The fuss over kernel design
|
|
|
Comments (20)
Gimme s'mo'
" Is the flip-side also true; taking creates a duty to take more?"
Ask anyone who lives in a country with a progressive income tax. Or rather, ask their tax-collector, and they'll shout "Hoorah!"
Ask anyone who lives in a country with a progressive income tax. Or rather, ask their tax-collector, and they'll shout "Hoorah!"
Bob --
>Ask anyone who lives in a country with a progressive income tax.
Heh, heh.
And politicians complaining that they can't take more!!!
BTW -- did you see the reports that April's Federal Government tax revenue was the second highest level in history?
Must be too much economic activity. Better raise those taxes and shut it down.
>Ask anyone who lives in a country with a progressive income tax.
Heh, heh.
And politicians complaining that they can't take more!!!
BTW -- did you see the reports that April's Federal Government tax revenue was the second highest level in history?
Must be too much economic activity. Better raise those taxes and shut it down.
It wasn't me who said, "The power to tax is the power to destroy", nor "There are the costs that are seen, and the costs that are unseen."
The missed opportunities from having that tax taken in the first place do indeed devastate economic prosperity.
The missed opportunities from having that tax taken in the first place do indeed devastate economic prosperity.
Hey, I like this thread. I demand you gimme s'mo'
:-)
http://www.mises.org/ will fill you to the brim, NoDough.
WATTABUNCHA HOOIE!!!
So, this mope seems to think he's got enough functional grey matter to tell Linus and co. what they should be doing in the kernel, but clearly doesn't have enough to comprehend what freedom really is.
First and foremost: Freedom is not a fairy tale concept.
Freedom is accessable and relevant in the real world where real people live, breathe, work, and play. Freedom in the real world has limits built of necessity. In fairy tale land, freedom might mean being able to do whatever you want whenever you want. Everywhere else, reality and the freedom of others intrude.
To the case at hand:
Linus sets the direction for Linux and others follow. Linus has earned his position as the steward of Linux. Love him or loathe him, agree or disagree, Linux was his baby and he's done a fine job of raising it to maturity. If that weren't so, the author wouldn't even have a topic. Nobody would care what Linus thinks or does.
Nobody is preventing development of a microkernel OS. The l4linux folks mentioned in the piece are trying to do exactly that with Linux. Others are free to make their own Linux flavors, just as folks like Andrew Morton and Alan Cox have done in the past (and present). For that matter, nobody is holding back development of the Hurd. Anybody hot for a microkernel OS is free to contribute time there.
The reality is that there are some very good arguments against developing Linux on a microkernel, and speed is only one. Micro-kernels in practice have shown themselves to be more difficult to debug (which, ahem, might explain the Hurd). Also, there is some question of benefit...In theory, the benefit of a microkernel is that failures in one subsystem don't kill the kernel. However, the smaller and safer the kernel, the less it can do, the less it can do, the smaller the benefit of having it up. At what point do the benefits of keeping kernel alive outweigh the penalties in speed and development difficulty?
Etc, etc, etc.
First and foremost: Freedom is not a fairy tale concept.
Freedom is accessable and relevant in the real world where real people live, breathe, work, and play. Freedom in the real world has limits built of necessity. In fairy tale land, freedom might mean being able to do whatever you want whenever you want. Everywhere else, reality and the freedom of others intrude.
To the case at hand:
Linus sets the direction for Linux and others follow. Linus has earned his position as the steward of Linux. Love him or loathe him, agree or disagree, Linux was his baby and he's done a fine job of raising it to maturity. If that weren't so, the author wouldn't even have a topic. Nobody would care what Linus thinks or does.
Nobody is preventing development of a microkernel OS. The l4linux folks mentioned in the piece are trying to do exactly that with Linux. Others are free to make their own Linux flavors, just as folks like Andrew Morton and Alan Cox have done in the past (and present). For that matter, nobody is holding back development of the Hurd. Anybody hot for a microkernel OS is free to contribute time there.
The reality is that there are some very good arguments against developing Linux on a microkernel, and speed is only one. Micro-kernels in practice have shown themselves to be more difficult to debug (which, ahem, might explain the Hurd). Also, there is some question of benefit...In theory, the benefit of a microkernel is that failures in one subsystem don't kill the kernel. However, the smaller and safer the kernel, the less it can do, the less it can do, the smaller the benefit of having it up. At what point do the benefits of keeping kernel alive outweigh the penalties in speed and development difficulty?
Etc, etc, etc.
