Advanced

I’m Saint iGNUcius: Stallman tells NIT students

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 56 comments
Him Vani; By Saroj Thakur
Mail this story
Print this story

“He is coming”, “He is coming”, the posters shouted from every nook and corner of the National Institute Technology (NIT) Hamirpur campus. Curious and inquisitive to know more, I stared hard at the picture of a benevolent looking man with an affectionate smile on his countenance. His long flowing hair and beard adding more mystery to his persona. Who is he? An apostle! I thought. What would he teach us about? I was surprised to know that he would teach us a lot about the moral and ethical issues that face the world of Free Software.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (56)

36 earlier comments in the full thread.

> You call that an argument?

As much as yours.

> created proprietary software concept in the first place

So now we go the chicken and the egg controversy...

And that last paragraph is just more spin...

It's obvious that you're incapable of even knowing what an open mind is. Go back to your mantra if it gives you release. Just don't chant it at me.
I also find it difficult to believe that GPL or any FOSS would have been successful if MS and other large Corporations had been at all ethical in their treatment of customers, and, competent in their software development. I really see the advancement of FOSS not so much as the success of Linux, but rather as the failure of Corporate proprietary vendors.

Jim, that is absolutely brilliant...

And great minds think alike. '-)

My boss made somewhat the same observation and is quoted in the "soon to be published" finale of my two part article.

My apologies, but Corporate insisted on review and Blue Pencil if necessary. He is emailing it to me by 9 EST tonight.

should be sometime between 7 and 8 in the am

Standby Scott...coming to you.

Really Jim...that is profound.

h
Is this discussion going anywhere? All I'm seeing is a lot of arguments both for and against Stallman and his actions but no one's really listening very hard. Might it not be time to agree to disagree and move on before a full-fledged flame war breaks out?

I know, I know, I'm one who loves flame wars but this isn't really a good subject. What Stallman has done has affected a lot of change in the world and I respect that far too much to want to see it diminished by a flame war. So how about it, folks? Kiss and make up or agree to disagree? ;-)

Just wondering......

DonK .

edit one: Oh crap! I crossed posts with helios who makes some good points. . . . Guess this thread isn't dead yet!
> Guess this thread isn't dead yet!

Now appearing for your Halloween entertainment: "The thread that wouldn't die!" :)
dek -

Stallman seems to bring out the worst in everyone, supporters and detractors alike.

It's a funny thing, too. Stallman is guilty, at most, of being sincerely blunt about his world view. I don't think I've ever read anything from him that was nasty in the way that his "supporters" can be.

I think the man is eccentric, and, in some ways, out of touch, but he's also brilliant and has earned respect even when we don't agree with him. For some of us, that's more often that others, but what the hey.
> > Guess this thread isn't dead yet!

For me it's definitely finished...
> I don't think I've ever read anything from him that was nasty in the way that his "supporters" can be.

Oooh! You must have been reading my mind. I was thinking about this just yesterday, although focused on Stallman and those who have criticized him over the past several months. I don't know that I would call him 'gracious', but he rarely actually attacks his opponents when he speaks/writes. He almost always sticks to the issue at hand. I have never seen him attack people the way Lyons attacked him.
Rev -

At worst, RMS can be accused of being occasionally bone-headed. That puts him in pretty good company.
Well, it wasn't us rms fanbois who start calling him a nutter, was it? Amazing how jimf now suddenly pulls back and sez "sheesh, you nasty fanbois hacking me apart. Just because I don't agree with rms' view". Wigglewigglewiggle, and I don't mean jimf's toes. And behold, suddenly the fanbois take all the blame. Jimf, that was absolutely brilliant you should go into politics, I'd even vote for you if I was allowed to. Imagine, you could be the next dubbyah, yay! It's amazing how people tend do forget what's been written at the beginning of this thread. It would be so easy to recall, all you'd need is to scroll to the top of this page.

