Advanced

Is GNU/Linux Really Replacing Windows?

Posted by grouch on · 10 comments
LXer Feature; By DC Parris
Mail this story
Print this story

LXer Feature: 11-Aug-2006

Don Parris' straw poll about replacing Windows with GNU/Linux on a couple of distribution listservs has taken on a whole life of its own in the Ubuntu Users forum. Are people really replacing Windows with GNU/Linux systems? What hardware and software issues prevent people from ditching Windows altogether? Should Microsoft be worried?

Note: We are asking people to respectfully cease posting on the Ubuntu Users' list and post any further contributions to the LXer Straw Poll forum. Thanks!



How LXer's GNU/Linux Straw Poll Works

Back when I first joined LXer - last Fall - I decided to find out just how many people were actually replacing Windows with GNU/Linux. My query came amid the numerous reports of Microsoft FUD, claims about growth, and various analysts' takes on the market. There is also the issue of hardware vendors who seem not to grasp the real nature of the desktop market. Microsoft had gone so far as to make claims that people in Asia bought GNU/Linux boxes, only to replace the OS with a pirated copy of Windows. So, the question remains, are people actually replacing Windows with GNU/Linux?



I would like to emphasize that straw polls are, by definition, non-scientific. Even so, the poll and the responses it has drawn are of some interest to the Free and Open Source Software community in general. The poll has become something of a pulse meter, and demonstrates progress toward eliminating what Ubuntu refers to as Bug #1. Let's see what other conclusions we might draw.



Ubuntu Conversions

The results from my initial straw poll amounted to a total of 72 responses. Out of that, some 55 people had replaced Windows on 134 machines. That article included users from the SUSE-OT list and 43 people from the Ubuntu Users list. Having recently moved the GNU/Linux Straw Poll to LXer, I have not included the few new responses here. Today, the numbers have changed, and show GNU/Linux gaining ground.



As of this writing, 259 people have responded on the Ubuntu Users list and forums. 193 people have replaced Windows on more than 348 laptops, desktops, and servers. What is significant is that, in the original poll, 29 out of 43 Ubuntu users reported having replaced Windows on one or more computers. That is roughly 67.44%. Today, 74.52% of the Ubuntu users report having replaced Windows. At least 4% never used Windows to begin with, being users of Mac, UNIX, or other GNU/Linux systems. And a few who previously said they had not completed conversion have now reported total conversion from Windows.



Several reported having ditched Windows at least three years ago. Several have converted others over. When we know how many, those numbers are included in our count. One person has converted 17 friends and family. Another is working on migrating 15 desktops at work from Windows to GNU/Linux. The reasons for ditching Windows are typical - licensing issues, malware, and Windows' infamous stability problems. Related to the stability issue is the frustration some feel having to re-install Windows on a frequent basis due to performance degradation issues.



There is still a significant number of people keeping Windows around for games and certain applications. Some have to use Windows at work because that's what their employer uses, while a few mentioned using GNU/Linux for work on personal laptops or desktops without their employer realizing that they don't use Windows. Some are simply hung up on their favorite Windows applications, and a few just like to tinker with different software technologies. Some users admit their unfamiliarity keeps them dual-booting for the moment, but definitely plan to drop Windows once they feel more comfortable in the GNU/Linux environment.



Hardware

Hardware still seems to be a sticking point for some. One user said, effectively, "lots of hardware still doesn't work with GNU/Linux". The irony is that the Linux kernel supports more hardware than any other major OS.

The fact is, lots of hardware does work with GNU/Linux, even when the manufacturer makes no claims about it. Buying a computer with GNU/Linux pre-installed eliminates the user's need to worry about hardware compatibility. Finally, enough people are switching to GNU/Linux, that any hardware manufacturer withholding GNU/Linux support is essentially shooting themselves in the foot.



