Novell Is Not SCO
|
|
|
Comments (26)
Missing the point.
5 earlier comments in the full thread.
"Novell has made a smart move to protect it's business and it's customers."
That remains to be seen. Many, including me, are jumping off the Novell/SUSE bandwagon. So I don't see how this move by Novel is "smart".
It looks to me like Microsoft thinks it has found a Judas goat in Novell. I will not be following them to the slaughterhouse. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judas_goat
That remains to be seen. Many, including me, are jumping off the Novell/SUSE bandwagon. So I don't see how this move by Novel is "smart".
It looks to me like Microsoft thinks it has found a Judas goat in Novell. I will not be following them to the slaughterhouse. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judas_goat
> But the Stockholders are mainly the top single digit percentage of the population.
Bull. Anyone who has a pension with a major corporation is a stockholder. Most people with 401K's are stockholders. Many people with IRA's are stockholders. Conservative estimates are that over 50% of Americans are now stockholders.
From pbs.org at http://www.pbs.org/fmc/book/14business6.htm :
"In 1998, 52 percent of Americans owned shares in public companies or equity mutual funds, either directly in their own accounts, or indirectly in retirement and trust accounts."
From http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2519/is_6_20/ai_5... :
"A little over three decades ago, only one in 10 American adults owned stock. Today, according to a Peter Hart survey conducted this past April for NBC and The Wall Street Journal, 53 percent of all adults now own at least $5,000 in stock."
and
"Since 1989, stock ownership has jumped 46 percent among households with incomes between $25,000 and $50,000 and by a massive 78 percent among those making between $10,000 and $25,000."
Bull. Anyone who has a pension with a major corporation is a stockholder. Most people with 401K's are stockholders. Many people with IRA's are stockholders. Conservative estimates are that over 50% of Americans are now stockholders.
From pbs.org at http://www.pbs.org/fmc/book/14business6.htm :
"In 1998, 52 percent of Americans owned shares in public companies or equity mutual funds, either directly in their own accounts, or indirectly in retirement and trust accounts."
From http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m2519/is_6_20/ai_5... :
"A little over three decades ago, only one in 10 American adults owned stock. Today, according to a Peter Hart survey conducted this past April for NBC and The Wall Street Journal, 53 percent of all adults now own at least $5,000 in stock."
and
"Since 1989, stock ownership has jumped 46 percent among households with incomes between $25,000 and $50,000 and by a massive 78 percent among those making between $10,000 and $25,000."
jdixon -
How dare you cloud the issue with facts?
At least you didn't mention that Novell, in looking out for its stockholders, is also protecting it's employees, it's customers, its' customers' employees, their families, etc.
We sure wouldn't want to do that, now would we?
How dare you cloud the issue with facts?
At least you didn't mention that Novell, in looking out for its stockholders, is also protecting it's employees, it's customers, its' customers' employees, their families, etc.
We sure wouldn't want to do that, now would we?
OK, but the old "we have a responsibility to our shareholders" is the tiredest excuse in the book for justifying all manner of abuses. With the implication that it's impossible to succeed by legitimate means, such as, oh you know, weird hippie jive like selling great products at fair prices, and delivering first-rate customer service. No business has a divine right to succeed, though they sure behave like they do. When they start implementing questionable practices, that's a sign they've lost their way.
So is this deal a 'questionable practice'? Time will tell, but already the deal reeks with the stench of classic Microsoft doubletalk, evasions, and Newspeak. It's quite understandable why there is so much criticism. I can see why SUSE users don't like it, and many people see a larger threat to FOSS and the GPL, because even if you can't find the smoking legalese, Microsoft's record speaks for itself.
So is this deal a 'questionable practice'? Time will tell, but already the deal reeks with the stench of classic Microsoft doubletalk, evasions, and Newspeak. It's quite understandable why there is so much criticism. I can see why SUSE users don't like it, and many people see a larger threat to FOSS and the GPL, because even if you can't find the smoking legalese, Microsoft's record speaks for itself.
> How dare you cloud the issue with facts?
