Advanced

Novell could be banned from selling Linux

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 49 comments
Reuters; By Jim Finkle
Mail this story
Print this story

The Free Software Foundation is reviewing Novell Inc.'s right to sell new versions of Linux operating system software after the open-source community criticized Novell for teaming up with Microsoft Corp. "The community of people wants to do anything they can to interfere with this deal and all deals like it. They have every reason to be deeply concerned that this is the beginning of a significant patent aggression by Microsoft," Eben Moglen, the Foundation's general counsel, said on Friday.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Microsoft, Novell, Community, Linux; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (49)

Oh Brother

20 earlier comments in the full thread.

> At this rate the only ones who will be left supporting FSF will be the lock steppers.

I question how relevant FSF is now. I think most of them probably are already lock steppers.
> ...Just because you question the source does not make the information passed any less valid.

I don't question the source. I know the source, and I know that thy know absolutely nothing about the subject they claim to be discussing. And knowing their past history, even the information they present as fact is suspect. I'll seek my information from other sources.

As for the Novell/Microsoft agreement, I've made my position on that clear in the past. I don't trust Microsoft, and I won't use Novell products, but from a business viewpoint Novell made a legal and expedient agreement. If Novell was the only Linux provider, I'd have problems with the agreement, but fortuantely for us they're not.
Quoting: Well, I really could care less about that, 'except' that, with that kind of attitude, they're driving away a substantial group who strongly support GPLv2 and the whole open source concept.


Just what kind of attitude are you talking about? You constantly try to paint everyone who says anything good about GPLv3 or FSF as cultist blind followers and no matter how much we try to disprove that you don't correct yourself one bit and just continue on and on with your rhetoric and FUD. Is your mind really *that* locked down into your own perspective that you just can't possibly grasp the possibility of you being wrong in your holy judgment of someone else?

It's like you set a picture in your mind that "those guys are blind cultists" and are now completely an utterly incapable to change this picture no matter what.

I can tell you I don't follow FSF 100% and I am still going to be called a blind follower of the FSF simply because I agree with GPLv3. Now who is trying to force whose opinion here?!

What am I supposed to say to earn your approval? Is there even such a thing considering that I have already been judged in your mind?

You just wont listen. You just wont even try to understand the perspective of those who you target. You are hopeless!

Therefore I don't hope your response will be any better than your previous ones, more spin, rhetoric and FUD.

Well thank you, you at least keep the flames going on LXer. It'd be such a boring place without you.

Sigh.
> I question how relevant FSF is now

Pretty damn relevant considering how many comments FSF stories generate. :)
> Pretty damn relevant

Well, at least controversial...
Quoting:You are hopeless!
Well said Libervis. You explained exactly what I think of Jimf's responses. Whether he is naive or doing it in on purpose, so far I couldn't tell.
Quoting:but his *interpretation* of the GPL is no more important that Steve Ballmer's interpretation.
Bigg Your statement is baseless since you haven't explained how his *interpretation* is different, would you care to do that? It would be enlightening for many of us.!!!
What I said is that his interpretation doesn't mean anything. He wrote a license, and if developers like that license, they can use it. He could think a GPL user is violating all that is holy, but only a court's opinion on that matters.
Clueless, flames? well that's an interesting way to discount what you don't want to hear.

RMS thought up his concept of the 4 user freedoms and eventually implemented that in the GPL license. With the advent of GPLv2, that has become pretty much the high standard for free software.

I shouldn't have to, but guess I'd better, point out that the '4 freedoms' are a 'philosophical' concept and that GPLv2 is the current contract that is enforceable under the law. FSF was set up by RMS to enforce the legal aspects of the GPL.

All that is hunky dory, and under the shelter of the GPLv2 contract, free software, and especially Linux has prospered. I have no disagreement with the GPLv2 contract, or, with the 'four freedoms' as a 'philosophical' concept.

But that's where I see the problem begins. RMS has set himself up as the sole interpreter of the '4 freedoms'. He has, for all practical purposes, formed a cult of believers. He is the President (apparently for life) of the FSF... In other words whatever RMS says or 'interprets' the 4 freedoms to be, gets thrown into GPL regardless of its effectiveness or even relevance.

