Advanced

Getting Cute with the GPL

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 87 comments
Growklaw.net; By Pamela Jones
Mail this story
Print this story

Eben Moglen has now stated that GPLv3 will be redrafted to include clear language that will make the Novell-Microsoft agreement an obvious GPL violation, and more: "GPL version 3 will be adjusted so the effect of the current deal is that Microsoft will by giving away access to the very patents Microsoft is trying to assert."

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Microsoft, Novell; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (87)

67 earlier comments in the full thread.

>everything under the GPLv3 is the "intellectual property" owned by "The Community".

In which case, Hell will freeze over before nVidia releases a GPLV3'd driver.
They don't have to make it GPLv3.

Case closed.
>They don't have to make it GPLv3.

Goodness!! Even you can see the light. Who'da thunk?
See the light? I never said GPL should be an exclusive Free Software license and I don't have any problems with other FS licenses in principle. I just think GPL is the best. :)

But if it doesn't suit Nvidia and AMD, they can choose a different FS license. As long as I can have a fully working free driver I'll be happy. Just give us the source and four freedoms and we'll take it from there (yes, they don't even need to distribute binaries, we'll build it ourselves) no matter which license you use to grant us those freedoms.
L -

On that I can agree completely.

I get more than a little antsy on the GPLV3 stuff -- especially when so many useful and important tools are GPL'd. The thought of the Linux kernel being on one license and tools on another, potentially incompatible license, gives me the willies.

And, to be honest, it does spook me to see them running back to the drawing board because of the Novell-Microsoft deal. I know these are smart people who've given everything a great deal of thought, but that particular scurry doesn't fit the picture.
I would also be concerned if GPLv3 ends up incompatible with GPLv2. I hope that it is compatible.

About running to the drawing board because of the Novell-MS deal I don't think that's what happened. I mean, I don't think that they have deliberately and specifically made this new patent provision the goal *after* the deal. I think the goal was such all along.

So it can't be just a reaction. They're just staying their course. ;)
>I would also be concerned if GPLv3 ends up incompatible with GPLv2. I hope that it is compatible.

RMS doesn't appear to be concerned about that and considers such talk as good as FUD. There was a radio interview with him recently that expresses his position (I thought) rather well. I can't remember the show it was on, but it was within the past 2-3 weeks. I'd be interested to hear what his personal take on Novell/MS is. He's a sharp cookie.
Dino, Don,

I don't see what is the big deal about Moglen's addition in v3. V2 says if you use GPLed code in your application, your whole code has to be GPLed, take it or leave it. Many developers and companies are happy with it and as a matter of fact, many prefer it because it protects their code. The addition into v3 does the same thing by extending v2 to cover patent covenants granted by any company. what is wrong with that? Why wouldn't any one who has GPLed their code not like it or accept it? What are they going lose?

Linux Kernel is a crucial part, If its developers adopt v3 many code will or will have to adopt it. And even if they don't, companies that use any v3 code will have to deal with at lest some code that is v3.

Let's wait and see what happens after Moglen issues his draft. Let's not kill it before we give it a chance to be reviewed by developers and companies. One thing I would like to see is what is so bad about this new proposed terms? Again, I don't see anything that the GPL2 didn't intend and v3 is only making it clear and assertive.

Let's stop splitting hair for moment.
Abe -

>The addition into v3 does the same thing by extending v2 to cover patent covenants granted by any company

The problem comes when you are trying to extend convenants granted by somebody else. You don't have the power to do that. They do.

I see potential nightmares that could keep code from being released under V3.
> I see potential nightmares that could keep code from being released under V3.

And ultimately cause everyone to reject GPLv3.

> Let's stop splitting hair for moment.

All the speculation on this deal, and on GPLv3 has become the equivelant of the medieval monks delema of 'how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?'. We simply don't have enough information to make a valid judgement, and in this case, faith just doesn't cut it.
>We simply don't have enough information to make a valid judgement, and in this case, faith just doesn't cut it.

I'll admit, however, that I feel better about it than I did before. I am now convinced that, other than adding confusion, V3 isn't likely to do substantial harm.

If it's really out there, people won't use it. If they need to, they will fork.
jimf
Quoting:And ultimately cause everyone to reject GPLv3.


"Everyone" is a gross generalization, don't you think?

Quoting:We simply don't have enough information to make a valid judgement, and in this case, faith just doesn't cut it.


Noone is taking it on faith. Otherwise why would we even bother discussing. We'd just say "everything is going to be fine, FSF knows best etc."

Observing, putting the dots together and discussing is not a faith based initiative. It is science. ;)
> Observing, putting the dots together and discussing is not a faith based initiative. It is science. ;)

Where did you learn your scientific method? That's not even remotely correct.

The scientific method is:

1) Observe, 2) Hypothesize, 3) Predict, 4) Test.

See http://teacher.pas.rochester.edu/phy_labs/AppendixE/Appendix...

What we are doing is more akin to the Socratic method: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socratic_method
"The problem comes when you are trying to extend convenants granted by somebody else. You don't have the power to do that. They do.

I see potential nightmares that could keep code from being released under V3."

I don't see how this could be a problem. GPLed code has the GPL (2 or 3) stuck with it and should be honored no matter who, how, or from it was obtained. If MS bought/downloaded Suse, they do that under the agreement of the GPL, otherwise the can't and shouldn't.

If GPL3 was not widely accepted, then it will not be adopted. Just like you stated, developers/companies will still use GPL2 as long as they can, or they will fork when they can't.

My point is still to wait and see how v3 is going to be received.
>My point is still to wait and see how v3 is going to be received.

As I said earlier, this whole exercise has had a palliative effect on me. I'm still perplexed by Moglen's midnight dash, but now convinced that his prior work (V2) is good enough to pull our tails out of the fire in the event he impales himself on good intentions.

I still get to yap, but not so worried.
"I still get to yap, but not so worried."

May be Lxer should have sound too so we can hear our yap. I must warn you though, mine could be very harmful.
>May be Lxer should have sound too so we can hear our yap.

Hmmm....

If that ever happens, I may have to get our Chihuahua involved. Thinks he's a macho little dude, but if that bark is worse than his bite, he's gumming his way through everything.
jdixon
Quoting:The scientific method is:

1) Observe, 2) Hypothesize, 3) Predict, 4) Test.

See [HYPERLINK@teacher.pas.rochester.edu]

What we are doing is more akin to the Socratic method:


Sounds like the socratic method fits well with the scientific method. Besides, a lot of the hypothesizing and predicting is done in cooperation and through discussion.

The point was simply that we're not taking anything based on faith here. Just that. Some think GPLv3 will be bad and some believe it will be good, based on their observations from their perspectives.
>Some think GPLv3 will be bad and some believe it will be good

Probably should substitute "could" for will, given that we have only a draft to date.
Indeed, you're right.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post