Advanced

Brendan Eich steps down at Mozilla

Posted by tuxchick on · 89 comments
Linux User
Mail this story
Print this story

Controversial Mozilla CEO Brendan Eich has left his position after concerns over his views on same-sex marriage came back into the public consciousness

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Mozilla, Linux; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (89)

69 earlier comments in the full thread.

@jdixon: But non-religious beliefs are fine? Well that lets out the roughly 80% of the US population who claim to be religious. So much for democracy or a republic. I guess we can only hope our atheist overlords.will be kind masters.

A constitution, particularly the constitution of the US, while not perfect, is generally drafted to protect *everyone* from everyone else. It matters not one whit if you constitute 51% or 99.9999% of the population. No-one should have the right to impose their belief that one section of society should have privileges that are out-of-bounds to another section.

Whether that is pay, fair dealing under the law, their status as a citizen, their ability to practice a religion or any other myriad aspect of life that does not directly impinge those same basic rights of other people.

That this is not overtly obvious to any right-minded, intelligent, thoughful citizen of the world in this century is quite staggering to me. Surely, it is self-evident?

Any religious person that does not feel this to be true can stick their religion where the sun don't shine.
@jdixon: If Eich was that kind of person, he'd have a clear cut discrimination lawsuit. Fortunately for Mozilla, he's not, and will continue the fiction that he "resigned".

Clearly in this case Eich would have a very difficult job determining that he was forced from his job by Mozilla.

The likelihood is that the board collectively came to the conclusion that his stay was causing bad press for Mozilla and him stepping down was the only way to deal with it.

He may well have been forced out of his job by a witch-hunt but I think it unlikely that he was pushed involuntarily.
> No-one should have the right to impose their belief that one section of society should have privileges that are out-of-bounds to another section.

Privileges and rights are not the same thing. There are lots of privileges that are available to others that are denied to me by law. I'm sure the same is true for you.

> ...or any other myriad aspect of life that does not directly impinge those same basic rights of other people.

As I noted before, marriage is not a politically enumerated right, at least not at the federal level. It is primarily a religious institution, predating both the US and the state of California by millennia. And the state Supreme Court upheld the law.

> ...in this case Eich would have a very difficult job determining that he was forced from his job by Mozilla.

He wouldn't have to. Read the law more carefully. "No employer shall make, adopt, or enforce any rule, regulation, or policy". By not taking action against the employees who called for Eich's resignation, Mozilla effectively made their stand Mozilla's policy. "No employer shall coerce or influence or attempt to coerce or influence his employees". The other employees were attempting to coerce Eich. Mozilla had a responsibility under the law to make it clear such actions wouldn't be tolerated. They did not do so. They are thus liable for the actions of their employees. While I am not a lawyer, I can guarantee that a good one would be salivating at the prospect of taking the case.
On Eitch getting INVOLUNTARILY shoved outta Mozilla for his personal views...

logic of devnet, NoDough, jdixon, +a zillion<

skelband, a -2> (GOTTA keep digging himself into a hole trying to defend that jerky nutjob OkCupid CE0...)

2 more cents+sense
Actually, marriage is a legal institution (a contract), dealing with property and inheritance (including women and children under the rubric of 'property') and political alliances, predating the church and temple by millennia. For most of history (even if we consider only Western, Christian-era history) the institution has been more about relations between the families, clans or nations being joined than about individual couples. Ordinary folk didn't even get married -- 'hand-fasting' and similar customs were good enough for them.

Here's a decent short summary of the history of marriage: http://theweek.com/article/index/228541/how-marriage-has-cha...

And SCOTUS acknowledged the right to marry back when the issue was about inter-racial marriage. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loving_v._Virginia and thus the loving vs. Virginia case has been cited in the more recent court decisions that struck down barriers to same-sex marriage.

> Actually, marriage is a legal institution (a contract)...

Yes, it is. But it has always been far more than that.

> predating the church and temple by millennia.

Predating any individual church and religion? Yes. Predating religion? There's absolutely no way to tell, since both go back past recorded history. However, within recorded history, marriages were almost always recognized through religious rites.

> And SCOTUS acknowledged the right to marry...

Not exactly. They recognized that the state has no authority to bar interracial marriages. That's not the same thing. Barring a constitutional amendment, the state undoubtedly has no authority to bar the contractual accoutrements of marriage to anyone deemed competent to make the contract (of course, that reopens the door to polygamy in the US, but that's another issue). But as I said, marriage has always been far more than that.
Too long, didn't read.

I'm just going to say, Firefox is an open source and collaborative project with millions of contributor. I'm not giving it up because of one person that have a different view about one subject and go to an alternative browser that does more to invade user's privacy and missing many features.

You can pry it from my cold dead hands.
> Privileges and rights are not the same thing. There are lots of privileges that are available to others that are denied to me by law. I'm sure the same is true for you.

