The 10 Best Linux Distributions
I've had several people ask me what I think the best, top, most user friendly, ultimate, and so on distribution is--so now I'm publishing my Top 10 Linux Distributions in reverse order of preference. Ease of installation, commercial support, community support, updates, administrative tools, stability, performance, and to a lesser extent--their ranking on DistroWatch.com. 10. SuSE (SLED, OpenSuSE, etc.) - This bottom spot belongs to Novell's Linux offerings mostly due to the commercial version's lackluster performance and overall updatedness (if that's a word). SuSE Linux seems to be a bit behind the curve for updated hardware drivers. Though it's community-supported OpenSuSE is quite up to date, SuSE takes this last place position with flying colors. Novell's sleeping with the enemy status also helps drop it into the Linux distribution dregs. 9. Slackware - This one is really hard for me to put this low in the list because it was my first Linux love and the oldest Linux distribution (1993). I installed it using 3.5" floppy disks on a Compaq desktop PC in the fall of 1995 leaving out the almost impossible to configure X Window system (would have been 2 more boxes of diskettes). Slackware's Patrick Volkerding and his loyal following have done a great job over the years in keeping the distribution alive but sadly I haven't used it in years due to its lagging development and infrequent releases. It is also only developed for the i386 platform. 8. Mandriva (Mandrake Linux, Connectiva, Lycoris) - Though wildly popular in other countries, I never really caught on to this one. In fact, I even turned down doing an article for a european magazine that was focusing on Mandriva. I am not repulsed by Mandriva but have just never found a reason to embrace it for myself or recommend it to others as an option. The reason for its placement higher than either SuSE or Slackware is its popularity in Europe and South America. Mandriva has made significant inroads in converting many european cities and companies to it--so for that alone it deserves higher than average marks. 7. Fedora - I used Red Hat Linux from version 4.0 up to version 9.0 when Red Hat, Inc. stopped creating and supporting it. Fedora grew out of that original Red Hat Linux project. Once Red Hat, Inc. made that decision, I fired off a scathing email to them criticizing their abandonment of a huge and loyal following. Fedora has never lived up to the same quality or stability of Red Hat Linux whose pinnacle was the 7.3 distribution. I tried using Fedora for a couple of years but have totally removed it from my arsenal of available and recommended distributions. Its popularity is the only reason it is included in this position or this list at all. 6. Gentoo - This is where it gets really tough for me because I'm including this distribution in a relatively high place though I don't care for it at all. So, why the high status? Gentoo is a source-based distribution that offers extreme performance, has some of the best developers and community in the world, and it uses the FreeBSD-like Portage for updates. Gentoo has an extremely loyal and religious following--who I'm sure I'll hear from because of its 'bottom 5' positioning. Hey, it's at the top of the bottom 5, if that's any consolation. Gentoo is not a distribution for casual users but if you're really into Linux and like to create something awesome, you should give it a try. Personally, I just don't have the time. 5. Knoppix - Knoppix is the original Live Linux CD and is still the force to be reckoned with in that area. Almost all other Live Linux CDs use Knoppix as a starting point. It is Debian-based and has absolutely never failed me. It is the best equipped Live CD I've seen to date and takes the top spot amongst all its competitors. If you want to use a Live Linux distribution, this is the one to choose. 4. Red Hat - Red Hat, Inc. is the top commercial Linux company in the world. Like it or not, companies that use Linux in the Enterprise, use Red Hat Linux--it's that good. Red Hat is perhaps only second to Debian in spawning new and interesting distributions and projects. Red Hat now focuses on Enterprise Linux and recently acquired Qumranet to bolster its position into the virtualization realm. 3. CentOS - Community ENTerprise Operating System is my personal Linux distribution of choice. Once I abandoned Fedora Linux, I needed another distribution that had a true Enterprise capability without the costs associated with that level of performance and stability. I chose CentOS. CentOS developers use SRPMS (Source Packages) from Red Hat to build this distribution so basically I'm getting the latest incarnation of Red Hat Enterprise Linux for free. By License (GPL), Red Hat must make the distribution available for free. The CentOS developers and community receive my highest praise for their efforts and I hope they keep it up for years to come. If you haven't tried CentOS, you should--I highly recommend it and use it daily. 2. Debian - For years, I shunned Debian as the outsider in the Linux World. To me, it was kind of the ugly puppy that you want to give away first so that you aren't stuck with it. It takes this coveted second place because of several factors: It has the largest worldwide community of volunteers who support it, it's one of the oldest distributions, it supports more platforms and languages than any other distribution, and has spawned more distributions and projects than all other distributions put together. I see Debian as more of a tool than as an end user distribution. To me, it's for developers and creative types to use as a base for other projects, distributions, and systems. On its own, it's quite capable but as a distribution base, it's limitless in scope. I recommend it to all those who want to build and distribute your own Linux flavor. 1. Ubuntu - You knew it didn't you? Ubuntu is the obvious choice for many reasons: It's Debian-based, has top-notch commercial support from Canonical, it's free, has frequent updates (twice per year for major releases), and its founder and benefactor Mark Shuttleworth is one of the nicest people you'll ever meet--who gives freely of his time, money, and energy to a myriad of causes--Ubuntu being only one. Ubuntu employees also appear to be the happiest of any I've ever met. They are congenial, inviting, engaging, and are truly excited about what they do. Ubuntu offers a second-to-none Desktop Edition and a hard-to-beat Server Edition. Currently at 8.04 (April 2008), its fans patiently await the 8.10 release which happens in just over two weeks from now. Get Ubuntu and free yourself from doing Windows. |
|
|
Comments (33)
13 earlier comments in the full thread.
