KDEs Next Generation Semantic Search
|
|
|
Comments (40)
20 earlier comments in the full thread.
> Are users with such a binary frame of mind worthy of the extra work needed to hold them to Linux ?
I don't know. Are the problems with KDE 4 and the insults from the KDE 4 dev's more than it's worth to stay with Linux? If the dev's are going to ignore you anyway, why not at least go with a solution you know will work?
I do know that if KDE and Gnome were my only options, I wouldn't be using Linux at this point. Since those are the two best known options, how many users aren't?
> Let them go.
Your choice. I'm fairly sure they feel the same way about you. Personally, I'd rather have a Linux solution that works for them. But apparently I'm now a minority in the Linux ecosystem in that regard. I guess they'll just have to use Android or a Chromebook if they want to use Linux.
I don't know. Are the problems with KDE 4 and the insults from the KDE 4 dev's more than it's worth to stay with Linux? If the dev's are going to ignore you anyway, why not at least go with a solution you know will work?
I do know that if KDE and Gnome were my only options, I wouldn't be using Linux at this point. Since those are the two best known options, how many users aren't?
> Let them go.
Your choice. I'm fairly sure they feel the same way about you. Personally, I'd rather have a Linux solution that works for them. But apparently I'm now a minority in the Linux ecosystem in that regard. I guess they'll just have to use Android or a Chromebook if they want to use Linux.
Quoting: Personally, I'd rather have a Linux solution that works for them
Exactly. Everything else is just excuses.
Thanks Fettoosh....we agree to disagree at times, but you definitely have hit on a major reason I wrote the articles: pure frustration at what was being done to a lovely desktop manager in my opinion and no-one would listen. It seems you cannot, cannot get the developers to even consider what you are saying unless you literally scream in their ears for at least three weeks......and three articles. I believe it is happening now and perhaps some good will come out of it. But even at developer level, there is a refusal to accept what is happening. Here's a real example:
Q.....If you turn off the semantic desktop is KMail affected ?
A....No.
And this is quite right, spot on, accurate to a micrometre....... in a theoretical sense; what they refuse to look at is the practical situation in which the semantic desktop operates.
What the developers refuse to accept is that Akonadi is also a crucial element in the running of the semantic desktop. It sits underneath and it's cache is referred to by semantic desktop elements and that cache in turn is developed from (at least) the data file components of the KDEPIM and they in turn are crucial to the semantic desktop data that will be sifted with a query. Those KDEPIM components will NOT run unless Akonadi is active and so on and so on. So, render Akonadi disabled and the structure grinds to a halt. Theoretically, Akonadi is not, not, NOT part of the semantic desktop if you consider only Nepomuk, but it is a crucial foundation stone to that desktop's operations.
nmset, you continue to amaze me.. Here's a quote from your post above:
Start quote. >YOU WILL have this programming and YOU WILL have no choice in the matter....
Yes, that's it, in KDE, GNOME, LXDE, VLC, Apple, Windows, BSD, Oracle... anywhere, really anywhere... because THEY do the job, not YOU, and THEY don't do it for YOU. End quote.
First, if you read my articles properly (and from what you are writing in the post quoted above, I still do not believe you have or if you have, then you switched off at the appropriate points where I diverge from your trodden paths), you will find that my biggest item of discontent at the end of Part 2 is the removal by the KDE developers of choice that was previously present in KDE4. Choice to run the desktop conventionally with the KDEPIM servicing its data files by unix operations or choice to run the full semantic desktop with the Akonadi and Nepomuk components running. And choice to store passwords in KWallet or in KMail itself...Go and read part 2 properly please.
And second.....if they do not do it for "YOU" (and here I assume you mean either me or the user base because they are the same), then who on human earth do they do it for ? Some esoteric concept that allows them to put the fruits of their labours at the foot of a "Developer's Deity" ? Or for pure hard cash ? Okay, that's cool, but ultimately they DO need their output to be used and the developer coterie should be hard wired into its user base.. The user base is the area that can give constant and useful feedback and right now we have evidence that not only is there minimum connection of the KDE devs with the user base, they actively ignore any feedback it gives - unless you scream and scream and scream - and most users don't have the time and/or enthusiasm to enter into such an all-consuming project.
