Advanced

Ballmer repeats threats against Linux

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 22 comments
ZDNet UK; By Richard Thurston
Mail this story
Print this story

Steve Ballmer has reissued Microsoft's patent threat against Linux, warning open-source vendors that they must respect his company's intellectual property.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Microsoft, Linux; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (22)

Who Needs to Learn Respect?

It is the proprietary vendors who infringe on copyrighted Free Software by incorporating that software into their code, not the other way around. As for patents, if you listed your patents, FOSS developers would be able to easily avoid infringing on your patents. But you don't. So who needs to learn to respect whom?
> As for patents, if you listed your patents, FOSS developers would be able to easily avoid infringing on your patents

Why wait? Go through the USPTO listings, grab all the Microsoft patents, post them prominently, and begin pulling together prior art on each one, to have it revoked, as a community effort. Make it a sister site with the one that holds the dirty-tricks stuff from the latest antitrust suit, and host it all well off US soil, someplace that'll shrug off DMCA takedown notices. (I do really expect to see DMCA takedown attempts on the Iowa stuff if it's Internet-hosted in the US -- has the Wayback Machine been purged yet? The Groklaw crowd has it all snagged.)

This is something the developers mustn't do (because of the treble penalty for knowing violations) but it's something the rest of the community can do. Any patents where prior art doesn't seem to be accruing can then be pointed out to developers who seem likely to stumble into danger from them; at that point they'll want to think up workarounds.
I have no respect for Microsoft's IP. I think it's all crap and I do not want it anywhere in my house.

I do however have respect for the law. I'd like to see the criminals at Microsoft try that for once.
Actually, I'd really like to see Microsoft prove that it has any intellect, let alone that can be called property. :-D
It all comes back to the validity, or lack of it, pertaining to the existence of 'any' software patent. Until the court decide to dismiss this travesty, MS, and all the other Corporate wonders, will continue to shake their clubs and stomp around the fire.
Oh great, more images of cavemen, as if Geiko hasn't done enough to warp my mind.
> Oh great, more images of cavemen, as if Geiko hasn't done enough to warp my mind.

Think about a Tyrannosaurus Rex being eaten alive by army ants, feet first, then. That's how I prefer to visualize Microsoft-versus-FOSS.
cr: I do like your idea. I just don't have the time or wherewithal to undertake starting a project like that.
Let him talk, his own words could lead Microsoft to defeat.

If a patent holder is aware of a violation of his patent rights and doesn't do anything about, after awhile he loses the right to do anything.
I thought that only held with trademarks. iirc, others around here have stated that your notion is false.
I have read that if you wait for a market to grow before enforcing your patents, you lose the right to enforce the patent. In other words, you can't sit by the sidelines as another company is advertising a product built on your patent, and after the market is big enough (based on the infringing company's efforts) claim your patent rights. Whether it is true or applies in this case I don't know.
It's bluster. All he can do is bully companies into paying yet more Microsoft taxes. Don't forget what Jeremy Allison said:

""I have had people come up to me and essentially off the record admit that they had been threatened by Microsoft and had got patent cross license and had essentially taken out a license for Microsoft patents on the free software that they were using, which they then cannot redistribute." http://blogs.zdnet.com/microsoft/?p=265
i like this quote from darkhatter :
Quoting:This is going to be hard for fan girls/boys to understand so I'll try and explain:

Ballmer has walked into a mall and said "I have c4 strapped to my body and I'm going to blow it up". We don't know if he actually has c4 on his body, but because he keeps saying this all our shoppers are leaving our store because they don't want to die. What Novell and I guess Red Hat are doing is if Ballmer does have c4 and he blows himself up he won't do it in their store.

Novell and Red Hat are a company in the end, if they are losing money they need to do fix it.
http://www.ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=366652

;-P
> if you listed your patents, FOSS developers would be able to easily avoid infringing on your patents.

That's not really true. There are so many patents on insanely trivial and obvious things (e.g., Y2K windowing), and even on things someone else invented (e.g., BlueJ), that just writing "Hello, world!" surely violates dozens.
> cr: I do like your idea. I just don't have the time or wherewithal to undertake starting a project like that.

Neither do I. I put the idea out there so that someone who does might come along, see it, and think, "Yeah, I can do that... That'll be *my* contribution."

It's all about Stone Soup vs Kool-Aid.
> There are so many patents on insanely trivial and obvious things...

Didn't (perhaps doesn't) IBM hold the patent on double xor'ing?

Respect My Authority!

Steve Ballmer.

Hmmm

So that's what Cartman will look like when he's all grown up. Inquiring minds want to know.
Not to be pickey, but that should really read 'Respect My Authoritah!" :D
----- Just "Bully" Ballmer doin' his thing.

U.S. President Teddy Roosevelt almost exactly a century ago also used the "Respect My Authoritah!" pitch, not unlike Bully Ballmer. As Teddy Roosevelt did quote "Men with the muckrake are often indispensable to the well-being of society, but only if they know when to stop raking the muck." "An epidemic in indiscriminate assault upon character does not good, but very great harm." "There should be relentless exposure of and attack upon every evil practice, whether in politics, in business, or in social life. I hail as a benefactor every writer or speaker, every man who, on the platform, or in book, magazine or newspaper, with merciless severity makes such attack, provided always that he in his turn remembers that the attack is of use only if it is absolutely truthful." Washington, DC, April 14, 1906

Highly doubtful that Bully Ballmer's muckraking threats against Linux is "absolutely truthful" no matter how much respect this guy yells for.
Ballmer raking muck? I seriously doubt it. I don't see how anyone can even put him in the same class as such noble folks. Bullying is completely opposite of muckraking.
According to the Wikipedia definition: A muckraker is an American English term for one who investigates and exposes issues of corruption that violate widely held values, such as political corruption, corporate crime, child labor, conditions in slums and prisons, unsanitary conditions in food processing plants (such as meat), fraudulent claims by manufacturers of patent medicines, labor racketeering, and similar topics. In British English however the term is applied to sensationalist scandal-mongering journalist, not driven by any social principles. (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muckraker)

We DO need a serious muckraker in the American English sense to counteract big Bully Ballmer. In that sense you are right on! Few such "noble folks" seem to be currently available to challenge Bully B head on. At the same time, we DO NOT necessarily need muckrakers in the British English sense (journalists?) to keep spinning and maybe even encouraging Bully B's continued threats and tantrums against Linux.
Aha! I never compared muckrakers with my British buddies when I was stationed in England. We were more interested in comparing terms like "fags", & "shagging" (a dance - performed vertically, not horizontally - on this side of the pond). ;-) Comparing our definitions of muckraking just didn't hold interest.

I studied the better-known US muckrakers in school. That was, to me, an interesting subject. Hence, my adamant position that Ballmer not receive such a noble title. I should have caught on, as I didn't understand why you were using muckraker in a bad sense. Now I do. Thanks for clearing that up. :-)

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post