Linus Torvalds needs to shut up about Apple
More than three years later and poor Linus still gets grief over $#!^ he said. In part, thanks to David Gewirtz’s post that time forgot referring to Linus’ comments regarding Apple’s filesystem. The post made me start thinking (always a dangerous thing to do) and I came up with the notion that Linus Torvalds needs to shut up about Apple. |
|
|
Comments (24)
What can you say
ZDnet needs to shut up about Linus
2 earlier comments in the full thread.
Or maybe your retort is more humour, and I'm not getting this joke either?
Well, you could answer 1 question:
Was your intent to point out that most people don't share David Gerwitz's sense that 3 year old items are news?
That part is pretty funny, I'll admit, but...
This whole "techie" claim is weakened by your little feature listing that compares the HFS to ext4.
It's not just that ext4 is but one of many file system choices available to Linux users, it's that bullet points are pretty useless in real technical evaluations. I could make a bullet-pointed feature list that makes a Chevy Cruze look better than an Audi R8, but execution matters.
And -- while I agree that Linus has a, ummmm, propensity to say unfortunately harsh things now and then, when it comes to evaluating system level software, he has a certain credibility that you (or I ) don't.
Quoting:Dude, or dudette, get a frickin' grip. It's humor. And, I am a tech person.
Yeah but you are no comedian, at least not intentionally.
Silly statement. Never mind that Linus did study computer science in college, and that is the original genesis of Linux, what have you got against the school of hard knocks?
I would take Linux over Ken Hess anyday, and his real-world knowledge/vision over many others.
I still remember when people were calling him backwards for building Linux on a monolithic kernel. Seems to work OK. The Hurd? Not so much.
Good engineering triumphs, even over "suboptimal" theoretical choices.
Oh, and the school of hard knocks is a mighty poor way to learn security. What good is the lesson, once the information is stolen?
The school of hard knocks is not the most pleasant way to learn anything, but it is your failures that teach you the most.
You, I presume, are much too successful to have learned much.
And, with all due respect to your awesome prowess, Linus ain't exactly some guy named Joe. He's got quite the resume -- not to mention circle of friends. Truth is, if you try to tell me Linus knows squat, I will accept that somebody almost certainly doesn't know what he thinks he does.
Wouldn't be a Finn, though.
Microsoft employs many PHDs, yet I feel very confident saying,
..And given some of the security lapses that have made it into Windows and other Microsoft products, including lots of information leaks, the record isn't stellar by a long shot.
So what was your point?
Once they did start using a kernel with real MAC, their customers found cold comfort in the PR blitz. "Trust us, we got it right this time!" Uh-huh. Sure.
Unix and VMS at least had a MAC infrastructure in place, even if it wasn't perfect. But MAC is no substitute for secure code, as the Morris worm demonstrated.
Then along comes some undergrad who says, "I can do that!" while publicly stating that he refuses to heed some very well-founded advice from those who have gone before. The next thing you know, a whole bunch of people and orgs have deployed his stuff, thinking it's trustworthy. Yet, they're no more qualified to reach that conclusion than he is.
Thinking like a criminal, while working for the good guys, is an art that takes years to master. And criminals know it. Linus does not think like a criminal; if he ever did take a software security course, either the instructor was just as unqualified, or Linus didn't pay attention in class.
If he did, he'd probably be working for Microsoft.
90% of people don't think like a criminal, and don't want to. That doesn't mean they can't do good work, even in security.
Only 3 days ago I have seen the results of a limited poll. ( probably very limited ) Question was if it's ok that the government was corrupt. Answer : 32% said NO-- 68% said YES, if I get my part of the benefits
So, you don't mind if I disagree with you ?
Of course, this has nothing to do with computers , but still......
Let us also not forget that Red Hat (and others) does significant commercial activity with Linux with customers who do worry and check to see if they are being attacked. Red Hat contributes a lot. They have lots of weight.
We also have to keep in mind we are not building with security as the highest of all concerns [think Alcatraz or where/how the President is protected in event of homeland attack.] The vanilla product does not trade off left and right for security. The PC hardware itself has security issues in the first place. Where security is more important and something like Linux is desired, there are patches out there to help add layers of security and there are security experts that you can contract to help you build up a full secure solution. The biggest threat is not within Linux kernel but in other layers above (including with human manipulation).
Open source means that people can point out security problems at any time. Do you want to give a list of significant security problems with Linux that exist today and which are being ignored? See, that would be a problem.
All of this said, I agree that the design is important, but am not in a position to specifically say that Linux has some significant flaw. I don't know Linux source very much nor am I a security expert.
These meatless throwaway "articles" are annoying. Ten minutes' work and whee, some sucker actually coughs up a paycheck for it. There is no real story here, just another link in the...er... (LXer TOS looms)...circle of lazy "journalist" self-gratification. First the original interview:
http://www.smh.com.au/news/technology/q-and-a-with-linus-tor...
Quoting: Q. Do you have a favourite between Leopard and Vista?
A. I don't think they're equally flawed. I think Leopard is a much better system. On the other hand, (I've found) OS X in some ways is actually worse than Windows to program for. Their file system is complete and utter crap, which is scary. I think OS X is nicer than Windows in many ways, but neither can hold a candle to my own (Linux). It's a race to second place!
I wish the interviewer had followed up-- what is about Apple's filesystem that is so bad? Maybe he didn't have a chance to follow up. Maybe Linus saying "crap" was good enough.
Then we get an 'article' dashed off from a Google alert that links to a 3-year old summary of the interview, http://www.zdnet.com/blog/government/linux-linus-calls-apple...
Then we get today's content-free flamebait. This is what I loathe about tech "journalism." It's junk. It's a waste of space and an abuse of one of the most wonderful technologies in human history. After reading all these "articles" I'm still wondering what is wrong with the Apple filesystem? There are maybe four thousand words expended in these four articles, and not one single word of substance addressing this question, just a bunch of Beavis and Butthead-style "hur hur, Linus said crap." The original interviewer does some actual work, and then a succession of lazy ripoffs follow. Which is nothing new, journalism has always been like that, the Internet just makes it easier.
dinotrac wrote:The school of hard knocks is not the most pleasant way to learn anything, but it is your failures that teach you the most.
Would you trust someone claiming to be a lawyer, who learned his practice that way?
Or a structural engineer?
Or a physician?
When others' lives and fortunes depend on you knowing how to do your job, the school of hard knocks is not a good entry to put on a resume.
Besides, we all know at least one person who stubbornly refuses to learn from his/her failures, always hoping for different results from the same choices.
Not at all. But since almost all government are corrupt, I'd merely note that 68% of the respondents have a firm grasp of reality.
> Would you trust someone claiming to be a lawyer, who learned his practice that way?
It's only in modern times that a law degree was required to be a lawyer. For a long time all you had to do was pass the bar exam, and you could do that by reading law on your own. Some of the best lawyers in history were self educated.
> Besides, we all know at least one person who stubbornly refuses to learn from his/her failures, always hoping for different results from the same choices.
Sure. But that's not a description of Linus Torvalds.
I would never trust anybody who was afraid to fess up to mistakes.
My experience is that there are two kinds of people:
Those who make mistakes, and...
wait.
Make that one kind of people.
That's how all surgeons and interventional cardiologists learn. It's estimated a cardiologist needs to perform more than a 100 catheterizations to BASIC competence. And it takes a lot more to get good. So I hope all of those "practice" patients didn't have any serious problems.
Of course that's about as pertinent as your statements about Linus.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post
