Microsoft may lodge patent lawsuit test case: Linux specialist
|
|
|
Comments (34)
extortion is never cheaper
4 earlier comments in the full thread.
It's easy to call it "Son of SCO". Troubled "Linux" software company replaces upper management and starts attacking Linux. Hmm, where have we seen this before....the main difference is the dirty hand of the evil empire is more apparent.
PEOPLE --- KEEP THE FACTS STRAIGHT!!!!
Of course Novell is finding their deal cheap. They aren't paying anything to Microsoft, Microsoft is paying them!
Just because you see a funny money column labelled "from Novell to Microsoft" it doesn't mean that Novell is paying any money.
What matters in any business deal is the net, and Microsoft is paying Novell hundreds of millions of dollars. From what I can tell, Novell gets a lot and gives up very little. Hard to call that a bad deal in business terms.
Of course Novell is finding their deal cheap. They aren't paying anything to Microsoft, Microsoft is paying them!
Just because you see a funny money column labelled "from Novell to Microsoft" it doesn't mean that Novell is paying any money.
What matters in any business deal is the net, and Microsoft is paying Novell hundreds of millions of dollars. From what I can tell, Novell gets a lot and gives up very little. Hard to call that a bad deal in business terms.
Dino, the fact that the money is flowing from Microsoft to Novell has no effect on my comment, which concerns the lack of judgment on the part of Novell's CEO. Regardless of how you look at it, making a deal with Microsoft and expecting them to keep their end of it does not show good judgment, and a lack of judgment that severe calls in to question the competency of the entire company.
That completely ignores the details of the agreement, about which I've already voiced my concerns.
That completely ignores the details of the agreement, about which I've already voiced my concerns.
jdixon -
My comment was not directed at any individual so much as everybody talking about Novell paying Microsoft. They're not.
RE: The Novell CEO...
Yeah. I don't know about the judgment because I haven't read the agreement (and don't plan to) and I don't know everything that drove it, but...
The guy might have been advised to wait until he had a better sense of what it's like to be on Microsoft's enemies list before entering into a far-ranging deal.
My comment was not directed at any individual so much as everybody talking about Novell paying Microsoft. They're not.
RE: The Novell CEO...
Yeah. I don't know about the judgment because I haven't read the agreement (and don't plan to) and I don't know everything that drove it, but...
The guy might have been advised to wait until he had a better sense of what it's like to be on Microsoft's enemies list before entering into a far-ranging deal.
dino, technically you are right. I think the Rev's point about the FUD aspects of the deal is the important bit. Novell is seeing a short-term financial gain, but how smart is it for the long-term to partner with someone who is the very publicly sworn enemy of your main product line, and the entire community and infrastructure that creates and supports it? Microsoft's top bosses make no secret of their hatred of FOSS and the GPL. It borders on mental illness- they could have chosen to use it just like anyone else, and benefited from it. Instead they keep trying the same deceit and backstabbing they always use.
The question of the effectiveness of their usual scorched-earth tactics is up in the air. I've puzzled on this until my puzzler is sore, and it seems their only real weapons are FUD and propaganda. I think Ballmer and Gates are incapable of telling the truth or making a simple, straightforward, declarative statement. It's all Wormtongue. I'm a lot less concerned about the potential impact on FOSS than I was before- as we have discussed in other threads, the GPL is strong and the worldwide FOSS community too diverse to attack.
But that won't stop them from trying. You know the much-overused saying "insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results." MS has two products in an extensive product line that turn profits- Office and Windows. Everything else they touch turns into a money sink. You'd think that fact alone would cause the decision-makers to consider different tactics.
I believe that over the long-term Microsoft will become friendlier to FOSS. It won't survive if it doesn't, and I'll wager there are a lot of folks in the rank-and-file who understand its value. But I doubt we'll see any changes in policy or tactics until Ballmer and Gates are gone. They have too much invested in boneheaded macho posturing to make any substantive changes.
If Novell comes out on top in their dealings with MS, or at least not toasted to a crisp, I will be happily surprised. Like the Rev, I am not happy at their being partners in MS' anti-Linux campaigning.
The question of the effectiveness of their usual scorched-earth tactics is up in the air. I've puzzled on this until my puzzler is sore, and it seems their only real weapons are FUD and propaganda. I think Ballmer and Gates are incapable of telling the truth or making a simple, straightforward, declarative statement. It's all Wormtongue. I'm a lot less concerned about the potential impact on FOSS than I was before- as we have discussed in other threads, the GPL is strong and the worldwide FOSS community too diverse to attack.
But that won't stop them from trying. You know the much-overused saying "insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results." MS has two products in an extensive product line that turn profits- Office and Windows. Everything else they touch turns into a money sink. You'd think that fact alone would cause the decision-makers to consider different tactics.
