Vmware sets up virtual-appliance marketplace
|
|
|
Comments (61)
41 earlier comments in the full thread.
Are you flaming Xen now? I'm confused. I thought Xen was good and Microsoft was bad.
No wait...I thought they BOTH were bad.
I need a drink.
No wait...I thought they BOTH were bad.
I need a drink.
What was the question?
> What was the question?
The question was, um, um, um... :-)
With respect to Xen, I thought it simply uses a different approach - without a hypervisor? - that would require some OS-specific stuff that the hypervisor eliminates. It is also newer, if I understand correctly. I believe that Xen offers some advantages, namely speed, but that the lack of the ability to run Windows is something of a downer for those organizations that need it. I'm sure there are other issues, but since I'm not into virtualization yet, I just can't say much.
The question was, um, um, um... :-)
With respect to Xen, I thought it simply uses a different approach - without a hypervisor? - that would require some OS-specific stuff that the hypervisor eliminates. It is also newer, if I understand correctly. I believe that Xen offers some advantages, namely speed, but that the lack of the ability to run Windows is something of a downer for those organizations that need it. I'm sure there are other issues, but since I'm not into virtualization yet, I just can't say much.
Quoting:The editors are CLEARLY pushing non-free software onto the GNU/Linux community via this channel. The only questions are:
1. Why are they doing it?
2. Why is nobody speaking up about it except me?
--
We keep running over the same old ground..
1. We are not and will never "push" non-libre software, period. We are a news website and we publish articles that have to do with Open Source Software. That means all the news, whether it be directly about it, related to it or affected by it. If people use Open Source Software directly or something even related to it they can come here and most likely find news articles about it. In this instance we are talking about VMWare, it is related to OSS and some people who use OSS use VMWare too. They should be able to know what is going on concerning it. To be informed one must know what is going on because things change all the time. Things that were once closed source are now open source, some things are not as open in their licensing as we would like them to be but to purposely not be informed of news relating to it is not the news it is censorship, in its most blatant form.
2. Your not alone. People tell us of things that are not "open source" all the time and we do as we always have, learn and try to do a better job. The more you know the better you get, no? You choose to argue from a point of view and in a way that brings you, unfortunatly, negative attention. If you started a thread about why you do not like it because it is not "free" software you would most likely find others who feel as you do, or at least in part. You could actually find camaraderie in a way. Which is why any one of us would start or participate in a thread at all. To talk to other people and express ourselves and respond to what others think. This is a place you can learn, from the news and each other but you are missing out on it.
"1. We are not and will never "push" non-libre software, period."
Funny, but I'd say there's quite a bit of pushing going on.
"We are a news website and we publish articles that have to do with Open Source Software."
As you may or may not know, "Open Source" as you call it is nothing more than a re-branding of "Free Software". Therefore, I will assume that you meant to type "We are a news website and we publish articles that have to do with Free Software".
"That means all the news, whether it be directly about it, related to it or affected by it."
I'm not sure what in the world you think VMware, nVidia, or Oracle's wares have to do with Free Software and I'm only addressing the stories you've cross posted today. Again, if you're going to (for whatever reason) use this site to inform people on the latest news about something as non-free as VMware, the LEAST you could do is provide some kind of warning.
If someone drove up to you in an expensive convertible with the top down and asked you for directions that you knew would take them through a crime infested and dangerous part of town, would you just provide the information and be on your way or would you extend yourself for a lousy few seconds and let them know they should be careful? We're talking about common decency and responsibility here.
"In this instance we are talking about VMWare, it is related to OSS and some people who use OSS use VMWare too"
This is a ridiculous as suggesting that LXer.com should start cross posting nutrition information because I use Free Software and I eat breakfast too. There is simply no relationship between something like VMware and Free Software other than the threat VMware poses to the Free Software Movement itself due to the software's restrictive license and its need to extend itself in order to extend its user base.
"They should be able to know what is going on concerning it"
VMware has a website right?
