Exclusive Q&A: Linus Torvalds
|
|
|
Comments (32)
12 earlier comments in the full thread.
It's scary that you can even do that parody Deb :)
Being spoon-fed images and emotions? I wuz watchin' that new movie by Al Gore, and from what I wuz seeing, its only because of the global warming that people are so dumb. So I guess like, I so way agree with you dood. I think it was yesterday when one of my girls said, "Like, have you seen the new Ima Stoner Video? I said, Like, yeah. It's totally awesome. And then we went to the mall and looked at some shoes then checked some Sk8R boyz out then went to my howz and watched Big Brother.
My husband came home and fruited up everything. Like, if he doesn't zone on the newz at least three timez a day, he's like, I dunno, having a cow over some doods killing some other doods in Greenland or somewhere. I dunno if thats the exact place, but its one of those totally hot places. Like, why don't they just balance their diets and quite smoking so much? I shur wish Billy Carter wuz still the Prez. At least he didn't let those Egyptians push us around like they crack on Prezident, uh, president, I can't remember his name but he'z the bald guy that used to own Enron I think.
Gotta go down to Starbucks, my girlz are meeting me there for a Sidney Sheecan Rally.
Luvs...
Deb
My husband came home and fruited up everything. Like, if he doesn't zone on the newz at least three timez a day, he's like, I dunno, having a cow over some doods killing some other doods in Greenland or somewhere. I dunno if thats the exact place, but its one of those totally hot places. Like, why don't they just balance their diets and quite smoking so much? I shur wish Billy Carter wuz still the Prez. At least he didn't let those Egyptians push us around like they crack on Prezident, uh, president, I can't remember his name but he'z the bald guy that used to own Enron I think.
Gotta go down to Starbucks, my girlz are meeting me there for a Sidney Sheecan Rally.
Luvs...
Deb
Jimf,
Yeah, that would be right. My criticism towards Linus is not so much about him spreading any FUD in that interview, as he did say some good things, such as about software patents threat. It's for his definition of Free Software as just a superior development methodology which I don't think it is and I don't think people should percieve it that way. But then again, what do I expect from Linus? He's admitted being apolitical (no matter how much I doubt that is even possible and of course no matter how much I think that's equivalent to seeing only parts of the picture rather than whole).
And also I think some of those religion related remarks are partly fueled by his past talks, especially those "kind" words directed at the FSF.
I'm calmed down about this though, if you will. Getting all too worked up wont help it. I'll better be trying to respond rationally to whatever next thing he says or point he makes than go balistic. ;)
Bob_Robertson,
Interesting point. However, we should then be trying to help him understand instead of just confirming his view of it as "religion".
He may not be the originator of FUD he may be spreading, due to his misunderstanding, but he still does spread (relay) it nonetheless.
Quoting:Well, essentially you're right. but remember that the preface to the interview is the interviewers spin and not anything that Linus said in the interview. So it's this 'P Ganapati' that's full of it, and is trying to put words in Linus's mouth.
Yeah, that would be right. My criticism towards Linus is not so much about him spreading any FUD in that interview, as he did say some good things, such as about software patents threat. It's for his definition of Free Software as just a superior development methodology which I don't think it is and I don't think people should percieve it that way. But then again, what do I expect from Linus? He's admitted being apolitical (no matter how much I doubt that is even possible and of course no matter how much I think that's equivalent to seeing only parts of the picture rather than whole).
And also I think some of those religion related remarks are partly fueled by his past talks, especially those "kind" words directed at the FSF.
I'm calmed down about this though, if you will. Getting all too worked up wont help it. I'll better be trying to respond rationally to whatever next thing he says or point he makes than go balistic. ;)
Bob_Robertson,
Quoting:The journalist isn't so much spreading fud as he is demonstrating his own tendency to ascribe to religion anything he doesn't already understand.
Interesting point. However, we should then be trying to help him understand instead of just confirming his view of it as "religion".