You're saying 'Oh no! RMS would never do that!' , but, if it looks like a duck, and, acts like a duck....

I'm as much against DRM as anyone here. I simply don't believe that the DRM restrictions issue can be successfully fought in a GPL contract. It will in my view do more to hurt free software than to curb the problem. I also see that censoring Novell, and by association, the whole SuSe community for doing something that is perfectly legal under the current GPLv2 license. I wouldn't have advised the deal. I certainly don't like, or trust MS, but, as you'd say, it's within the 'rules'.

Overall, RMS and 'his' FSF have pretty much lost most of there creditability, at least in my eyes, and, I don't think I'm alone. There is a very good reason that the Constitution divides church and state. I'm of the opinion that that needs to be applied between RMS and the FSF if that's to (re)gain it's credibility.

Now, If you guys still think I'm 'clueless', or, opposed to software freedom, or, just don't think I belong in your cult, so be it. Other than being pretty addicted to Linux, I have no vested interest here.
Quoting:What I said is that his interpretation doesn't mean anything
Sorry, my mistake, I thought you said developers had a different interpretation. Please blame it on old age. But on the contrary, his interpretation is what counts because he wrote the GPL, he knows what was the GPL intent and purpose. That is why he is in the process of changing it to make his interpretation clear and understandable by everyone, including the courts.
Quoting:He could think a GPL user is violating all that is holy, but only a court's opinion on that matters
Let's not go with what he thinks and go with what he says. For what he thinks could depend on each individual's interpretation. Both RMS & Moglen openly said that Novell is not in violation of the GPL2 letter. And it is certainly absolutely true that the courts' interpretation is what counts, but, we need to understand that this is exactly why GPL2 is being revised in GPL3. But some people are objecting to doing that before they even see the draft which hasn't been released yet. If some developers don't see Novell-MS contract a threat; RMS, Moglen & many others think otherwise. RMS has the full right to do whatever he feel is appropriate to circumvent any further such contracts. Who will adopt GPL3 and who doesn't, that is something we shall see when it is released for comments and feedbacks.
Quoting:Interesting way to discount what you don't want to hear. He has, for all practical purposes, formed a cult of believers.
Just because we strongly disagree with your points doesn't mean we are a cult. It is obvious that it is you who doesn't want to hear what you don't like. Stop this silly senseless labeling.
Quoting:Other than being pretty addicted to Linux, I have no vested interest here.
Well you haven't demonstrated to us what harm the GPL3 going to bring to you and many others. You keep claiming that developers "will" not adopt GPL3 license, but all indication proves otherwise. Samba declaring their support and intent to adopt it is one example. Linus has some issues with it but the Linux kernel developers haven't made a final decision, when they see the draft or final version, they might decide otherwise. You keep knocking RMS & FSF. You don't like what RMS and FSF are doing, that is your problem. You and others who don't want RMS to be president, can become members to voice your opinion and vote to even prevent RMS from being elected. I don't think there is anything that would prevent you from doing just that. Act on it.

Final thought On this issue, I happen to agree with RMS, Moglen & FSF that the Novel-MS deal is harmful and damaging to FOSS in general and to other than Suse distributors. Yes, some people don't agree with me, but to me, Novell-MS deal doesn't bring noticeable benefit to FOSS, so why have it. May be Novell will gain from it, but in my opinion, this gain on the account of others is not justified. Novell might have desperately needed this contract, but, in my opinion, Suse, which used to be my favorite distro but no more, is not that important to sacrifice FOSS for the sake of Novell.
> It is obvious that it is you who doesn't want to hear what you don't like.

Well, I hear what you're 'saying', It simply doesn't make much sense. We've both said where we stand. At this point I'm only answering to be polite, but really discounting you as much as you are me. Not much of a logical discussion is possible really ;-)
Pah. jimf is wrong wrong WRONG. Purely logical. And right! I win I win I win! :D

seriously jimf, you may be right about the FSF taking the wrong path. I take issue with your continual categorization of people who support the FSF or RMS as cultists, lock-steppers, and other uncomplimentary terms. There's no call for that; it's unfair and insulting.