I don't know where this "rights" thing comes into it.

I don't believe that anyone necessarily has the right to marriage. What I do believe is that privileges that are accorded only to the few merely because of their gender is the very definition of sexual discrimination. That is what I'm against.

Yes, a poor person may get unemployment benefit whereas I, as an employed person, do not. However, I would expect the same treatment as an unemployed person regardless of any other factor which is out of my control such as gender, sexual orientation or belief system.

> As I noted before, marriage is not a politically enumerated right, at least not at the federal level. It is primarily a religious institution, predating both the US and the state of California by millennia. And the state Supreme Court upheld the law.

Again, I'm not talking about marriage as a right. I'm talking about equal treatment under the law.

> He wouldn't have to. Read the law more carefully. "No employer shall make, adopt, or enforce any rule, regulation, or policy". By not taking action against the employees who called for Eich's resignation, Mozilla effectively made their stand Mozilla's policy. "No employer shall coerce or influence or attempt to coerce or influence his employees". The other employees were attempting to coerce Eich. Mozilla had a responsibility under the law to make it clear such actions wouldn't be tolerated. They did not do so. They are thus liable for the actions of their employees. While I am not a lawyer, I can guarantee that a good one would be salivating at the prospect of taking the case.

That's all very well, but you are assuming that Mozilla pushed him. That is far from clear. It's possible but even Eich's issued statement makes no such assertion, although we do know that it often does happen.

Let me make myself clear on this though. I do *not* support the action taken against Eich by OKCupid. It is possible to be right and a dick simultaneously. OKCupid are just as guilty as Eich of trying to influence people and events by their actions to further their particular beliefs. I happen to agree ith OKCupid's assessment of Eich's actions. However, there is a point at which action taken against someone becomes disproportionate and I think any right-minded person would agree that the word disproportionate in this case hardly seems adequate.

I merely believe that Eich is misguided and wrong. These donations were made, I believe, 6 years ago. Eich *may* have changed his views since then. I do not know. Whatever the rights and wrongs, I judge someone on their beliefs and actions now. People can change and they should have the opportunity to do so if they wish.

Quoting:I merely believe that Eich is misguided and wrong. These donations were made, I believe, 6 years ago. Eich *may* have changed his views since then. I do not know. Whatever the rights and wrongs, I judge someone on their beliefs and actions now. People can change and they should have the opportunity to do so if they wish.


That's not the debate. He isn't wrong for having an opinion outside of work. He has nothing to apologize for and shouldn't be asked to do so.

The debate is whether or not what you do in your personal time gives people the right to persecute you in your professional one. That's what is happening to him.

Once he was put in the place of CEO...employees threw a hissy fit and said they would all quit...a coup honestly...all about the guy who CO FOUNDED MOZILLA. Nice eh?

He was pushed out...make no mistake. He was there 2 weeks as CEO and rather see his company implode he removed himself. The focus should have been on software, instead it was on him.

Odd thing is that he made this donation in 2008...how many releases has Mozilla had since then? How many employees revolted when he was named CTO a few years ago? None, that's how many. Somehow, changing hats from running technology for a tech company to running the entire company made him a bigot in the eyes of people. I'm not buying it.

I think someone out there was butthurt with him being CEO and they made a mountain out of a mole hill.

I also think ANYONE who agrees with how this entire effed up situation was handled by employees at Mozilla is taking a dump on the constitution in order to force their own view onto people. Sad really.
> What I do believe is that privileges that are accorded only to the few merely because of their gender is the very definition of sexual discrimination.

Privileges can be accorded on pretty much any basis anyone wants. So women's only schools, women's only sports, and too many other women's only programs to mention are sexual discrimination? Ditto for the NBA, NFL, etc.?

> ...but you are assuming that Mozilla pushed him.

I made no such assumption. Re-read my post. The actions of the other employees constituted attempted coercion. Mozilla didn't discipline them, but rather accepted their conduct, and is thus responsible for it. And in doing so they set a corporate policy which is against California state law.

> I merely believe that Eich is misguided and wrong

His beliefs may be misguided and wrong. That's for each person to judge for themselves. His decision to support those beliefs via political action was not. That's the way our system is supposed to work.

> The focus should have been on software, instead it was on him.

Isn't that the point I opened this thread with? :)
> Privileges can be accorded on pretty much any basis anyone wants. So women's only schools, women's only sports, and too many other women's only programs to mention are sexual discrimination? Ditto for the NBA, NFL, etc.?

Perhaps so. They are private clubs. The government or the state *must* not engage in such activities.

You can elect to support or not support, agree or not agree with private organisations. The government takes your rmoney and enforces it's edicts by rule of force. That's why we have constitutions to protect people from injustices perpetrated by them. There is a fundamental difference.
> Odd thing is that he made this donation in 2008...how many releases has Mozilla had since then? How many employees revolted when he was named CTO a few years ago? None, that's how many. Somehow, changing hats from running technology for a tech company to running the entire company made him a bigot in the eyes of people. I'm not buying it.