He may not be the originator of FUD he may be spreading, due to his misunderstanding, but he still does spread (relay) it nonetheless.
>He may not be the originator of FUD he may be spreading, due to his misunderstanding, but he still does spread (relay) it nonetheless.
Journalists originate their fair share of FUD in this world, even when just passing on the "facts".
How this works is best seen in a jury trial. Both sides have the same facts to work with, but present opposite cases based on their selection and connection of the facts. Journalists are far more than mere relays. Like lawyers, they color everything they do by selection and presentation.
Journalists originate their fair share of FUD in this world, even when just passing on the "facts".
How this works is best seen in a jury trial. Both sides have the same facts to work with, but present opposite cases based on their selection and connection of the facts. Journalists are far more than mere relays. Like lawyers, they color everything they do by selection and presentation.
> Journalists originate their fair share of FUD in this world, even when just passing on the "facts".
And lest we think this is some kind of new age phenomenon, one has only to look back to the yellow journalism in the 19th and even 18th centuries. It's usually even worse than this guys.
And lest we think this is some kind of new age phenomenon, one has only to look back to the yellow journalism in the 19th and even 18th centuries. It's usually even worse than this guys.
jimf --
I think what's changed is not so much journalism, but journalists estimation of themselves.
They are believing their own PR these days.
Can anyone whip up a head of righteous indignation faster than a journo whose reporting you question?
I think what's changed is not so much journalism, but journalists estimation of themselves.
They are believing their own PR these days.
Can anyone whip up a head of righteous indignation faster than a journo whose reporting you question?
> Can anyone whip up a head of righteous indignation faster than a journo whose reporting you question?
Hmmm. A federal official accused of an ethics violation? No. A WV official accused of accepting bribes and/or vote buying? No. A prominent minister accused of infidelity? No. A prominent corporation accused of accounting irregularities? No. An LXer editor accused of intellectual dishonesty? Well, maybe :).
I'd say you're right. All the others seem to have a much more realistic assessment of themselves.
Hmmm. A federal official accused of an ethics violation? No. A WV official accused of accepting bribes and/or vote buying? No. A prominent minister accused of infidelity? No. A prominent corporation accused of accounting irregularities? No. An LXer editor accused of intellectual dishonesty? Well, maybe :).
I'd say you're right. All the others seem to have a much more realistic assessment of themselves.
> I think what's changed is not so much journalism, but journalists estimation of themselves.
It used to be that the bias of a particular news source was recognized, known and dealt with. The Post City Democrat would not be kind to Republicans, for example.
As long as everyone, even the paper, admitted it, there wasn't so much FUD because the bias could be worked out of it.
Now, there is this absurd expectation of "neutrality", of "fairness". A schooled (spit!) Journalist may very well believe that they are being fair just because that is what they have been _taught_ is fair.
John R. Lott's second book, _The Bias Against Guns_, cites many cases where firearms accidents and people killed by being shot made headlines not just where they occurred, but across the country, while a far greater number of deaths due to accidental drowning or murder with a baseball bat didn't even make the front page of the local paper.
...Because they are so _RARE_, while other kinds of accidents and deaths are much more common and therefore don't sell papers.
So the impression of readers is that there is some kind of flurry of firearms-related events, when there is no such thing (except in Washington DC).
I don't mind if you want to disagree with the subject, I know firearms aren't for everyone. It is this effect of journalists asserting their own bias while endlessly proclaiming their "fair and balanced" coverage that I want to make clear, and firearms are one of the most egregiously abused things in so-called "news" stories.
It used to be that the bias of a particular news source was recognized, known and dealt with. The Post City Democrat would not be kind to Republicans, for example.
As long as everyone, even the paper, admitted it, there wasn't so much FUD because the bias could be worked out of it.
Now, there is this absurd expectation of "neutrality", of "fairness". A schooled (spit!) Journalist may very well believe that they are being fair just because that is what they have been _taught_ is fair.