"Things that were once closed source are now open source, some things are not as open in their licensing as we would like them to be but to purposely not be informed of news relating to it is not the news it is censorship, in its most blatant form"
Again, we clearly disagree here. What you consider news, I consider to be off-topic. Censorship is not relevant here since readers are free to go directly to the horse's mouth to get their fill of VMware related news. The problem here is that LXer.com doesn't recognize when it goes out of scope and takes no responsibility for the quality of the service it provides.
Funny, but I'd say there's quite a bit of pushing going on.
"We are a news website and we publish articles that have to do with Open Source Software."
As you may or may not know, "Open Source" as you call it is nothing more than a re-branding of "Free Software". Therefore, I will assume that you meant to type "We are a news website and we publish articles that have to do with Free Software".
"That means all the news, whether it be directly about it, related to it or affected by it."
I'm not sure what in the world you think VMware, nVidia, or Oracle's wares have to do with Free Software and I'm only addressing the stories you've cross posted today. Again, if you're going to (for whatever reason) use this site to inform people on the latest news about something as non-free as VMware, the LEAST you could do is provide some kind of warning.
If someone drove up to you in an expensive convertible with the top down and asked you for directions that you knew would take them through a crime infested and dangerous part of town, would you just provide the information and be on your way or would you extend yourself for a lousy few seconds and let them know they should be careful? We're talking about common decency and responsibility here.
"In this instance we are talking about VMWare, it is related to OSS and some people who use OSS use VMWare too"
This is a ridiculous as suggesting that LXer.com should start cross posting nutrition information because I use Free Software and I eat breakfast too. There is simply no relationship between something like VMware and Free Software other than the threat VMware poses to the Free Software Movement itself due to the software's restrictive license and its need to extend itself in order to extend its user base.
"They should be able to know what is going on concerning it"
VMware has a website right?
"Things that were once closed source are now open source, some things are not as open in their licensing as we would like them to be but to purposely not be informed of news relating to it is not the news it is censorship, in its most blatant form"
Again, we clearly disagree here. What you consider news, I consider to be off-topic. Censorship is not relevant here since readers are free to go directly to the horse's mouth to get their fill of VMware related news. The problem here is that LXer.com doesn't recognize when it goes out of scope and takes no responsibility for the quality of the service it provides.
Also, this is the 3rd time someone has disabled my account. As you can see, I don't plan on going anywhere.
Actually, Open Source is not a rebranding of Free Software; there are many speeches, both written and recorded, that come from the mouth of Richard Stallman on that matter.
I use VMWare on Linux, therefore it is related to Free Software, even if it is not Free Software itself.
I would love to have some information on breakfast, because as a Free Software fan, I find it interesting that proprietary cereals, such as Rice Krispies, have an Open Source alternative, such as Crispy Puffed Rice. Finally we have software...I mean, cereal...that the average consumer can...um...well, consume.
I see VMWare only as a tool, and not controlling the OSes that I have installed. I can easily install them on a real box, except that real boxen cost money. I am all for Free Hardware, but the enterprise just doesn't want to listen!!
When a company goes "out of scope" and produces garbage, it's up to the consumer to jump ship.
Go on, jump!!
I use VMWare on Linux, therefore it is related to Free Software, even if it is not Free Software itself.
I would love to have some information on breakfast, because as a Free Software fan, I find it interesting that proprietary cereals, such as Rice Krispies, have an Open Source alternative, such as Crispy Puffed Rice. Finally we have software...I mean, cereal...that the average consumer can...um...well, consume.
I see VMWare only as a tool, and not controlling the OSes that I have installed. I can easily install them on a real box, except that real boxen cost money. I am all for Free Hardware, but the enterprise just doesn't want to listen!!
When a company goes "out of scope" and produces garbage, it's up to the consumer to jump ship.
Go on, jump!!
This thread should be able to die fairly quickly now.
>Actually, Open Source is not a rebranding of Free Software; there are many speeches, both written and recorded, that come from the mouth of Richard Stallman on that matter.
