Advanced

Introducing K16 and the Future of KDE

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 112 comments
KDE.news; By Frank Karlitschek
Mail this story
Print this story

Where will KDE be in five years? To answer this question, we plan to bring together visionaries, strategists, planners, out-of-the-box-thinkers, realists, dreamers, doers, creators, leaders, coders from the KDE community and everybody else who is interested in discussing the future of KDE and picturing what it will be.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Community, KDE

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (112)

92 earlier comments in the full thread.

Quoting:I didn't know there was an aggregate source of all the various contributors and users saying negative things about KDE4. Most people I develop my distribution of Linux with actually like KDE4 and I don't hear much negative from them


If I didn't try to personalise your 2010.12 distro with KDE4, I'd probably be very happy. Problem is it doesn't suit the way i like to do things, no Distribution does. So I customise.

I can't customise KDE4.5.4 to suit my needs.

I can customise every other Linux Desktop I've tried, to suit my personal preferences.

I can think I a lot of people who would be very happy with you customisation of KDE4, only they would never use it. They are already happy enough with what Microsoft gives them as the defaults on Windows.
Gee, I just dropped in to see if things were the same. They are.

What I didn't realize is that I'm not the only lonely person on Christmas. What a pointless argument, might as well argue on YouTube with people who think food just "falls from trees".

Good night, all, sleep well.
@Bob, it's morning here. I slept well thank you.
> ...give me links to your examples please.

Simply search the archives here for the KDE4 discussions. You'll find numerous examples. Tracyanne in particular has given numerous examples of problems and the responses, and the open letters from the developers have been discussed. But if you can read the comment in the first post on this thread and not find it condescending, then I doubt any of them will convince you.

> As for a complete break with the code base, we will have to disagree. It is not a step I would ever encourage if you want to keep a happy user base.

It can be done. You simply have to keep the user interface the same or similar enough for the changes to be obvious. If the interface must change, then the information on the differences should be in a faq and the help files. It's not like no one has ever managed this type of transition before.
Many, many thanks Jdixon.......you said precisely what I intended but described very badly. I keep thinking of the code and interface as a single unit and at that time was thinking of the interface, whereas they can (as you say) be considered and managed separately. As you have correctly pointed out, it is the GUI interface that must remain recognisable after an upgrade, even if the code underneath it is different. And that's the link that I think KDE4 broke rather horribly.
Quoting:Boy you are very touchy. Look at me...I'm like one of 2 people here that are trying to defend a project that is provided FOR FREE to ANYONE out there to use how they see fit...


Part of the problem is that not everyone can use it as they see fit. I know I can't, and I'm still trying (with KDE4.5.4 on PCLinuxOS 2010.12)

Quoting:I'm trying to stick up for developers that put blood, sweat, and tears into a project


Good for you. I might point out that the amount blood sweat an tears expended does not necessarily make the project good or useful, or any less difficult for ordinary users to deal with.

Quoting:from people saying they're all jackasses and not concerned with anyone but themselves.


From a user perspective they, and you, certainly look like jackasses who are only concerned about themselves. Far too many public statements (like the one that started this thread), and including at least one made by yourself, the one you linked to from this thread, in fact, are antagonistic towards the user, blame the user for any problems they have with KDE4.

I have never yet seen contrition from a KDE4 developer or apologist when it is demonstrated that the system is overly complex and obtuse (as I demonstrated when I accidentally discovered the route to setting the bottom panel to max width and auto hide),for example.

Quoting:I'm getting pounded left and right and people are using straw man arguments as proof that what they're saying is true.


Strawman arguments, please. If they were strawmen there would be no pounding, you would be able to answer them with more than rhetoric.

Quoting:Yet, here I am...still trying to reason with the unreasonable.


In the face of having demonstrations of where KDE4 is overly complex and obtuse, and still lacks useful functionality we loved in KDE3, more arrogance.
FOSS is about producing good quality software. The low price has nothing to do with it. How many patches has Linus refused over the years? All of them had low price tags too. If you don't want criticism, don't work on KDE. If criticism is a surprise then you've been living under a rock and have no business in this community.

And once more just so I get the point across: It's about the quality of the software, and if you want someone to make you feel good, you're looking for a therapist, not the FOSS community.
Quoting:Have you read my articles ?


Not until after you posted links to them in this thread...so you can see why I came to the conclusion I did...I don't read every single thing that comes across lxer.com nor that happens to go inside the forums here...I've only recently started visiting the forums after a year or more away.

Quoting:What would you call the attitude exhibited in your blog post, the one you linked to, and your statements that indicate that the problem with KDE4 is a user problem


You're taking it in the context of RIGHT NOW. It was written during the early parts of KDE4 (check date on the article). Most people attacked KDE4 without putting in any effort to find out how the configuration screens had changed. So, the article, when written at the time (it did post to lxer.com as well then...I know there is a thread on it here (found it: http://lxer.com/module/forums/t/29399/ ) I think I did a pretty good job at setting out to bust myths that accompanied KDE4 back then. Everyone was freaked out by the huge change. Also, my article was written in response to this article http://it.toolbox.com/blogs/locutus/what-i-dont-like-about-k... (summary paragraph at the end of the post links to it).