John R. Lott's second book, _The Bias Against Guns_, cites many cases where firearms accidents and people killed by being shot made headlines not just where they occurred, but across the country, while a far greater number of deaths due to accidental drowning or murder with a baseball bat didn't even make the front page of the local paper.
...Because they are so _RARE_, while other kinds of accidents and deaths are much more common and therefore don't sell papers.
So the impression of readers is that there is some kind of flurry of firearms-related events, when there is no such thing (except in Washington DC).
I don't mind if you want to disagree with the subject, I know firearms aren't for everyone. It is this effect of journalists asserting their own bias while endlessly proclaiming their "fair and balanced" coverage that I want to make clear, and firearms are one of the most egregiously abused things in so-called "news" stories.
>Now, there is this absurd expectation of "neutrality", of "fairness". A schooled (spit!) Journalist may very well believe that they are being fair just because that is what they have been _taught_ is fair.<
I couldn't agree more, what comes to mind first for me is the FOX News tag line "Fair and Balanced"..my ass! They might as well be BUSH News for as "Balanced" as they are.
Journalism students are taught how to get published, not how to observe and record impartially. But lets be honest, no one is impartial. Its not possible. It is hard to be enthralled by a writer that is not in some way emotionally involved with the subject matter.
Whether or not you agree with the writer, emotional writing is usually a good read.
I couldn't agree more, what comes to mind first for me is the FOX News tag line "Fair and Balanced"..my ass! They might as well be BUSH News for as "Balanced" as they are.
Journalism students are taught how to get published, not how to observe and record impartially. But lets be honest, no one is impartial. Its not possible. It is hard to be enthralled by a writer that is not in some way emotionally involved with the subject matter.
Whether or not you agree with the writer, emotional writing is usually a good read.
Scott -
But everyone knows where Fox news comes from, and I don't see them denying it very seriously.
Compare that to the spasms of "NO NO NO NO you stupid person -- you just think I'm biased because you're a dim-witted ordinary person who doesn't know diddly about journalism, how it works, and why you should kiss my feet" you get from most other news feeds.
But everyone knows where Fox news comes from, and I don't see them denying it very seriously.
Compare that to the spasms of "NO NO NO NO you stupid person -- you just think I'm biased because you're a dim-witted ordinary person who doesn't know diddly about journalism, how it works, and why you should kiss my feet" you get from most other news feeds.
dino,
anyone in this society with an ounce of intelegence learns to read between the lines early on. Consider the source is a must.
anyone in this society with an ounce of intelegence learns to read between the lines early on. Consider the source is a must.
Your both right, the problem is that most people are entertained by Drama and that's most of what passes for news and journalism.
Real News Informs, Real Journalism Reveals. That's my opinion. :-)
Real News Informs, Real Journalism Reveals. That's my opinion. :-)
> Real News Informs, Real Journalism Reveals. That's my opinion. :-)
Well, that's the ideal. In fact, there is little real news any more. Mostly just heavily biased commentary that passes for Journalism.
Well, that's the ideal. In fact, there is little real news any more. Mostly just heavily biased commentary that passes for Journalism.
jimf & Scott -
I'm actually optimistic about the state of journalism today, which, I guess, is bucking the conventional wisdom.
Two big reasons:
1. A decline in traditional media.
Competition and fragmentation have taken a toll on the newspapers, networks, etc that have provided our news. While bad in terms of cutting resources, it's good in puncturing the balloon. BTW -- I include cable news in traditional media even though it is a relatively recent arrival -- gaining traction just over 25 years ago with the Iran hostage crisis. CNN sprang from a traditional media mindset, traditional media sources, power,etc. Only the use of a coaxial cable and the ability to be on all the time made it different. Others may argue, and it certainly is no slam-dunk.
2. The rise of Fox and non-traditional media.
I put Fox in the camp of traditional media because, though a late-arrival, it is more like the other cable news networks than anything else. I think it operates in much the same way as the other traditional news organizations. The only difference is that the people who put on the news have conservative views whereas the people who run the others have liberal views. Fox may even have higher standards of fairness, given that it is a natural target for those "other" news organizations.