Sorry, Dino. The old stock ownership lie is a pet peeve of mine. I'll try to do better in the future. :)
Sorry, Dino. The old stock ownership lie is a pet peeve of mine. I'll try to do better in the future. :)
The stockowners issue is really missing the point. On those grounds, MS is perfectly correct in its policies (monopolistic behavior notwithstanding).
You cannot debate when stockowners come into the picture. Taco Bell was doing what it had to do to maximize shareholder benefits when it was paying undocumented individuals literally pennies per pound of tomatoes picked. Nike, Addidas, Walmart have perfect justifications for paying their employees in other countries a couple of dollars for a hard days work while the consumers still have to pay $100 for a pair of sneakers.
The consumer is no longer a companies customer. The customers are the stockholders. I say why should we not be able to pay $100 for a pair of sneakers that was made in America and $40 for a similar pair made in China, all things like quality being equal. Why am I, as a consumer, not seeing the benefit when a company saves money.
But coming back to the existing debate, can anyone tell me exactly what Novell is protecting its stockholders from? Which patents does Linux violate that Novell had to settle "I chose that word very carefully" with MS? Anyone?
You cannot debate when stockowners come into the picture. Taco Bell was doing what it had to do to maximize shareholder benefits when it was paying undocumented individuals literally pennies per pound of tomatoes picked. Nike, Addidas, Walmart have perfect justifications for paying their employees in other countries a couple of dollars for a hard days work while the consumers still have to pay $100 for a pair of sneakers.
The consumer is no longer a companies customer. The customers are the stockholders. I say why should we not be able to pay $100 for a pair of sneakers that was made in America and $40 for a similar pair made in China, all things like quality being equal. Why am I, as a consumer, not seeing the benefit when a company saves money.
But coming back to the existing debate, can anyone tell me exactly what Novell is protecting its stockholders from? Which patents does Linux violate that Novell had to settle "I chose that word very carefully" with MS? Anyone?
>The stockowners issue is really missing the point. On those grounds, MS is perfectly correct in its policies (monopolistic behavior notwithstanding).
Ummm...no, at least not with regard to illegal policies. Legal obligations are bounded by a need to follow the law.
As to Microsoft being perfectly correct in it's policies that do not fall outside the law, that all depends on whether they make Microsoft stronger or weaker.
Ummm...no, at least not with regard to illegal policies. Legal obligations are bounded by a need to follow the law.
As to Microsoft being perfectly correct in it's policies that do not fall outside the law, that all depends on whether they make Microsoft stronger or weaker.
> Why am I, as a consumer, not seeing the benefit when a company saves money.
Have you checked the prices at Walmart or Target lately? You are seeing the benefit. Not from all companies admittedly, but the companies that serve their customers grow. Those that don't tend to wither.
> can anyone tell me exactly what Novell is protecting its stockholders from?
From the threat of a lawsuit by Microsoft. Duh.
> Which patents does Linux violate...
We don't know. That uncertainty is enough to prevent some companies from using Linux. By eliminating that uncertainty, Novell hopes to grow their customer base.
Novell's actions are perfectly understandable, from a corporate viewpoint. The question is, do they make sense from a community viewpoint?
Have you checked the prices at Walmart or Target lately? You are seeing the benefit. Not from all companies admittedly, but the companies that serve their customers grow. Those that don't tend to wither.
> can anyone tell me exactly what Novell is protecting its stockholders from?
From the threat of a lawsuit by Microsoft. Duh.
> Which patents does Linux violate...
We don't know. That uncertainty is enough to prevent some companies from using Linux. By eliminating that uncertainty, Novell hopes to grow their customer base.
Novell's actions are perfectly understandable, from a corporate viewpoint. The question is, do they make sense from a community viewpoint?
>The question is, do they make sense from a community viewpoint?
Time will have to tell on that one.
Time will have to tell on that one.
> Time will have to tell on that one.
Agreed. In the meantime though, I'm glad I use Slackware.
Agreed. In the meantime though, I'm glad I use Slackware.
>Ummm...no, at least not with regard to illegal policies. Legal obligations are bounded by a need to follow the law.