Every time Linus anounces a debuging cycle, some dork pops up agian with this kind of tripe. As you say dino, if these guys want a microkernel, Hurd has been around forever, even though it has yet to get it's butt up off the deck.
Jimf, I think it's envy. The nasty green-eyed monster.
The folks who just *know* that a micro-kernel is better dislike that a macro-kernel like this "Linux" upstart has gotten all the glory.
My evidence for this is they way they bluster and fuss, but don't simply write a better kernel, a micro-kernel, and blow Linux off the map.
Many "better" products have fallen by the way-side of history because of being beaten by marketing. The first time I saw AmigaDos, I was dumbfounded! Many people simply think their idea was better and that the only reason they were beaten _was_ marketing. That's just ego.
The beauty of a free market is that it tends toward efficiency. Efficiency isn't guaranteed, of course, there will always be back-sliding, like Microsoft Bob.
Truth to tell, I wish I could find a copy of Bob just to say I have one. :^)
The folks who just *know* that a micro-kernel is better dislike that a macro-kernel like this "Linux" upstart has gotten all the glory.
My evidence for this is they way they bluster and fuss, but don't simply write a better kernel, a micro-kernel, and blow Linux off the map.
Many "better" products have fallen by the way-side of history because of being beaten by marketing. The first time I saw AmigaDos, I was dumbfounded! Many people simply think their idea was better and that the only reason they were beaten _was_ marketing. That's just ego.
The beauty of a free market is that it tends toward efficiency. Efficiency isn't guaranteed, of course, there will always be back-sliding, like Microsoft Bob.
Truth to tell, I wish I could find a copy of Bob just to say I have one. :^)
Truth to tell, I wish I could find a copy of Bob just to say I have one. :^)
I understand :D
I understand :D
> My evidence for this is they way they bluster and fuss, but don't simply write a better kernel, a micro-kernel, and blow Linux off the map.
Well, to be fair, there was a microkernel OS which blew the competition away years before Linux came along. Namely OS-9 (no, not the Mac one). Unfortunately, it was an 8 bit OS, and the only readily available desktop systems for it were the Tandy Color Computer line.
Well, to be fair, there was a microkernel OS which blew the competition away years before Linux came along. Namely OS-9 (no, not the Mac one). Unfortunately, it was an 8 bit OS, and the only readily available desktop systems for it were the Tandy Color Computer line.
Oh yeah, an acquaintance of mine had OS-9 on the CoCo, and at the time it was just as astounding as AmigaDos was a few years later. Just like when I saw a small Unix server, with dumb terminals, jumping through hoops at the company where I was putting together PC clones in 1986.
It was just so much more capable than anything we were building, so why aren't we selling those?
It was just so much more capable than anything we were building, so why aren't we selling those?
Bob --
>so why aren't we selling those?
You know the answer to that as well as I do:
I - B - M.
Back then, if you didn't know computers, you still knew Big Blue. If you didn't want to pay the freight for Big Blue boxes, you could still buy something cloned from the "blessed" systems...
>so why aren't we selling those?
You know the answer to that as well as I do:
I - B - M.
Back then, if you didn't know computers, you still knew Big Blue. If you didn't want to pay the freight for Big Blue boxes, you could still buy something cloned from the "blessed" systems...
Not just that. It was *UNIX*! Something incomprehensible, expensive, and most of all didn't have any graphics and games.
Games are what kept me in MS-DOS-compatible machines, games are what kept me going until 1995 when, after having used SunOS at work for 2+ years I finally heard about this "linux" thing. At the same time I took home a pre-release version of Win95, I also created a Linux desktop that did everything that the SunOS SPARC-2 did at work. Same tools, same basic structure, it was very understandable at last.
I still had Win95 for games, the Linux box became a server, which went for 8 years without a crash or "theraputic reboot". It wasn't until 2000 that I went full Linux, and I was thrilled when Savage was released for Linux so I could have some "game" again that wasn't NetHack or web based turn stuff that I was never good at anyway.
Although Microsoft holds the business high-ground because of Office, it's games that rule the home machine. Even my mother uses her machine mostly for Mahjong style games which, of course, were written for Windows.
Games are what kept me in MS-DOS-compatible machines, games are what kept me going until 1995 when, after having used SunOS at work for 2+ years I finally heard about this "linux" thing. At the same time I took home a pre-release version of Win95, I also created a Linux desktop that did everything that the SunOS SPARC-2 did at work. Same tools, same basic structure, it was very understandable at last.