3. Blogs, baby!
Whether it's bringing down Dan Rather, highlighting plagiarism, or the recent expose of photoshopped and other faked photos coming from Lebanon, bloggers have made it riskier for journalists to lie.
My favorite example of that didn't even require bloggers to leap into action -- their mere existence was sufficient.
I am speaking of a Molly Ivins column in which she made the statement that the American Invasion of Iraq had killed more Iraqi civilians than Saddam. She retracted the statement very shortly after it appeared. She treated it as a simple error on her part, but I believe she realized that bloggers would rip her to shreds and she moved to head them off at the pass. Why? If she hadn't retracted the statement, somebody would point out that a reporter with here liberal credentials would know a thing or three about Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, both of which kept a pretty decent tab on Saddam's atrocities. That realization would show her "mistake" to be a lie. Not good for credibility or future opportunities.
I'm actually optimistic about the state of journalism today, which, I guess, is bucking the conventional wisdom.
Two big reasons:
1. A decline in traditional media.
Competition and fragmentation have taken a toll on the newspapers, networks, etc that have provided our news. While bad in terms of cutting resources, it's good in puncturing the balloon. BTW -- I include cable news in traditional media even though it is a relatively recent arrival -- gaining traction just over 25 years ago with the Iran hostage crisis. CNN sprang from a traditional media mindset, traditional media sources, power,etc. Only the use of a coaxial cable and the ability to be on all the time made it different. Others may argue, and it certainly is no slam-dunk.
2. The rise of Fox and non-traditional media.
I put Fox in the camp of traditional media because, though a late-arrival, it is more like the other cable news networks than anything else. I think it operates in much the same way as the other traditional news organizations. The only difference is that the people who put on the news have conservative views whereas the people who run the others have liberal views. Fox may even have higher standards of fairness, given that it is a natural target for those "other" news organizations.
3. Blogs, baby!
Whether it's bringing down Dan Rather, highlighting plagiarism, or the recent expose of photoshopped and other faked photos coming from Lebanon, bloggers have made it riskier for journalists to lie.
My favorite example of that didn't even require bloggers to leap into action -- their mere existence was sufficient.
I am speaking of a Molly Ivins column in which she made the statement that the American Invasion of Iraq had killed more Iraqi civilians than Saddam. She retracted the statement very shortly after it appeared. She treated it as a simple error on her part, but I believe she realized that bloggers would rip her to shreds and she moved to head them off at the pass. Why? If she hadn't retracted the statement, somebody would point out that a reporter with here liberal credentials would know a thing or three about Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, both of which kept a pretty decent tab on Saddam's atrocities. That realization would show her "mistake" to be a lie. Not good for credibility or future opportunities.
> Two big reasons:
Ahh, that's actually three dino :)
> 1. A decline in traditional media.
I'd also argue that the level of traditional journalism and of journalists as well as their integrity declined exponentially as the type of media changed and 'News' began to be valued only for its entertainment value. No more Murrow's, no more Cronkite's...
> 2. The rise of Fox and non-traditional media.
Fox was never 'fair and balanced', though, it may have tried to be early on. Now, it's just a wholly owned subsidiary. It's disturbing that you would believe otherwise dino.
> 3. Blogs, baby!
This is a very mixed bag...
The up side is that there are many very fine Writers and Journalists who now get heard. It's also amazing the quality and quantity of information that we now have available to us. But...
The down side is that 'any ass' can ( and does) have his own Blog, so, the overall quality of information is abysmal, and the level of disinformation is appalling. Blogs 'can' expose untruths, but, they can just as easily perpetuate popular myths and lies. The old programming adage 'garbage in, garbage out'.
Ahh, that's actually three dino :)
> 1. A decline in traditional media.
I'd also argue that the level of traditional journalism and of journalists as well as their integrity declined exponentially as the type of media changed and 'News' began to be valued only for its entertainment value. No more Murrow's, no more Cronkite's...
> 2. The rise of Fox and non-traditional media.
