Canonical Seeks Independent Developers for Ubuntu Linux
Are you an app developer with an “itch to scratch,” or an independent programmer eager for more exposure to the open source channel? If so, the Canonical team is building a site just for you, to help you integrate your work into Ubuntu. Here’s a look at the strategy so far. |
|
|
Comments (36)
16 earlier comments in the full thread.
Now the question is, how much will Canonical try to influence or impede the direction of said distro? There's a lot to be said for independence.....
Unless independence doesn't come with a paycheck.
Quoting: So what are users supposed to do for the next year? Put up with a sh*tty DE, or just not use their computer at all while waiting for things to "mature"? Why should users put up with a POS DE for a year when they had something before that worked just fine for them?As others have pointed out, if you have something that works, why change it? My desktop at work is still ubuntu 10.04 LTS. I saw no need to move to 10.10 or 11.04, because, as you so aptly put it, it works "just fine" and it will probably keep running 10.04 just fine for a couple more years. Then we look around at the distro landscape and decide which way to go.
However, I do have a netbook and unity is not a bad fit there, so I'm installing the ubuntu 11.10 beta. I'll look at kde 4.7 too - who knows, that might even be a better netbook interface than unity.
Ah but that is the sore spot, isn't it? "We" are not giving the current crop of touch tablet experiments a chance. "My" users won't love it, because I'm sure as heck not going to recommend it to them.
If I get "my" users on Unity or Gnome 3, I will have to use it too to be able to support them. I don't see it happening. These interfaces are tablet based. My users have full-fledged desktop PC's. I have a full-fledged desktop PC. I'm not willing to deal with a tablet interface on a non-tablet device.
Apart from the ill fitting use case, these new environments are fickle with the hardware and drivers they require. Hardware was finally becoming less of an obstacle and then our GUI Overlords decide we need 3D capable hardware and drivers just to display a GUI. That is a trap I'm not willing to step into just right now.
So who is going to push these glorious new interface onto newbies? I'm not. What I support is what I use. So "my" users will probably (and eventually) move to XFCE if the Mint team is unable to make something sane out of Gnome 3.
Xubuntu has been around for years, but Canonical never gave out Xubuntu LiveCDs in their old ShipIt service. Only Ubu and Kubu were available, and Xubu made their own separate arrangement. It will be the same for Lubu and E17tu and whateverelse 'buntu.
Quoting: because I'm sure as heck not going to recommend it to them.
Where is the choice you enjoy for your users too? You think they don't deserve it or not capable? Don't underestimate the power of freedom.
Quoting:So who is going to push these glorious new interface onto newbies? I'm not.
How long you think you will be able to keep them under your control? Not for long, I think.
Quoting:Where is the choice you enjoy for your users too? You think they don't deserve it or not capable? Don't underestimate the power of freedom.
How long you think you will be able to keep them under your control? Not for long, I think.
Trololol
You really don't understand how this works, do you? It's not a question of control. It's a question of trust.
Quoting:TrolololWhat is Trololol?
From definition #3 of a strikingly similar word at http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Trololo (the profanity within is slightly edited here):
Quoting:"Trololo" is any b*sh* (or other) speech which is completely unfounded in reality, contains absolutely no truthful substance but is spoken in a happy, optimistic way. Generally, the speaker is not aware that they are completely full of sh* - this is most common amongst clueless businessmen or entrepreneurs pitching venture capitalists on lame business ideas.
Trololo is interchangeable with "B*sh*" but contains a connotation of a positive, clueless delivery on the part of the person speaking it e.g., the person speaking does not realize that they are full of sh* and is way too happy.
The Trololo-er is someone who has committed the ultimate sin of buying into their own b*sh*.
(Based on the world famous "Trololo" video posted on YouTube featuring a happy Russian singer happily spouting / singing nonsensical phrases)
"That presentation was the worst bunch of Trololo I ever heard."
"Did you hear that Trololo Steve Jobs was spouting about Adobe Flash?"
"Our CEO is the king of Trololo, I have never met someone who has b*sh*ted themselves so thoroughly."
"Trololo[l]" as its clearly intended meaning of "b*sh*" would then apply to the quote that immediately precedes it:
Quoting:Where is the choice you enjoy for your users too? You think they don't deserve it or not capable? Don't underestimate the power of freedom.
How long you think you will be able to keep them under your control? Not for long, I think.
Quoting:Trololol
@fewt === Sewage tank, poke it with a stick and it stinks the whole neighborhood.