This blanket denial/dismissal/refusal to listen by the KDE devs is not only unwise, it's destructive. Right now, the situation with KDE4 looks to me very eerily similar to what happened with the release of KDE4.0, and the mass migration of users away from its software. Think about it please......if the devs DON'T listen to and develop for the user base, why are they there and what is their function ?
Q.....If you turn off the semantic desktop is KMail affected ?
A....No.
And this is quite right, spot on, accurate to a micrometre....... in a theoretical sense; what they refuse to look at is the practical situation in which the semantic desktop operates.
What the developers refuse to accept is that Akonadi is also a crucial element in the running of the semantic desktop. It sits underneath and it's cache is referred to by semantic desktop elements and that cache in turn is developed from (at least) the data file components of the KDEPIM and they in turn are crucial to the semantic desktop data that will be sifted with a query. Those KDEPIM components will NOT run unless Akonadi is active and so on and so on. So, render Akonadi disabled and the structure grinds to a halt. Theoretically, Akonadi is not, not, NOT part of the semantic desktop if you consider only Nepomuk, but it is a crucial foundation stone to that desktop's operations.
nmset, you continue to amaze me.. Here's a quote from your post above:
Start quote. >YOU WILL have this programming and YOU WILL have no choice in the matter....
Yes, that's it, in KDE, GNOME, LXDE, VLC, Apple, Windows, BSD, Oracle... anywhere, really anywhere... because THEY do the job, not YOU, and THEY don't do it for YOU. End quote.
First, if you read my articles properly (and from what you are writing in the post quoted above, I still do not believe you have or if you have, then you switched off at the appropriate points where I diverge from your trodden paths), you will find that my biggest item of discontent at the end of Part 2 is the removal by the KDE developers of choice that was previously present in KDE4. Choice to run the desktop conventionally with the KDEPIM servicing its data files by unix operations or choice to run the full semantic desktop with the Akonadi and Nepomuk components running. And choice to store passwords in KWallet or in KMail itself...Go and read part 2 properly please.
And second.....if they do not do it for "YOU" (and here I assume you mean either me or the user base because they are the same), then who on human earth do they do it for ? Some esoteric concept that allows them to put the fruits of their labours at the foot of a "Developer's Deity" ? Or for pure hard cash ? Okay, that's cool, but ultimately they DO need their output to be used and the developer coterie should be hard wired into its user base.. The user base is the area that can give constant and useful feedback and right now we have evidence that not only is there minimum connection of the KDE devs with the user base, they actively ignore any feedback it gives - unless you scream and scream and scream - and most users don't have the time and/or enthusiasm to enter into such an all-consuming project.
This blanket denial/dismissal/refusal to listen by the KDE devs is not only unwise, it's destructive. Right now, the situation with KDE4 looks to me very eerily similar to what happened with the release of KDE4.0, and the mass migration of users away from its software. Think about it please......if the devs DON'T listen to and develop for the user base, why are they there and what is their function ?
>if the devs DON'T listen to and develop for the user base, why are they there and what is their function ?
They don't have a function for any, because their user base do not order work from them, they are not employed by their user base, they are not mandated by any authority. They code by themselves and true, expect to gather momentum from users if and only if users find it useful for them. If the latter expectation is not fulfilled, they would do something else. This is true for closed and paid software also, just look at where Windows 8 is. The contract is : software as is, use at your own risks; it's written everywhere. You can't order anything from them. If one has a request to make, the proper channel is the bug tracker.
They don't have a function for any, because their user base do not order work from them, they are not employed by their user base, they are not mandated by any authority. They code by themselves and true, expect to gather momentum from users if and only if users find it useful for them. If the latter expectation is not fulfilled, they would do something else. This is true for closed and paid software also, just look at where Windows 8 is. The contract is : software as is, use at your own risks; it's written everywhere. You can't order anything from them. If one has a request to make, the proper channel is the bug tracker.