Like I said before, I think that he has been shamefully treated wrt OKCupid in this regard. I do not support the hounding out of someone from their job because of views held, regardless of how abhorrent they may be considered by others.

However being the CEO of a large organisation like Mozilla means that you guide the organisation morally as well as practically. Mozilla (irrespective of whether or not you think they are hypocrites) takes a strong moral stance on certain values.

It is not wrong for him to be called out if people consider that these views are at odds with that stance. The role is fundamentally different from that of a CTO. A CEO is the public face of an organisation and his character reflects on that organisation directly.

Although the views that Eich has were pretty unremarkable and commonplace as the acceptance of slavery was at one time, this is no longer the case. I put this issue as firmly in the same bracket as requiring schoolkids in the US to include "under God" in the declaration they make. Times change and so do attitudes.
> The government or the state *must* not engage in such activities.

With respect to rights, I agree. However, the same is not true with respect to privileges. The government can define who is and who is not eligible for a privilege pretty much as it sees fit.

I would argue that defining the nature of marriage is such a case. As long as the law is equally applied, the government can define it pretty much as it wishes. And, being government, that decision is going to be made on a political basis. Which means, ultimately, the will of the people should decide the matter. Making a matter political is very much a case of live by the sword, die by the sword.

Now, my personal view is that marriage should be completely outside the scope of government. But when the government grows as large and power hungry as ours has become, that's a lost cause. They won't allow it. And of course I feel that way about a lot of things our government has arrogated unto themselves.

> However being the CEO of a large organisation like Mozilla means that you guide the organisation morally...

I think you misunderstand the nature of corporations. By definition, they are inherently amoral. Only people can have morals. At best, you can say the people making up the corporation largely share certain moral values. And do you really think one person should be "guiding" the morals of other adults? That's a rather perilous path to tread.

> Although the views that Eich has were pretty unremarkable and commonplace as the acceptance of slavery was at one time, this is no longer the case.

Do I really need to repeat that Prop. 8 passed in the most reliably liberal state in the country? And that only a short six years ago. I wouldn't be at all sure of that position.
> Do I really need to repeat that Prop. 8 passed in the most reliably liberal state in the country? And that only a short six years ago. I wouldn't be at all sure of that position.

What short and selective memories we have. Here's a reminder, perhaps a little hysterical, but not too far off the mark:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/outward/2014/04/04/brendan_eich_s...

"Liberal" is not a word that easily comes to mind in this context.

I guess that as a Brit, I'm still shocked at the kinds of things they put on TV here (Canada) and in the US in attack ads. Some of the mainstream political commercials are outright offensive to me. (They're free to put them on of course, that is the price of living in a free society, the freedom to shock and the freedom to say things that others find uncomfortable.)

But this is the kind of thing Eich and his brethren were supporting, and this is the least "uncomfortable" that I could find. This is a family site after all...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75J3TN9Zzck
> What short and selective memories we have.

Why would I remember ads aimed a California residents? I don't live anywhere near California. That doesn't change either the fact that California is the most reliably liberal (in the modern sense) state in the US, or the fact that Prop. 8 passed.
The analysis at the time was that Prop. 8 passed in 2008 because it was up in the same election as Obama for his first term as president, and the overwhelming turnout was more conservative about marriage than it otherwise would have been in a run-of-the-mill California election.

Quoting:The analysis at the time was that Prop. 8 passed in 2008 because it was up in the same election as Obama for his first term as president, and the overwhelming turnout was more conservative about marriage than it otherwise would have been in a run-of-the-mill California election.


That's completely illogical. How does a huge turnout for a progressive candidate prop up a vote for a conservative proposition?

Edit: And if the progressives are this conservative, how much more popular would the proposition be if the conservatives turned out?
skelband wrote: But this is the kind of thing Eich and his brethren were supporting, and this is the least "uncomfortable" that I could find. This is a family site after all...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75J3TN9Zzck

I'm not sure why that video makes you uncomfortable, if anything the quite realistic unease of the gay couple in the video shows how artificial the concept of a gay marriage really is...

What I'm uncomfortable about is all those numerous ads shown on British TV where the man of the house is always portrayed as clumsy and incompetent while the wife is the one that in in control of the situation.

Back on topic, I agree with those on here who said Eich has been the victim of a witch hunt, in fact I'm convinced somebody wasn't happy about him becoming CEO and therefore started this smear campaign on purpose. What is quite sad though is that this smear campaign has been successful, the result is that people will think twice about freely expressing their opinion, enforced conformism wins.

Quoting:...enforced conformism wins.


I believe that's called fascism.
No, it's called "totalitarianism." It comes in many different colors, (modern) Fascism being but one.

(Then again, look up the history of the term "fascism" and be prepared for a shock.)

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post