Stallman, Torvalds, Moglen share views on DRM and GPLv3
|
|
|
Comments (54)
34 earlier comments in the full thread.
dinotrac: >"Goodness gracious, sounds like you've never been near a garage."
Nice of you to make such an unfounded presumption. Any time you want to have a race at disassembling and reassembling any vehicle on the road, bring it on, otherwise, I will assume you are again playing the arm-chair theorist.
Nice of you to make such an unfounded presumption. Any time you want to have a race at disassembling and reassembling any vehicle on the road, bring it on, otherwise, I will assume you are again playing the arm-chair theorist.
Grouch, I'll take that challenge!
My first real job was auto mechanic, both gas and diesel. I got out when microchips started appearing because that made it too expensive to run my own shop, and working for other people has always been itchy and galling. Tell ya what- let's each bring the 60s vehicle of our choice and a sack of tools, and the race is on. :D Hey, who remembers how to tweak twin carburetors? wahahaaa, I do!
My first real job was auto mechanic, both gas and diesel. I got out when microchips started appearing because that made it too expensive to run my own shop, and working for other people has always been itchy and galling. Tell ya what- let's each bring the 60s vehicle of our choice and a sack of tools, and the race is on. :D Hey, who remembers how to tweak twin carburetors? wahahaaa, I do!
ps- that business with the big automakers refusing to release trouble codes and technical data is all true. They want to shut out independent repair shops. Which doesn't even pertain to the source code, but simply capturing and reading program output, and having current specs. Lovely little world we live in.
tuxchick2:
Don't be wimping out on me. Let's do a real challenge: Just about any post-2000 GM vehicle. '60s vehicles actually have room around the mechanical parts, and they don't have to be retrained just to be able to idle.
Don't be wimping out on me. Let's do a real challenge: Just about any post-2000 GM vehicle. '60s vehicles actually have room around the mechanical parts, and they don't have to be retrained just to be able to idle.
Quoting:Tell ya what- let's each bring the 60s vehicle of our choice and a sack of tools, and the race is on.
-begin subliminal suggestion- pink t-shirt that says "I got beat by a girl" -end subliminal suggestion>-
grouch, that is just plain sadistic.
SFN, you are now my favorite LXer person.
SFN, you are now my favorite LXer person.
txchick -
Yes ma'am. Let's keep apples with apples and oranges with oranges.
Yes ma'am. Let's keep apples with apples and oranges with oranges.
> who remembers how to tweak twin carburetors?
You auto people are such whimps, try balancing 4 kehins by ear on an early cb750...
You auto people are such whimps, try balancing 4 kehins by ear on an early cb750...
Quoting:try balancing 4 kehins by ear on an early cb750
Try tuning a Bosendorfer 200 Conservatory Grand by ear. It's hell, I tell you.
Quoting:SFN, you are now my favorite LXer person.
-begin channeling Rowan Atkinson- It's a race! I'm winning! -end channeling Rowan Atkinson-
> Try tuning a Bosendorfer 200 Conservatory Grand by ear. It's hell, I tell you.
Hell I'm sure, but hardly automotive :D
Hell I'm sure, but hardly automotive :D
jimf -
Hey...
It's about as big and heavy, and moves about as fast without gas...
Hey...
It's about as big and heavy, and moves about as fast without gas...
eeee Rowan Atkinson is creepy. If he ever got an elevator with me, I would push him out.
> Try tuning a Bosendorfer 200 Conservatory Grand by ear. It's hell, I tell you.
Unless you're completely tone deaf, in which case it's a piece of cake. The results may be less than desired, however. :)
Unless you're completely tone deaf, in which case it's a piece of cake. The results may be less than desired, however. :)
>If he ever got an elevator with me, I would push him out.
With or without the turkey head?
With or without the turkey head?
> It's about as big and heavy, and moves about as fast without gas...
So dino, we'll consider that equal in another 20 years or so.
So dino, we'll consider that equal in another 20 years or so.
Quoting:Rowan Atkinson is creepy
My mom says the same thing. I got a Mr. Bean T-Shirt just to annoy her.
That would, at least, eliminate any controversy with regard to Linux by establishing that GPLV3 is not entended for Linux.
The GPL was never a Linux kernel license. It has always been a license designed to uphold the ideals about software freedom espoused by the FSF. The GPL is an FSF license intended mostly for GNU. Torvalds just happened to choose the GPLv2 when he released the Linux kernel in 1991.
The FSF will write any future updates with the most rigorous protections possible to safeguard the four freedoms. Torvalds can take it or leave it, but Torvalds can rest assured that a very big chunk of "his OS" will go GPLv3, whether any outsider likes it or not. All GNU software will adopt the "or later version" and will effectively become GPLv3 after the first GPLv3 patches enter the tree.
If GPLv2 is a must for distributors and Torvalds, then they better start forking the whole software base of the GNU project. GNU will become GPLv3. It will be interesting to see if the GNU projects infrastructure and developer-base can be successfully replicated by the groups wanting to keep a "pure" GPLv2 environment.
Disclaimer: The reason I'm not all riled up about this, is because I am not opposed to the proposed changes. They make sense to me. As with any license, you can accept or reject it, but rejection means foregoing the covered software.
The GPL was never a Linux kernel license. It has always been a license designed to uphold the ideals about software freedom espoused by the FSF. The GPL is an FSF license intended mostly for GNU. Torvalds just happened to choose the GPLv2 when he released the Linux kernel in 1991.
The FSF will write any future updates with the most rigorous protections possible to safeguard the four freedoms. Torvalds can take it or leave it, but Torvalds can rest assured that a very big chunk of "his OS" will go GPLv3, whether any outsider likes it or not. All GNU software will adopt the "or later version" and will effectively become GPLv3 after the first GPLv3 patches enter the tree.
If GPLv2 is a must for distributors and Torvalds, then they better start forking the whole software base of the GNU project. GNU will become GPLv3. It will be interesting to see if the GNU projects infrastructure and developer-base can be successfully replicated by the groups wanting to keep a "pure" GPLv2 environment.
Disclaimer: The reason I'm not all riled up about this, is because I am not opposed to the proposed changes. They make sense to me. As with any license, you can accept or reject it, but rejection means foregoing the covered software.
A bit of background may be in order:
Quoting: [From http://www.onlamp.com/pub/a/onlamp/2005/09/22/gpl3.html?page... ]
[Federico Biancuzzi:] A lot of free software projects choose to use the following phrase in every of their program files:
This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
But this means:
1. The user will choose which particular version of GPL he prefers, not the original software author. 2. The user could choose this moving target (GPL 2.0, 2.1, 2.x, 3.x) appropriately in case of a lawsuit.
How can this undefined condition be a good thing?
[Richard Stallman:] This achieves two goals. First, that we can release future GPL versions and they will apply to the existing software. Second, that in releasing future GPL versions, we cannot impose any new restrictions on the existing software.
GPL version 3 will need to contain specific requirements that GPL version 2 does not have. Nothing large--the overall idea will be the same--but there will be some. I designed the words you've quoted to make it possible to distribute the existing code under GPL version 3, without imposing even the smallest new requirement on existing code, because people will still be able to use it under GPL version 2.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Valid point, but the GPLv3 would still give them the right to do so. So if the manufacturer wants to lock down the hardware so they can't, he shouldn't use GPLv3'ed software.
It's also, despite continuous attempts by governments to do so, proven impossible to outlaw or even significantly reduce stupidity. So trying to make it impossible to modify braking systems is probably a futile endeavor.