Windows Application Ports

Novell's survey of Most Wanted Mac/Windows-only Applications points to a potential tipping point for a number of computer users. The GNU/Linux Straw Poll doesn't agree completely with Novell's list. It does suggest that only one or two applications need to be ported to enable an even greater number of users to ditch Windows altogether. A software developer wondering whether it should port its software can simply take a look at how Firefox and OpenOffice.org have been stealing market share from Microsoft's offerings. After all, these are multi-platform applications.



Off-Base Complaints

User comments continued to draw helpful responses, even when the complaints seemed a little unreasonable. One user recently reported that he would not recommend GNU/Linux to anyone. Among his complaints was the lack of a graphical tool for editing GRUB's menu.lst, an ATI X600 video card, a program to import bookmarks from firefox (to what he didn't say), and not having a way to "refresh" his Ubuntu 6.06 while keeping /home. Funny, that last one. A few people responded almost immediately with instructions on how to do just that. Still, I don't know many 'average' computer users who want to edit their GRUB menu, or why that would prevent him from recommending GNU/Linux to anyone.



Perhaps that user's funniest complaint was a problem he had run into while trying to dual-boot Ubuntu with Windows. It's one of those complaints that just seems to miss the point of the poll - find out who is replacing Windows with GNU/Linux. Why would dual-boot issues present an obstacle to replacing another operating system? Such off-base objections suggest that most practical objections have already been overcome. I raised the question as to whether the guy would recommend GNU/Linux if it were pre-installed. He hasn't answered yet.



The Bottom Line

The number of people who really can ditch Windows right now - with little or no fuss - is pretty darned high. In fact, more and more people are converting from Windows to GNU/Linux. Analysts are advising businesses to hold off migrating to Windows Vista. Businesses are saying they have no plans to do so. Respectable tech publications are comparing some GNU/Linux distributions favorably to Windows Vista. Yeah, I think Microsoft should be pretty worried about the future of its flagship software.



We'll certainly continue to track this issue. We encourage you to respond - only if you haven't already - to the GNU/Linux Straw Poll.



References

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: GNU, Linux, LXer, Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (10)

grouch Story submitter ·
Lots of places switching, lots of reasons for doing so.

Venezuela Promotes Open Source http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=57888

Deal aims to move 50,000 Asian Windows desktops to Linux http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=66191

Government says all new PCs must be Linux-friendly http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=62216

State Government CIOs Vote for OS http://weblog.infoworld.com/openresource/archives/2006/08/st...

Working Linux Emergency Response System Undermined at Homeland Security by Microsoft Lobbying http://lxer.com/module/newswire/view/57181/index.html

Extremadura.gov switches onto Linux http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=66506

OSS moving into government http://www.tectonic.co.za/view.php?src=rss&id=1085

Moroccan fisheries escapes proprietary net http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=64830

Caught on Tape: Vista Beta takes on Novell's Linux Desktop http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=62827

German tax office opens door to SuSE Linux http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=62760

Is Microsoft bracketed by GNU/Linux? http://lxer.com/module/newswire/ext_link.php?rid=60378

Mark of the Microsoft Beast http://trends.newsforge.com/article.pl?sid=06/07/25/2018237

Schools Save Big with Open Source http://www.networkworld.com/weblogs/smb/2006/012953.html

Free Software: Who's Looking Out for You? http://www.enterprisenetworkingplanet.com/netsecur/article.p...

The Ten Commandments of software manufacturers fighting FLOSS http://www.digital-copyright.ca/node/2507

Granny Finds Linux/KDE Easier Than Windows [humor] http://www.reallylinux.com/docs/gran5.shtml

Mandrake 8.1 easier than Win-XP [and this was back in 2001!] http://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/12/18/mandrake_8_1_easier_...

Linux free, easy & secure http://www.itweek.co.uk/personal-computer-world/features/216...
It's easy to look at today's rough edges and be discouraged wherever Windows or Mac might seem crisper, slicker, able to do things Linux can't, etc.

But...

Today's Linux desktop is amazing. We forget how many things it makes easy that Windows makes hard.

and...

You absolutely cannot believe the progress in the last 5-6 years. Heck -- go back 8 years and there was not KDE (well, KDE was in beta, with 1.0 around the corner) and there was no GNOME.

