Advanced

Comment: OpenOffice's Tale of Two Cities

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 12 comments
The H Open; By Oliver Diedrich
Mail this story
Print this story

Failure in Freiburg, success in Munich. Experiences with open source software in the public sector couldn't be more different. If there's a lesson to be drawn from this, it's "go the whole hog or not at all". At first sight it looks pretty straightforward – a licence for Microsoft Office Professional 2010 costs just under €400. Add that up over 10,000 workplaces (as is the case in Munich's city administration) and it comes to more than €4 million. For open source alternatives OpenOffice and LibreOffice, by contrast, licensing costs are zero, so you've saved at least €4 million. In view of the state of public finances, you'd think that would be the end of the discussion..

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Migrations

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (12)

Quoting:Against this backdrop, the council's decision to put the OpenOffice experiment out of its misery and allow its staff to get back to working properly is understandable.


Pretty good article summarizing the obstacles and road blocks faced by Munich and the efforts made to successfully overcome MS lock-in & monopoly. Unfortunately, Freiburg didn't [edited] reach to the same results.

The fact that, two organizations that basically have similar IT requirements and functions yet the results are different is indicative of couple things: Migrating from MS to FOSS is doable and more importantly beneficial, and if an organization is committed and convinced of such effort, it better do its home work in planning and preparing to avoid failure

Munich has better IT staff who foreseen the benefits of FOSS, made the commitment to break the lock-in/monopoly, and most importantly, took the matters very seriously. They took their time understanding the situation, established objectives, developed requirements and plans, and persisted to achieve their goals. Freiburg should have learned and gained from the Munich experience. Obviously they didn't.
Freiburg is one of the three dozen largest cities in Germany -- and the other three dozen or so cities in this class have been participating in a general drive to implement Open Source software and Open Document Formats, and having quite good results in managing similar migrations to FOSS.software. These cities have also made a point of collaborating and sharing expertise and experience in these efforts, so Freiburg has not been forced to "go it alone" or been unable to take advantage of advice from others in very similar circumstances.

Part of the hullabaloo about the Freiburg return to the Microsoft fold was the recent incident of the "expert consultant's report" commissioned by Freiburg IT. This report declared the migration a stumbling failure and recommended promptly returning to MS and proprietary software. But despite the attention given to this recommendation the report was (aside from these damning conclusions and very broad brush-stokes) apparently deemed too 'top secret' for the eyes of the Freiburg city councillors

Over the years, I have acquired the distinct impression that from the very beginning the Freiburg IT staff (and much of the non-IT staff) actively and stubbornly opposed the migration. They didn't want this project to succeed -- and did want the migration to fail. So of course it did fail. I personally suspect there was a fair bit of politics, covert collusion and subtle sabotage involved.
Quoting:... and did want the migration to fail. So of course it did fail.


I thought it would be the case and they ought to be fired.

I wonder how the other cities are doing, any news about their progress?

I see that I have overstated the prevalence of such projects. However, besides Munich I find Jena, Leipzig, and other German cities, large and small, have had successful projects along these lines.

(And the vote was apparently 25-20)
And never, ever, evvveeerrrrr underestimate the power of a whiny employee. Ever.
Quoting:And never, ever, evvveeerrrrr underestimate the power of a whiny employee. Ever.
The only power such a one inherently has, is to get him/herself fired. All other powers are granted by the powers-that-be.
Oh no Gus....some of the places I've worked, especially when employee work stations were concerned, the movement of one icon on the desktop sent howls of outrage throughout the workforce. Yeah, in a perfect world, such people would be shown the door but when you manage extremely specialized and talented people, they wield the might. The article about the movement back to MS Office in Freiburg even alluded strongly to employee sniveling facilitated the switch back.

Management can easily be manipulated, given the choice of capitulation or spending 6 months to a year filling a highly specialized slot. Especially when XYZ corp has an open position for that employee to run to.
I work in a place (state government agency in the U.S., as a contractor) where this migration (as least in terms of Office suite) was done successfully before I ever got here. It can work. It should work. It really should take some degree of effort to make it not work.
Where I work it was tried, but there had already been such an investment into complex, macro-driven spreadsheets, that MS Office was impossible to move from.

Effectively, they programmed in Excel.
Quoting:It really should take some degree of effort to make it not work.


Not really. If the IT staff aren't convinced, it is very easy for them to sabotage any effort initiated by management or anyone else for that matter.

IT staff should be convinced and enthusiastic to gain the support of the users first. Management almost always goes with what the users want and need since they are considered to be the ones doing the productive work, not the IT staff.

IT staff can never convince all the users, but they only need influential key users to succeed.

Quoting:the movement of one icon on the desktop sent howls of outrage
Then I'm inclined to think they were trained monkeys, rather than observant, rational humans. Sorry, I just tend to be rather unsympathetic towards unobservant types.
Is anyone up to date on the options for converting MS Office macros into OpenOffice and/or Libre Office macros?

I seem to recall that such a feature was one of the reasons to pay for the Paid and Supported version of OO.o from Sun. I don't know how that's evolved since -- especially with the take-over by Oracle since then.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post