True. But the law is only as strong as the people who uphold them. Now, how much does MS pay to lobbyists every year? All these ideas sound good on paper, but the reality is that MS has in the past and still is destroying competetion by unfair means.
>You are seeing the benefit. Not from all companies admittedly, but the companies that serve their customers grow. Those that don't tend to wither.
I am not really seeing any benefit. Unless you consider the couple of dollars discount on a $20 item to be a good deal keeping in mind the money cities pay to Walmart for opening its doors within their city limits takes away from local budgets for city infrastructure. Or how about so many of their employees are on govt. healthcare which makes you the one who is ultimately paying for these discounts.
>From the threat of a lawsuit by Microsoft. Duh.
Again, a lawsuit for which infringement? Did Novell know about anything specific? If so, they should have made it open knowledge so that those pieces could be removed instead of dangling like a sword on the Linux community. I really don't like the veiled threats about suing other Linux users that Ballmer is handing out to anyone who would listen.
If Novell did not know of any infringing code, then this deal does not make much sense to me.
True. But the law is only as strong as the people who uphold them. Now, how much does MS pay to lobbyists every year? All these ideas sound good on paper, but the reality is that MS has in the past and still is destroying competetion by unfair means.
>You are seeing the benefit. Not from all companies admittedly, but the companies that serve their customers grow. Those that don't tend to wither.
I am not really seeing any benefit. Unless you consider the couple of dollars discount on a $20 item to be a good deal keeping in mind the money cities pay to Walmart for opening its doors within their city limits takes away from local budgets for city infrastructure. Or how about so many of their employees are on govt. healthcare which makes you the one who is ultimately paying for these discounts.
>From the threat of a lawsuit by Microsoft. Duh.
Again, a lawsuit for which infringement? Did Novell know about anything specific? If so, they should have made it open knowledge so that those pieces could be removed instead of dangling like a sword on the Linux community. I really don't like the veiled threats about suing other Linux users that Ballmer is handing out to anyone who would listen.
If Novell did not know of any infringing code, then this deal does not make much sense to me.
> If Novell did not know of any infringing code, then this deal does not make much sense to me.
It's not designed to make sense to us. It's designed to make sense to Pointy Haired CEO's and their ilk. By having Microsoft officially bless SUSE as a Microsoft approved and lawsuit free solution, Novell has increased their potential market penetration dramatically.
It's not designed to make sense to us. It's designed to make sense to Pointy Haired CEO's and their ilk. By having Microsoft officially bless SUSE as a Microsoft approved and lawsuit free solution, Novell has increased their potential market penetration dramatically.
> By having Microsoft officially bless SUSE as a Microsoft approved and lawsuit free solution, Novell has increased their potential market penetration dramatically.
That's where the rub really lies for me. There should be no need for Microsoft's blessing. That's where the real trouble lies. Even if there is no cold hard truth to back the notion, it's as if we can only have peace _if_ we first get Uncle Bill's (Steve's?) blessing. That's not peace at all.
That's where the rub really lies for me. There should be no need for Microsoft's blessing. That's where the real trouble lies. Even if there is no cold hard truth to back the notion, it's as if we can only have peace _if_ we first get Uncle Bill's (Steve's?) blessing. That's not peace at all.
Rev -
>There should be no need for Microsoft's blessing.
Sure, and executives should understand all of that and should understand the difference between low-cost vs cost/benefit and all that good stuff.
Think of a million marketing ploys designed to get your foot in the door. It doesn't matter how good you are if you can't get in the door.
At least part of the message this deal sends to IT executives is that dealing with Novell is dealing with grown-ups who understand their concerns, or, more to the point, the concerns their bosses will have. Risk management is all the rage these days.
>There should be no need for Microsoft's blessing.
Sure, and executives should understand all of that and should understand the difference between low-cost vs cost/benefit and all that good stuff.
Think of a million marketing ploys designed to get your foot in the door. It doesn't matter how good you are if you can't get in the door.
At least part of the message this deal sends to IT executives is that dealing with Novell is dealing with grown-ups who understand their concerns, or, more to the point, the concerns their bosses will have. Risk management is all the rage these days.