You simply cannot compare today's Linux desktop with the early versions. It is utterly unfair.

And...it gets better.

With the demise (in an practical sense) of XFree86 and rise of X.org, the graphics handling promises to get better and better.

gcc keeps moving forward in ways that will help KDE, at least...

All the new users add potential new developers, but, more important, they add eyes, hands, and FEEDBACK.

I would not be shocked in 5-10 years to see articles asking things like "Is there a place for Windows in today's world?"

OK, a little surprised, maybe, but not shocked.
Great list, grouch, and good points, dinotrac.

May I add something just from my personal surrounding?

A colleague changed from Windows to Etch after a hard disk crash, and because he didn't have a license. An aunt changed from Windows to Sarge after her old computer got slower and slower, and because she didn't have a license. My own brother changed from Windows to Breezy and now Dapper because he had just enough of it. He is *teaching* Windows and Office, but is now switching over to teaching OpenOffice as well. Will he go back to Windows? "Never ever", he said on his (german) blog on http://willi.lonien.de/?p=4

There's hope...

cheers, wjl
"You simply cannot compare today's Linux desktop with the early versions. It is utterly unfair."

I started out with Suse 8.1.I was dual booting and still getting used to linux.By the time Suse 9.1 was out I was 100% linux on my home computer.I don't remember exactly how long that time frame was,but from that point till now,the advances in linux have been incredible.
Yay yay! :)

I love this optimism! It's true really, when you put things into perspective (step back and look at the recent history of GNU/Linux and Free Software), we might actually be taking over the world with it. ;)

As that RedHat video suggests: Despite ridicule, ignorance and opposition, truth happens!

Or there's that famous Gandhi saying (it was Gandhi right?):

"First they ignore you. Then they laugh at you. Then they fight you. Then you win."

I strongly recommend watching that video: http://www.redhat.com/truthhappens/

I've recently compiled a list of cool and motivating videos regarding Free Software (and more broadly culture): http://tinyurl.com/ocuhg

So.. what to say. Never give up all you Free Software and GNU/Linux advocates. In the long term we actually seem to be winning!

Cheers Daniel

*edited to fix the url*
Libervis, the link to your site says "Page not found"
Sorry, the LXer commenting system seems to be skewing it..

Here's another try:

http://www.libervis.com/video_compilation_on_free_digital_cu...

EDIT: No that doesn't work. LXer keeps putting space between c and ulture in the URL. :|

it's basically this: libervis.com/video_compilation_on_free_digital_culture

EDIT: Ok here's a tinyurl which may work: http://tinyurl.com/ocuhg
grouch Story submitter ·
I just sent a message to Dave about it.
Linux really does support more hardware out of the box than Windows. I had the unfortunate opportunity of setting an up a slightly older machine for my girlfriend, who insisted on Win2k or above (no Linux); I still can't get the onboard sound card to work, and I had to buy a $2 S3Virge video card because the onboard video wouldn't do anything over 640x480x16colors, and the vendor website only provided drivers through winME with the excuse that the Win2k drivers were included on any Win2k install CD. Well, they weren't.

In order to get more info. on the machine, I booted a live linux cd (Puppy), and everything worked perfectly---sound card, video, network card and all, 'out of the box.' Windows 2000 couldn't achieve that, and the ironic thing is that I expected it to. I expected it to immediately recognize my hardware (a Compaq Presario isn't exactly 'exotic' hardware) and install the appropriate drivers. I kind of expected it to work better than Linux.

But it didn't, and it made me realize how far Linux has come in the area of hardware support, even if the hardware was 'older.' I wish my girlfriend would try Linux, but I'm not a zealot and I understand her reasons wanting to stay with what she knows, but I think the idea of Linux not working with hardware is a myth and I'll never go back to any version of Windows.
Meh, WinXP doesn't even support SATA drives out of the box. You either need to fuss with floppy drivers during the install or get your hand on a CD that includes them (like a vendor specific CD).

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post