Linux’s iPod Generation Gap
|
|
Comments (28)
The iPodders
It comes back down to the same old question:
7 earlier comments in the full thread.
Heck, I'm finished posting for the day...
coward.
;0)
Dino:
> And where is the line?
Each developer decides that for him/herself. That's the way an open system like this works. But you know that.
> coward.
I think you probably should put a smily after that, otherwise the intent can be misconstrued. :)
> And where is the line?
Each developer decides that for him/herself. That's the way an open system like this works. But you know that.
> coward.
I think you probably should put a smily after that, otherwise the intent can be misconstrued. :)
jd -
Smiley applied.
Smiley applied.
Heck, I've been around here long enough to know that 'misconstrued' is dino's middle name :)
jimf --
That's Mr. construed to you!
That's Mr. construed to you!
I stand corrected...
Quoting:If we don't care about most users, we should just say so.
Um, yeah. I don't care about most users.
>Um, yeah. I don't care about most users.
That's a start.
That's a start.
> Um, yeah. I don't care about most users.
I support users in Debian related Distros, so obviously I do care, however, I have to limit that. I have no sympathy for those people who 'say' they want Linux, then feel that they are entitled, without effort on their part. Or those who refuse to learn anything new. They are users in only the basest sense, and Linux is far better off without them. The same applies to those who aren't at least interested in learning about the GPL and FOSS.
Just packing the room with bodies doesn't enrich Linux.
I support users in Debian related Distros, so obviously I do care, however, I have to limit that. I have no sympathy for those people who 'say' they want Linux, then feel that they are entitled, without effort on their part. Or those who refuse to learn anything new. They are users in only the basest sense, and Linux is far better off without them. The same applies to those who aren't at least interested in learning about the GPL and FOSS.
Just packing the room with bodies doesn't enrich Linux.
jimf -
Sounds like you don't care about most users, either.
That's ok...there is no need to care. Lots of people think Linux shouldn't serve the "I just want to use my computer to do the things I need/want to do" crowd.
It makes it easier to frame the issue. Pains me, though. I love Linux. I love free software. I think all software should be free. At the same time, I don't want to cough up for a Mac in order to complete my computing experience.
Sounds like you don't care about most users, either.
That's ok...there is no need to care. Lots of people think Linux shouldn't serve the "I just want to use my computer to do the things I need/want to do" crowd.
It makes it easier to frame the issue. Pains me, though. I love Linux. I love free software. I think all software should be free. At the same time, I don't want to cough up for a Mac in order to complete my computing experience.
Quoting:I love Linux. I love free software. I think all software should be free.
I agree completely, but, let's look at what 'free' software is.
Free software, In this case Linux, was created by a bunch of people who cared enough to contribute, either directly by coding, or, by contributing whatever other talents they had, to the community. It isn't expected that everyone be a coder, or that the contribution has to be earthshaking, but we all 'should' give something back.
Now, that isn't stated in the GPL, or written in stone anywhere, but we all know that it's there, and it's the element that ties us together and makes Linux a community like no other. Every time we bring in a bunch of users who have no regard for this tradition we dilute the spirit of that community, and that is inexcusable... And, very sad.
Quoting:I don't want to cough up for a Mac in order to complete my computing experience.
In the end, I don't think you'll have to dino. Look at the track record. I've seen Linux supply pretty much what is needed to get the job done. It may take them a little time to accomplish that, and, I'm never sure 'how' they do it, but, it will happen. :D
"If we don't care about most computer users, life gets easier, but might not get better. We don't have to make any compromises or hard choices. It's "my way or the highway" all the way.
Hummm...I bet if many Linux Advocates had an idea how prevelant this attitude is, they would not have given chunks of their life trying to "spread the word." I do see it now that I am paying attention.
Community or idividual A tells the thirsting masses there is an oasis and to follow them to drink.
Community or individual B stands at the waters edge, relieving themselves in the pool as the ones that thirst approach. "It is MY pool and I will taint it if I wish."
What were the words to Cher's song? "If I could turn back time.?
Hummm...I bet if many Linux Advocates had an idea how prevelant this attitude is, they would not have given chunks of their life trying to "spread the word." I do see it now that I am paying attention.
Community or idividual A tells the thirsting masses there is an oasis and to follow them to drink.
Community or individual B stands at the waters edge, relieving themselves in the pool as the ones that thirst approach. "It is MY pool and I will taint it if I wish."
What were the words to Cher's song? "If I could turn back time.?
perseis -
Personally, I never took Linus's goal of "world domination" as a joke.