I thought this WAS his humor piece. :)
Quoting:Slackware now requires a smidge more than what the most tricked-out 80386 system can support. The oldest supported hardware is now the i486.
Slackware 12.0 would boot and install fine on my VIA C3 Samuel CPU. None of the Slackware 12.1 kernels would boot.
I'd try Slackintosh on my Power Mac G4, but it runs Debian Etch so well, it would be hard for me to do any experiments on it until I get a few more drives to work with.
1. The one I'd like to have 2. The one my friends are bragging about. 3. The one I actually use.
Sigh.
"It makes a funny noise when I do that."
Fedora is great, provided you wait until two or three months after the release to install. For me the big problem is that there is only 13 months of support for each release. I really liked Fedora 7 for the few times I used my wife's laptop but then all of a sudden Fedora 9 was released and that was the end of Fedora 7. I like the ability to run a distro for at least 18 months, with security updates, if I choose.
Just repeating the response I saw on here, yea these many months ago.
Quoting:Really, Fedora rocks the boat!!
Quoting:And occasionally tips it over.
Gentoo grows the trees, builds the tools, builds the boat, rocks the boat, and then occasionally tips it over. :P
My Favorite, No, My Favorite, No No, MY Favorite...lol!!
A 500 horsepower engine on a 12-foot dinghy, held on with Super-Glue.
Just don't open the throttle too quickly.
I tried SimplyMEPIS too, that wasn't too bad. Only a PITA to install VMWare. Gentoo shows that the hard and very user unfriendly way of installing VMWare in Debian clones isn't necessary at all; under Gentoo it 'just works'. Didn't like Ubuntu because it was rather difficult to change the configuration to my likings. Also Gentoo is complete compared to other more 'lean' spartan distro's when it comes to development environment. When I want to compile something in Ubuntu there are a lot of files and libraries etc. the system just misses. I remember installing Debian once, but it was rather difficult because of all the really confusing ncurses menu's, you have no idea where you are coming from and where to go to (same for FreeBSD). Installing it is needlessly difficult. They should look at OpenBSD for something that's simple to install. I can explain to my mum (the most digital-illiterate person I know) how to install OpenBSD: Look at the cursor, and answer the questions. I can't explain to her how to install Debian or FreeBSD, because I myself don't even know which menu-item to choose. I just can't find my way around in those silly user-unfriendly menu's. You need a 'HOWTO' to know which menu-item to choose in which order, while OpenBD is simple to install without anything at hand (except some configuration parameters maybe).
Suse plainly didn't work - without changing the whole packet manager. After that I quite liked it, but it was slow. Slackware required too much effort to run, but it was the first Linux I used so maybe that's why. I also didn't know how to resolve dependencies back then, because every BSD - the only OS except Win and Dos I had used back then - does it for you. I'm trying Sabayon, but after using it for more than 10 minutes it always 'almost hangs' meaning every action including typing a single character takes more than ten seconds to process. Apart from that Sabayon is rather good, but of course the slowdown is a showstopper. I need a new version probably.
I remember also wanting to try Mandriva but I couldn't figure out which of the versions I needed. Knoppix also worked rather well. Since the moment I started using Gentoo Linux, it's too hard for me to use FreeBSD, because I seem to use some functions in Linux which FreeBSD didn't have the last time I tried it. I wanted to try VLOS but figured out it wasn't gratis so I refrained from it.
Despite all the distro's I tried I haven't find a 'really good one' yet, but Gentoo is closest. One of the only distro's which doesn't force you to use a bloated WM like XFCE by the way (exaggerating here of course! But it is true, XFCE is more bloated than what I use).
What I don't like about it is the limited availability of some packages, the painstakingly process of updating configuration files, some problems the packet manager spits out and the far-too-many USE-flags, and the really stupid ACL-issue. For the rest I'm happy with it.
However, fact remains: There's no sensible discussion possible to talk about the ten best Linux distro's if you haven't defined 'best'. Most articles don't.
But as said, there is no one Best distro for everyone. It all depends on the person and their individual tastes and personality.
When they botched the dependencies to/from libffi, it broke the GCC update, which then broke my ability to get any updates at all. Thus, I had a functional system that was stuck. I even tried installing the binary package to get things back, and it still was dead in the water.
I felt like I was waiting for an update for Windows. And that is a showstopper.
If after many dozen Linux installs, a half-dozen i386 OpenBSD installs, a couple NetBSD and FreeBSD installs, I can't get a system to boot, that tells me something.
@hk, 3.5 is current Sabayon, however there is an updated install medium coming out soon so that your not spending a long time downloading the updates after you install, so keep your eye's peeled for 3.5.1, and for mercies sake please get the DVD version, putting portage compatability into the CD version is a bear, trust me I know, I wrote up the process.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post