So, it was a direct response to someone else's dismissive KDE4 article on another site. If I came off as arrogant it was to match tone.

Quoting:If I didn't try to personalise your 2010.12 distro with KDE4


I'm not a PCLinuxOS developer nor have I been for many years. The last release I worked on was PCLinuxOS 2007 release...I left the developer ranks after that and I don't use PCLinuxOS anymore. Not because I don't think it is good (It is pretty decent) but because I work on Unity Linux (http://unity-linux.org) which is a derivative of Mandriva and have done so for 2+ years.

Quoting:From a user perspective they, and you, certainly look like jackasses who are only concerned about themselves.


If I'm so concerned with myself, why would I give any time to this argument at all? I'm not officially recognized as a KDE developer but am rather a minimalistic contributor. My only attempt in this conversation is to get people to get off the bandwagon of bashing KDE4. It's been cool for a very long time to bash KDE4...cool like owning an ipod/pad/mac. But whatever, it's impossible I guess.

I'm surprised that anyone thinks I look like a jackass...I've been able to post in the past (Since January 2005 fwiw) without worrying that someone is going to personally attack me (save for Penguin Pete) or call me names. I thought I might have earned some lxer cred..but I guess not.
Quoting:You're taking it in the context of RIGHT NOW.


No I'm taking it in the context of a recent similar statement by another KDE developers/apologists, and also things you've said on this thread.

Sorry if I confused you with PCLOS development, I guess I missed the bit where you'd parted company. I'll have to check out Unity Linux.

We all get to look like jackasses from time to time, I've done my share. It's the nature of the beast. Holding strong opinions. So I don't hold it against you. But I do want you to see things from my/our perspective, and just accept publicly that there may actually be some substance to the continuing complaints about KDE4. Even better I'd like to see the KDE developers like Aaron thingy publicly admit it at the KDE mutual admiration festival (I won't hold my breath though).
In my opinion, the KDE4 developers achieved something that no other Linux DE developers could do: They created a DE that turned me -- a 3-plus-year, loyal KDE3-only user -- into a very happy Xfce user who has absolutely no interest in ever using KDE again.
> My only attempt in this conversation is to get people to get off the bandwagon of bashing KDE4.

People who liked, and if fact were loyal users of, KDE3 will probably always bash KDE4. The developers changed too much without consulting users or advising them of how to work around the changes. A system which worked well and met most of it's users needs was replaced by one which was largely incomplete, required completely new operations to get the same work done, and was poorly documented (to put it kindly). And you're surprised?

I'm an outside observer in this matter. I usually run older, relatively underpowered systems. I therefore tend to use XFCE as my desktop environment. I normally only use some specific KDE apps, and only when I need their functionality. So I've watched the debate with interest, and made the occasional comment. Based solely on those observation, I've concluded that the KDE4 developers don't care what the KDE3 users think, and don't care if they use KDE4 or not. They think what they've made is better, and if you don't agree with them you're either misinformed or stupid. If that's my take on the matter as an outside observer, think how the KDE3 users who have tried to use the system and asked for help when it didn't work as they expected feel.

On its own merits, without reference to KDE3, and after 3 years of work, KDE4 is probably now a passably usable system. It will probably eventually find new users to replace the ones they've lost, but they'll never get the old KDE3 users back, and it'll never again be the user friendly interface that most newbie friendly distros used. Those days are gone, and the developers have only themselves to blame.

Now, I've recently upgraded to a newer system which is probably powerful enough to handle KDE4. But as I noted, I normally use XFCE and only a few KDE apps (mostly K3B). I would need a reason to switch to using KDE4. KDE4's much touted features don't give me that. A developer base which doesn't seem to care what the existing user base thinks and actively insults their complaints doesn't give me that. So why on earth would I ever want to switch to KDE4?
> We all get to look like jackasses from time to time,

All too true.
It's sad there isn't some "real market survey" though, since the most vocal group with a certain opinion is not always the largest group.

Happy people most of the times aren't vocal, only dissatisfied users are. Therefore the net is full with writings of the latter.
@hans -

Wonder how you define happy in a case like this?

Sounds like most of the "unhappy" users are actually pretty happy now, we're just happily using something else.
One more thought or three, then I shall find another dead equine to flog--- the KDE4 supporters strategy of continually focusing on why the critics are wrong is doomed to failure. You can't argue with "I don't like it because it does not do what I want." If KDE4 has so many great new and cool features, then tell what they are. There are all these weird buzzwords floating around, semantic desktop, Activities, Nepomuk, Akonadi, and all this crazy stuff, and it's meaningless. When I hear 'database backend and search index' I think 'Windows bloaty junk, yuck.' And then I look on my little laptop and I see that this database index is nearly 2 GB! Now what in the heck do I need all that for? How do I benefit? I don't. I find stuff faster and more precisely with find, grep, and locate, and they don't bring my dual-core system to a screeching halt, in classic Windows fashion, every time the index is updated. Why not just make a nice friendly graphical front-end to find, grep, and locate that makes common searches pointy-clicky, plus a box for arbitrary user command options?