I believe in law, freedom, and representative government even for those poor slackers who don't bother to vote. I believe that a free society is the best society and that free societies don't overtly designate a segment of their citizenry as "citizens, second class" or some such thing.
I believe that free software is good for everyone, even those who are not able to understand why. I don't much understand open heart surgery and certainly would not appreciate the technique of a surgeon who saved my life by performing a delicate procedure on me. I would, however, appreciate the result -- life vs. death.
Lots of people find it very hard to understand what software freedom is all about. We talk a lot about source code, something most people never see and wouldn't comprehend if they did.
That's ok. They're still better off with free software. I'd like them to understand that, but I don't require it.
Personally, I never took Linus's goal of "world domination" as a joke.
I believe in law, freedom, and representative government even for those poor slackers who don't bother to vote. I believe that a free society is the best society and that free societies don't overtly designate a segment of their citizenry as "citizens, second class" or some such thing.
I believe that free software is good for everyone, even those who are not able to understand why. I don't much understand open heart surgery and certainly would not appreciate the technique of a surgeon who saved my life by performing a delicate procedure on me. I would, however, appreciate the result -- life vs. death.
Lots of people find it very hard to understand what software freedom is all about. We talk a lot about source code, something most people never see and wouldn't comprehend if they did.
That's ok. They're still better off with free software. I'd like them to understand that, but I don't require it.
"Lots of people find it very hard to understand what software freedom is all about."
You may freely count me among that demographic. My husband has drilled "free as in beer" and "free as in freedom" into my head so often I am thinking of setting up a toll booth in front of the resulting cavity. As a member of the recently enlightened, I can honestly report that this issue isn't one of burning importance to most people. Then again, most people act as cattle and form feeding lines behind the most recent Microsoft display at Circuit City. I was usually near the front of that line most times.
My point was that I see a terrible rift in the Linux Community. And Yes Jessica, there IS a Linux Community, thank you. I received an email in the lobby4linux gmail account a short time ago and it was someone who developed programs for Red Hat. This person was addressing my husband concerning a recent blog he had written and the gist of it was "if you don't produce code, STFU." (his rude acronym, not mine). I was later to see that my husband responded in a simple yet profound way.
"OK Einstein, Let's put your theory to work. You are now Bach. Write your brilliant music, but know that it will rot on the parchment on which you record it. No orchestra will ever reproduce it, no musician will ever admire it." That struck home with me, and I hope with the software writer. There are many gears to this machine, and not just the biggest one makes the bell ring.
It was only after reading that exchange that I realized that the Linux Community isn't one happy family like I thought it was. It can get down right mean in here. That disturbs me more than I want it to.
You may freely count me among that demographic. My husband has drilled "free as in beer" and "free as in freedom" into my head so often I am thinking of setting up a toll booth in front of the resulting cavity. As a member of the recently enlightened, I can honestly report that this issue isn't one of burning importance to most people. Then again, most people act as cattle and form feeding lines behind the most recent Microsoft display at Circuit City. I was usually near the front of that line most times.
My point was that I see a terrible rift in the Linux Community. And Yes Jessica, there IS a Linux Community, thank you. I received an email in the lobby4linux gmail account a short time ago and it was someone who developed programs for Red Hat. This person was addressing my husband concerning a recent blog he had written and the gist of it was "if you don't produce code, STFU." (his rude acronym, not mine). I was later to see that my husband responded in a simple yet profound way.
"OK Einstein, Let's put your theory to work. You are now Bach. Write your brilliant music, but know that it will rot on the parchment on which you record it. No orchestra will ever reproduce it, no musician will ever admire it." That struck home with me, and I hope with the software writer. There are many gears to this machine, and not just the biggest one makes the bell ring.
It was only after reading that exchange that I realized that the Linux Community isn't one happy family like I thought it was. It can get down right mean in here. That disturbs me more than I want it to.
>That disturbs me more than I want it to.
Don't let it.
I've always thought that The Simpson's was the perfect family show, and not in spite of the family's severely dysfunctional state.
You see, all families are dysfunctional. We may had it, may deny it, but it's true. Human beings who hold on to their passions and their soul will sometimes rub at the edges.
The value of a family, or of a community, does not show up when everybody is smiling and playing party games. It comes to bear when the going is tough and seeing eye to eye seems impossible.
Families can yell, they can harumph, they can do stupid things, but, if, in the end, they are there for each other, they are good.
In the Linux community, we have lots of harumphing. Lots of smart people, lots of spouting off. It's been that way all along, and yet Linux is more than still around, it's stronger than ever.
Relax, shake your head at foolishness, but don't worry too much. The community is stronger than the people who make it up.
Don't let it.
I've always thought that The Simpson's was the perfect family show, and not in spite of the family's severely dysfunctional state.