Quoting:@fewt === Sewage tank, poke it with a stick and it stinks the whole neighborhood.
trololol
Trust was mentioned and as myself and many others have brought to light. This isn't about code. This isn't about features or individual choices.
This is indeed about trust.
It's been quoted here a dozen times so I am going to assume most everyone here has read it. One Gnome Dev/Knight-of-the-Round-Table stated that no community extensions or hacks would be accepted into Gnome3 because it would taint the direction and vision the Gnome Team has for #3. This tells me that if left to the Gnome Devs, there will be NO features introduced into the Gnome shell/Gnome3 unless they originate from the Devs.
And we've seen their vision of the future and that vision is keyboard shortcuts where they are just friggin' goofy.
But to my point. Am I going to introduce my kids to an environment where their needs are secondary to the developer's "vision"? No...We've begun working with the Xfce folks and if what I read is indeed what will take place, Xfce is about to undergo some fantastic improvements...improvements based on user input...not on a handful of narcissistic devs.
When 10.04 reaches end of life, we will have our Xfce distro ready to go. I don't care how good Unity or Gnome may have gotten by then. If I don't trust you, I don't work with you...period.
Quoting:This is indeed about trust. ...
... I don't care how good Unity or Gnome may have gotten by then. If I don't trust you, I don't work with you...period
No one can disagree with either of those statements.
On the other hand, Trust goes both ways.
Most who use FOSS, especially the old timers, had to put some trust in the developers to start using their software. For a long time, no one knew whether they would succeed or not, but the trust was there and developers in general, in one way or another, delivered.
Now we are at a turning point where new innovations and concepts are changing the hardware landscape, which consequently is also changing the software paradigm. So why are we losing this trust?
Some see drastic changes in the DE and they don't believe it is going to add any value to what is already in existence, but have we given them enough time to prove their plans? I certainly do think so and we ought to.
Just like KDE went through a very rough development period, close to three years I believe to reach a good level of usability, reliability, and elegance; for various reasons, I don't expect it to take that long for Gnome 3 & Unity.
So why are we jumping the gun again with Gnome 3 & Unity? I am not saying the complains and discontents are not warranted, on the contrary, they are important and essential to influence the direction the developers are taking. But what is also as important is to make sure we don't destroy the trust and the support we give to the developers. I believe these are the life line for them, and without trust and support, we might be contributing to the destruction of good technology and losing a chance to make the Linux Desktop better suited for various devices that would help it to proliferate faster.
KDE suffered an onslaught of criticism and bashing for a while, but they tenaciously persisted and eventually succeeding in their efforts. Whether Gnome & Unity are going to survive theirs I can't tell, but I suggest it is better to wait and see how things are going to develop, especially when there are many other options still available to us.
One thing KDE had going for it is making major changes in the back end while keeping the front end basically the same. That is something Gnome & Unity overlooked and made a mess of. We don't know whether this is going to be detrimental or not, but if they had to do that, at least they should have kept Gnome 2.x fully supported and as long as the new GUI is still in development.
That certainly would have been my preference for what they should have done.
It seems to me that the Gnome devs had two different agendas going on here. Firstly, they justified the move to Gnome 3 by claiming that aspects of the old DE's behaviour were klunky and bug ridden. Then they go on to change the entire desktop paradigm beyond all recognition.
There is something strange going on here. A commentator on one of the the blogs featured on LXer stated that Gnome have only limited resources to work with, but they still managed to justify writing Gnome Shell instead of just tackling the inadequacies of the underlying Gnome architecture. I find a big contradiction there.
If they have limited resources, they should be far more frugal as to what they devote their time to. Instead of fixing the bugs, they have rewritten the GUI and ended up with a Beta-class product that is less reliable than Gnome 2. They're not moving forward, they've taken a big step back.
Quoting:I suggest it is better to wait and see how things are going to develop, especially when there are many other options still available to us.It is probably better for those particular end-users who have ALREADY LOST the necessary trust in Gnome 3 & Unity to explore on an earlier basis rather than on a later basis, those "many other options still available". Furthermore, such end-users might even wish to seriously consider abandoning ship A.S.A.P. (assuming that they haven't done so already!), while just sitting around waiting to "see how things are going to develop" with the aforementioned end-user complaints concerning Gnome 3 & Unity development.
Granted there may be a diminishing number of persons, such as the trusting commentator quoted here, who will no doubt disagree with the actual timing of the abandonment of Gnome 3 & Unity. So be it.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

I thought it already had become part of the family. Wasn't there an article here about it last week or the week before?