How do users benefit from Nepomuk? Why use confusing terminology like 'cashews' and 'dashboard'? In all other software a dashboard is a nice comprehensive control and monitoring panel. In KDE4 it is Spartan. Why does it take so many clicks to get to configuration menus with only one or two options? How does breaking configuration menus into multiple tabs with hardly any options on each tab benefit users? It drives me nuts. It takes too long to faff around and discover that there is no there there. I still remember Aaron Seigo ranting about how the old Gwenview had all these configuration options which screamed 'Look at me! Look how how powerful and amazing I am!' That is a very weird attitude, and that was when I developed serious doubts about the future of KDE. It's like Havoc Pennington infected KDE4 with the early Gnome 2 philosophy of simplifying the user experience by removing features wholesale. And the Gnome 2 philosophy of not listening to users-- remember how Havoc resisted the many pleas for a menu editor? And how Gnome finally got one because a college student took a summer off to write one and then managed to get Gnome to accept it? It wasn't a question of having enough developer bandwidth, Havoc just didn't want one.

Why is there still no 'open as root' option for config files?

I believe that the majority of KDE4 fans like it for its looks and fancy effects. In fact most reviews talk about appearance rather than function. Which is fine, just be honest about it and spare us the blahblah how it's all revolutionary and cool, because when it comes to functionality and efficiency I am not seeing revolutionary and cool, just lots of ornamentation and system hoggery.
I'll be interested to see what people think of two things that are coming in the near future on the other side of the fence:

1) Gnome Shell 2) Ubuntu Unity Desktop

@tc - that was the clearest and most comprehensive critique of kde4 I can remember ever seeing.
Quoting: I'll be interested to see what people think of two things that are coming in the near future on the other side of the fence:

1) Gnome Shell 2) Ubuntu Unity Desktop


I'll happily discuss them in another thread. In the mean time what about a few issues that have been raised in previous posts that haven't been resolved yet.
TC: I'm sorry to say, but your rant seems a bit uninformed and I even addressed the very topic of NEPOMUK before.

Think of having 'updatedb', but no '(s)locate'.

That's the current situation of NEPOMUK: There IS 'updatedb', but 'slocate' is not ready as of yet (4.5 era).

So, of course you don't benefit from your 2GB index at all, if there's no way to search it! It was pretty much the same situation as with KDE-PIM until 4.4: There was Akonadi, but nothing was using it yet (as far as I understood).

I think I said this before: If KDE4 was about new frameworks (though it seems other people think it was about QT4?), then KDE4 is not ready yet because (almost) "nothing" is using the new frameworks yet. Okay, it's coming, some of it came in 4.5 I believe - though I saw very strong advices not to use Kontact 4.5.1 as sometimes it "ate mail" so still at 4.4.x here - and some of it in 4.6. There are some frameworks which were used from the start though like Plasma, and Sonet by Amarok I believe, though I'm not sure as I'm no Desktop Environment user, I'm mainly a "KDE Apps"-user.

In my opinion, they just forgot the zero in the middle and the beta at the end of the version numbers, because if it was 4.0.6b which was coming, it would be easier to explain it would be the first version making use of Nepomuk.

Above, I explained why I think these frameworks are useful. But of course, frameworks which are not used are useless. And sad thing, whenever they will actually be used, they'll probably become even slower.

Don't buy into the "new storage backend", it's just another way of saying "Kontact relies on / uses MySQL/InnoDB now". That easy! As to the why: Seems someone developed the idea of "one size fits all"-software: The backend should be usable for single end-users, but also for Kolab-groupware aimed at hundreds of users simultaneously trying to access some addressbook and adding / changing / deleting contacts.

When comparing netbooks to laptops there are two ways to look at it: -One can say: The new netbooks don't resemble laptops well enough, because I can't do everything with it I did with my laptop, -One can say: The new netbooks resemble laptops TOO MUCH, because of the resemblance people develop the idea a netbook should be able to do the same as laptops did.

I think such is the case with KDE4: One can say it doesn't resemble KDE3 well enough, but one could also go the other way and say it's too much like 3, and therefore people expect they can do the same with it as with 3.

If it was developed as a parallel project aimed at different form factors, some cloud sauce and then called "K Cloud Environment", people would probably have no problem with it not being able to perform the functions which KDE3 performed. Now, because of resemblance and familiarity, people think it should perform the same functions as KDE3 did.

No matter what way you look at it, the situation is pretty messed up. A few years ago (2007 I think), I heard about the new KDE4 frameworks and thought this was all going to be pretty exciting, but boy did I know it would take another four years to develop it.

That was probably the biggest problem about KDE4: It was aiming too high. Even Microsoft can't fully rewrite their software to (use) new frameworks within a few years. Let alone a volunteer project which already suffered from a lack of developers / testers / documentation writers and so on.

Maybe if they developed the frameworks one by one it would have made sense, but they decided it would be "cleaner" and "easier" to start from scratch. But it proved to be too much work, I think I can say now; still struggling with Akonadi-errors and manually adding the leap second table to MySQL (an error which Bugzilla said should already have been fixed in my version???)
Forum posting should work again..;-)

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post