has been Debian centric with Linspire and Freespire.

Linspire looks forward to helping forge MORE work between all Linux companies. The real challenge here is the monopoly of the mind Microsoft holds over desktop users. By working together, we stand the best chance of succeeding in breaking through that wall.

Thanks,

Kevin Carmony CEO, Linspire
No problem Kevin. I know all too well what can happen when people assume more than they should. I'm subject to that myself sometimes. ;-) My personal assumption was that ESR felt he needed a way to break ties with Fedora, more so than trying to please or help Linspire/Ubuntu. I actually don't think the Fedora devs thought of Linspire as inciting ESR, but rather ESR making changes according to his values, which align well with Linspire's.

Also, it's good to hear that you're working to introduce CNR to Fedora and other distros. Sounds cool.
Any unification in packaging is a step forward for that matter. Let's just not concede choice, not only in terms of packaging options; also the choice to avoid proprietary software and binary drivers.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post