Do you know "nmset", your post above is one of the saddest and most discouraging responses I have ever seen in this whole debate and if that is the way you perceive the situation, then I truly have sympathy and pity for you. It is almost reminiscent of the heartbreaking despondency of a long term "prisoner of war". Such a person has no fight left in them and all initiative has been squashed - you just take the punishment that is handed out by the people in charge. If they care to give you some tasty scraps, then you glow with pleasure, tell them they are great and hope they don't kick you next day - which they invariably do.
Well frankly, I don't buy it and I am prepared to fight. A developer base in FOSS should know, in fact, MUST know what its user base thinks of the product. The aim is to expand, not shrink and if the product can be improved by feedback, then that should be given and listened to. The reason I wrote these articles is because it was very obvious that the KDE developers were NOT listening to their user base and somehow, someway I wanted to give constructive and positive feedback....but I've said this all before and it's getting monotonous to have to repeat it to you every few posts.
Windows8 got where it is because it stems from a monopoly which began with Win3.5, expanded to Win95, Win98SE and so forth.....there were NO real competitors and vendor-lockin holds the user base even today. You should not compare Windows in any meaningful way with the procedures of a FOSS developer group. In fact it should be distasteful for anyone to do so. The protocols of a closed source "cathedral" developer company are very different to those of FOSS...
Finally, I have tried once, a few years ago, using the bugtracker.....yeah, right. Ever seen what happens when you throw a stone into a 300 metre shaft ? You don't even know it has hit the bottom. Besides, a bugtracker is designed to report bugs.....that's how I see it. "Feedback on structures" and "constructive suggestions" do NOT come under the heading of bugs......If the KDE developers seriously wanted constructive feedback then they would have a designated and moderated feedback site - with responses to those putting in the information. I gave up fighting my way through the maze of KDE links, menus and so forth......and eventually walked out.
Well frankly, I don't buy it and I am prepared to fight. A developer base in FOSS should know, in fact, MUST know what its user base thinks of the product. The aim is to expand, not shrink and if the product can be improved by feedback, then that should be given and listened to. The reason I wrote these articles is because it was very obvious that the KDE developers were NOT listening to their user base and somehow, someway I wanted to give constructive and positive feedback....but I've said this all before and it's getting monotonous to have to repeat it to you every few posts.
Windows8 got where it is because it stems from a monopoly which began with Win3.5, expanded to Win95, Win98SE and so forth.....there were NO real competitors and vendor-lockin holds the user base even today. You should not compare Windows in any meaningful way with the procedures of a FOSS developer group. In fact it should be distasteful for anyone to do so. The protocols of a closed source "cathedral" developer company are very different to those of FOSS...
Finally, I have tried once, a few years ago, using the bugtracker.....yeah, right. Ever seen what happens when you throw a stone into a 300 metre shaft ? You don't even know it has hit the bottom. Besides, a bugtracker is designed to report bugs.....that's how I see it. "Feedback on structures" and "constructive suggestions" do NOT come under the heading of bugs......If the KDE developers seriously wanted constructive feedback then they would have a designated and moderated feedback site - with responses to those putting in the information. I gave up fighting my way through the maze of KDE links, menus and so forth......and eventually walked out.
You seem to desperately want to own what's not yours, you can't.You seem to think that whatever you request must be listened to and must be implemented, it won't ever be this way. I repeat, it's true for any software editor. Even if you pay for software, you pay for a license to use it as is and nothing more, it won't ever be your software.If you hire a company to develop software for you, then you can design it ground up as you want, and they will write it as you want and it will be yours. Here, you (me, anyone else...) don't pay anything, can't order any work, and are lucky enough to find tons of software to use gratis : why should one overbear the KDE team ? If one does not like what they do, it's wiser to move to something else than stil expecting what will never happen and shouting at them. Fight ? There's no fight, there's nothing to gain, they have their agenda.
First: You are merely confirming what I said in my previous post as to how I see your perceptions of the entire developer-user base situation. Again, I see your position with considerable sadness.
Second: Do not impute to me something I have never, never, never implied or stated. I do NOT "desperately want to own what's not" mine. Professionally, I am a scientist and what you have indicated above is utterly against my ethics and probity; further, it is without any foundation, pure exaggeration and I am extremely offended by such a suggestion.