You anti-rms folks seems to have a very convoluted view on the history of free software. According to your point of view, free software was nothing more than one or two people sitting in a dark, wet dungeon hacking some code together noone would use. Then ms came along, then linux came along and suddenly everything changed? Bah, is PCs all you know? Folks have been using GNU tools on their Sun/SGI/DEC/HP/NeXT/yni workstations long before the Linux kernel became barely usable. At work, I've got a Sun Sparcstation 20 on my desk, running SunOS 4 (yeah, that's the stuff before Slowlaris), the latest kernel compiled in 1994. Guess what, it comes with GNU Emacs, gcc and lots of other GNUddies. It's GNU software that has been keeping this machine in a usable state for all these years.
As far as Stallman, He put himself up on a pedestal a long time ago, and has been playing the 'nut' ever since. If anyone in any way questions his credibility, a dozen of you 'fanbois' (your word, not mine) come raging out of the woodwork. Makes it pretty difficult to have a discussion of any sort when everyone is convinced they have god's word.

> Folks have been using GNU tools on their Sun/SGI/DEC/HP/NeXT/yni workstations long before the Linux kernel became barely usable.

None of it went anywhere until Linux took it up. So was it GNU or was it Linux? I guess you're to be praised for your skill at recycling. Have fun with your green screen.
Yeah, right. Insulting a person by calling him a nutter is a very effective way of questioning his credibilty, isn't it. If you were after a serious discussion about RMS's credibility you would never have started this thread the way you did. Nah, just keep on trolling. No clueful person will ever answer to a thread you start again. What a shame that I did not realise you're just a clueless troll in the first place.

Oh and btw, I don't have a problem labelling myself an RMS fanboi, I admire the man.

"None of it went anywhere until Linux took it up": durkadurkaidonthaveacluejihad. I was using GNU tools on my Amiga back in the early nineties. For some software that never went anywhere it was quite usable actually. How about you giving some example of your theory about the early history of GNU software, huh?
>was using GNU tools on my Amiga back in the early nineties

Ummmm.....GNU tools have been around for a good while, but they haven't existed in a vacuum. Prior to the big explosion in Linux use in the mid-nineties, few people used,. cared about, or knew about GNU tools. That statement would be true if every single user of every single UNIX box anywhere in the world was toted up.
> I have never seen him attack people the way Lyons attacked him.

RMS has his flaws, but he's a good person. Based solely on what I've read by him, I don't think I can say the same for Lyons.

> Insulting a person by calling him a nutter is a very effective way of questioning his credibilty, isn't it.

I think we can all agree that Stallman's behavior is at the extreme edge of what most people would consider "normal", and sometimes goes over that edge. That should do nothing to detract from his accomplishments. The GPL and the GNU project allowed Free Software to be where it is today. Without him and his work, there would be no Linux distributions as we know them.

That said, without the Linux kernel, we'd still be stuck with the Hurd project and the BSD's. It is the combination of the Linux kernel and GNU which got us where we are today; not either one by itself. This disagreement between the kernel developers and the FSF is something that needs to be resolved. We don't really have the manpower to fork the entire GNU project. I'm open to suggestions; I have no idea how to resolve it. :(



dcparris:

it's all mine. feel free to quote.
incinerator,

You say that the 4 'freedoms' are not socialistic in nature. I think I owe you a serious response on that one.

I have to point out that the GPL amounts to a closed system, or collective if you will. Code is written, GPL'd, and not allowed to be used with anything else, but can be used by anyone within that (collective) system. If we're talking concepts, I don't know how else you can classify it other than socialist derived. Frankly, I could care less what label you put on it, nor am I attaching any stigma to it.

If you want a closer approximation of a Libertarian license, then I suggest you look at the BSD license which doesn't have those restrictions.
Jimf,

Credit cards also form this same kind of system. You must opt in to this credit card 'collective'. Only members of the 'collective' accept and process the credit cards.

Does that mean that a big chunk of the USA's consumer economy is socialist.

It's not a completely closed system. GPL can share code under the BSD or similar licenses, or in the public domain. A copyright holder can release their code under a commercial license as well as the GPL. But the GPL software does try to create a rather open ended community.