I believe that over the long-term Microsoft will become friendlier to FOSS. It won't survive if it doesn't, and I'll wager there are a lot of folks in the rank-and-file who understand its value. But I doubt we'll see any changes in policy or tactics until Ballmer and Gates are gone. They have too much invested in boneheaded macho posturing to make any substantive changes.
If Novell comes out on top in their dealings with MS, or at least not toasted to a crisp, I will be happily surprised. Like the Rev, I am not happy at their being partners in MS' anti-Linux campaigning.
> I believe that over the long-term Microsoft will become friendlier to FOSS
Well, they'll 'pretend' to be friendlier...
> It won't survive if it doesn't
One can only hope that's true.
Well, they'll 'pretend' to be friendlier...
> It won't survive if it doesn't
One can only hope that's true.
> My comment was not directed at any individual so much as everybody talking about Novell paying Microsoft. They're not.
Understood and agreed. Novell is actually coming out quite well in the deal, and has gained the blessing of SUSE as a "Microsoft approved" version of Linux. I can understand why they made the deal, they just forgot the cardinal rule of the software business: You can never trust Microsoft.
Understood and agreed. Novell is actually coming out quite well in the deal, and has gained the blessing of SUSE as a "Microsoft approved" version of Linux. I can understand why they made the deal, they just forgot the cardinal rule of the software business: You can never trust Microsoft.
> My comment was not directed at any individual so much as everybody talking about Novell paying Microsoft. They're not.
But yes, they are. I agree that the net $ transfer is to Novell as a result of the patent "agreement". However I suspect it was structured as a two way payment at Microsoft's demand so that they could claim it as a precedent. In other words "Look everyone, Linux is paying us for our intelectual property!".
But yes, they are. I agree that the net $ transfer is to Novell as a result of the patent "agreement". However I suspect it was structured as a two way payment at Microsoft's demand so that they could claim it as a precedent. In other words "Look everyone, Linux is paying us for our intelectual property!".
jimf, this has probably been said already- MS doesn't need a formal deal with a commercial Linux vendor to do better interoperability. Duh. :) I wonder if Novell gets access to Windows and other MS application internals? That's the missing piece in true interoperability. So yeah, it's all a shuck. It's still going to be interesting to see how it all plays out. The ink on the agreement isn't even dry and Ballmer's already foaming about litigation. That sure shows you where their minds are at. Not innovation, and not interoperability, that's for sure.
>That sure shows you where their minds are at.
Can you guess where their heads are at?
Can you guess where their heads are at?
>However I suspect it was structured as a two way payment at Microsoft's demand so that they could claim it as a precedent. In other words "Look everyone, Linux is paying us for our intelectual property!".
I have no doubt that is why Microsoft wanted it done that way.
I have no doubt that is why Microsoft wanted it done that way.
TC: I wonder if Novell gets access to Windows and other MS application internals?
My understanding is that, yes, Novell gets to play nicer with AD. So there is some improved interoperability, and I can kind of understand them wanting to get at that, even if I disapprove of their strategy. Not that they sought my approval to begin with, but... Novell has a right to seek better interoperability, even while the rest of us are trying to convince MS to use the existing standards.
You're correct about my primary point. Novell had to be aware of MS' position unless they have been under a rock for the past several years. I've only been paying attention for the last two or so, and I know. Still, My guess is that they realized they could gain from MS' FUD, which helps them compete against Red Hat, assuming the FUD is effective. Well, we know some will buy into it, even if not the controller where I work. I think most (even Windows admins) realize what game is being played. So Novell gets some potential Red Hat customers, and possibly a few of the more gullible current ones.
I find it difficult to respect Novell's decision to accept the patent terms, regardless of their desire to put their customers at ease, because it plays into Microsoft's hand, and helps divide the community at just the moment when the community should be most united. Remember that MS is launching Vista!
My understanding is that, yes, Novell gets to play nicer with AD. So there is some improved interoperability, and I can kind of understand them wanting to get at that, even if I disapprove of their strategy. Not that they sought my approval to begin with, but... Novell has a right to seek better interoperability, even while the rest of us are trying to convince MS to use the existing standards.
You're correct about my primary point. Novell had to be aware of MS' position unless they have been under a rock for the past several years. I've only been paying attention for the last two or so, and I know. Still, My guess is that they realized they could gain from MS' FUD, which helps them compete against Red Hat, assuming the FUD is effective. Well, we know some will buy into it, even if not the controller where I work. I think most (even Windows admins) realize what game is being played. So Novell gets some potential Red Hat customers, and possibly a few of the more gullible current ones.
I find it difficult to respect Novell's decision to accept the patent terms, regardless of their desire to put their customers at ease, because it plays into Microsoft's hand, and helps divide the community at just the moment when the community should be most united. Remember that MS is launching Vista!