All I have ever indicated is that I wish to be heard, just as I am listening to you on this thread. Equally, I am sure you would be offended if I did not extend to you the courtesy of listening to what you have to say. In a similar way, I wish the user base to be heard by the KDE developers. But ultimately, it is up to the KDE developers to choose whether they will listen and/or take any action. That is always their right and I will be the first to accept that. The eventual outcome is in their hands, as always. I may not like it, but that is absolute fact.
Third: If you wish to adopt what I see as a defeatist attitude, that's your privilege and right. Go for it.
Fourth: Fight ? Hah !......nmset, I have good reason to believe I have already very firmly won. And I am not going to explain that any further.
Fifth and finally.....this debate between you and I is now utterly pointless. I've said all I wish to say and my perception is that you are simply regurgitating your same stale arguments again and again so that I have to respond in new and different ways. Let's leave it. You will not change my concepts, and to be honest, I don't have any desire to change yours since you obviously wish to stay where you are. Thankyou.
Post Script......Do please nmset, read a short story from Rudyard Kipling's wonderful book "Plain Tales from the Hills". The short story is called "Pig". It explains very nicely why I will be unlikely to respond to any further material from you. It's a very clever story by the way.
Second: Do not impute to me something I have never, never, never implied or stated. I do NOT "desperately want to own what's not" mine. Professionally, I am a scientist and what you have indicated above is utterly against my ethics and probity; further, it is without any foundation, pure exaggeration and I am extremely offended by such a suggestion.
All I have ever indicated is that I wish to be heard, just as I am listening to you on this thread. Equally, I am sure you would be offended if I did not extend to you the courtesy of listening to what you have to say. In a similar way, I wish the user base to be heard by the KDE developers. But ultimately, it is up to the KDE developers to choose whether they will listen and/or take any action. That is always their right and I will be the first to accept that. The eventual outcome is in their hands, as always. I may not like it, but that is absolute fact.
Third: If you wish to adopt what I see as a defeatist attitude, that's your privilege and right. Go for it.
Fourth: Fight ? Hah !......nmset, I have good reason to believe I have already very firmly won. And I am not going to explain that any further.
Fifth and finally.....this debate between you and I is now utterly pointless. I've said all I wish to say and my perception is that you are simply regurgitating your same stale arguments again and again so that I have to respond in new and different ways. Let's leave it. You will not change my concepts, and to be honest, I don't have any desire to change yours since you obviously wish to stay where you are. Thankyou.
Post Script......Do please nmset, read a short story from Rudyard Kipling's wonderful book "Plain Tales from the Hills". The short story is called "Pig". It explains very nicely why I will be unlikely to respond to any further material from you. It's a very clever story by the way.
> You seem to desperately want to own what's not yours...
He wants the software he uses on his machine to meet his needs. He doesn't own the software, the devs don't own his machine.
> If one does not like what they do, it's wiser to move to something else
Actually, I agree. And I've done so. Where I disagree is that you seem to think that the KDE devs are deserving of anything other than contempt.
By treating former devoted users as a captive test base for use in developing their grand vision, treating those who had legitimate complaints about the software as the problem, and insulting them in their responses; the KDE devs lost any right to any degree of respect, either as developers or people. And the current responses to Ridcully's writeups show that nothing has changed in that regard.
He wants the software he uses on his machine to meet his needs. He doesn't own the software, the devs don't own his machine.
> If one does not like what they do, it's wiser to move to something else
Actually, I agree. And I've done so. Where I disagree is that you seem to think that the KDE devs are deserving of anything other than contempt.
By treating former devoted users as a captive test base for use in developing their grand vision, treating those who had legitimate complaints about the software as the problem, and insulting them in their responses; the KDE devs lost any right to any degree of respect, either as developers or people. And the current responses to Ridcully's writeups show that nothing has changed in that regard.
>Ridcully's writeups
Unfortunately, and it's the central problem, the writeups breathed a profound misunderstanding of the semantic desktop as implemented in KDE, about the way to use kwallet so that it does not get in the user's way on a 'stand-alone" PC, about akonadi becoming a core architectural element by design. We may like, dislike, request, write, complain, propose... but we can't say : I want KDE (or other stuff) and I want it this way.
