Advanced

Linspire frees "Click 'N Run" software service

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 41 comments
DesktopLinux.com
Mail this story
Print this story

In a surprise move, Linspire is now offering its CNR ("Click 'N Run") software service at no charge to its Linspire and Freespire Linux distribution customers. In addition, the company will soon be open-sourcing the CNR Client. CNR, previously a fee-based service offered at annual subscription rates of $20 for basic and $50 for premium ("Gold") access to new programs, had been the San Diego-based company main source of income.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Linspire, Linux; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (41)

surprise move?

I don't know why this comes as a surprise to so many people. linspire announced all this earlier in the year when they made their press releases about freespire.
--- le boborooster entree

This person attended LW in SF and received too many copies of Freespire. Verily, piles of these CDs were easily available to all attendees. At LWSF, there were competitors to Freespire present, and this free CNR comes as little surprise to many of us there. Competitors present included K/Ubuntu, Novell's SLED (and OpenSUSE), Fedora, the Debian booth in the corner, FreeBSD near Debian, Xandros ... etc. The Linspire/Freespire team had a room all too itself at LWSF and this fact was promoted to attendees via the CD-handouts and the raffles announced on the Expo floor.

Perhaps remaining objections to Linspire can be summarized as follows:

1. Linspire/Freespire includes binaries not under the GPL. See other more extensive (and passionate) LXer comments on this subject elsewhere other than in this response.

2. Linspire/Freespire's current decision to provide free its CNR service is suspicious, and its not doing so before indicates that apologies are certainly due.

It seems to moi that Linspire/Freespire almost HAD to offer free CNR service regardless of free updates also available via apt-get or similar open source packages. Linspire and Freespire are currently ranked 30th and 37th respectively on the DistroWatch.com site. These ranking are well below that of the other distros listed above, for those who use such rankings as measurements of a distro's success. Its now-free CNR service can possibly help it climb the rankings and possibly surpass Xandros, the latter which still charges $$$ for packaged versions other than its 30-day demo.

Likely that Linspire too will continue to charge its fee for CD/DVD media, packaging, manuals and continued full support for its core Linspire product. OTOH, Freespire is to remain a completely libre distro available by download and supported by online community offerings similar to Debian, OpenSUSE and FC.

--- So says le boborooster, and not le Donald. Firez-vous away!
good post boborooster. A couple of extra points:

- I'm happy that with Freespire there is one more "libre" GNU/Linux distro out there.

- I'm not happy that linspire is doing that. I don't like their business model. I don't like that made a deal with microsoft. I do not trust them. Imho they just use freespire to lure users into their "non-free" linspire business model.

- I'm not happy that freespire simply ignores certain licensing issues with non-free software, like nvidia/ati drivers etc. Their approach is to ignore these issues, using the excuse of trying to make "the customers happy". This way, we'll never convince ati/nvidia and the likes to provide Free Software drivers (or alternatively, documentation that enables others to write these drivers) for their products.

Apologies are in order

18 earlier comments in the full thread.

> would like to make clear that I don't see a problem with Linspire charging a fee. I can even see a subscription based update service.

> What I do have a problem with is their inclusion of non-free codecs - their "compromise your freedom" mentality.

Well, we'll just have to disagree.

I don't have a problem with them charging a fee for access to their commercial packages or Linspire specific packages. However, the unmodified or only slightly modified Debian packages should have been provided as a free or very low cost service. Lumping everything together into on rather expensive service wasn't the right way to do things.

As to the non-free aspects of their distrbution, that doesn't bother me. The fact that I have no interest in such a system doesn't mean that there aren't those for whom it's a perfect fit, and I have no problem with Linspire servicing that market.
Quoting:How about thanks and congratulations for doing the right thing?


If somebody does something wrong and you yell at them so they stop doing it, should they be thanked and congratulated? In that situation, if I do either of those things, it's generally with a degree of sarcasm.
> If somebody does something wrong and you yell at them so they stop doing it, should they be thanked and congratulated?

Well, it depends on how serious the something wrong is. The things Linspire was doing were more of an annoyance than a hazard. It's not like they were hurting people. So, while I don't think they should be congratulated, a simple thank you might be appropriate. Sort of like thanking your neighbor for turning down his stereo when it was bothering you.
Quoting:Sort of like thanking your neighbor for turning down his stereo when it was bothering you.


Hmm. Yeah, I never do that. If it's bad enough that I have to complain, I might say, "THANK YOU!" as in "AND DON'T DO IT AGAIN!"