While it is impossible to fathom the "brains" behind Microsoft, does anyone here believe they would really sue anyone like the article says? It seems pretty far-fetched. Sure, they have all the money in the world, but it takes more than that to win a lawsuit, even here in the good ole US of A. So far they've been successful with little more than bluff, bluster, bullying, and pure propaganda. I can't imagine what they would hope to gain by suing a Linux user, even in the delusional Redmond universe. Seems to me there is far more to lose, like accelerated customer defections.
This Inquirer article has a table of noteworthy losses: http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=24621
Groklaw, of course, goes into much more detail on everything: http://www.groklaw.net/staticpages/index.php?page=2005010107...
Does anyone know if it's typical of large companies to be involved in so many lawsuits?
This Inquirer article has a table of noteworthy losses: http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=24621
Groklaw, of course, goes into much more detail on everything: http://www.groklaw.net/staticpages/index.php?page=2005010107...
Does anyone know if it's typical of large companies to be involved in so many lawsuits?
Don, the other thing I wonder about are the real goals of the new management team at Novell. Are they really there to run the company, or were they imported like Darl and his henchpeople for a different purpose? Those ole boyz in the executive suites inhabit a different world from us mere mortals anyway. I wonder, in this case, how different. We all take for granted the vast flow of information exchange that's available to us these days, and the passions that come with being a part of the FOSS world. But a lot of people are still living in the pre-Internet era where it was safe to ignore the peons, and have no idea what they're getting into when they run afoul of FOSS users.
>I can't imagine what they would hope to gain by suing a Linux user
I made my point regarding this in another thread, but here's the gist: When Bill's Secret Army sues someone for using non-licensed software, they're suing Windows users. If they sue a Linux user for using infringing software, they're suing, among others, Red Hat and Oracle. There's no way they want that sort of battle, especially since they'll have to show what Linux is infringing upon (probably nothing).
I made my point regarding this in another thread, but here's the gist: When Bill's Secret Army sues someone for using non-licensed software, they're suing Windows users. If they sue a Linux user for using infringing software, they're suing, among others, Red Hat and Oracle. There's no way they want that sort of battle, especially since they'll have to show what Linux is infringing upon (probably nothing).
TC: I think it's hard to say about Hovsepian & Co., whether they are really Son of SCO, though that isn't impossible. I should hope they have seen the light, especially since they are the ones claiming SCO doesn't really own the rights to their UNIX platform. That said, you are correct in that many, especially in the upper echelons, simply pay little or no attention to anything coming from the bottom of the totem pole. It's really easy for a guy like Hovsepian to cut a deal, possibly even with good intentions, only to discover that he's the only one that thinks much of it. I guess that's one reason it gets lonely at the top. ;-)
Also, I could kind of understand claims of patent infringement in Samba, but how would Linux infringe on MS patents?
Also, I could kind of understand claims of patent infringement in Samba, but how would Linux infringe on MS patents?
my 2 cents,
This was stated near the beginning, I have and continue to enjoy using SuSE. I know shoot me now. I have never tried to explain it but of all the distro's it is the one that I have been able to get to do the things I want it to do.
All of this has nothing to do with recent events..so..
Any wrath from the decision to sleep with the devil does not deserve to be transferred to the people who contribute to OpenSuSE. Money going this way or that is not the fault of the community of developers who have tried to make SuSE worth using.
We all know why M$ agreed to the deal and we all have opinions, including Novell on why they did the deal but the GPL is clear on who must benefit. We all must..
I guess I lost my point but all I hear from Microsoft is Ballmer trying to scare people and so far no one is buying it.
Sorry for the rant.
This was stated near the beginning, I have and continue to enjoy using SuSE. I know shoot me now. I have never tried to explain it but of all the distro's it is the one that I have been able to get to do the things I want it to do.
All of this has nothing to do with recent events..so..
Any wrath from the decision to sleep with the devil does not deserve to be transferred to the people who contribute to OpenSuSE. Money going this way or that is not the fault of the community of developers who have tried to make SuSE worth using.
We all know why M$ agreed to the deal and we all have opinions, including Novell on why they did the deal but the GPL is clear on who must benefit. We all must..
I guess I lost my point but all I hear from Microsoft is Ballmer trying to scare people and so far no one is buying it.
Sorry for the rant.
Well, that's just it. Ballmer is beating the water to scare the fish.
>Well, that's just it. Ballmer is beating the water to scare the fish.
Beware the piranha....
Beware the piranha....
> Beware the piranha....
They're really just carp ;-)
They're really just carp ;-)
Illegal software user says Microsoft is evil?
I'm sorry... but I just had to laugh. I certainly don't like Microsoft, but getting fined because you chose to use software illegally isn't going to get you sympathy.
Bad article... just more FUD.
Bad article... just more FUD.