Unfortunately, and it's the central problem, the writeups breathed a profound misunderstanding of the semantic desktop as implemented in KDE, about the way to use kwallet so that it does not get in the user's way on a 'stand-alone" PC, about akonadi becoming a core architectural element by design. We may like, dislike, request, write, complain, propose... but we can't say : I want KDE (or other stuff) and I want it this way.
Quoting: We may like, dislike, request, write, complain, propose... but we can't say : I want KDE (or other stuff) and I want it this way.
We can say whatever we want. You really don't need thousands of words to tell how you don't want people to disagree with you.
@nmset
I would say you are right if this was another corporate open source project, where the corporation is paying for a number of features irrespective of user wishes. Unfortunately KDE bills itself as a community project, and users expect something different form a community project. People who contributed to the project, and feel frustrated with the direction the project has taken, have a right to complain publicly after spending time submitting patches, translations, artwork, bugs etc.
I would suggest you read a little bit more about community projects, how they work, and what should be the interaction between the corporation financing the project and the community. Also get your friend Jos Poortvliet to do some reading on the subject as well.
I would say you are right if this was another corporate open source project, where the corporation is paying for a number of features irrespective of user wishes. Unfortunately KDE bills itself as a community project, and users expect something different form a community project. People who contributed to the project, and feel frustrated with the direction the project has taken, have a right to complain publicly after spending time submitting patches, translations, artwork, bugs etc.
I would suggest you read a little bit more about community projects, how they work, and what should be the interaction between the corporation financing the project and the community. Also get your friend Jos Poortvliet to do some reading on the subject as well.
@nmset. Unfortunately, you have a profound misunderstanding of what I published and what it means. Those three documents are written and based on experimental evidence and they show perfectly the problems with the KDE4 software that involves the "semantic desktop" even obliquely. They demonstrate the foundational function of Akonadi and the interfering operation of KWallet. The point I have made to you again, and again, and again ad nauseum is that what is in those articles is what actually happened and demonstrated by illustrations.
I continue to be amazed at your refusal to acknowledge this simple fact: if you disable Akonadi then the KDEPIM software (KMail, Kontact, Kalendar, etc.) collapses/freezes and if that package collapses so does the semantic desktop which depends on that sql data cache in whatever form the cache data happens to take. Read the articles again. I proved it by actual computer operations and any denials you put forward simply don't add up.
Oh yes.....one last thing nmset, no matter how you cut it, Akonadi is central to the main problems with the KDE4 desktop. It's constant operations slow the desktop down....Its operations are essential to the data required by the semantic desktop. It is so integrated that if you delete Akonadi, you destroy the desktop and re-installation is the only cure. What is so frightening about admitting these facts - they have been demonstrated in the articles ?
Jazz, that's a great comment, and one that nmset and Poortvliet would do well to consider.
Post script.....Sorry Tuxchick, I meant to put this in as well, but you beat me to it and very nicely too. Nmset, I have EVERY right to say what I think about KDE4 development directions and to make suggestions. And I most definitely can say how I would like the package to operate.....Whether I get what I want is another matter, but I definitely have the right to say what I think. JDixon has also fingered another problem very nicely too. The fact that the KDE4 team is virtually ignoring the user base shows arrogance and contempt. As I have indicated, developers need proper feedback if they wish to produce a product that the user base wants; not just me, but all of us. Right now, there is not even a proper channel for such feedback, and I have looked for it on the KDE site.
I continue to be amazed at your refusal to acknowledge this simple fact: if you disable Akonadi then the KDEPIM software (KMail, Kontact, Kalendar, etc.) collapses/freezes and if that package collapses so does the semantic desktop which depends on that sql data cache in whatever form the cache data happens to take. Read the articles again. I proved it by actual computer operations and any denials you put forward simply don't add up.
Oh yes.....one last thing nmset, no matter how you cut it, Akonadi is central to the main problems with the KDE4 desktop. It's constant operations slow the desktop down....Its operations are essential to the data required by the semantic desktop. It is so integrated that if you delete Akonadi, you destroy the desktop and re-installation is the only cure. What is so frightening about admitting these facts - they have been demonstrated in the articles ?
Jazz, that's a great comment, and one that nmset and Poortvliet would do well to consider.