You see, all families are dysfunctional. We may had it, may deny it, but it's true. Human beings who hold on to their passions and their soul will sometimes rub at the edges.
The value of a family, or of a community, does not show up when everybody is smiling and playing party games. It comes to bear when the going is tough and seeing eye to eye seems impossible.
Families can yell, they can harumph, they can do stupid things, but, if, in the end, they are there for each other, they are good.
In the Linux community, we have lots of harumphing. Lots of smart people, lots of spouting off. It's been that way all along, and yet Linux is more than still around, it's stronger than ever.
Relax, shake your head at foolishness, but don't worry too much. The community is stronger than the people who make it up.
Helios told me one time that there is more collective wisdom on one LXer discussion page than can be found in any given corporate board room at any given time. Telling him he's right only encourages him, so we'll keep that little nod of agreement between us.
> there is more collective wisdom on one LXer discussion page than can be found in any given corporate board room at any given time.
What a put down... I can tell that you've never been in a corporate board room :D. That's the equivelent of 'better than nothing'.
What a put down... I can tell that you've never been in a corporate board room :D. That's the equivelent of 'better than nothing'.
Do I care about most users? Yes. Do I want everyone to use Free Software? Yes. Do I want everyone to use GNU/Linux? Not necessarily. They can use *BSDs, future Haiku OS or even OpenSolaris if they wish.
It's not about the OS, it's about freedom. As long as they have that when using software it's great and I wish it for everyone in the world.
When you put it that way, then the choice is not set between GNU/Linux and Windows or OSX, but between Free Software and nonfree software. If you manage to switch 90% of all computer users to GNU/Linux, you didn't necessarily switch 90% of all users to Free Software. If you compromised with nonfree software even when there was an alternative possibility (which includes even creating the alternative if it's missing) you didn't switch 90% users to Free Software, you merely switched alot of them to a half-free OS (GNU/Linux with proprietary software on top which didn't have to be there).
So again, it's not about the OS. It's about Free Software. If you look at it that way you wont compromise with nonfree software just to bring more users to an OS. You will try your best to support creating Free Software applications and programs that are still missing rather than just slapping the next ported proprietary solution onto an OS and inviting everyone over.
What about users who refuse to understand freedom in Free Software? Well, they are not the reason for you to offer them proprietary software. They'll understand, eventually, when in the Free World you helped create, Free Software principles become a norm they, as the sheep they are, take by default.
It's not about the OS, it's about freedom. As long as they have that when using software it's great and I wish it for everyone in the world.
When you put it that way, then the choice is not set between GNU/Linux and Windows or OSX, but between Free Software and nonfree software. If you manage to switch 90% of all computer users to GNU/Linux, you didn't necessarily switch 90% of all users to Free Software. If you compromised with nonfree software even when there was an alternative possibility (which includes even creating the alternative if it's missing) you didn't switch 90% users to Free Software, you merely switched alot of them to a half-free OS (GNU/Linux with proprietary software on top which didn't have to be there).
So again, it's not about the OS. It's about Free Software. If you look at it that way you wont compromise with nonfree software just to bring more users to an OS. You will try your best to support creating Free Software applications and programs that are still missing rather than just slapping the next ported proprietary solution onto an OS and inviting everyone over.
What about users who refuse to understand freedom in Free Software? Well, they are not the reason for you to offer them proprietary software. They'll understand, eventually, when in the Free World you helped create, Free Software principles become a norm they, as the sheep they are, take by default.
> there is more collective wisdom on one LXer discussion page than can be found in any given corporate board room at any given time.
Not a suprise. The collevtive wisdom in your average corporate board room is alarmingly low, especially when IT is involved. In my entire life I have only met one suit who "gets" IT. I am working for him now. Sadly he's low on the suit-scale so his hands are often tied by those above him, but he knows how to play the political management game and, more importantly, he knows how to shield the geeks below from the corporate politics above him. If I had anyone else ablove me I would have jumped ship already.
Not a suprise. The collevtive wisdom in your average corporate board room is alarmingly low, especially when IT is involved. In my entire life I have only met one suit who "gets" IT. I am working for him now. Sadly he's low on the suit-scale so his hands are often tied by those above him, but he knows how to play the political management game and, more importantly, he knows how to shield the geeks below from the corporate politics above him. If I had anyone else ablove me I would have jumped ship already.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

So we have to throw away 20 years of struggle to carve out a free zone, just so that Joe Schmoe, who ridiculed us for years, can be catered to with a mockery of what was once FL/OSS.
Corporate "ethics" must be strong stuff, it even permeates former OSS luminaries.