> FSF or RMS as cultists

So make up your own definition. I'm from the generation that invented the damned things, and I'm just calling it as I see it.
Try meditating on the face of our Beloved Leader and Prophet for a couple of hours, that'll clear your head. :)
I would just like to say that this thread is my entertainment for today...

and so far its working..;-)
I'm with Abe here, obviously, and on the Novell-MS deal I'd just like to add that besides it being not so incredibly good for the FOSS community it potentially detracts from it by allowing MS to stir some legal FUD on our expense, even if it isn't working so well.

As for Jimf, tuxchick has a point. Remember windowsrefund? As far as I know he was banned from these forums because he was insulting much in the similar way Jimf is here, because yes it is quite insulting to be called a blind sheep for disagreeing with you.

If the discussion was kept without these, then we could have just peacefully ended it in disagreement. But when you go around insulting this is becoming much more difficult. Readers without as much background in these issues may actually buy your classifications and hence agree with your insults. Can you blame us for being so defensive then?

Let's just keep it clean and cool and please let's not jump at every freaking opportunity to blackpaint someone we don't agree with.

Thanks
> it is quite insulting to be called a blind sheep for disagreeing with you.

Yeah, well it's not a complement to be called clueless either, kinda 'the pot calling the kettle black' ;-)

As far as the comparision with that 'other person', I think you're way out of line. I didn't troll, and I find it 'seriously' insulting to have you insinuate that... Just because you don't agree with me is no reason for that kind of slam... A new low Libervis.
Getting back to the OP, it does seem that the FSF is taking the Novell-Microsoft deal very seriously, and they want to torpedo it. Do we agree on that?

I have no disagreement with anyone who says the deal is a shoddy underhanded attempt to attack Linux with patent threats. That's quite evident to anyone with the patience to sift the reams of double-talk spewed forth by both Novell and MS. Whether the attacks will succeed is a wide-open question. I don't think they will. I think their Cunning Evil Plot is more like a Desperate Flail.

It seems a large leap from "GPL2 left this tiny loophole that MS exploited, and Novell is 'tards for being party to it, and GPL3 will close the loophole" to "we the people want the deal killed dead dead dead." That's the part I don't get.
Jimf, read back. I didn't call you clueless. It was "hopeless" and that's a whole different word with a whole different meaning. It means that I am losing all hope of you actually cutting some slack to those you disagree with and stopping with your rhetoric and yes.. insults.

Also I didn't say you trolled. I didn't wholesale compare you with w3f, just your constant naming of us as blind followers being insulting much the same way w3f was being insulting in his not-so-friendly rants against those who he saw as ignorant towards "freedoms 0-3".

So it wasn't a low blow from my part nor was it intended as such. In fact, just by claiming that I am kicking you with a "new" low blow is quite a low blow from you. ;)

But sorry man, my intentions are not to war on you, but to at least try, hopefully, to have you see that things may not be all that simple as you see them, that just because someone happens to agree with RMS or FSF doesn't mean he is automatically a blind follower (which implies we are incapable of reasoning for ourselves and then choosing who to follow and who to agree with).

You certainly have some people that you mostly agree with and possibly even admire. What would it be like if I called you a blind follower of those people? Can't you see what I'm getting at here?
> It seems a large leap from "GPL2 left this tiny loophole that MS exploited, and Novell is 'tards for being party to it, and GPL3 will close the loophole" to "we the people want the deal killed dead dead dead." That's the part I don't get.

Is there a major GPLed project out there, outside of Novell (especially outside of Ximian), that has come out and said they want the deal to stay?

When egomaniacs strike...

"The community of people wants to do anything they can to interfere with this deal and all deals like it. "

Hmmmm...

No news in the article, but that line really raises a red flag with me.

"The community of people", eh?

That sure sounds like an egotistical windbag to me.

The FSF may want to do anything. Moglen may want to do anything. RMS may want to do anything. Lots of others may want to do anything. But, last I looked, "the community of people" includes a whole bunch of folks who aren't anxious to do anything they can to interfere with the deal.

