Advanced

Ubuntu Uproar Echoes Through Blogosphere

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 26 comments
LinuxInsider; By Katherine Noyes
Mail this story
Print this story

Well it's been another wild week here in the Linux blogosphere, but this time the cause will come as no surprise to anyone who cares about Linux or FOSS. Last week, of course, was the week that included Oct. 18 -- a date most of us have had marked on our calendars for the past oh, say, six months. Why? Because it was none other than the official release date of Ubuntu 12.10 "Quantal Quetzal."

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Linux, Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (26)

6 earlier comments in the full thread.

Thing is,... Many third party packages (Hulu Desktop as one example) are released in binary for only two distros; Fedora & Ubuntu. That will keep Ubuntu relevant for some time, at least. Personally, I've switched to Kubuntu... for most of my machines, at least. I now tend to stick with LTS releases, if I can help it. Change can be too much of a hassle, when things are just working right.
Hulu Desktop? Never heard of that. I'm intrigued.
Nice app, but buggy under KDE,... You have to manually tweak its config file to allow the exact screen rez and full screen.
Quoting:I think what Markie is doing makes perfect commercial sense, Ubuntu/Unity isn't my cup of tea, and it isn't what a great many who saw Ubuntu as an easy Debian want, but Ubuntu/Unity, and other derivatives of Ubuntu, such as Zorin, which use the Ubuntu Software centre, and the underlying GNOME 3 libraries are what impress Windows refugees, who are looking for a cheaper, more secure, more stable Windows like experience.
OTOH, while this commentator may insist that "what Markie is doing makes perfect commercial sense", others continue to question such decisions, e.g., author Sam Varghese in the recent piece entitled 'Mark Shuttleworth's big mistake', linked to at LXer via http://lxer.com/module/newswire/view/175606.

Perhaps it may be more illuminating to focus upon the actual message of pieces such as Vargese's, rather than on the messenger(s) ??



Varghese's rant is garbage, not message. He goes on and on about the many times that Shutlleworth has pizzed off the "community" and then fails to provide any examples of said pizzing, sans the Amazon Search idea. So what if Varghese "questions such decisions." Who cares, really? People will always question. It doesn't make it an important "message." It's just some guy's opinion.

I don't use Ubuntu and Unity isn't for me, but I call bu11**** when I see it. Regardless of where I think Ubuntu may be heading, I hope it works out for them in the end. I'd rather see another successful, commercialized Linux desktop than another failed Lindows.
Quoting:Varghese's rant is garbage, not message.
As always... This is the same guy who launched into personal attacks on me because I dared write that Ubuntu users did, in fact, have the right to ask for a decent product. Fortunately his editors pulled the libelous bits. I have yet to see anything from Mr. Varghese I'd consider credible and valuable.
If Microsoft or Apple included sponsored Amazon results, from which they stood to get a piece of the action, when you searched your drive, can you imagine the uproar FROM LINUX USERS?

But it's OK if Ubuntu does it?
> But it's OK if Ubuntu does it?

That's for each person to decide for themselves. But for me, no.
@steven, I don't give a rats who does it. As far as I'm concerned it's a non issue.
Honestly, while this advertising on the desktop might not be as bad as it looks, a for-profit company run by a multimillionaire/billionaire, whose product is built squarely on the shoulders of non-profit, non-corporate Debian, asking for DONATIONS ... it just doesn't smell right.
Here we go with the generating income from free software is wrong method of thinking. My guess is that Ubuntu has costs it must cover to continue its operations, and it's ex-CEO isn't willing to shoulder said costs for eternity. I also don't care what Ubuntu does as it wouldn't affect me even if I used it.

Pricey Microsoft & Apple operating systems shouldn't be given equal consideration when discussing what's right and wrong with generating revenue on the backs of its user base with that of no-cost operating systems who must seek a means to survive.
So you're saying that what's not OK for Microsoft and Apple is OK for Ubuntu because Ubuntu is available for free?

What other Linux distribution is doing this to its users? Hell, what other OS in general is doing it?
The problem is not about Ubuntu making a profit from FLOSS -- that's a red herring.

The problem is choosing to implement things like, by default, infringe user privacy in order to generate that revenue (eg. the folding of Amazon search into desktop search -- if the same "feature" had been offered as an opt-in service, easily toggled by even the techno-clueless customers that Canonical is reaching out to, no one would have minded, and many would have praised this as a small but genuine innovation).

We all hope that Canonical/Ubuntu becomes a great success -- we just don't like some of the things it's done in pursuit of that goal.

And additionally, since Canonical made a great deal of its ethical/moral/philosophical foundations, they can expect departures from such a standard to be criticized, as well.
Quickly, open a window-- the blogothphere is thickening.
What's it really like "inside" Canonical? I wonder.
Quoting:What's it really like "inside" Canonical? I wonder.


The bozone?

Eh, nevermind. That's not really fair.
Quoting:So you're saying that what's not OK for Microsoft and Apple is OK for Ubuntu because Ubuntu is available for free?
Yes I am. When I pay for an operating system, I don't expect to be (asked | forced | tricked) to continue generating revenue for Apple or Microsoft. What I'm not saying, however, is that Canonical is doing it the best way. Clearly they aren't.
The EFF called out Ubuntu for privacy and security concerns. It's not just the "blogothphere".

(My brain hurts just thinking about how tuxchick's word would actually sound.)
Can we all just agree that Ubuntu never does anything wrong and should be held to a different set of standards than everybody else?
Why is it always the Debian derivatives that come up with these weird ideas about how to make money? Xandros, Lindows/Linspire, Ubuntu. What's wrong with the Red Hat/SuSE model of selling support & maintenance contracts? I'm surprised after all these years that a smart guy like Shuttleworth hasn't figured out that if he really wants to make money, he needs to try to beat Red Hat at its own game. Its not as though Red Hat's systems are so hassle-free to work with that they couldn't use the competition.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post