A fifteenth chance for GNOME
|
|
|
Comments (31)
11 earlier comments in the full thread.
I'd like to know where you get that????????
I prefer the elegant simplicity of Gnome over the gnarish Gnightmare that KDE presents. Sure, there are things that can be improved but, on the whole, I Much Prefer what I'm looking at now!! KDE strikes me as being a kludgy combination of Windows and Gnome together!
I suppose, though as you say later, "Again, the point is that one man's 'elegance' is another's nightmare.", the personal choice and aesthetics of every user must be respected and, in this mode, GNU/LInux is far superior to anything else out there today!
Don K.
On the other hand, I find nothing elegant and a lot of disfunctionality in Gnome's design. But, that's just the opinion of this old Controls Engineer and Graphics Designer. Use what you want.
:) What can I say, I like my screen space (and it saves my cpu for more important things, like firefox tabs and the 10+ other apps I have running at all times....).
As for gnome/kde, I've used both now and then through the years. I was always slightly more partial to gnome cuz I thought it looked a little cleaner, but both take up too much screen space for my taste with stuff I'd never use.
But then, as we say often, it's all about choice.
It's the 'hug' part that's creepy :D
The ultimate personification... I'm not even going to touch that one :D
Seriously, the one big negative to all this rivalry is that no one can rationally discuss what a logical and (somewhat) universal interface could be. the personification of our chosen GUI makes the evaluation and recognition of superior design elements in other GUIs, or even our own, difficult if not impossible. To a greater extent, we go with what we first learn, and what works for us, without thinking how it could be 'improved'.
There is also the thought that even if a 'universal' interface is possible, only noobs and business's would want it. Most experienced users would reject, or modify immediately.
Very true. Some of us just can't resist the urge to tweak/replace/etc. our interfaces. Whereas your average user just happily uses what they learn first and gets lost if you change it. And of course as you mention the business end. I would think a business or a location where multiple people have to share computers (schools/colleges/etc.) would use a single interface to keep everything uniform and cut down on headaches for the IT staff cuz Bob sits down at the comp that Joe usually uses and "can't" work because the interface is a little different(ignoring per-user profiles and such like that that might get around the issue).
At least several of our servers are linux.
(I'm sorry this post is way late and out of order.)
I saw it, ok, just decided to ignore it so I could insult KDE a little bit! ;-)
Seriously, aren't you glad you have a choice? Don't you wish every one did?
ewwwwhhh, I got flux all over me now, Dude!
PCLinuxOS just accomplished what I had come to enjoy in Mepis and a few others. Want a gnome app? just app get the little troll and there he is. I like banshee and the gnome search tool (gnome-utils) and a few other offerings while running in KDE. best of both worlds is...well the best of both worlds. However, when Im on an "in and out" mission, it's Ice baby Ice all the way...
no nonsense, no clutter (I get distracted with all the pretty sparklies) just get it done and get gone.
The gnome mixing with KDE IS cool though. Texstar belts another one into the Crawford Boxes.
Look. Everyday I boot to init 3 so I keep my network functionality. Then, using GNU/Linux' built-in, powerful virtualization technology, I load EMACS. (And people think VMWare is cool!) From there, I have instant access to e-mail, calendar, tasklist, newsgroups and web, not to mention my IDE/office suite combo - all at the tap of a simple keyboard shortcut like this:
^+shift+o+O+w+[F5]+ex
O.k., so it's a memory hog, compared to that *other* cheesy little postcardware program. Still beats KDE and GNOME hands down! :-D
Wow Don, I just know that won over a whole mob of noobs to EMACS :)
Back when the PC came out, nobody thought there would be very many ordinary users -- the market was projected at a quarter million or so units. Projection was wrong.
Later, when designing a "home" PC, IBM figured a stripped down and cute little thing with a funky (but wireless) keyboard was just the ticket. They were wrong.
Look around at what a lot of ordinary users are doing. They're editing their pictures and videos on their computers, making newsletters, doing lots of things nobody ever figured an "ordinary" user would want to do.
I'm highly skeptical of a such a thing as a universal interface. I have no doubt that some elements will be common and useful to all, but look at that crowd of ordinary users. They are old, young, colorblind, near-sighted, eagle-eyed, patient, ADD, left-handed, right-handed, one-handed (in some cases, no-handed), American, Asian, highly educated, barely literate, etc, etc, etc.
It's hard for me to believe that a computer -- with its fantastic ability to morph into whatever you may need it to be -- best serves all of those people with a single interface. Even books, which are far more constrained than computers, do better than that. Books come in regular print, large print, braille, annotated versions, illustrated versions, pop-up books, etc. They even come on tape.
I suspect that extent to which ordinary users leave their interfaces alone is a matter of not knowing enough to seriously mess with them, it not being easy enough (which includes being easily reversed if an experiment turns out unsatisfying), and there not being sufficiently useful options available to be worth the effort.
I tried emacs once, but my computer lost all of its vim and vigor, so I gave it up. :)
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Absolutely.
Whether or not you agree with any particular GUI interface design, the diversity of interfaces in linux should be regarded as one of its strengths, something to be celebrated, not fought over. You certainly don't get that kind of choice in Windows.
As I've noted before, even though I much prefer the KDE primary interface, I really like many of the GTK apps, so, I too benefit from having more than one type of development in Linux.
Sal, I do find it odd that GTK app designers can come up with clean, logical, and functional interfaces, while Gnome itself is such mess :D
Again, the point is that one man's 'elegance' is another's nightmare.
> *hugs fluxbox*
But that's just 'wrong'! :D