Why open source is under-utilised in graphics
|
|
Comments (5)
Loose ends
Fine art and applied art
First of all, open source methodology is not applicable to fine art. Have you seen any bugfixes to "Mona Lisa" recently? "Mona Lisa 2.0"? ;) When an artist finishes his work it's like "Voila!" - it's done! It's perfect! How dare you even think about modifying it!?
Software is much like applied art - a chair may be a piece of art, too, but if it's not comfy, it's useless and needs fixing. So chairs can have bugfixes like software. Icons and logos may fit here too, probably. But it's an important distinction, I think.
Software is much like applied art - a chair may be a piece of art, too, but if it's not comfy, it's useless and needs fixing. So chairs can have bugfixes like software. Icons and logos may fit here too, probably. But it's an important distinction, I think.
You make a great point.
I'll take it one step further, because I think it helps to illustrate the difference between art and code.
Intellectual property law has long recognized -- more or less -- the ancient notion of an artist's "moral rights" in his work. I find it hard to define the concept,but, to give you an idea, Michealangelo's moral rights in his sculpture of "David" would be violated by the attachment of a fig leaf.
The whole notion of artistic expression runs counter to the ideas of FOSS. At the core of FOSS, though not explicitly stated, is the notion that software is just sort of "out there" for the taking. The RMS four freedoms imply that individual creativity has little to do with software, that, instead, software is some kind of common good.
You can see this attitude from RMS in nearly any reference he make to Linux or to Linus.
I'll take it one step further, because I think it helps to illustrate the difference between art and code.
Intellectual property law has long recognized -- more or less -- the ancient notion of an artist's "moral rights" in his work. I find it hard to define the concept,but, to give you an idea, Michealangelo's moral rights in his sculpture of "David" would be violated by the attachment of a fig leaf.
The whole notion of artistic expression runs counter to the ideas of FOSS. At the core of FOSS, though not explicitly stated, is the notion that software is just sort of "out there" for the taking. The RMS four freedoms imply that individual creativity has little to do with software, that, instead, software is some kind of common good.
You can see this attitude from RMS in nearly any reference he make to Linux or to Linus.
Does "ancient" mean "obsolete"? :)
You know, when a piece of art is "perfect", it's "perfect" in the form and shape the artist has given it. Any deviation makes it less perfect. So in a desire to maximize world's perfection any modification is considered a crime ;) I've written a couple of poems, so I think I know how it works...
...and fortunately I don't think that way about software I write :)
You know, when a piece of art is "perfect", it's "perfect" in the form and shape the artist has given it. Any deviation makes it less perfect. So in a desire to maximize world's perfection any modification is considered a crime ;) I've written a couple of poems, so I think I know how it works...
...and fortunately I don't think that way about software I write :)
ancient means ancient.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

I use it regularly, and quite like it — but there are incompletenesses. The artwork sections are kind of dodgy; CMYK barely exists; many of the “themes” aboard (like area (“paint”) gradients) are restricted in range or manage to address only a small cross-section of the available capabilties... and so on.
The GIMP is extremely powerful, but the learning curve is kind of chunky, so very few people persist to the point of learning how to do real work with it. The minority who do, produce beauty.
I think that’s reflective of so much FOSS. Even OpenOffice Writer is good at editing HTML, but getting it to accept something simple like relative hyperlinks is an uphill march.
It’s the little things — yes, really it is — the kinds of things which get brushed past during release time, but which are ever so important to new users, or people coming from “alien” packages (PhotoShop or MS-Word, for the above) & expecting to do well.
Having learned how to use The GIMP (not perfectly, but reasonably well), going back to PhotoShop is quite painful. I think that’s a clear illustration that the problem is two-sided; that people have invested so much (financially or emotionally) in closed-source alternatives that they just beat their heads against the problems until they’re (more or less) solved. Much of that commitment is absent for FOSS programs, because they’re free.