Advanced

Should I Really Care About Linux?

Posted by gsh on · 24 comments
OSWeekly.com; By Brandon Watts
Mail this story
Print this story

When ZDTV (later renamed TechTV, then G4TechTV and finally G4) first broadcasted its signal across the airwaves, I was intrigued by the ongoing enthusiasm that was expressed for a little operating system called Linux. Mention was made of the OS on The Screen Savers, Call for Help, and pretty much every other program on the network.

[Very strange editorial. One try with Red Hat, circa 1998, followed by one try with Mandrake "a few years later", and then this writer dismisses GNU/Linux as not worth the effort: "I haven't installed another distribution of Linux since that time [...]"!

As much as I dislike Microsoft Windows, and despise the consistently unethical behavior of Microsoft, I have at least given each version of MS Windows a chance to show me that it is not as untrustworthy and antagonistic to the user as the previous versions. In each mutation, MS Windows has become less trustworthy and more antagonistic toward the user, even as it became more filled with "features" and eye-candy.

If I followed this author's model, I would be rejecting MS Windows based on experience with MS Windows 3.0 and 3.11. Likewise, I could dismiss Apple based on the shortcomings of the Apple II and Lisa, compared to a commodity PC with Kanotix or SUSE or Debian GNU/Linux today. I just don't understand the purpose of the article. -- grouch]

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial; Groups: GNU, Linux

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (24)

re:Should I really care

2 earlier comments in the full thread.

>We need to convey an empathetic voice toward those users who have the desire to do more with computing.

Maybe that's the problem. Maybe Linux just doesn't make sense for most people.
It doesn't yet it does...

It doesn't make sense for people to want to use something because it's free and because it has no DRM or TC. People don't care about these things (for the most part...if it works, they don't mind being locked in or they don't mind paying money for it). People use things because they work. UI reigns supreme now.

Functions/Features are dead. Apple nailed it with their IPOD as far as design and ease of use are concerned...but they failed to allow people to completely control their entire experience by locking them into their DRM. So now instead of "look my Linux can do XGL and boot from my ThumbDrive" we should be concentrating on "how can we improve what we have to better suit the user experience".

http://linux-blog.org/index.php?/archives/157-Perspective-is... If Linux continues to match Vista and OSX feature for feature, we'll always just be a cloned effort. Instead, doing something truly unique by keeping the end user experience in mind, we could vault Linux to the forefront the way the IPOD has done for music players.
>If Linux continues to match Vista and OSX feature for feature, we'll always just be a cloned effort. Instead, doing something truly unique by keeping the end user experience in mind, we could vault Linux to the forefront the way the IPOD has done for music players.

Which is a tricky thing to do when you're talking computers, but hey...
I think you fine lxer persons are confusing a number of issues. The core issue is what is the Linux/FOSS target user? The common assumption is "Linux needs to be designed to appeal to the masses." If that's the case, then yes, bring on the binary blobs, the closed codecs, the "open source" DRM. Because it's going to continue be a struggle to get hardware vendors to support Linux and other non-windoze platforms.

On the other hand, if Free Software is meant to deliver maximum freedoms to users and developers, to protect the hard work of developers, to continue to supply first-rate power tools to power users, system administrators, and network admins, and to keep the available Free Software code pool wide and deep, none of those nasty things need apply.

Yeah, I know certain persons are going to quibble and claim that Free Software is only about freedom, and if that means putting up with crappy, buggy, inadequate software, well hey that's OK. I don't agree with that at all. Remember, legend has it that Saint RMS started on his path when he was confronted with crappy proprietary printer code that he could not fix, and the vendor refused to fix. He already had cruddy software; he didn't need to start a revolution to insure a steady supply.
Quoting:If Linux continues to match Vista and OSX feature for feature, we'll always just be a cloned effort. Instead, doing something truly unique by keeping the end user experience in mind, we could vault Linux to the forefront the way the IPOD has done for music players.


There are efforts in that direction, such as the KDE 4 Plasma interface. Alot could come out of it.

GNOME is already quite user friendly in terms of usability (hiding the rest of the less important clutter of features).

As for motivations for trying GNU/Linux they can be either technical or "ideological", that is the freedom. And I'm not necessarily talking about switching to GNU/Linux because of suddenly discovered belief that all software should be free, but being chased away by an increasinly obvious imposition of control over proprietary OS's in form of TC and DRM.

In other words, the second motivation is realization that, indeed, they are loosing freedom and need something where they can have it again: GNU/Linux.