Post script.....Sorry Tuxchick, I meant to put this in as well, but you beat me to it and very nicely too. Nmset, I have EVERY right to say what I think about KDE4 development directions and to make suggestions. And I most definitely can say how I would like the package to operate.....Whether I get what I want is another matter, but I definitely have the right to say what I think. JDixon has also fingered another problem very nicely too. The fact that the KDE4 team is virtually ignoring the user base shows arrogance and contempt. As I have indicated, developers need proper feedback if they wish to produce a product that the user base wants; not just me, but all of us. Right now, there is not even a proper channel for such feedback, and I have looked for it on the KDE site.
>if you disable Akonadi
>Akonadi is central to the main problems with the KDE4 desktop
But you must not touch Akonadi ! It's a core component by design. Would one disable one or two pistons in his car engine ? Would one replace glibc by bionic ?
>It's constant operations slow the desktop down
No, this cannot be reproduced faithfully. I use KDE on more than one machine and I really cannot say so. Nepomuk used to be a CPU burner in the early days of it's integration in KDE but that's no longer the case.
But you must not touch Akonadi ! It's a core component by design. Would one disable one or two pistons in his car engine ? Would one replace glibc by bionic ?
>It's constant operations slow the desktop down
No, this cannot be reproduced faithfully. I use KDE on more than one machine and I really cannot say so. Nepomuk used to be a CPU burner in the early days of it's integration in KDE but that's no longer the case.
> But you must not touch Akonadi ! It's a core component by design. Would one disable one or two pistons in his car engine ?
Oh that's not so !!!!! Of course you can disable Akonadi......I showed how it can be done in Part 1. Once that file is modified, Akonadi is halted. And it is NOT central to KDE4........it is ONLY central to the operations of the semantic desktop. The rest of the desktop is now open to the user to be set up in any way they desire. The KDE4 desktop is ONLY destroyed if you uninstall Akonadi......Go and read Part 1 for heaven's sakes. You are arguing from points that have already been shown to be incorrect by my researches.
>It's constant operations slow the desktop down
No, this cannot be reproduced faithfully.
Again, that is not so !!......Person after person on the internet is reporting how much better KDE4 works with Akonadi disabled. Once you have Akonadi out of the way, you can do whatever you jolly well please to the desktop; install other email clients, etc. What you must however do is uninstall ALL members of the KDEPIM because they will still fret after Akonadi. And that tells you one more thing: those additional KDEPIM members are automatically running......and the user of the desktop has not requested that to be the case.
Oh that's not so !!!!! Of course you can disable Akonadi......I showed how it can be done in Part 1. Once that file is modified, Akonadi is halted. And it is NOT central to KDE4........it is ONLY central to the operations of the semantic desktop. The rest of the desktop is now open to the user to be set up in any way they desire. The KDE4 desktop is ONLY destroyed if you uninstall Akonadi......Go and read Part 1 for heaven's sakes. You are arguing from points that have already been shown to be incorrect by my researches.
>It's constant operations slow the desktop down
No, this cannot be reproduced faithfully.
Again, that is not so !!......Person after person on the internet is reporting how much better KDE4 works with Akonadi disabled. Once you have Akonadi out of the way, you can do whatever you jolly well please to the desktop; install other email clients, etc. What you must however do is uninstall ALL members of the KDEPIM because they will still fret after Akonadi. And that tells you one more thing: those additional KDEPIM members are automatically running......and the user of the desktop has not requested that to be the case.
...................It's a core component by design.
>>3 years ago it was small core, now it is big core :-)
...................I use KDE on more than one machine >>>so do I . to be exact, on 7 partitions.t
..................Nepomuk used to be a CPU burner in the early days of it's integration in KDE >>> It still is on low ram machines
And with this, I am out. Too hot a conversation for me :-)
...................I use KDE on more than one machine >>>so do I . to be exact, on 7 partitions.t
..................Nepomuk used to be a CPU burner in the early days of it's integration in KDE >>> It still is on low ram machines
And with this, I am out. Too hot a conversation for me :-)
@Francy.......never be worried about giving an opinion on this site....whether it is "hot" or "cool". Everybody should be able to put an opinion and the more the better. I am certain that everybody will welcome anything you have to say.