Fox was never 'fair and balanced', though, it may have tried to be early on. Now, it's just a wholly owned subsidiary. It's disturbing that you would believe otherwise dino.
> 3. Blogs, baby!
This is a very mixed bag...
The up side is that there are many very fine Writers and Journalists who now get heard. It's also amazing the quality and quantity of information that we now have available to us. But...
The down side is that 'any ass' can ( and does) have his own Blog, so, the overall quality of information is abysmal, and the level of disinformation is appalling. Blogs 'can' expose untruths, but, they can just as easily perpetuate popular myths and lies. The old programming adage 'garbage in, garbage out'.
jimf -
GIGO rules!
The big win is independent quality control on the folks who used to control the flow of information. Lots of s**t out in blogland, but, if you're a journalist, you face the same problem the DHS (in the US) faces in fighting terrorists:
They've got to be right everytime, the bloggers (or terrorists) only have to break through now and then. A career can be ruined by getting caught once.
GIGO rules!
The big win is independent quality control on the folks who used to control the flow of information. Lots of s**t out in blogland, but, if you're a journalist, you face the same problem the DHS (in the US) faces in fighting terrorists:
They've got to be right everytime, the bloggers (or terrorists) only have to break through now and then. A career can be ruined by getting caught once.
> A career can be ruined by getting caught once
And 'everyone' screws up at least once.
And 'everyone' screws up at least once.
So in essence, what it really comes down to is if the person doing the reporting or writing is worth reading. Whether or not you feel that they are giving you the truth as they see it.
I can forgive someone for getting something wrong if they did not have all the facts, or the facts change. I am guilty of that as we all are.
But to be intentionally lied too and expect to take anything they say seriously after that, No. Sure it takes time to figure it sometimes but once you do, you can never go back to believing them again.
I can forgive someone for getting something wrong if they did not have all the facts, or the facts change. I am guilty of that as we all are.
But to be intentionally lied too and expect to take anything they say seriously after that, No. Sure it takes time to figure it sometimes but once you do, you can never go back to believing them again.
I will never be a still target for the label of "biased". My beliefs, loyalties and goals are well stated by most anything I have written to this point. As well, a to-the-point question as to my "politics" will give you a direct, honest answer. Bias is only present when the presenter hides or distorts his direction, motive and feelings concerning the topic.
I finished school late in life and had the privilege of attending ASU for my final semester. I took some BS classes (pun fully intended even if none was perceived) and one of them was journalism 101. The first thing Dr. Latts asked: "How many of you are entering this field so you can make a difference?"
more than half the hands in the class raised.
"Good!" he said, I knew there was a problem when I walked in. There are too many people here. The School of Social Work is two blocks away. You can "make a difference" there. Here I am going to teach you how to recognize, gather and report the news...not your opinion of it.
It is painfully obvious way too many journalists did not attend Dr. Latt's classes.
I finished school late in life and had the privilege of attending ASU for my final semester. I took some BS classes (pun fully intended even if none was perceived) and one of them was journalism 101. The first thing Dr. Latts asked: "How many of you are entering this field so you can make a difference?"
more than half the hands in the class raised.
"Good!" he said, I knew there was a problem when I walked in. There are too many people here. The School of Social Work is two blocks away. You can "make a difference" there. Here I am going to teach you how to recognize, gather and report the news...not your opinion of it.
It is painfully obvious way too many journalists did not attend Dr. Latt's classes.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

My husband came home and fruited up everything. Like, if he doesn't zone on the newz at least three timez a day, he's like, I dunno, having a cow over some doods killing some other doods in Greenland or somewhere. I dunno if thats the exact place, but its one of those totally hot places. Like, why don't they just balance their diets and quite smoking so much? I shur wish Billy Carter wuz still the Prez. At least he didn't let those Egyptians push us around like they crack on Prezident Delay.
Gotta go down to Starbucks, my girlz are meeting me there for a Sidney Sheecan Rally.
Luvs...
Deb