From what I gather it was just a case of software being transferred unwittingly to another department on a reused computer. That department didn't have licenses for the software and didn't use it. But it was still loaded, which was a violation. I think that there was a case of a shady IT employee that also caused them problems.
Plus, it was not getting fined that was his problem. The problem was the draconian way they were raided and embarrassed publicly for something that was a mistake they would have fixed voluntarily.
Plus, it was not getting fined that was his problem. The problem was the draconian way they were raided and embarrassed publicly for something that was a mistake they would have fixed voluntarily.
By design, it is impossible to be in compliance with Microsoft licenses.
>By design, it is impossible to be in compliance with Microsoft licenses.
Just goes to show why it's important to read those things carefully.
You'd be amazed at how many people forget to do the Hokey Pokey and shake it all about, or to say "Simon says" when starting up a program.
Just goes to show why it's important to read those things carefully.
You'd be amazed at how many people forget to do the Hokey Pokey and shake it all about, or to say "Simon says" when starting up a program.
>By design, it is impossible to be in compliance with Microsoft licenses.
Probably 10-15% (more in some cases) of IT time is spent trying to make sure you're in compliance with licenses of the various programs you use, if you use Windows. This includes having to be on the phone when you have to reinstall an app, or when you move it to another machine, or when something goofy "breaks" within the program and it tells you that it's not longer licensed, or if another user tries to use the software on the same machine in a different profile...it goes on and on. Then you have to keep track of what expires when...man, it's enough to make you puke.
Probably 10-15% (more in some cases) of IT time is spent trying to make sure you're in compliance with licenses of the various programs you use, if you use Windows. This includes having to be on the phone when you have to reinstall an app, or when you move it to another machine, or when something goofy "breaks" within the program and it tells you that it's not longer licensed, or if another user tries to use the software on the same machine in a different profile...it goes on and on. Then you have to keep track of what expires when...man, it's enough to make you puke.
> This includes having to be on the phone when you have to reinstall an app
Assuming the company even lets you reinstall it. In one case here, since the company didn't purchase a maintenance contract on the software, they said we couldn't reinstall the software on a new machine. Names withheld to protect the guilty. :(
Assuming the company even lets you reinstall it. In one case here, since the company didn't purchase a maintenance contract on the software, they said we couldn't reinstall the software on a new machine. Names withheld to protect the guilty. :(
My fave is when the CD key doesn't work on a new installation, and I have to call MS "support", and their CD key generator is "down", and my customer won't let me get a CD key off the Internet because of fear of the license police, and it takes 2-3 days to resolve. And that's just to install the dommed software. What they really want is for the customer to move to Volume Licensing and Software Assurance, which over the long-term costs more, is less flexible, and easier for them to track than purchasing full retail boxed sets.
I finally figured out a hack, though- I have a friend with a deep intimidating voice. He pretends to be an attorney. We tried it twice, and both time the CD key generator was "fixed" in record time.
I finally figured out a hack, though- I have a friend with a deep intimidating voice. He pretends to be an attorney. We tried it twice, and both time the CD key generator was "fixed" in record time.
>they said we couldn't reinstall the software on a new machine.
Man, that's bad. You never know what a nice thing no license problems are until you have no license problems!
Man, that's bad. You never know what a nice thing no license problems are until you have no license problems!
cjocox: The Ernie Ball case was used in this article as an example of the kind of company (size/money) that MS might go after in a patent infringement case. The point is that MS is likely to go after a company similar to Ernie Ball - one that is visible, but doesn't have the funds to defend itself. How they will attempt to enforce their patents should prove interesting.
>but doesn't have the funds to defend itself.
Red Hat and Oracle have the funds, however. If MS goes after somebody, it will be interesting to see what the reaction from those companies is. Neither will sit on the sideline and have their business threatened. I would think it's possible that Oracle could make patent claims on SQL Server, given the ridiculous nature of software patents. If MS were to do it they could face a fight they couldn't hope to win.
When they went after Ernie Ball, they effectively went after themselves, and drove Ball to the penguin. If they go after Red Hat, they go after a company with billions of dollars in cash, and Oracle, who has even more to play with. It's not the same scenario, and I think it's a bit unlikely -- highly unlikely -- that they'll do it. They're already getting bad press for threatening something like that.
Red Hat and Oracle have the funds, however. If MS goes after somebody, it will be interesting to see what the reaction from those companies is. Neither will sit on the sideline and have their business threatened. I would think it's possible that Oracle could make patent claims on SQL Server, given the ridiculous nature of software patents. If MS were to do it they could face a fight they couldn't hope to win.
When they went after Ernie Ball, they effectively went after themselves, and drove Ball to the penguin. If they go after Red Hat, they go after a company with billions of dollars in cash, and Oracle, who has even more to play with. It's not the same scenario, and I think it's a bit unlikely -- highly unlikely -- that they'll do it. They're already getting bad press for threatening something like that.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post