I would agree thought that it is that kind of offense.
jdixon and SFN -

There is a difference.

You are comparing the case of somebody who was doing NOTHING WRONG -- ie, producing Linspire, with somebody who is doing something clearly wrong.

How about a different comparison...

As a Christian, I have no right whatsoever to complain if you choose to be Moslem, Buddhist, Hindu, or atheist.

I can believe that you are wrong and that you will suffer for your wrong-headedness, but that doesn't matter. In any civil sense, you are free to pursue your belief/non-belief. You break no laws, you don't violate my space (and, by the way, the loud stereo is actually a form of trespassing). If I am upset at you for your beliefs, it is my problem -- not yours. That's between you and your god or empty void.

Should you see the light and be saved, however, I would be thoroughly justified in offering you congratulations.

The Linspire folks have made a step in the right direction. They were doing nothing wrong. Your upset is your own problem. It is fully appropriate to thank them for climbing on board and to congratulate them for another foot in with the good guys (they already had one foot in with nvu and some other stuff).

To do otherwise is just peevish.
SFN:

> Yeah, I never do that.

I think this falls into the "you catch more flies with honey than vinegar" category.
Quoting:I think this falls into the "you catch more flies with honey than vinegar" category.
Well, flies just aren't my bag. People either, for that matter.

Quoting:Should you see the light and be saved, however, I would be thoroughly justified in offering you congratulations.
Sure but you wouldn't be justified in saying that I should congratulate someone because you believe they have seen the light.
>Sure but you wouldn't be justified in saying that I should congratulate someone because you believe they have seen the light.

Agree completely. And, if you don't believe that Linspire has changed in any significant way or moved toward the light, etc, you would be justified in your position.

I may simply have misread you...I got the impression you were unhappy with their past behavior and would withhold congratulations on the basis that they are now where they should have been all along.
Quoting:I may simply have misread you...I got the impression you were unhappy with their past behavior and would withhold congratulations on the basis that they are now where they should have been all along.


No, that's right. I would do that. I can't get behind congratulating them for doing what they should have done all along after much pressure from others.

The issue here has to do with the original intent of the post. The whole "owe them an apology" thing. Even changing "apology" to "thanks" or "congratulations" doesn't fly. They are owed nothing for finally giving in and doing the right thing.
I agree that nobody owes them an apology. I don't agree with most of the criticism that has been leveled at them, but it was justifiable.

(justifiable vs. justified == yes, you make a reasonable and valid argument vs. I agree with your conclusions)

Nobody accused them of doing anything they weren't doing. No apologies required.

Congratulations on joining the brethren -- welcome to the club, etc, perfectly justified but not required.
Quoting:Congratulations on joining the brethren -- welcome to the club, etc, perfectly justified but not required.


Motioned and accepted.
> Congratulations on joining the brethren -- welcome to the club, etc, perfectly justified but not required.

> Motioned and accepted.

Yes, I think we can agree on that. Some people (not me) might wish for more, but I doubt they'll get it.
Apologize? Feh. By their CEO's own misleading statements and behavior they prove they don't get Free Software, and don't want to. Use it all you want- I think they are not good for Free Software, and never will be under the current management.
TC:

Thanks for illustrating what I was referring to in my opening post. ;^)
NoDough:

Told you so. :)
I forgot to say I think that's a pretty decent review, though I'm still wishing for long-term reviews of distros instead of the same old "here's how it installed and what it comes with." These are useful, but it's even more useful to know how it behaves over a period of time, especially since linux installations these days are dead-easy. Like the early Mandrake Linuxes installed like champions, but then fell apart in a few days. I'll take a somewhat difficult install over something that installs easily, then caves in any day.

Quoting:I'm still wishing for long-term reviews of distros instead of the same old "here's how it installed and what it comes with."


Great idea for a site after1year.com, after1month.org or whatever.
Quoting:Created an open source HTML editor (Nvu)


linspire has not created nvu. nvu is actually the editor of the old mozilla all-in-one package (now known as seamonkey)

so linspire continued the development of the mozilla editor, but unfortunately they didn't put enough work into it yet.

nvu is buggy and crashes, but it is the only wysiwyg html editor that i can find which runs on linux and windows, so it is the only thing i can recomend to windows usersasking for my help.

greetings, eMBee.
> nvu is buggy and crashes

Ahh... not here, it's quite solid on Debian, and, it certainly puts out better code than the MS equivelant.
> and, it certainly puts out better code than the MS equivelant.

Talk about damning with faint praise.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post