I realize that, Dino. I do. I still think it's cowardice, or at least capitulating to it.
Rev -
You say tomato and I say...wait, I say tomato, too. I don't run in the social circles that can get away with saying to - MAH -to.
You say tomato and I say...wait, I say tomato, too. I don't run in the social circles that can get away with saying to - MAH -to.
Yo comprendo.
I came upon this http://www.novell.com/linux/microsoft/faq_opensource.html reading an article and it answers some questions.
This is the same link posted, apparently, in another thread. But thanks! :-)
It is the point.
Mr. Vaughan-Nichols,
if Novell has made this deal with Microsoft only to make its investors happy, what if I can ask, does this do for open source and the community. If I understand you, correct me if Iam wrong, it was Novell's change to open source that investors are un-happy ?.
The facts are, the community's history is longer then Novell's with open source, the community has with nothing more then the drive to change the way software is created, along with added freedoms for the user, that propiretary have never done. The community's investment in this deal between Novell and Microsoft is larger then most will find they can believe; the lack of respect from proprietary for open source, have most of them believe that open source is something to step on and over that such deals as Novell's is a clear example of such thinking.
While Novell did not step on the community, they did step over them, the same people that make thousands upon thousands of downloads to test the SUSE kernel (OpenSUSE); bug finds and the reports make up more of Novell's R&D then Novell could ever buy at any price, all this ends up as part/whole in Novell's commercial products that this deal pays Novell well for. I for one are sick of the community bashing, when the community makes it known that the line is not respected, and opinions passed, are seen as the community's lack of vision to see the good ?.
Last, Novell had no business making this deal without the community that supports them, free of charge for work knowledge and duty to something the community believes in. If investors are the only drive for Novell, to drive them not to respect others and their work; why should the community beliveve and react the way proprietary want them to ?.
if Novell has made this deal with Microsoft only to make its investors happy, what if I can ask, does this do for open source and the community. If I understand you, correct me if Iam wrong, it was Novell's change to open source that investors are un-happy ?.
The facts are, the community's history is longer then Novell's with open source, the community has with nothing more then the drive to change the way software is created, along with added freedoms for the user, that propiretary have never done. The community's investment in this deal between Novell and Microsoft is larger then most will find they can believe; the lack of respect from proprietary for open source, have most of them believe that open source is something to step on and over that such deals as Novell's is a clear example of such thinking.
While Novell did not step on the community, they did step over them, the same people that make thousands upon thousands of downloads to test the SUSE kernel (OpenSUSE); bug finds and the reports make up more of Novell's R&D then Novell could ever buy at any price, all this ends up as part/whole in Novell's commercial products that this deal pays Novell well for. I for one are sick of the community bashing, when the community makes it known that the line is not respected, and opinions passed, are seen as the community's lack of vision to see the good ?.
Last, Novell had no business making this deal without the community that supports them, free of charge for work knowledge and duty to something the community believes in. If investors are the only drive for Novell, to drive them not to respect others and their work; why should the community beliveve and react the way proprietary want them to ?.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Nicely said! I have also said so (in a lot worse way) on other threads. I do not claim to be a Linux expert that I know for a fact so many people here are. I have been using Linux for a while, but I am one of those people who after something is working, don't mess around with it too much.
I am using Linux for the principle of it. I don't have a need to be running Linux. I don't have a need to dual boot, or put up with the (increasingly rare) "bugs" that crop up from time to time, but I do. I am sure many people are like me. We got tired of MS, and liked Linux for what it stands for, and started using it, even if not improving it or evangelizing it.
As helios put it, "Novell threw off millions of people who were looking to them for leadership...someone to take Linux to where it needs to go. Many thought Novell was the great hope for Linux."
Many people like me don't care about the legality issues, the wait-and-see stuff that's blowing around. We are looking for an appropriate response, and for leadership. Instead of waiting for MS to come up and say we are going to sue or not sue, or whatever they want out of this deal, someone should be saying what MS can and cannot do. Granted we don't have all the details of the deal, but we do have the GPL licenses. Can someone just go through it and elaborate what it says in english, what loopholes are present etc?