My "dramatic rebuttals" immediately above are purely because the gentleman/lady concerned has had the evidence put in front of him/her in so many different ways now that it has become cumulatively "flippin terrifyin' " and yet still there is a persistent denial of what has been proven experimentally to be the case......there !! I promise to turn off my "yellin at yer" shift key. :-) LOL.
Postscript........and just for you, I have removed the shouts in the above post........ :-) :-)
My "dramatic rebuttals" immediately above are purely because the gentleman/lady concerned has had the evidence put in front of him/her in so many different ways now that it has become cumulatively "flippin terrifyin' " and yet still there is a persistent denial of what has been proven experimentally to be the case......there !! I promise to turn off my "yellin at yer" shift key. :-) LOL.
Postscript........and just for you, I have removed the shouts in the above post........ :-) :-)
>uninstall ALL members of the KDEPIM
But I want KDEPim ! And KDE just rocks, no bottlenecks anywhere. Are you misusing the software ? Ok, you'll say many others are saying as you, I would say used to say as you, for none of these have said same with latest release, in fact, none of the yelling voices have tested the latest release.
> The KDE4 desktop is ONLY destroyed if you uninstall Akonadi
That's what we call a core component, you have to live with it, like it or not.
But I want KDEPim ! And KDE just rocks, no bottlenecks anywhere. Are you misusing the software ? Ok, you'll say many others are saying as you, I would say used to say as you, for none of these have said same with latest release, in fact, none of the yelling voices have tested the latest release.
> The KDE4 desktop is ONLY destroyed if you uninstall Akonadi
That's what we call a core component, you have to live with it, like it or not.
Quoting:Would one disable one or two pistons in his car engine ?
Actually, it is the Crank Shaft of the engine that links all the pistons (PIM's Apps - KMail, Kontact, Kalendar, etc.) to work in unison with Semantic Search. :-)
Could it be removed? NOT if you wanted to have all PIM's apps. (KMail, Kontact, Kalendar, etc.) integrated and working together for better management and searchability of personal information. KDE devs know what they are doing, PIM is really really important for the business word and is becoming more so for individuals. How else can we explain the popularity of smart phones & tablets. Its all about access to personal information now a days.
Quoting:No, this cannot be reproduced faithfully. I use KDE on more than one machine and I really cannot say so. Nepomuk used to be a CPU burner in the early days of it's integration in KDE but that's no longer the case.
That is my experience too. Like I said before, on my Toshiba NB205 that has Atom N280 1.66 GHz processor with only 1GB of memory, I hardly uses notice Akonadi.
Quoting:Oh that's not so !!!!! Of course you can disable Akonadi.
That is correct and you did show it @Ridcully. On my netbook, I have Nepomuk disabled and when I boot, Nepomuk (Semantic Search) it is not running and neither Akonadi. but when I launch KMail, Akonadi is automatically started. when I exit Kmail, Akonadi is stopped but its children processes/threads are still there. But CPU is not heavily used just like when KMail was running and hardly noticeable.
Quoting:..................Nepomuk used to be a CPU burner in the early days of it's integration in KDE >>>It still is on low ram machines
That is true for any application when physical memory is all used up and and system start faulting (swapping) pages.
Quoting:> The KDE4 desktop is ONLY destroyed if you uninstall Akonadi
That's what we call a core component, you have to live with it, like it or not.
No, KDE4 desktop is not destroyed. It would have been nice if Kmail would have been independent from Akonadi but that is not the case for various reasons technical or otherwise . Many users who don't want PIM just go with other mail agent and still enjoy and love what KDE offers them by having KMail/Akonadi disabled. On the other hand, many users want, need, & require PIM integration, and that is the whole idea of KDE trying to accommodate to as many users as possible. Its KDE superb reconfigurability that is unique in KDE. May be we all should read this recent article.
And please let's not keep going in circles about this issue.
@Fettoosh.......last sentence.........AGREED !!! And gladly - there will be no more from me on this thread.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Are users with such a binary frame of mind worthy of the extra work needed to hold them to Linux ? Many have switched to XFCE, LXDE and what else. Someone leaving GNU/Linux simply doesn't deserve it. Let them go.