Ultimately I believe that second point should be even more propagated than the first point (technical reasons) because the second point is going to matter more and more to users as the industry tightens its control forces.

tuxchick -

Well, that is the old question: Should it be for an elite clique, or for a broader audience.

Frankly, I would be very sad to discover that I am insufficiently elite to use Linux. I seriously dislike Windows. Don't want to live there.

But...

I see no point in having computers I can't use to do the things I want to do. I didn't buy them to look good in the office (which is why they don't!!).

So...

I want everything to be free. In the absence of free, I will take available and works well at a price I can live with.
tuxchick2:

Quoting:Remember, legend has it that Saint RMS started on his path when he was confronted with crappy proprietary printer code that he could not fix, and the vendor refused to fix. He already had cruddy software; he didn't need to start a revolution to insure a steady supply.


No he didn't start a revolution to ensure a steady supply of cruddy software, of course. He didn't start a revolution to ensure a steady supply of brilliant high quality code either. ;)

He started it because he wanted to ensure a steady state of freedom, so that he can have the right to ensure better software. Freedom is first, and quality is only the consequence of having it.
> and quality is only the consequence of having it.

Or so we hope.
dino, I take your meaning, though I quibble a bit with 'elite clique.' I don't feel particularly leet, nor do most of my customers that I've managed to move to nice Linux boxen over the years. They want to get their work done, and they don't want to be jerked around by vendors. It actually seems pretty simple, but of course the real world has this astonishing inability to see things in the same steady, clear-eyed fashion as me. :)

Libervis, while ensuring code quality is not explicit, it is strongly implicit in freedoms 1,2, and 3:

- The freedom to study how the program works, and adapt it to your needs (freedom 1) - The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor (freedom 2) - The freedom to improve the program, and release your improvements to the public, so that the whole community benefits (freedom 3)

Yes, but the freedom is an apparent prerequisite. That's all I'm saying, freedom is the first goal and the most important one, as everything else hinges on it.
T & L :

Yes, can you imagine how awful it would be if, say, you had a robot garage loader and your software stopped working and you didn't have the source code so you couldn't get it going again?

Of course, nobody would let themselves get in that position, would they?
Libervis, I'll agree with that.
dino repeats the question: "Why should non-techies care, especially non-techies who feel no special hatred towards Microsoft?"

If you have been following along here at LXer, you will know the answer...

If they don't care, all of their cars will be trapped by giant, unlicensed robo-garages.

So use open source, or bow down to your new, unlicensed, robo-garage overlords.
The scariest part of this is their 'solution' is the lack of one. This is the most compelling case for open source I've seen in a long time, but, once again, government hasn't learned anything.
jimf -

No kidding. Why isn't the Yo-Yo (with apologies to Duncan and friends of Duncan) who inked that deal made to stand in the main town square wearing stocks? Better yet, locked into the Robo-Garage naked with and covered in honey with fire-ants nearby?
Lol, just lock him in a car in the garage next time the system fails...
dinotrac: >Quoted: "a lot of people just don't see a need to really care about what's going on in the Penguin Land. Everyday users just go with the majority, and it would take some drastic changes for most people to seriously consider using Linux"

>"I disagree with you grouch."

You fail to attribute the quoted statements. This plus your statement following the quote makes it appear that you are quoting me. To set the record straight, I did not make the statements you quote.
grouch:

Sorry. I was quoting the original article.
Quoting:The core issue is what is the Linux/FOSS target user? The common assumption is "Linux needs to be designed to appeal to the masses." If that's the case, then yes, bring on the binary blobs, the closed codecs, the "open source" DRM. Because it's going to continue be a struggle to get hardware vendors to support Linux and other non-windoze platforms.


As stated in my lil ditty up there... It doesn't need to appeal to the masses. It needs to be usable to the nth degree. Mass appeal would be a byproduct of this. Linux will succeed no matter what happens because it already is a success. To appeal more to everyone or to anyone it needs to become the most usable operating system on the planet. Through trial and error I feel we'll get there...eventually. We'd get there a lot sooner if programmers and application designers would keep usability in the forefront of the mind while creating programs.
Stories and threads like this really get my goad.

Linux is failing to penetrate the market of the masses! Oh no! What ever shall we do!?

Puh-lease! Can anyone else show my an OS that has achieved double-digit growth year over year for its entire existence? I don't think so.

If this is failure, then three cheers for failure.

On the thinking of cats...

“The cat, having sat upon a hot stove lid, will not sit upon a hot stove lid again. But he won't sit upon a cold stove lid, either.” --Mark Twain
Burned once, burned forever? Oh you poor humans, so vulnerable.

;)

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post