I stand by my view that the GPL is about as socialist as 'We the People' or 'E Pluribius Unum'.

> Credit cards also form this same kind of system

I'm sure that banks would find that amusing. One important difference here. Not every user can become a credit card member. The main one being current possession of propriety or money (just try and get one without that). With GPL, the ability to use the system is automatic and anyone can use it.

Yes, GPL can share code with other systems, but only under very specific conditions, and, it always stays GPL'd.

> I stand by my view that the GPL is about as socialist as 'We the People' or 'E Pluribius Unum'.

True, but perhaps not the way you think. The Founding Fathers were pretty socialist for their time :D
"I have to point out that the GPL amounts to a closed system, or collective if you will"

The system is not that isolated, actuallty. You can always dual-license a piece of work you claim copyright on. See mysql, qt etc. for examples. Once derivative works and contributions come into play, things get more tricky though. Of course it is a collective system, but your conclusion that this makes the GPL and the four software freedoms socialist has no merits. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commons As you can see, the concept of "collective" ownership of property has been around virtually forever. Actually, the legal concept of private property was created much later than the concept of the commons. Socialism is a theory established during the beginnings of the Modern Times. Just because a certain system of ownership or utilisation of property has collective characteristics doesn't mean it is socialist. Labelling any of these systems socialist just because they have a collective aspect does not constitute a valid conclusion. Unless you have factual evidence that such a system is based on socialist or communist ideas, labelling it such is non-sense.

The concept of the four software freedoms is a very new one. I have yet to see any credible evidence that it's explicitly or implicitly based on socialist or communist ideas. Thus, anyone labelling that concept as socialist or communist either does - not have a clue about history and political theory, or - deliberately uses these terms in order to discredit the idea of the four software freedoms.

Unless you can present credible evidence that RMS et al. actually have formalised the concept of the four software freedoms by referring to socialist/communist/marxist/leninist/stalinist/maoist/castroist/whatever ideas, I won't take your claim seriously.
dinotrac:
Quoting:You may not like what they do, but it is not a bad thing to feed your family while meeting a need in the marketplace. Writing and supporting software is not starving widows and children, it is not stealing candy from babies and it is not blowing up buildings. It is feeding your family by writing and supporting software.


Yes, I don't like what they do because I believe it is bad. And I wont bend that belief just because I may consider this person to generally be a good one. That's what I was talking about and not that everyone else must absolutely share my belief.

Now why do I still believe it is bad? The license may be something people first have to accept, but does that make the license terms any less bad than they are, any less freedom restrictive once agreed upon? I would be willing to bet that most people using such restrictive software didn't read the license and don't exactly know what they're agreeing to. This weakens the argument that they've fully willingly given up their freedom.

Quoting:but it is not a bad thing to feed your family while meeting a need in the marketplace


I have to respond to this directly because this is not something you can do only by writing proprietary software, and I think you know it. You can make money writing Free Software that fills a need in the marketplace as well. The model may be different, but that't it. You'll still have to invest in marketing just as much as you'd have to if it was proprietary. Lone programmers often strive to get their software anywhere. With Free Software they are at least able to build upon the strenghts of the community and code they share which considerably eases things up for them.

As for jimf, so long and thanks for all the fish. You're on my ignore list. If anyone looks over jimf's posts and sees pretty much all the ingredients of the "good old" FUD and twisting, you'd be right to think that's what it is.

That was no way to start nor continue the discussion jimf.
I would be willing to bet that most people using such restrictive software didn't >read the license and don't exactly know what they're agreeing to.

I would bet that you are wrong when talking about one person shops providing proprietary software as they tend to be serving business clients rather than the consumer market. But, so what? One person shops don't have market power.

As to free software, some people can make money off of that, but not everybody can. Not that it matters.

You are free to dislike people feeding their families doing something that is legal and has no effect on you whatsoever.

As to limiting anybody's freedom by doing so, you are equally free to continue being dead solid wrong.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post