Advanced

The Emerging Dell-Linux-Apple War

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 34 comments
IT Management; By Rob Enderle
Mail this story
Print this story

While we spend a lot of time talking about Linux vs. Windows and Windows vs. the MacOS, the real battle for the Windows desktop alternative may be the preliminary round between the MacOS and Linux. That battle really kicks off this year with Apple stepping up their effort sharply with the Leopard, and Dell becoming aggressive (with others likely to follow) with SUSE Linux (though this choice may change). These two platforms have distinct advantages and disadvantages against each other and the winner will likely be the solution that walks away with the greatest number of advantages and the least number of disadvantages.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: SUSE, Linux; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (34)

14 earlier comments in the full thread.

I thought that they named that kid Laura (Didiot) DiDio.
> What matters is the things that people want to run, and most of those are on Windows.

That's a real catch 22. My suspicion is that large part of what MS touts as being the trend becomes 'what people want', not for any superior or specific function, but just because it's the fad. Actually Dino, it's the idea that Linux is just gonna run all my old Windows apps, and everything will work exactly the same is the real 'silliness'. Linux is a whole new OS. It's only natural that many things will be 'different'. Many of us think that different is far superior.

It's great that Linux provide alternatives to windows apps (and even ways to run the native ones), but, I for one, don't want Linux to become anything like clone of windows. That's totally unacceptable. If that means that some can't or won't ween themselves away from from Windoz, so be it.

Quoting:I still think we need to do something about bob's "if Ogara and Enderle were to have kids" comment. I think I'm going to need therapy to get over that one.


The counselor is "in".

Get over it.

That'll be $1.00. Sorry, but Lucy had to raise her rates, and she takes a bit of a cut from her understudies.

Nevertheless, in order to mitigate potential future litigation I'll encourage Bob to add references to Enderle and Didiot/Gara/etc. to the list of violations in the ToS.
I feel much better now, kthx
Being a libertarian anarchist capitalist gun toting Linux using Austrian economist, I tend to offend people by just _existing_.

My most humble apologies to anyone injured in this thread. However, since I didn't start the thread, I don't consider myself to have _initiated_ force. :^)

Bob_R: All you need now is a pouch of Red Man chewing tobacco, and you'd fit right in in the Carolinas. ;-)

> Bob_R: All you need now is a pouch of Red Man chewing tobacco, and you'd fit right in in the Carolinas.

Well, he'd still need a Tar Heels bumper sticker. Though here at Myrtle Beach he could probably get by with a WVU one.
> ... for example Quick books and Quicken...

Well, Quicken is supported by Codeweavers' Crossover Office. I suspect they're working on Quickbooks.
quote:: Well, Quicken is supported by Codeweavers' Crossover Office. I suspect they're working on Quickbooks.: quote

not well, not all versions, and not conveniently unfortunately. You have to want to use Linux, not want to use a computer that happens to have Linux on it.
> not well, not all versions, and not conveniently unfortunately.

Well, Codeweavers doesn't list a version on their list of supported apps, but they do list Quicken as a supported app, so I'm sure they'd be willing to work on any problems with you. Quickbooks obviously isn't there yet.
Since Intuit did the TurboTax spyware thing, I don't use any Intuit products under any circumstances.
>Since Intuit did the TurboTax spyware thing, I don't use any Intuit products under any circumstances.

You are not the problem.

It's all those other silly people.
"you'd fit right in in the Carolinas"

Ooops, sorry, I forgot one: Atheist.

So no, I don't fit in in the Carolinas. :^(

California was wonderful, best weather I've ever experienced, but a very intrusive government.

I joined the Free State Project, but my wife saw "snow" and won't move there.

...So I'm stuck in the Bible belt. It's clear that my address is already on some "no visit" list, because soon after I moved here one group of evangelical Baptists came to get to "know" me, and then no one else. Very strange, I see the Mormon's doing mission on their bicycles too, but they never seem to make it to where I live. Hmmmm....

I was thinking of handing out a care-package, a Knoppix CD and a Richard Dawkins DVD, but then realized I'd get lynched by a bunch of respectable types.

Quoting:So I'm stuck in the Bible belt. It's clear that my address is already on some "no visit" list, because soon after I moved here one group of evangelical Baptists came to get to "know" me, and then no one else. Very strange, I see the Mormon's doing mission on their bicycles too, but they never seem to make it to where I live.
I have something similar. All of the various faith peddlers come by to talk to the others in my home but they won't talk to me. As a matter of fact, if I'm outside mowing the lawn or washing the car or whatever, they cross the street as they pass my house then cross back after they pass.

I've checked in the mirror for the pentagram but I can't find it.

I'd feel slighted but I don't enjoy talking to people - peddlers or otherwise - so it works for me.
I know why they dont visit me. Has something to do with a friend and his very goth sister visiting one day. The doorbell rang and she kindly went to see who it was. She opened the door and without missing a beat called over her shoulder "The sacrifices are here". I swear we saw smoke coming from those bicycle tires as they receded down the driveway.

Regardless of how wierd she gets sometimes for that alone she is always welcome in my house.
What would be really good is if a FOSS accounting application were to support the Quick Books and Quicken File Formats, for both read and write. That would be a really good start.
Gnucash imported my old quicken (99 or 2000? I think) files quite well when I switched over (I believe I did the quicken export to qif and then imported that). Though unfortunately most of the other linux finance apps I tried at the time didn't. (I tried many at that time to see what would import and how well)
I've heard that Gnucash is getting better and better. Personally, I've never needed anything more complex than a spreadsheet.

The first time I heard of the "no convert list", someone I know was warned by a neighbor that "the Witnesses are heading your way", so they dressed up in black robes (yes, they had some, don't know why) and candles, and met them at the door.

They, too, were never visited again by any denomination.

Goth chicks are cool. Nothing phases them. Do a Google images search for "harajuku" for some good Japanese Goth stuff. I was walking through Harajuku one day, and the Hare Krishna were there too, handing out bags of popcorn and singing and dancing. Brightly dressed Goth chicks munching on saffron-yellow bags of popcorn...

I miss Tokyo.

I saw this on a zdnet blog here http://talkback.zdnet.com/5208-12554-0.html?forumID=1&thread... , and I think it's well worth thinking about.

quote::For desktop Linux to be viable, it has to ... ... be readily available to consumers -- which means that Dell needs to support whever distributions it selects to pre-load.

Dell gets to decide which distributions of Linux it will pre-load and Dell gets to choose which hardware configurations to support. Just like they do with Windows.

Dell's 'real' concern is that they won't sell enough systems with (any distribution of) Linux pre-loaded to pay the costs of establishing a support model.

Ultimately, this is a chicken-or-the-egg problem. You can't get enough consumer customers unless you provide support but you cannot afford to provide support unless you have enough consumer customers.

Dell can only afford to do this if they have a major Linux vendor willing to partner with them to make Desktop Linux a viable consumer product. So far, no Linux vendor has been willing to take that leap. It's no one's fault but their own. ::quote

The important bit here, I think is this

quote:: Ultimately, this is a chicken-or-the-egg problem. You can't get enough consumer customers unless you provide support but you cannot afford to provide support unless you have enough consumer customers.

Dell can only afford to do this if they have a major Linux vendor willing to partner with them to make Desktop Linux a viable consumer product. So far, no Linux vendor has been willing to take that leap. It's no one's fault but their own. ::quote

I think it would be a useful exercise if those 95,000 + people, who told Dell they want Linux, were to rev up the Linux vendors. I think it might be interesting to see what transpires. It certainly can't make things any worse.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post