I still had Win95 for games, the Linux box became a server, which went for 8 years without a crash or "theraputic reboot". It wasn't until 2000 that I went full Linux, and I was thrilled when Savage was released for Linux so I could have some "game" again that wasn't NetHack or web based turn stuff that I was never good at anyway.
Although Microsoft holds the business high-ground because of Office, it's games that rule the home machine. Even my mother uses her machine mostly for Mahjong style games which, of course, were written for Windows.
pf, all this micro- vs. macro-kernel silliness is so last millennium anyway. Forward-thinking geeks are solidly behind the kernel architecture of the 21st Century: the Redenbacher kernel architecture. Everything else is obsolete in comparison to the great kernel genius Orville Redenbacher.
I am treating this issue with all the seriousness it deserves.
I am treating this issue with all the seriousness it deserves.
tc -
Mmmmmmmmmm.
Redenbacher kernel(s).
Popped to perfection.
Perfect mate to fried twinkies with cheese.
Wait...hold on...gotta defib.
There. That's better. At least the popcorn is healthy. I'm sure the butter doesn't matter.
Mmmmmmmmmm.
Redenbacher kernel(s).
Popped to perfection.
Perfect mate to fried twinkies with cheese.
Wait...hold on...gotta defib.
There. That's better. At least the popcorn is healthy. I'm sure the butter doesn't matter.
> Everything else is obsolete in comparison to the great kernel genius Orville Redenbacher.
Yes, but that merely shifts the arguments higher up the stack. The flame wars now concern hot air or oil.
Yes, but that merely shifts the arguments higher up the stack. The flame wars now concern hot air or oil.
Aren't most flame wars just hot air anyway?
Bob--
Especially if there's a little oil involved...
Especially if there's a little oil involved...
Author might have lost touch with reality
The author (Luke Kenneth Casson Leighton) needs to take a vacation. Just because he has a hard time using L4Linux, it is not Linus' nor his team of developers responsibility to make L4Linux a mainstream kernel option.
LKCL is quick to lay overburdening responsibilities upon everybody but himself and the L4Linux team. If L4Linux is not usable in day to day fashion, it either means that L4Linux is stillborn or that they did a miserable job of implementing it.
The complaints that mainstream GNU/Linux can't work with the hacked L4Linux toolchain is not a concern of the mainstream GNU/Linux distributions. If LCKL wants a fully functioning L4Linux distribution, he is Free to start one. Get the L4Linux sources, get a modern vanilla distro and make LCKL L4Linux happen.
I have to wonder, since when do you become a monk in the Church of the Greater Good when you give something to somebody else? I better stop giving to fundraisers lest I have to sacrifice my life completely to the whims of the takers of my gifts or else be visited by the Inquisition from the Church of the Greater Good. Better to be a taker myself. You get to be on the nice side of insanity ;)
LKCL is quick to lay overburdening responsibilities upon everybody but himself and the L4Linux team. If L4Linux is not usable in day to day fashion, it either means that L4Linux is stillborn or that they did a miserable job of implementing it.
The complaints that mainstream GNU/Linux can't work with the hacked L4Linux toolchain is not a concern of the mainstream GNU/Linux distributions. If LCKL wants a fully functioning L4Linux distribution, he is Free to start one. Get the L4Linux sources, get a modern vanilla distro and make LCKL L4Linux happen.
I have to wonder, since when do you become a monk in the Church of the Greater Good when you give something to somebody else? I better stop giving to fundraisers lest I have to sacrifice my life completely to the whims of the takers of my gifts or else be visited by the Inquisition from the Church of the Greater Good. Better to be a taker myself. You get to be on the nice side of insanity ;)
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Maybe it's because I read the thing, and the comment by the author (quoted above) following the article, at a weird, wee hour, but I just don't get it. Giving creates a duty to give more? Is the flip-side also true; taking creates a duty to take more?
Bwahaha! Now I understand why there is a CREDITS file in the Linux source. I can contact each and every one of them to remind them of their duty to serve ME forever! Gimme gimme gimme gimme gimme s'mo'!
Hey, author. I don't know you and if I owe you anything, it's a hard way to go. I've given out some bash scripts and php and even helped with a compiled thingy or two. If you happened to stumble on one of them and used it, I still don't owe you jack. Those who have given so much more (you concentrated on the Linux developers, but there's a world of generous free software developers out there) owe you even less.
Read some free software licenses sometime. Your greed doesn't trump license, morality nor logic.