Unless, of course, those who disagree aren't welcome to be part of the community.

In which case, I think the community should swith the Hurd, as you really can't trust any software produced by folks who aren't worthy to be part of the "community of people".
As pointed out on slashdot, Moglen was taken somewhat out of context here.

I share your automatic distrust with anyone purporting to speak for 'the people', though (cue Who's "Won't Get Fooled Again" here). Stone Soup v. Redmond Koolaid is revolutionary enough without raising New-Left Inferi.

http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=07/02/03/0921201&thresho...
"That sure sounds like an egotistical windbag to me."

Doesn't to me - but who do sound like egotistical windbags are the guys who made this deal - ballmer, ron H., bill g -

I am sick of the country supporting businesses like microsoft just because they have board of directors.

the country is headed for deep deep deep dudo when we let companies run roughshod over the common folk just because we aren't greedy and we don't have a bank of lawyers/lobbyists to call on. i.e microsoft, apple, riaa, mpaa.

If they came and asked me if they should take action today I would say go for it.

I wish someone would sue ballmer for slander for making those comments after the deal. just because they made a deal with novell does not make what he said true.

novell had no right to make deal without at least asking their employees or the community. that would of been the right thing to do but they chose greed instead.

so I don't think we should be calling eblen an egomaniac when there are plenty of them running these companies that are trying to exploit the open source community all in the name of pleasing their board of directors.

>As pointed out on slashdot, Moglen was taken somewhat out of context here.

No time to check the context -- but am happy if it changes the meaning enough to matter.
This is one weird-sounding article. "The community of people" are not marching in lockstep, and certainly not with torches and pitchforks to storm the Novell stronghold. If Moglen really said that, he's a nut. There's nothing in this article that makes sense, or explains itself.
auuggh, SJV tries to get to the truth, but either I'm dim or it's still not making sense: http://www.linux-watch.com/news/NS6837365670.html

""What he actually asked me," said Moglen in an email interview, "was 'Is it true that some members of the community want GPLv3 to keep Novell from distributing future versions of GPL'd software?' I said, 'Yes, the Free Software Foundation is opposed to the deal, and is thinking about what to do; there will be a new draft soon [of the GPLv3]" (GNU General Public License Version 3).

Therefore, "The actual quote he prints is entirely accurate, but his lede destroys the context and is making unnecessary waves.""

So then it wasn't really a quote, but a paraphrase? I'm no lawyer, but I think I know the difference between a quotation and paraphrase, and "The community of people wants to do anything they can to interfere with this deal and all deals like it" is not what Moglen said. So how can it be a quote?

Maybe they're all mad, and we're trying to make sense out of nonsense.

Ow head hurts.
Therefore, "The actual quote he prints is entirely accurate, but his lede destroys the context and is making unnecessary waves.""

That makes it sound like he really said it, but that it meant something different in the context in which it was said.

Gots to tell ya, tc, I'm hard pressed to imagine the context in which that quote doesn't make Moglen look bad.



This is the lede, which is just a dumb made-up word that means lead:

"BOSTON, Feb 2 (Reuters) - The Free Software Foundation is reviewing Novell Inc.'s (NOVL.O: Quote, Profile, Research) right to sell new versions of Linux operating system software after the open-source community criticized Novell for teaming up with Microsoft Corp."

Do you see a problem with it? It seems accurate to me. Then the second paragraph is supposedly a quotation: ""The community of people wants to do anything they can to interfere with this deal and all deals like it. They have every reason to be deeply concerned that this is the beginning of a significant patent aggression by Microsoft," Eben Moglen, the Foundation's general counsel, said on Friday."

Then Moglen says to SJV ""The actual quote he prints is entirely accurate, but his lede destroys the context and is making unnecessary waves."" Then he says what he really said, which is not the same as what Reuters quoted. So no matter how I read it, Moglen sounds like he's tripping on something groovy.

>Moglen sounds like he's tripping on something groovy.

Agreed. I don't see how the actual quote can be entirely accurate if he said something else altogether.

But then, I rarely do an drug stronger than coffee.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post