None of which change the fact that Open Source software is free software. There might be a package or two -- though none that I can think of -- that are not both Open Source and Free, but I can't think of any off the top of my head.
Open Source software is Free software and Free software is Open Source, notwithstanding RMS's occasional habit of sitting on a corncob.
None of which change the fact that Open Source software is free software. There might be a package or two -- though none that I can think of -- that are not both Open Source and Free, but I can't think of any off the top of my head.
Open Source software is Free software and Free software is Open Source, notwithstanding RMS's occasional habit of sitting on a corncob.
I hope so.
That was to dcparris.
And I'm really just tired of the bs in this thread. I know people have strong feelings, but this is getting out of control. I appreciate differing opinions, and I have had people I disagreed with eventually convince that they were right, but they were never so ill spirited in doing so.
Open Solaris, I don't believe, is Free Software in the eyes of the FSF. The licenses are very much incompatible. I don't know that the BSD license meets those criteria, either.
And I'm really just tired of the bs in this thread. I know people have strong feelings, but this is getting out of control. I appreciate differing opinions, and I have had people I disagreed with eventually convince that they were right, but they were never so ill spirited in doing so.
Open Solaris, I don't believe, is Free Software in the eyes of the FSF. The licenses are very much incompatible. I don't know that the BSD license meets those criteria, either.
rijl--
There is more than one BSD license. In the eyes of the FSF, they are free software licenses, but only the one without the advertising clause is both free and compatible with the GPL.
Open Solaris is released under CDDL, which the FSF considers to be a free software license, but incompatible with the GPL.
There is more than one BSD license. In the eyes of the FSF, they are free software licenses, but only the one without the advertising clause is both free and compatible with the GPL.
Open Solaris is released under CDDL, which the FSF considers to be a free software license, but incompatible with the GPL.
Cool. Good to know. Thanks.
Well, RMS acknowledged to me that Open Source is really Free Software. What happens to many people is that they mistakenly identify "Open Source Software" with "non-copyleft" and "Free Software" with "copyleft". That is a mistake because even RMS considers non-copyleft licenses to be "Free Software". He only considers the "Open Source Software" camp to be different in philosophy. That is why many OSI-approved licenses are also approved by the FSF.
>He only considers the "Open Source Software" camp to be different in philosophy.
It didn't start out that way, though ESR got a little to focused on the sizzle of corporate acceptance and forgot about the steak of freedom.
Make that eggplant if you're vegetarian.
It didn't start out that way, though ESR got a little to focused on the sizzle of corporate acceptance and forgot about the steak of freedom.
Make that eggplant if you're vegetarian.
You guys must be kidding me. Do you seriously think I'm going to be silenced so easily? Not going to happen.
As for those of you of think that Open Source is not a re-branding of Free Software, please study the history of the movement for more than 2 seconds. There is simply NO dispute that this is fact. Of course, many who subscribe to the Open Source propaganda machine would never want to admit this is the case since the Free Software movement involves so much more than simple pragmatism. To those people, I can only say "You can't handle the truth!"
As for those of you of think that Open Source is not a re-branding of Free Software, please study the history of the movement for more than 2 seconds. There is simply NO dispute that this is fact. Of course, many who subscribe to the Open Source propaganda machine would never want to admit this is the case since the Free Software movement involves so much more than simple pragmatism. To those people, I can only say "You can't handle the truth!"
DC:
> This thread should be able to die fairly quickly now.
I apologize. I've got to learn to stop feeding the troll.
> This thread should be able to die fairly quickly now.
I apologize. I've got to learn to stop feeding the troll.
Quoting:I apologize. I've got to learn to stop feeding the troll.
I was thinking the same thing about myself. It's really obvious that's all he's doing but it's so hard to pass him up. After this many years online, I should know better.
Had we all just ignored him, this thread would have died almost immediately.
I'm out.
don't slam the door on your way out
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Eh? AFIAK, that's already happened. See http://www.osnews.com/story.php?news_id=15221 and http://news.zdnet.com/2100-3513_22-6095158.html